arXiv++ Combinatorics

For integer $n>0$, let $f(n)$ be the number of rows of the largest all-0 or all-1 square submatrix of $M$, minimized over all $n\times n$ $0/1$-matrices $M$. Thus $f(n)= O(\log n)$. But let us fix a matrix $H$, and define $f_H(n)$ to be the same, minimized over over all $n\times n$ $0/1$-matrices $M$ such that neither $M$ nor its complement (that is, change all $0$'s to $1$'s and vice versa) contains $H$ as a submatrix. It is known that $f_H(n)\ge εn^c$, where $c, ε>0$ are constants depending on $H$. When can we take $c=1$? If so, then one of $H$ and its complement must be an acyclic matrix (that is, the corresponding bipartite graph is a forest). Korandi, Pach, and Tomon conjectured the converse, that $f_H(n)$ is linear in $n$ for every acyclic matrix $H$; and they proved it for certain matrices $H$ with only two rows. Their conjecture remains open, but we show $f_H(n)=n^{1-o(1)}$ for every acyclic matrix $H$; and indeed there is a $0/1$-submatrix that is either $Ω(n)\times n^{1-o(1)}$ or $n^{1-o(1)}\times Ω(n)$.