arXiv++ Combinatorics

For spin systems, such as the $q$-colorings and independent-set models, approximating the partition function in the so-called non-uniqueness region, where the model exhibits long-range correlations, is typically computationally hard for bounded-degree graphs. We present new algorithmic results for approximating the partition function and sampling from the Gibbs distribution for spin systems in the non-uniqueness region on random regular bipartite graphs. We give an $\mathsf{FPRAS}$ for counting $q$-colorings for even $q=O\big(\tfracΔ{\logΔ}\big)$ on almost every $Δ$-regular bipartite graph. This is within a factor $O(\logΔ)$ of the sampling algorithm for general graphs in the uniqueness region and improves significantly upon the previous best bound of $q=O\big(\tfrac{\sqrtΔ}{(\logΔ)^2}\big)$ by Jenssen, Keevash, and Perkins (SODA'19). Analogously, for the hard-core model on independent sets weighted by $λ>0$, we present an $\mathsf{FPRAS}$ for estimating the partition function when $λ=Ω\big(\tfrac{\logΔ}Δ\big)$, which improves upon previous results by an $Ω(\log Δ)$ factor. Our results for the colorings and hard-core models follow from a general result that applies to arbitrary spin systems. Our main contribution is to show how to elevate probabilistic/analytic bounds on the marginal probabilities for the typical structure of phases on random bipartite regular graphs into efficient algorithms, using the polymer method. We further show evidence that our result for colorings is within a constant factor of best possible using current polymer-method approaches.

We study the complexity of approximating the partition function $Z_{\mathrm{Ising}}(G; β)$ of the Ising model in terms of the relation between the edge interaction $β$ and a parameter $Δ$ which is an upper bound on the maximum degree of the input graph $G$. Following recent trends in both statistical physics and algorithmic research, we allow the edge interaction $β$ to be any complex number. Many recent partition function results focus on complex parameters, both because of physical relevance and because of the key role of the complex case in delineating the tractability/intractability phase transition of the approximation problem. In this work we establish both new tractability results and new intractability results. Our tractability results show that $Z_{\mathrm{Ising}}(-; β)$ has an FPTAS when $\lvert β- 1 \rvert / \lvert β+ 1 \rvert < \tan(π/ (4 Δ- 4))$. The core of the proof is showing that there are no inputs~$G$ that make the partition function $0$ when $β$ is in this range. Our result significantly extends the known zero-free region of the Ising model (and hence the known approximation results). Our intractability results show that it is $\mathrm{\#P}$-hard to multiplicatively approximate the norm and to additively approximate the argument of $Z_{\mathrm{Ising}}(-; β)$ when $β\in \mathbb{C}$ is an algebraic number such that $β\not \in \mathbb{R} \cup \{i,-i\}$ and $\lvert β- 1\rvert / \lvert β+ 1 \rvert > 1 / \sqrt{Δ- 1}$. These are the first results to show intractability of approximating $Z_{\mathrm{Ising}}(-, β)$ on bounded degree graphs with complex $β$. Moreover, we demonstrate situations in which zeros of the partition function imply hardness of approximation in the Ising model.

We study the computational complexity of approximating the partition function of the ferromagnetic Ising model with the external field parameter $λ$ on the unit circle in the complex plane. Complex-valued parameters for the Ising model are relevant for quantum circuit computations and phase transitions in statistical physics, but have also been key in the recent deterministic approximation scheme for all $|λ|\neq 1$ by Liu, Sinclair, and Srivastava. Here, we focus on the unresolved complexity picture on the unit circle, and on the tantalising question of what happens around $λ=1$, where on one hand the classical algorithm of Jerrum and Sinclair gives a randomised approximation scheme on the real axis suggesting tractability, and on the other hand the presence of Lee-Yang zeros alludes to computational hardness. Our main result establishes a sharp computational transition at the point $λ=1$, and more generally on the entire unit circle. For an integer $Δ\geq 3$ and edge interaction parameter $b\in (0,1)$ we show #P-hardness for approximating the partition function on graphs of maximum degree $Δ$ on the arc of the unit circle where the Lee-Yang zeros are dense. This result contrasts with known approximation algorithms when $|λ|\neq 1$ or when $λ$ is in the complementary arc around $1$ of the unit circle. Our work thus gives a direct connection between the presence/absence of Lee-Yang zeros and the tractability of efficiently approximating the partition function on bounded-degree graphs.

We study the complexity of approximating the partition function of the $q$-state Potts model and the closely related Tutte polynomial for complex values of the underlying parameters. Apart from the classical connections with quantum computing and phase transitions in statistical physics, recent work in approximate counting has shown that the behaviour in the complex plane, and more precisely the location of zeros, is strongly connected with the complexity of the approximation problem, even for positive real-valued parameters. Previous work in the complex plane by Goldberg and Guo focused on $q=2$, which corresponds to the case of the Ising model; for $q>2$, the behaviour in the complex plane is not as well understood and most work applies only to the real-valued Tutte plane. Our main result is a complete classification of the complexity of the approximation problems for all non-real values of the parameters, by establishing \#P-hardness results that apply even when restricted to planar graphs. Our techniques apply to all $q\geq 2$ and further complement/refine previous results both for the Ising model and the Tutte plane, answering in particular a question raised by Bordewich, Freedman, Lovász and Welsh in the context of quantum computations.

We define a discrete-time Markov chain for abstract polymer models and show that under sufficient decay of the polymer weights, this chain mixes rapidly. We apply this Markov chain to polymer models derived from the hard-core and ferromagnetic Potts models on bounded-degree (bipartite) expander graphs. In this setting, Jenssen, Keevash and Perkins (2019) recently gave an FPTAS and an efficient sampling algorithm at sufficiently high fugacity and low temperature respectively. Their method is based on using the cluster expansion to obtain a complex zero-free region for the partition function of a polymer model, and then approximating this partition function using the polynomial interpolation method of Barvinok. Our approach via the polymer model Markov chain circumvents the zero-free analysis and the generalization to complex parameters, and leads to a sampling algorithm with a fast running time of $O(n \log n)$ for the Potts model and $O(n^2 \log n)$ for the hard-core model, in contrast to typical running times of $n^{O(\log Δ)}$ for algorithms based on Barvinok's polynomial interpolation method on graphs of maximum degree $Δ$. We finally combine our results for the hard-core and ferromagnetic Potts models with standard Markov chain comparison tools to obtain polynomial mixing time for the usual spin Glauber dynamics restricted to even and odd or `red' dominant portions of the respective state spaces.

We study the problem of approximating the value of the matching polynomial on graphs with edge parameter $γ$, where $γ$ takes arbitrary values in the complex plane. When $γ$ is a positive real, Jerrum and Sinclair showed that the problem admits an FPRAS on general graphs. For general complex values of $γ$, Patel and Regts, building on methods developed by Barvinok, showed that the problem admits an FPTAS on graphs of maximum degree $Δ$ as long as $γ$ is not a negative real number less than or equal to $-1/(4(Δ-1))$. Our first main result completes the picture for the approximability of the matching polynomial on bounded degree graphs. We show that for all $Δ\geq 3$ and all real $γ$ less than $-1/(4(Δ-1))$, the problem of approximating the value of the matching polynomial on graphs of maximum degree $Δ$ with edge parameter $γ$ is #P-hard. We then explore whether the maximum degree parameter can be replaced by the connective constant. Sinclair et al. showed that for positive real $γ$ it is possible to approximate the value of the matching polynomial using a correlation decay algorithm on graphs with bounded connective constant (and potentially unbounded maximum degree). We first show that this result does not extend in general in the complex plane; in particular, the problem is #P-hard on graphs with bounded connective constant for a dense set of $γ$ values on the negative real axis. Nevertheless, we show that the result does extend for any complex value $γ$ that does not lie on the negative real axis. Our analysis accounts for complex values of $γ$ using geodesic distances in the complex plane in the metric defined by an appropriate density function.

The antiferromagnetic $q$-state Potts model is perhaps the most canonical model for which the uniqueness threshold on the tree is not yet understood, largely because of the absence of monotonicities. Jonasson established the uniqueness threshold in the zero-temperature case, which corresponds to the $q$-colourings model. In the permissive case (where the temperature is positive), the Potts model has an extra parameter $β\in(0,1)$, which makes the task of analysing the uniqueness threshold even harder and much less is known. In this paper, we focus on the case $q=3$ and give a detailed analysis of the Potts model on the tree by refining Jonasson's approach. In particular, we establish the uniqueness threshold on the $d$-ary tree for all values of $d\geq 2$. When $d\geq3$, we show that the 3-state antiferromagnetic Potts model has uniqueness for all $β\geq 1-3/(d+1)$. The case $d=2$ is critical since it relates to the 3-colourings model on the binary tree ($β=0$), which has non-uniqueness. Nevertheless, we show that the Potts model has uniqueness for all $β\in (0,1)$ on the binary tree. Both of these results are tight since it is known that uniqueness does not hold in the complementary regime. Our proof technique gives for general $q>3$ an analytical condition for proving uniqueness based on the two-step recursion on the tree, which we conjecture to be sufficient to establish the uniqueness threshold for all non-critical cases ($q\neq d+1$).

We examine the computational complexity of approximately counting the list H-colourings of a graph. We discover a natural graph-theoretic trichotomy based on the structure of the graph H. If H is an irreflexive bipartite graph or a reflexive complete graph then counting list H-colourings is trivially in polynomial time. Otherwise, if H is an irreflexive bipartite permutation graph or a reflexive proper interval graph then approximately counting list H-colourings is equivalent to #BIS, the problem of approximately counting independent sets in a bipartite graph. This is a well-studied problem which is believed to be of intermediate complexity -- it is believed that it does not have an FPRAS, but that it is not as difficult as approximating the most difficult counting problems in #P. For every other graph H, approximately counting list H-colourings is complete for #P with respect to approximation-preserving reductions (so there is no FPRAS unless NP=RP). Two pleasing features of the trichotomy are (i) it has a natural formulation in terms of hereditary graph classes, and (ii) the proof is largely self-contained and does not require any universal algebra (unlike similar dichotomies in the weighted case). We are able to extend the hardness results to the bounded-degree setting, showing that all hardness results apply to input graphs with maximum degree at most 6.

We study the computational complexity of approximately counting the number of independent sets of a graph with maximum degree Delta. More generally, for an input graph G=(V,E) and an activity lambda>0, we are interested in the quantity Z_G(lambda) defined as the sum over independent sets I weighted as w(I) = lambda^|I|. In statistical physics, Z_G(lambda) is the partition function for the hard-core model, which is an idealized model of a gas where the particles have non-negibile size. Recently, an interesting phase transition was shown to occur for the complexity of approximating the partition function. Weitz showed an FPAS for the partition function for any graph of maximum degree Delta when Delta is constant and lambda< lambda_c(Tree_Delta):=(Delta-1)^(Delta-1)/(Delta-2)^Delta. The quantity lambda_c(Tree_Delta) is the critical point for the so-called uniqueness threshold on the infinite, regular tree of degree Delta. On the other side, Sly proved that there does not exist efficient (randomized) approximation algorithms for lambda_c(Tree_Delta) < lambda < lambda_c(Tree_Delta)+epsilon(Delta), unless NP=RP, for some function epsilon(Delta)>0. We remove the upper bound in the assumptions of Sly's result for Delta not equal to 4 and 5, that is, we show that there does not exist efficient randomized approximation algorithms for all lambda>lambda_c(Tree_Delta) for Delta=3 and Delta>= 6. Sly's inapproximability result uses a clever reduction, combined with a second-moment analysis of Mossel, Weitz and Wormald which prove torpid mixing of the Glauber dynamics for sampling from the associated Gibbs distribution on almost every regular graph of degree Delta for the same range of lambda as in Sly's result. We extend Sly's result by improving upon the technical work of Mossel et al., via a more detailed analysis of independent sets in random regular graphs.