arXiv++ Combinatorics

We develop the framework of $α$-largeness introduced by Ketonen and Solovay, by proving a partition theorem for $α$-large sets with $α< ε_0$ which generalizes theorems from Ketonen and Solovay and from Bigorajska and Kotlarski. We also prove that for every $ω^{nk+3}$-large set $X$ with $\min X \geq 18$, every coloring $f : [X]^2 \to k$ admits an $ω^n$-large $f$-homogeneous subset. This bound is tight, up to an additive constant.

We conduct a computability-theoretic study of Ramsey-like theorems of the form "Every coloring of the edges of an infinite clique admits an infinite sub-clique avoiding some pattern", with a particular focus on transitive patterns. As it turns out, the patterns corresponding to separable permutations play an important role in the computational features of the statement. We prove that the avoidance of any separable permutation is equivalent to the existence of an infinite homogeneous set in standard models, while this property fails for any other pattern. For this, we develop a novel argument for relativized diagonal non-computation.

The family of finite subsets $s$ of the natural numbers such that $|s|=1+\min s$ is known as the Schreier barrier in combinatorics and Banach Space theory, and as the family of exactly $ω$-large sets in Logic. We formulate and prove the generalizations of Friedman's Free Set and Thin Set theorems and of Rainbow Ramsey's theorem to colorings of the Schreier barrier. We analyze the strength of these theorems from the point of view of Computability Theory and Reverse Mathematics. Surprisingly, the exactly $ω$-large counterparts of the Thin Set and Free Set theorems can code $\emptyset^{(ω)}$, while the exactly $ω$-large Rainbow Ramsey theorem does not code the halting set.