arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $M$ be a simple connected binary matroid, and let $e$ and $f$ be distinct elements of $M$. It is well known that, when the only circuits containing $e$ are spanning, $M$ is a circuit with at least three elements. This paper proves that if every circuit containing $\{e,f\}$ is spanning, then the canonical tree decomposition of $M$ is a path in which each vertex is labeled by a circuit, a copy of $U_{1,3}$, or a binary spike having one non-tip element deleted.

In 1963, Halin and Jung proved that every simple graph with minimum degree at least four has $K_5$ or $K_{2,2,2}$ as a minor. Mills and Turner proved an analog of this theorem by showing that every $3$-connected binary matroid in which every cocircuit has size at least four has $F_7, M^*(K_{3,3}), M(K_5),$ or $ M(K_{2,2,2})$ as a minor. Generalizing these results, this paper proves that every simple matroid in which all cocircuits have at least four elements has as a minor one of nine matroids, seven of which are well known. All nine of these special matroids have rank at most five and have at most twelve elements.

Halin proved that every minimally $k$-connected graph has a vertex of degree $k$. More generally, does every minimally vertically $k$-connected matroid have a $k$-element cocircuit? Results of Murty and Wong give an affirmative answer when $k \le 3$. We show that every minimally vertically $4$-connected matroid with at least six elements has a $4$-element cocircuit, or a $5$-element cocircuit that contains a triangle, with the exception of a specific non-binary $9$-element matroid. Consequently, every minimally vertically $4$-connected binary matroid with at least six elements has a $4$-element cocircuit.

Given an $n$-connected binary matroid, we obtain a necessary and sufficient condition for its single-element coextensions to be $n$-connected.

Let $M$ be an internally $4$-connected binary matroid with every element in three triangles. Then $M$ has at least four elements $e$ such that si$(M/e)$ is internally 4-connected.

Let $M$ be a $3$-connected binary matroid; $M$ is called internally $4$-connected if one side of every $3$-separation is a triangle or a triad, and $M$ is $(4,4,S)$-connected if one side of every $3$-separation is a triangle, a triad, or a $4$-element fan. Assume $M$ is internally $4$-connected and that neither $M$ nor its dual is a cubic Möbius or planar ladder or a certain coextension thereof. Let $N$ be an internally $4$-connected proper minor of $M$. Our aim is to show that $M$ has a proper internally $4$-connected minor with an $N$-minor that can be obtained from $M$ either by removing at most four elements, or by removing elements in an easily described way from a special substructure of $M$. When this aim cannot be met, the earlier papers in this series showed that, up to duality, $M$ has a good bowtie, that is, a pair, $\{x_1,x_2,x_3\}$ and $\{x_4,x_5,x_6\}$, of disjoint triangles and a cocircuit, $\{x_2,x_3,x_4,x_5\}$, where $M\backslash x_3$ has an $N$-minor and is $(4,4,S)$-connected. We also showed that, when $M$ has a good bowtie, either $M\backslash x_3,x_6$ has an $N$-minor; or $M\backslash x_3/x_2$ has an $N$-minor and is $(4,4,S)$-connected. In this paper, we show that, when $M\backslash x_3,x_6$ has an $N$-minor but is not $(4,4,S)$-connected, $M$ has an internally $4$-connected proper minor with an $N$-minor that can be obtained from $M$ by removing at most three elements, or by removing elements in a well-described way from one of several special substructures of $M$. This is a significant step towards obtaining a splitter theorem for the class of internally $4$-connected binary matroids.

Let $M$ be a $3$-connected binary matroid; $M$ is internally $4$-connected if one side of every $3$-separation is a triangle or a triad, and $M$ is $(4,4,S)$-connected if one side of every $3$-separation is a triangle, a triad, or a $4$-element fan. Assume $M$ is internally $4$-connected and that neither $M$ nor its dual is a cubic Möbius or planar ladder or a certain coextension thereof. Let $N$ be an internally $4$-connected proper minor of $M$. Our aim is to show that $M$ has a proper internally $4$-connected minor with an $N$-minor that can be obtained from $M$ either by removing at most four elements, or by removing elements in an easily described way from a special substructure of $M$. When this aim cannot be met, the earlier papers in this series showed that, up to duality, $M$ has a good bowtie, that is, a pair, $\{x_1,x_2,x_3\}$ and $\{x_4,x_5,x_6\}$, of disjoint triangles and a cocircuit, $\{x_2,x_3,x_4,x_5\}$, where $M\backslash x_3$ has an $N$-minor and is \ffsc. We also showed that, when $M$ has a good bowtie, either $M\backslash x_3,x_6$ has an $N$-minor and $M\backslash x_6$ is $(4,4,S)$-connected; or $M\backslash x_3/x_2$ has an $N$-minor and is \ffsc. In this paper, we show that, when $M\backslash x_3,x_6$ has no $N$-minor, $M$ has an internally $4$-connected proper minor with an $N$-minor that can be obtained from $M$ by removing at most three elements, or by removing elements in a well-described way from a special substructure of $M$. This is the penultimate step towards obtaining a splitter theorem for the class of internally $4$-connected binary matroids.

Our splitter theorem for internally 4-connected binary matroids studies pairs of the form (M,N), where N and M are internally 4-connected binary matroids, M has a proper N-minor, and if M' is an internally 4-connected matroid such that M has a proper M'-minor and M' has an N-minor, then |E(M)|-|E(M')|>3. The analysis in the splitter theorem requires the constraint that |E(M)|>15. In this article, we complement that analysis by using an exhaustive computer search to find all such pairs satisfying |E(M)|<16.

We prove that the non-regular binary matroids with no $P_9^*$-minor have linear growth rate and the maximum size binary matroids with no $P_9^*$-minor are graphic. The main technique in the proof is the Strong Splitter Theorem using which we find the precise infinite families of 3-connected binary matroids with no $P_9^*$-minor.

In this paper, we give a complete characterization of binary matroids with no $P_9$-minor. A 3-connected binary matroid $M$ has no $P_9$-minor if and only if $M$ is one of the internally 4-connected non-regular minors of a special 16-element matroid $Y_{16}$, a 3-connected regular matroid, a binary spike with rank at least four, or a matroid obtained by 3-summing copies of the Fano matroid to a 3-connected cographic matroid $M^*(K_{3, n})$, $M^*(K_{3, n}^{\prime})$, $M^*(K_{3, n}^{\prime\prime})$, or $M^*(K_{3, n}^{\prime\prime\prime})$ ($n\ge 2$). Here the simple graphs $K_{3, n}^{\prime}, K_{3, n}^{\prime\prime}$, and $K_{3, n}^{\prime\prime\prime}$ are obtained from $K_{3, n}$ by adding one, two, or three edges in the color class of size three, respectively.

Let $M$ be a 3-connected binary matroid and let $Y(M)$ be the set of elements of $M$ avoiding at least $r(M)+1$ non-separating cocircuits of $M$. Lemos proved that $M$ is non-graphic if and only if $Y(M)\neq\emp$. We generalize this result when by establishing that $Y(M)$ is very large when $M$ is non-graphic and $M$ has no $M\s(K_{3,3}"')$-minor if $M$ is regular. More precisely that $|E(M)-Y(M)|\le 1$ in this case. We conjecture that when $M$ is a regular matroid with an $M\s(K_{3,3})$-minor, then $r\s_M(E(M)-Y(M))\le 2$. The proof of such conjecture is reduced to a computational verification.

Let M and N be internally 4-connected binary matroids such that M has a proper N-minor, and |E(N)| is at least seven. As part of our project to develop a splitter theorem for internally 4-connected binary matroids, we prove the following result: if M\e has no N-minor whenever e is in a triangle of M, and M/e has no N-minor whenever e is in a triad of M, then M has a minor, M', such that M' is internally 4-connected with an N-minor, and 0 < |E(M)|-|E(M')| < 3.

Let AG(3,2)xU(1,1) denote the binary matroid obtained from the direct sum of AG(3,2) and a coloop by completing the 3-point lines between every element in AG(3,2) and the coloop. We prove that every internally 4-connected binary matroid that does not have a minor isomorphic to M(K5\e) is isomorphic to a minor of (AG(3,2)xU(1,1))*.

We give a characterization of the internally 4-connected binary matroids that have no minor isomorphic to M(K3,3). Any such matroid is either cographic, or is isomorphic to a particular single-element extension of the bond matroid of a cubic or quartic Mobius ladder, or is isomorphic to one of eighteen sporadic matroids.

We consider some applications of our characterisation of the internally 4-connected binary matroids with no M(K3,3)-minor. We characterise the internally 4-connected binary matroids with no minor in some subset of {M(K3,3),M*(K3,3),M(K5),M*(K5)} that contains either M(K3,3) or M*(K3,3). We also describe a practical algorithm for testing whether a binary matroid has a minor in the subset. In addition we characterise the growth-rate of binary matroids with no M(K3,3)-minor, and we show that a binary matroid with no M(K3,3)-minor has critical exponent over GF(2) at most equal to four.