arXiv++ Combinatorics

By Tutte's classic theorem of 1956 that every 4-connected planar graph is Hamiltonian, every planar graph of order at least three with toughness greater than $\frac{3}{2}$ is Hamiltonian. In 1999, Owens constructed a sequence of maximal planar graphs whose toughness approaches $\frac{3}{2}$ from below and which do not contain even a 2-factor, and he asked whether there exists a maximal planar graph with toughness exactly $\frac{3}{2}$ and with no 2-factor. In 2025, Shan constructed a $\frac{3}{2}$-tough plane triangulation with no 2-factor. In that construction, there are many pairs of vertices of degree $3$ that have a common neighbor. By imposing a distance condition on the vertices of degree $3$, Hao, Ma, Shan, and Yang recently proved that every $\frac{3}{2}$-tough plane triangulation of order at least three whose vertices of degree $3$ are pairwise at distance at least $3$ has a 2-factor, and they asked whether every such graph is Hamiltonian. We answer this question in the negative, and in fact prove the following stronger statement: for every positive integer $\ell$, there exists a $\frac{3}{2}$-tough non-Hamiltonian plane triangulation whose vertices of degree $3$ are pairwise at distance at least $\ell$. Thus, although the distance condition guarantees the existence of a 2-factor, it does not guarantee that the graph is Hamiltonian: the essential obstruction to a Hamiltonian cycle is a certain local configuration involving a vertex of degree $3$, rather than the proximity of such configurations in the graph.

By work of Enomoto, Jackson, Katerinis, and Saito from 1985, every $2$-tough graph has a $2$-factor, and this toughness bound is best possible: for every $\varepsilon>0$, there exist $(2-\varepsilon)$-tough graphs with no $2$-factor. It is natural to ask whether the latter statement remains true for triangle-free graphs. Bauer, van den Heuvel, and Schmeichel conjectured this in 1996. In the same paper, they proposed an infinite family of triangle-free graphs with no $2$-factor whose toughness they believed approaches $2$, but the required toughness bound was not established. In this paper, we confirm their conjecture. For every even integer $q\ge 6$, we construct a triangle-free graph $G_q$ with no $2$-factor and with toughness \[ τ(G_q) =\frac{2q^2-q-2}{q^2+q} =2-\frac{3q+2}{q^2+q}. \] In particular, $τ(G_q)\to 2$ as $q\to\infty$, showing that the threshold $2$ for the existence of a $2$-factor remains best possible even within the class of triangle-free graphs.

Let $D$ be a digraph. In this note, an \emph{arc coloring} of $D$ is an assignment of colors to the arcs of $D$ such that no two arcs with a common tail receive the same color and no two arcs with a common head receive the same color. Under such a coloring, each vertex $v$ is associated with an \emph{out-color set} and an \emph{in-color set}, consisting of the colors assigned to the arcs with tail $v$ and to the arcs with head $v$, respectively. An arc coloring of $D$ is \emph{vertex-distinguishing} if any two distinct vertices have different out-color sets and different in-color sets. The minimum number of colors required for a vertex-distinguishing arc coloring of $D$ is called the \emph{vertex-distinguishing chromatic index} of $D$, denoted $χ_{vd}^{\prime}(D)$. In 2016, Li, Bai, He, and Sun conjectured that $χ_{vd}^{\prime}(D)=k(D)$ for any digraph $D$ with at most one source and at most one sink, where $k(D)$ is a natural lower bound determined by the outdegree and indegree sequences of $D$. We confirm this conjecture.

Let $G$ be a simple graph with maximum degree $Δ(G)$. A subgraph $H\subseteq G$ is $Δ(G)$-overfull if $|E(H)|>Δ(G)\left\lfloor |V(H)|/2\right\rfloor$. In any edge coloring of $G$, each color class restricted to $H$ is a matching of size at most $\left\lfloor |V(H)|/2\right\rfloor$. Thus, if $G$ contains a $Δ(G)$-overfull subgraph, then $G$ cannot be edge-colored with only $Δ(G)$ colors. By Vizing's Theorem, $χ'(G)\le Δ(G)+1$, and hence $G$ is class $2$. In 1986, Chetwynd and Hilton conjectured that whenever $Δ(G)>|V(G)|/3$, the converse also holds: every class $2$ graph $G$ contains a $Δ(G)$-overfull subgraph. This statement, commonly known as the Overfull Conjecture, is one of the most influential conjectures in graph edge coloring. It would imply a polynomial-time algorithm for determining the chromatic index of graphs $G$ with $Δ(G)>|V(G)|/3$, and would also imply several other longstanding conjectures in the area, including the Just-overfull Conjecture and the Vertex-splitting Conjecture. In previous work, the third author verified the conjecture for large graphs $G$ with maximum degree at least $13|V(G)|/14$. In this paper, we confirm the conjecture for robust expanders satisfying certain density constraints. As a consequence, for every $0<\varepsilon<1$, the conjecture holds for all sufficiently large graphs $G$ with maximum degree at least $(1+\varepsilon)|V(G)|/2$.

A graph $G$ with maximum degree $Δ$ is $Δ$-critical if it is connected, satisfies $χ'(G)=Δ+1$, and the deletion of any edge reduces its chromatic index to $Δ$. A $Δ$-critical graph $G$ is called nontrivial if it contains no $Δ$-overfull subgraph; that is, no $H \subseteq G$ such that $|E(H)| > Δ\lfloor |V(H)| /2 \rfloor$. There are no $1$-critical graphs, and the $2$-critical graphs are exactly the odd cycles. By work of Chetwynd and Yap from 1983, there is a unique nontrivial $3$-critical graph of order $9$, and exactly two nontrivial $3$-critical graphs of order $11$. In 2005, Bokal, Brinkmann, and Grünewald showed that there are exactly fourteen nontrivial $3$-critical graphs of order $13$. For even orders, Brinkmann and Steffen proved in 1997 that no $3$-critical graphs of even order exist below order $22$, there is exactly one 3-critical graph of order $22$, and that there are exactly nine $3$-critical graphs of order $24$. To the best of our knowledge, there has been no further progress on the existence of nontrivial $3$-critical graphs of odd orders beyond the cases established two decades ago. In this paper, using computer-assisted search techniques, we determine the exact numbers of nontrivial $3$-critical graphs of odd orders from $15$ to $21$. The same data pipeline also reproduces the known order-$22$ count of Brinkmann and Steffen, with one nontrivial $3$-critical graph. Beyond enumeration, we prove a characterization theorem for all nontrivial 3-critical graphs, with one case based on snarks. We also provide an analysis of our search algorithm.

Let $k \in \mathbb{N}$ and let $G$ be a simple graph with maximum degree $Δ$. A $k$-colouring $\varphi$ of $G$ is an assignment of colours from $\{1,2,\ldots,k\}$ to the vertices of $G$. We call $\varphi$ proper if adjacent vertices receive distinct colours, and equitable if the sizes of any two colour classes differ by at most one. The celebrated Hajnal--Szemerédi theorem states that a proper equitable $k$-colouring exists whenever $k \ge Δ+ 1$. In this paper, we study its tree colouring variant in which each colour class induces a forest. This is closely related to the vertex arboricity which was introduced by Chartrand, Kronk, and Wall. More precisely, we prove that if $n \ge 3Δ^4$ and $k \ge (Δ+2)/2$, then every $n$-vertex graph with maximum degree at most $Δ$ contains an equitable tree $k$-colouring. This confirms a conjecture of Wu, Zhang, and Li when $Δ$ is even and up to an additive constant of $1$ otherwise for large $n$. We also consider $d$-degenerate colouring in which each colour class induces a $d$-degenerate graph.

Let $k \ge 1$ be an integer and let $G$ be a nonempty simple graph. An \emph{edge-$k$-coloring} $\varphi$ of $G$ is an assignment of colors from $\{1,\ldots,k\}$ to the edges of $G$ such that no two adjacent edges receive the same color. For a vertex $v \in V(G)$, we write $\varphi(v)$ for the set of colors assigned to the edges incident with $v$. The coloring $\varphi$ is called \emph{vertex-distinguishing} if $\varphi(u) \ne \varphi(v)$ for every pair of distinct vertices $u,v \in V(G)$. A vertex-distinguishing edge-$k$-coloring exists if and only if $G$ has at most one isolated vertex and no isolated edge. The least integer $k$ for which such a coloring exists is called the \emph{vertex-distinguishing chromatic index} of $G$, denoted $χ'_{vd}(G)$. In 1997, Burris and Schelp conjectured that for every graph $G$ with at most one isolated vertex and no isolated edge, $ k(G) \;\le\; χ'_{vd}(G) \;\le\; k(G)+1$, where $k(G)$ is the natural lower bound required for a vertex-distinguishing coloring in $G$. In 2004, Balister, Kostochka, Li, and Schelp verified the conjecture for graphs $G$ satisfying $Δ(G) \ge \sqrt{2|V(G)|} + 4 $ and $δ(G) \ge 5$. For graphs that do not satisfy these conditions, the best known general upper bound on $χ'_{vd}(G)$ remains $|V(G)| + 1$, established in 1999 by Bazgan, Harkat-Benhamdine, Li, and Woźniak. In this paper, we prove that $χ'_{vd}(G) \le \floor{5.5k(G)+6.5}$, which represents a substantial improvement over the bound $|V(G)| + 1$ whenever $k(G) = o(|V(G)|)$. We further show that $χ'_{vd}(G) \le k(G) + 3$, for all $d$-regular graphs $G$ with $d \ge \log_2 |V(G)|\geq 8$.

Let $n\in \mathbb{N}$ and $d_1 \geq d_2 \geq d_n\geq 1$ be integers. There is characterization of when $(d_1, d_1, \ldots, d_n)$ is the degree sequence of a graph containing a perfect matching, due to results of Lovász (1974) and Erdős and Gallai (1960). But \emph{which} perfect matchings can be realized in the labelled graph? Here we find the extremal answers to this question, showing that the sequence $(d_1, d_2, \ldots, d_n)$: (1) can realize a perfect matching iff it can realize $\{(1, n), (2,n-1), \ldots, (n/2, n/2+1)\}$, and; (2) can realize any perfect matching iff it can realize $\{(1, 2), (3,4), \ldots, (n-1, n)\}$. Our main result is a characterization of when (2) occurs, extending the work of Lovász and Erdős and Gallai. Separately, we are also able to establish a conjecture of Yin and Busch, Ferrera, Hartke, Jacobsen, Kaul, and West about packing graphic sequences, establishing a degree-sequence analog of the Sauer-Spencer packing theorem. We conjecture an $h$-factor analog of our main result, and discuss implications for packing $h$ disjoint perfect matchings.

We give a uniform and self-contained proof that if $G$ is a connected graph with $χ(G) = Δ(G)$ and $G\neq \overline{C_7}$, then $G$ contains either $K_{Δ(G)}$ or an odd hole where every vertex has degree at least $Δ(G)-1$ in $G$. This was previously proved in series of two papers by Chen, Lan, Lin, and Zhou, who used the Strong Perfect Graph Theorem for the cases $Δ(G)=4, 5, 6$.

We prove that for all $\varepsilon>0$, there exists a positive integer $n_0$ such that if $G$ is a graph on $n\geq n_0$ vertices with $δ(G)\geq\tfrac{1}{2}(1 + \varepsilon)n$, then $G$ satisfies the Total Coloring Conjecture, that is, $χ_T(G)\leq Δ(G)+2$.

The toughness of a graph $G$ is defined as the minimum value of $|S|/c(G-S)$ over all cutsets $S$ of $G$ if $G$ is noncomplete, and is defined to be $\infty$ if $G$ is complete. For a real number $t$, we say that $G$ is $t$-tough if its toughness is at least $t$. Followed from the classic 1956 result of Tutte, every more than $\frac{3}{2}$-tough planar graph on at least three vertices has a 2-factor. In 1999, Owens constructed a sequence of maximal planar graphs with toughness $\frac{3}{2}-\varepsilon$ for any $\varepsilon >0$, but the graphs do not contain any 2-factor. He then posed the question of whether there exists a maximal planar graph with toughness exactly $\frac{3}{2}$ and with no 2-factor. This question was recently answered affirmatively by the third author. This naturally leads to the question: under what conditions does a $\frac{3}{2}$-tough maximal planar graph contain a 2-factor? In this paper, we provide a sufficient condition for the existence of 2-factors in $\frac{3}{2}$-tough maximal planar graphs, stated as a bound on the distance between vertices of degree 3.

In 1973, Chvátal conjectured that there exists a constant $t_0$ such that every $t_0$-tough graph on at least three vertices is Hamiltonian. While this conjecture is still open, work has been done to confirm it for several graph classes, including all $F$-free graphs for every 5-vertex linear forest $F$ other than $P_5$ and $2P_2\cup P_1$. In this note, we show that 11-tough $(2P_2 \cup P_1)$-free graphs on at least three vertices are Hamiltonian.

In 1973, Chvátal conjectured that there exists a constant $t_0$ such that every $t_0$-tough graph on at least three vertices is Hamiltonian. This conjecture has inspired extensive research and has been verified for several special classes of graphs. Notably, Jung in 1978 proved that every 1-tough $P_4$-free graph on at least three vertices is Hamiltonian. However, the problem remains challenging even when restricted to graphs with no induced $P_4\cup P_1$, the disjoint union of a path on four vertices and a one-vertex path. In 2013, Nikoghosyan conjectured that every 1-tough $(P_4\cup P_1)$-free graph on at least three vertices is Hamiltonian. Later in 2015, Broersma remarked that ``this question seems to be very hard to answer, even if we impose a higher toughness." He instead posed the following question: ``Is the general conjecture of Chvátal's true for $(P_4\cup P_1)$-free graphs?" We provide a positive answer to Broersma's question by establishing that every $23$-tough $(P_4\cup P_1)$-free graph on at least three vertices is Hamiltonian.

Generalizing Chvátal's classic 1972 result, Hoàng proposed in 1995 the following conjecture, which strengthens Chvátal's result in terms of toughness: Let $t\ge 1$ be a positive integer and $G$ be a $t$-tough graph on $n \ge 3$ vertices with degree sequence $d_1, d_2, \dots, d_n$ in non-increasing order. Suppose for each $i\in [1, \lfloor\frac{n-1}{2} \rfloor]$, if $d_i \le i \text{ and } d_{n-i+t} < n - i $ implies $d_j + d_{n-j+t} \ge n$ for all $j\in [i+1, \lfloor\frac{n-1}{2} \rfloor]$, then $G$ is Hamiltonian. Hoàng verified the conjecture for $t=1$. In this paper, we verfity the conjecture for all $t\ge 4$. Our proof relies on a toughness closure lemma for $t\ge 4$ that we previously established. Additionally, we show that the toughness closure lemma does not hold when $t=1$.

Given an integer $k\ge1$, an edge-$k$-coloring of a graph $G$ is an assignment of $k$ colors $1,\ldots,k$ to the edges of $G$ such that no two adjacent edges receive the same color. A vertex-distinguishing (resp. sum-distinguishing) edge-$k$-coloring of $G$ is an edge-$k$-coloring such that for any two distinct vertices $u$ and $v$, the set (resp. sum) of colors taken from all the edges incident with $u$ is different from that taken from all the edges incident with $v$. The vertex-distinguishing chromatic index (resp. sum-distinguishing chromatic index), denoted $χ'_{vd}(G)$ (resp. $χ'_{sd}(G)$), is the smallest value $k$ such that $G$ has a vertex-distinguishing-edge-$k$-coloring (resp. sum-distinguishing-edge-$k$-coloring). Let $G$ be a $d$-regular graph on $n$ vertices, where $n$ is even and sufficiently large. We show that $χ'_{vd}(G) =d+2$ if $d$ is arbitrarily close to $n/2$ from above, and $χ'_{sd}(G) =d+2$ if $d\ge \frac{2n}{3}$. Our first result strengthens a result of Balister et al. in 2004 for such class of regular graphs, and our second result constitutes a significant advancement in the field of sum-distinguishing edge coloring. To achieve these results, we introduce novel edge coloring results which may be of independent interest.

Let $G$ be a graph (with multiple edges allowed) and let $T$ be a tree in $G$. We say that $T$ is $\textit{even}$ if every leaf of $T$ belongs to the same part of the bipartition of $T$, and that $T$ is $\textit{weakly even}$ if every leaf of $T$ that has maximum degree in $G$ belongs to the same part of the bipartition of $T$. We confirm two recent conjectures of Jackson and Yoshimoto by showing that every connected graph that is not a regular bipartite graph has a spanning weakly even tree.

Let $H$ be a 2-regular graph and let $G$ be obtained from $H$ by gluing in vertex-disjoint copies of $K_4$. The "cycles plus $K_4$'s" problem is to show that $G$ is 4-colourable; this is a special case of the \emph{Strong Colouring Conjecture}. In this paper we reduce the "cycles plus $K_4$'s" problem to a specific 3-colourability problem. In the 3-colourability problem, vertex-disjoint triangles are glued (in a limited way) onto a disjoint union of triangles and paths of length at most 12, and we ask for 3-colourability of the resulting graph.

In 1980, Akiyama, Exoo, and Harary conjectured that any graph $G$ can be decomposed into at most $\lceil(Δ(G)+1)/2\rceil$ linear forests. We confirm the conjecture for robust expanders of linear minimum degree. As a consequence, the conjecture holds for dense quasirandom graphs of linear minimum degree as well as for large $n$-vertex graphs with minimum degree arbitrarily close to $n/2$ from above.

We prove that for any graph $G$, the total chromatic number of $G$ is at most $Δ(G)+2\left\lceil \frac{|V(G)|}{Δ(G)+1} \right\rceil$. This saves one color in comparison with a result of Hind from 1992. In particular, our result says that if $Δ(G)\ge \frac{1}{2}|V(G)|$, then $G$ has a total coloring using at most $Δ(G)+4$ colors. When $G$ is regular and has a sufficient number of vertices, we can actually save an additional two colors. Specifically, we prove that for any $0<\varepsilon <1$, there exists $n_0\in \mathbb{N}$ such that: if $G$ is an $r$-regular graph on $n \ge n_0$ vertices with $r\ge \frac{1}{2}(1+\varepsilon) n$, then $χ_T(G) \le Δ(G)+2$. This confirms the Total Coloring Conjecture for such graphs $G$.

Generalizing both Dirac's condition and Ore's condition for Hamilton cycles, Chvátal in 1972 established a degree sequence condition for the existence of a Hamilton cycle in a graph. Hoàng in 1995 generalized Chvátal's degree sequence condition for 1-tough graphs and conjectured a $t$-tough analogue for any positive integer $t\ge 1$. Hoàng in the same paper verified his conjecture for $t\le 3$ and recently Hoàng and Robin verified the conjecture for $t=4$. In this paper, we confirm the conjecture for all $t\ge 4$. The proof depends on two newly established results on cycle structures in tough graphs, which hold independent interest.