arXiv++ Combinatorics

IMPORTANT NOTE: This paper is much rougher than I'd usually submit, and not entirely complete, though the main theorems and proofs should not be hard to follow. Given the ongoing strike at UK Universities it may be some time before I get to complete it to my satisfaction, and in the meantime people I've shared the preliminary draft with would like to be able to reference it. Hence I'm uploading it in its current form, and will update it later. The main new result of this paper is to count the number of (n,n+1)-core partitions with odd parts, answering a question of Zaleski and Zeilberger with bounty a charitable contribution to the OEIS. Along the way, we prove a general theorem giving a recurrence for (n,n+1)-core parts whose smallest part and consecutive part differences are restricted to lie in an arbitrary set M. This theorem unifies many known results about (n,n+1)-core partitions with restrictions. We end with discussions of extensions of the general theorem that keep track of the largest part, number of parts, and size of the partition, and about a few cases where the same methods work on more general simultaneous cores.

We observe that for a and b relatively prime, the "abacus construction" identifies the set of simultaneous (a,b)-core partitions with lattice points in a rational simplex. Furthermore, many statistics on (a,b)-cores are piecewise polynomial functions on this simplex. We apply these results to rational Catalan combinatorics. Using Ehrhart theory, we reprove Anderson's theorem that there are (a+b-1)!/a!b! simultaneous (a,b)-cores, and using Euler-Maclaurin theory we prove Armstrong's conjecture that the average size of an (a,b)-core is (a+b+1)(a-1)(b-1)/24. Our methods also give new derivations of analogous formulas for the number and average size of self-conjugate (a,b)-cores. We conjecture a unimodality result for q rational Catalan numbers, and make preliminary investigations in applying these methods to the (q,t)-symmetry and specialization conjectures. We prove these conjectures for low degree terms and when a=3, connecting them to the Catalan hyperplane arrangement and quadratic permutation statistics.

We derive an algorithm to produce explicit formulas for certain generating functions of double Hurwitz numbers. These formulas generalize a formula of Goulden, Jackson and Vakil for one part double Hurwitz numbers. Immediate consequences include a new proof that double Hurwitz numbers are piecewise polynomial, an understanding of the chamber structure and wall crossing for these polynomials, and a proof of the Goulden, Jackson and Vakil's Strong Piecewise Polynomiality conjecture. The method is a straightforward application of Okounkov's expression for double Hurwitz numbers in terms of operators on the infinite wedge. We begin with a introduction to the infinite wedge tailored to our use.

Double Hurwitz numbers count covers of the projective line by genus g curves with assigned ramification profiles over 0 and infinity, and simple ramification over a fixed branch divisor. Goulden, Jackson and Vakil have shown double Hurwitz numbers are piecewise polynomial in the orders of ramification, and Shadrin, Shapiro and Vainshtein have determined the chamber structure and wall crossing formulas for g=0. This paper gives a unified approach to these results and strengthens them in several ways --- the most important being the extension of the results of Shapiro, Shadrin and Vainshtein to arbitrary genus. The main tool is the authors' previous work expressing double Hurwitz number as a sum over certain labeled graphs. We identify the labels of the graphs with lattice points in the chambers of certain hyperplane arrangements, which are well known to give rise to piecewise polynomial functions. Our understanding of the wall crossing for these functions builds on the work of Varchenko, and could have broader applications.

Hurwitz numbers count genus g, degree d covers of the projective line with fixed branch locus. This equals the degree of a natural branch map defined on the Hurwitz space. In tropical geometry, algebraic curves are replaced by certain piece-wise linear objects called tropical curves. This paper develops a tropical counterpart of the branch map and shows that its degree recovers classical Hurwitz numbers.