arXiv++ Combinatorics

The third problem in Ben Green's collection of 100 open problems asks whether an open subset of $(0,1)$ that does not contain $x,y,z$ with $xy=z$ must have measure at most 1/3. We give an affirmative answer to this question. As part of the proof we obtain a result of independent interest that gives a lower bound for the size of the sumset and the difference set of a set of reals in terms not just of its size but also of a parameter that measures how far it is from being an interval.

We present a short, digested, human-verified version of the recent OpenAI-generated counterexample to the Erdős unit distance conjecture, and a sequence of reflections on it. The argument relies crucially on ideas that may, at least in retrospect, be attributed to Ellenberg-Venkatesh, Golod-Shafarevich, and Hajir-Maire-Ramakrishna.

We prove a Freiman--Ruzsa-type theorem with polynomial bounds in arbitrary abelian groups with bounded torsion, thereby proving (in full generality) a conjecture of Marton. Specifically, let $G$ be an abelian group of torsion $m$ (meaning $mg=0$ for all $g \in G$) and suppose that $A$ is a non-empty subset of $G$ with $|A+A| \leq K|A|$. Then $A$ can be covered by at most $(2K)^{O(m^3)}$ translates of a subgroup of $H \leq G$ of cardinality at most $|A|$. The argument is a variant of that used in the case $G = \mathbf{F}_2^n$ in a recent paper of the authors.

We prove a conjecture of K. Marton, widely known as the polynomial Freiman--Ruzsa conjecture, in characteristic $2$. The argument extends to odd characteristic, with details to follow in a subsequent paper.

Let $p$ be a prime, let $S$ be a non-empty subset of $\mathbb{F}_p$ and let $0<ε\leq 1$. We show that there exists a constant $C=C(p, ε)$ such that for every positive integer $k$, whenever $φ_1, \dots, φ_k: \mathbb{F}_p^n \rightarrow \mathbb{F}_p$ are linear forms and $E_1, \dots, E_k$ are subsets of $\mathbb{F}_p$, there exist linear forms $ψ_1, \dots, ψ_C: \mathbb{F}_p^n \rightarrow \mathbb{F}_p$ and subsets $F_1, \dots, F_C$ of $\mathbb{F}_p$ such that the set $U=\{x \in S^n: ψ_1(x) \in F_1, \dots, ψ_C(x) \in F_C\}$ is contained inside the set $V=\{x \in S^n: φ_1(x) \in E_1, \dots, φ_k(x) \in E_k\}$, and the difference $V \setminus U$ has density at most $ε$ inside $S^n$. We then generalize this result to one where $φ_1, \dots, φ_k$ are replaced by homomorphisms $G^n \to H$ for some pair of finite Abelian groups $G$ and $H$, and to another where they are replaced by polynomial maps $\mathbb{F}_p^n \to \mathbb{F}_p$ of small degree.

Let $p$ be a prime and let $S$ be a non-empty subset of $\mathbb{F}_p$. Generalizing a result of Green and Tao on the equidistribution of high-rank polynomials over finite fields, we show that if $P: \mathbb{F}_p^n \rightarrow \mathbb{F}_p$ is a polynomial and its restriction to $S^n$ does not take each value with approximately the same frequency, then there exists a polynomial $P_0: \mathbb{F}_p^n \rightarrow \mathbb{F}_p$ that vanishes on $S^n$, such that the polynomial $P-P_0$ has bounded rank. Our argument uses two black boxes: that a tensor with high partition rank has high analytic rank and that a tensor with high essential partition rank has high disjoint partition rank.

We show that the slice rank of the direct sum of two tensors is equal to the sum of their slice ranks. The upper bound is trivial, but the lower bound needs more than a one-line proof, for reasons we explain. This result generalizes the fact, shown by Tao, that the slice rank of a diagonal tensor is equal to the number of non-zero entries of that tensor.

An example is presented of a subset $A$ of $\mathbb Z_N$ of density $α$ such that the largest non-trivial Fourier coefficient of the characteristic function of $A$ is very small, but the probability that a random arithmetic progression (mod $N$) of length 4 lies in $A$ is significantly smaller than $α^4$.

Considering a natural generalization of the Ruzsa-Szemerédi problem, we prove that for any fixed positive integers $r,s$ with $r<s$, there are graphs on $n$ vertices containing $n^{r}e^{-O(\sqrt{\log{n}})}=n^{r-o(1)}$ copies of $K_s$ such that any $K_r$ is contained in at most one $K_s$. We also give bounds for the generalized rainbow Turán problem $\operatorname{ex}(n, H,$rainbow-$F)$ when $F$ is complete. In particular, we answer a question of Gerbner, Mészáros, Methuku and Palmer, showing that there are properly edge-coloured graphs on $n$ vertices with $n^{r-1-o(1)}$ copies of $K_r$ such that no $K_r$ is rainbow.

Let $G_1, \dots, G_k$ and $H$ be vector spaces over a finite field $\mathbb{F}_p$ of prime order. Let $A \subset G_1 \times\dots\times G_k$ be a set of size $δ|G_1| \cdots |G_k|$. Let a map $φ\colon A \to H$ be a multi-homomorphism, meaning that for each direction $d \in [k]$, and each element $(x_1, \dots, x_{d-1}, x_{d+1}, \dots, x_k)$ of $G_1\times\dots\times G_{d-1}\times G_{d+1}\times \dots\times G_k$, the map that sends each $y_d$ such that $(x_1, \dots,$ $x_{d-1},$ $y_d,$ $x_{d+1}, \dots,$ $x_k) \in A$ to $φ(x_1, \dots,$ $x_{d-1},$ $y_d,$ $x_{d+1}, \dots,$ $x_k)$ is a Freiman homomorphism (of order 2). In this paper, we prove that for each such map, there is a multiaffine map $Φ\colon G_1 \times\dots\times G_k \to H$ such that $φ= Φ$ on a set of density $\Big(\exp^{(O_k(1))}(O_{k,p}(δ^{-1}))\Big)^{-1}$, where $\exp^{(t)}$ denotes the $t$-fold exponential. Applications of this theorem include: $\bullet$ a quantitative inverse theorem for approximate polynomials mapping $G$ to $H$, for finite-dimensional $\mathbb{F}_p$-vector spaces $G$ and $H$, in the high-characteristic case, $\bullet$ a quantitative inverse theorem for uniformity norms over finite fields in the high-characteristic case, and $\bullet$ a quantitative structure theorem for dense subsets of $G_1 \times\dots\times G_k$ that are subspaces in the principal directions (without additional characteristic assumptions).

Let $G_1, \dots, G_k$ be finite-dimensional vector spaces over a finite field $\mathbb{F}$. A multilinear variety of codimension $d$ is a subset of $G_1 \times \dots \times G_k$ defined as the zero set of $d$ forms, each of which is multilinear on some subset of the coordinates. A map $φ$ defined on a multilinear variety $B$ is multilinear if for each coordinate $d$ and all choices of $x_i \in G_i$, $i\not=d$, the restriction map $y \mapsto φ(x_1, \dots, x_{d-1}, y, x_{d+1}, \dots, x_k)$ is linear where defined. In this note, we show that a multilinear map defined on a multilinear variety of codimension $d$ coincides on a multilinear variety of codimension $d^{O(1)}$ with a multilinear map defined on the whole of $G_1\times\dots\times G_k$.

Suppose that a binary operation $\circ$ on a finite set $X$ is injective in each variable separately and also associative. It is easy to prove that $(X,\circ)$ must be a group. In this paper we examine what happens if one knows only that a positive proportion of the triples $(x,y,z)\in X^3$ satisfy the equation $x\circ(y\circ z)=(x\circ y)\circ z$. Other results in additive combinatorics would lead one to expect that there must be an underlying "group-like" structure that is responsible for the large number of associative triples. We prove that this is indeed the case: there must be a proportional-sized subset of the multiplication table that approximately agrees with part of the multiplication table of a metric group. We also present an example that suggests that our result cannot be strengthened to yield a dense subset that agrees with part of the multiplication table of a group.

Let $G$ be a regular graph of degree $d$ and let $A\subset V(G)$. Say that $A$ is $η$-closed if the average degree of the subgraph induced by $A$ is at least $ηd$. This says that if we choose a random vertex $x\in A$ and a random neighbour $y$ of $x$, then the probability that $y\in A$ is at least $η$. The work of this paper was motivated by an attempt to obtain a qualitative description of closed subsets of the Cayley graph $Γ$ whose vertex set is $\mathbb F_2^{n_1}\otimes \dots \otimes \mathbb F_2^{n_d}$ with two vertices joined by an edge if their difference is of the form $u_1\otimes \cdots \otimes u_d$. For the matrix case (that is, when $d=2$), such a description was obtained by Khot, Minzer and Safra, a breakthrough that completed the proof of the 2-to-2 conjecture. In this paper, we formulate a conjecture for higher dimensions, and prove it in an important special case. Also, we identify a statement about $η$-closed sets in Cayley graphs on arbitrary finite Abelian groups that implies the conjecture and can be considered as a "highly asymmetric Balog-Szemerédi-Gowers theorem" when it holds. We conclude the paper by showing that this statement is not true for an arbitrary Cayley graph. It remains to decide whether the statement can be proved for the Cayley graph $Γ$.

The Erdős-Rogers function $f_{s,t}$ measures how large a $K_s$-free induced subgraph there must be in a $K_t$-free graph on $n$ vertices. While good estimates for $f_{s,t}$ are known for some pairs $(s,t)$, notably when $t=s+1$, in general there are significant gaps between the best known upper and lower bounds. We improve the upper bounds when $s+2\leq t\leq 2s-1$. For each such pair we obtain for the first time a proof that $f_{s,t}\leq n^{α_{s,t}+o(1)}$ with an exponent $α_{s,t}<1/2$, answering a question of Dudek, Retter and Rödl.

Let $G$ be the special linear group $\mathrm{SL}(2,q)$. We show that if $(a_1,\ldots,a_t)$ and $(b_1,\ldots,b_t)$ are sampled uniformly from large subsets $A$ and $B$ of $G^t$ then their interleaved product $a_1 b_1 a_2 b_2 \cdots a_t b_t$ is nearly uniform over $G$. This extends a result of the first author, which corresponds to the independent case where $A$ and $B$ are product sets. We obtain a number of other results. For example, we show that if $X$ is a probability distribution on $G^m$ such that any two coordinates are uniform in $G^2$, then a pointwise product of $s$ independent copies of $X$ is nearly uniform in $G^m$, where $s$ depends on $m$ only. Extensions to other groups are also discussed. We obtain closely related results in communication complexity, which is the setting where some of these questions were first asked by Miles and Viola. For example, suppose party $A_i$ of $k$ parties $A_1,\dots,A_k$ receives on its forehead a $t$-tuple $(a_{i1},\dots,a_{it})$ of elements from $G$. The parties are promised that the interleaved product $a_{11}\dots a_{k1}a_{12}\dots a_{k2}\dots a_{1t}\dots a_{kt}$ is equal either to the identity $e$ or to some other fixed element $g\in G$, and their goal is to determine which of the two the product is equal to. We show that for all fixed $k$ and all sufficiently large $t$ the communication is $Ω(t \log |G|)$, which is tight. Even for $k=2$ the previous best lower bound was $Ω(t)$. As an application, we establish the security of the leakage-resilient circuits studied by Miles and Viola in the "only computation leaks" model.

A remarkable result of Bergelson, Tao and Ziegler implies that if $c>0$, $k$ is a positive integer, $p\geq k$ is a prime, $n$ is sufficiently large, and $f:\mathbb F_p^n\to\mathbb C$ is a function with $\|f\|_\infty\leq 1$ and $\|f\|_{U^k}\geq c$, then there is a polynomial $π$ of degree at most $k-1$ such that $\mathbb E_xf(x)ω^{-π(x)}\geq c'$, where $ω=\exp(2πi/p)$ and $c'>0$ is a constant that depends on $c,k$ and $p$ only. A version of this result for low-characteristic was also proved by Tao and Ziegler. The proofs of these results do not yield a lower bound for $c'$. Here we give a different proof in the high-characteristic case when $k=4$, which enables us to give an explicit estimate for $c'$. The bound we obtain is roughly doubly exponential in the other parameters.

A theorem of Bogolyubov states that for every dense set $A$ in $\mathbb{Z}_N$ we may find a large Bohr set inside $A+A-A-A$. In this note, motivated by the work on a quantitative inverse theorem for the Gowers $U^4$ norm, we prove a bilinear variant of this result in vector spaces over finite fields. Namely, if we start with a dense set $A \subset \mathbb{F}^n_p \times \mathbb{F}^n_p$ and then take rows (respectively columns) of $A$ and change each row (respectively column) to the set difference of it with itself, repeating this procedure several times, we obtain a bilinear analogue of a Bohr set inside the resulting set, namely the zero set of a biaffine map from $\mathbb{F}^n_p \times \mathbb{F}^n_p$ to a $\mathbb{F}_p$-vector space of bounded dimension. An almost identical result was proved independently by Bienvenu and Lê.

We prove a number of results related to a problem of Po-Shen Loh, which is equivalent to a problem in Ramsey theory. Let $a=(a_1,a_2,a_3)$ and $b=(b_1,b_2,b_3)$ be two triples of integers. Define $a$ to be 2-less than $b$ if $a_i<b_i$ for at least two values of $i$, and define a sequence $a^1,\dots,a^m$ of triples to be 2-increasing if $a^r$ is 2-less than $a^s$ whenever $r<s$. Loh asks how long a 2-increasing sequence can be if all the triples take values in $\{1,2,\dots,n\}$, and gives a $\log_*$ improvement over the trivial upper bound of $n^2$ by using the triangle removal lemma. In the other direction, a simple construction gives a lower bound of $n^{3/2}$. We look at this problem and a collection of generalizations, improving some of the known bounds, pointing out connections to other well known problems in extremal combinatorics, and asking a number of further questions.

This is a survey of the use of Fourier analysis in additive combinatorics, with a particular focus on situations where it cannot be straightforwardly applied, but needs to be generalized first. Sometimes very satisfactory generalizations exist, while sometimes we have to make do with theories that have some of the desirable properties of Fourier analysis but not all of them. In the latter case, there are intriguing hints that there may be more satisfactory theories yet to be discovered. This article grew out of the Colloquium Lectures at the Joint Meeting of the AMS and the MAA, given in Seattle in January 2016.

A result of Fiz Pontiveros shows that if $A$ is a random subset of $\mathbb{Z}_N$ where each element is chosen independently with probability $N^{-1/2+o(1)}$, then with high probability every Freiman homomorphism defined on $A$ can be extended to a Freiman homomorphism on the whole of $\mathbb{Z}_N$. In this paper we improve the bound to $CN^{-2/3}(\log N)^{1/3}$, which is best possible up to the constant factor.