arXiv++ Combinatorics

In 1967 Herbert Scarf suggested a new proof of Brouwer fixed point theorem based on a surprising analogue of Sperner's lemma. This analogue was motivated by Scarf's work in game theory and mathematical economics. Moreover, Scarf proved a much general version of Sperner's lemma dealing with colorings by vectors. The present paper begins by revisiting Scarf's ideas from the point of view of the basic theory of simplicial cochains in the spirit of author's papers arXiv:1909.00940 and arXiv:2012.13104. After this we get to the main new results of the paper, namely, to a generalization of Scarf results to colorings with colors belonging to an oriented matroid. No knowledge of the theory of oriented matroids is assumed. In the last section we return to the original Scarf theorem and reprove it using even more classical methods of the combinatorial topology of Euclidean spaces. Also, we generalize a theorem of Kannai.

The present paper is a continuation of author's paper arXiv:1909.00940 [math.AT] devoted to the lemmas of Alexander and Sperner, but is independent from it. We begin by a step back from Alexander and Sperner to Lebesgue work on the invariance of the dimension. In contrast with almost everybody else, Lebesgue worked with cubes rather than with simplices. His methods were developed by Hurewicz and Lusternik-Schnirelmann and then forgotten. In the present paper these methods are recast in the language of cubical chains and cochains. After this, we present a new approach to Lebesgue and Lusternik-Schnirelmann theorems which is both conceptual and elementary. It is based on adaptation of Serre's definition of products of singular cubical cochains to discrete setting. The main results are new purely combinatorial "cubical lemmas". This approach also clarifies the cubical versions of Sperner lemma of Kuhn and Ky Fan. In particular, Ky Fan's lemma can be understood as a natural strengthening of Lebesgue or Kuhn's results under a transversality assumption. The exposition does not assume any knowledge of algebraic topology.

Alexander's lemma is a version of Sperner's lemma published by Alexander two years earlier than Sperner's paper. The present paper is devoted to a modern but elementary exposition of lemmas of Alexander and Sperner and their main topological applications: Brouwer's theorems about the topological invariance of dimension and of domains (here we follow Lebesgue ideas in the form given to them by Sperner), Brouwer's fixed-point theorem, and Alexander's theorem about the topological invariance of homology groups. Along the way we relate the Knaster-Kuratowski-Mazurkiewich argument with the notion of simplicial approximations, provide a cohomological interpretation of Sperner's lemma and of its combinatorial proof, and explain how classical proofs of Sperner's and Alexander's lemma lead to path-following algorithms. The exposition does not assume any knowledge of algebraic topology.

The paper is devoted to a somewhat idiosyncratic account of the theorem of de Bruijn-Erdös and Hanani from the combinatorics of finite geometries and its various proofs. Among the proofs discussed are the original proofs by de Bruijn--Erdös and Hanani and few others. It is explained how one of the proofs was discovered, and how another one could have been discovered.

The paper is devoted to a proof of the de Bruijn-Erdös theorem in incidence geometry based on the Ph. Hall's marriage theorem (the theorem about the systems of distinct representatives).

The paper is devoted to a detailed self-contained exposition of a part of the theory of affine planes leading to a construction of affine (or, equivalently, projective) planes not satisfying the Desarques axiom. It is intended to complement the introductory expositions of the theory of affine and projective planes. A novelty of our exposition is a new notation for the ternary operation in a ternary ring, much more suggestive than the standard one.

The goal of this paper is to present an algebraic approach to the basic results of the theory of linear recurrence relations. This approach is based on the ideas from the theory of representations of one endomorphisms (a special case of which is well known as the theory of the Jordan normal form of matrices). The notion of the divided derivatives, an analogue of the divided powers, turned out to be crucial for proving the results in a natural way and in their natural generality. The final form of our methods was influenced by the the umbral calculus of G.-C. Rota.

The Tutte polynomial of a connected graph was originally defined by Tutte as a sum over all spanning trees of monomials depending on a fixed linear order on the set of edges. Tuttle proved that while these monomials do depend on the linear order, the sum does not. The present paper is a result of a reflection upon this classical theorem of Tutte. It is devoted to an elementary and detailed proof of this theorem in its natural generality, i.e. not for graphs, but for matroids. In contrast with usual methods, the emphasis is on the properties of maps (as opposed to elements) naturally associated to a matroid (or a graph) and an order. In order to fully explain the four-fold symmetry of the proof, we introduce notion of linking between two matroids on the same set. While every matroid is, in fact, linked only to itself and to its dual matroid, the notion of a linking identifies the essential features of the theory and allows to replace the usual four similar arguments by a single one. This is done in Theorem 9.1, which is the focal point of the present paper. With the exception of Introduction, the present paper is self-contained modulo basic concepts related to sets and maps. In particular, no knowledge of the matroid theory or of the graph theory is assumed.

The proof of Brouwer's fixed-point theorem based on Sperner's lemma is often presented as an elementary combinatorial alternative to advanced proofs based on algebraic topology. The goal of this note is to show that: (i) the combinatorial proof of Sperner's Lemma can be considered as a cochain-level version, written in the combinatorial language, of a standard cohomological argument; (ii) the standard deduction of Brouwer's theorem from Sperner's lemma is similar to the usual deduction of Brouwer's theorem from the no-retraction theorem and is closely related to the notion of a simplicial approximation. In order to make these connections transparent, we included the above mentioned standard arguments, so the note is self-contained modulo some basic ideas of combinatorial topology.