Papers by Bernd Schulze
36 paper(s) by this author
· All BibTeX
Uniquely realizable crystalline structures
We construct infinite periodic versions of the stress matrix and establish sufficient conditions for periodic tensegrity frameworks to be globally rigid in $\mathbb{R}^d$ in the cases when the lattice is either fixed, fully flexible, or flexible with a volume constraint for the fundamental domain. For the fixed and fully flexible lattice variants, we also establish necessary and sufficient conditions for generic infinite periodic bar-joint frameworks to be globally rigid in $\mathbb{R}^d$. These results provide periodic versions of the fundamental results of Connelly, as well as Gortler, Healy and Thurston on the global rigidity of generic finite bar-joint frameworks.
Non-Euclidean Crystallographic Rigidity
This paper establishes combinatorial characterisations of forced-symmetric and forced-periodic rigidity (under a fixed lattice) of bar-joint frameworks in non-Euclidean normed planes. In $\ell_q$-planes for $q\in(1,\infty)\backslash\{2\}$, we prove characterisations for forced-periodic rigidity and forced-reflectionally-symmetric rigidity. We also characterise forced-symmetric rigidity in this space with respect to the orientation-reversing wallpaper group $\mathbb{Z}^2\rtimes\mathcal{C}_s$, otherwise known as $pm$ in crystallography. In the $\ell_1$ and $\ell_\infty$-planes, we provide characterisations for forced-periodic rigidity and forced-$\mathbb{Z}^2\rtimes\mathcal{C}_s$-symmetric rigidity. All of these characterisations are proved by inductive constructions involving Henneberg-type graph operations.
Rigidity of polytopes with edge length and coplanarity constraints
We investigate a novel setting for polytope rigidity, where a flex must preserve edge lengths and the planarity of faces, but is allowed to change the shapes of faces. For instance, the regular cube is flexible in this notion. We present techniques for constructing flexible polytopes and find that flexibility seems to be an exceptional property. Based on this observation, we introduce a notion of generic realizations for polytopes and conjecture that convex polytopes are generically rigid in dimension $d\geq 3$. We prove this conjecture in dimension $d=3$. Motivated by our findings we also pose several questions that are intended to inspire future research into this notion of polytope rigidity.
Counting for rigidity under projective transformations in the plane
Let $P$ be a set of points and $L$ a set of lines in the (extended) Euclidean plane, and $I \subseteq P\times L$, where $i =(p,l) \in I$ means that point $p$ and line $l$ are incident. The incidences can be interpreted as quadratic constraints on the homogeneous coordinates of the points and lines. We study the space of incidence preserving motions of the given incidence structure by linearizing the system of quadratic equations. The Jacobian of the quadratic system, our projective rigidity matrix, leads to the notion of independence/dependence of incidences. Column dependencies correspond to infinitesimal motions. Row dependencies or self-stresses allow for new interpretations of classical geometric incidence theorems. We show that self-stresses are characterized by a 3-fold balance. As expected, infinitesimal (first order) projective rigidity as well as second order projective rigidity imply projective rigidity but not conversely. Several open problems and possible generalizations are indicated.
Orientation-Reversing Crystallographic Rigidity
This paper provides a combinatorial characterisation for generic forced symmetric rigidity of bar-joint frameworks in the Euclidean plane that are symmetric with respect to the orientation-reversing wallpaper group $\mathbb{Z}^2\rtimes\mathcal{C}_s$, also known as $pm$ in crystallography, under a fixed lattice representation. Corresponding results for the wallpaper groups $cm$ and $pg$ follow directly from this. The method used also provides an inductive construction for the corresponding gain graphs, in terms of Henneberg-type graph operations.
Klein-Arnold tensegrities
In this paper, we introduce new classes of infinite and combinatorially periodic tensegrities, derived from algebraic multidimensional continued fractions in the sense of F. Klein. We describe the stress coefficients on edges through integer invariants of these continued fractions, as initiated by V.I. Arnold, thereby creating a novel connection between geometric rigidity theory and the geometry of continued fractions. Remarkably, the new classes of tensegrities possess rational self-stress coefficients. To establish the self-stressability of the frameworks, we present a projective version of the classical Maxwell-Cremona lifting principle, a result of independent interest.
Generic infinitesimal rigidity for rotational groups in the plane
In this paper we establish combinatorial characterisations of symmetry-generic infinitesimally rigid frameworks in the Euclidean plane for rotational groups of order 4 and 6, and of odd order between 5 and 1000, where a joint may lie at the centre of rotation. This extends the corresponding results for these groups in the free action case obtained by R. Ikeshita and S. Tanigawa in 2015, and our recent results for the reflection group and the rotational groups of order 2 and 3 in the non-free action case. The characterisations are given in terms of sparsity counts on the corresponding group-labelled quotient graphs, and are obtained via symmetry-adapted versions of recursive Henneberg-type graph constructions. For rotational groups of even order at least 8, we show that the sparsity counts alone are not sufficient for symmetry-generic infinitesimal rigidity.
Projective rigidity of point-line configurations in the plane
In this paper, we establish a general setup for studying incidence-preserving motions of projective geometric configurations of points and lines via a "projective rigidity matrix". The spaces of infinitesimal motions of a point-line configuration and dependencies amongst the point-line incidences can be interpreted as the kernel and co-kernel of this projective rigidity matrix, respectively. We also introduce a symmetry-adapted projective rigidity matrix for analysing symmetric configurations and their symmetry-preserving motions. The symmetry may be a point group or a more general symmetry, such as an autopolarity.
Rigidity of symmetric frameworks with non-free group actions on the vertices
For plane frameworks with reflection or rotational symmetries, where the group action is not necessarily free on the vertex set, we introduce a phase-symmetric orbit rigidity matrix for each irreducible representation of the group. We then use these generalised orbit rigidity matrices to provide necessary conditions for infinitesimal rigidity for frameworks that are symmetric with a cyclic group that acts freely or non-freely on the vertices. Moreover, for the reflection, the half-turn, and the three-fold rotational group in the plane, we establish complete combinatorial characterisations of symmetry-generic infinitesimally rigid frameworks. This extends well-known characterisations for these groups to the case when the group action is not necessarily free on the vertices. The presence of vertices that are fixed by non-trivial group elements requires the introduction of generalised versions of group-labelled quotient graphs leads to more refined types of combinatorial sparsity counts for characterising symmetry-generic infinitesimal rigidity.
Rigidity of symmetric linearly constrained frameworks in the plane
Published
• View Publication
• BIB
A bar-joint framework $(G,p)$ is the combination of a finite simple graph $G=(V,E)$ and a placement $p:V\rightarrow \mathbb{R}^d$. The framework is rigid if the only edge-length preserving continuous motions of the vertices arise from isometries of the space. Motivated by applications where boundary conditions play a significant role, one may generalise and consider linearly constrained frameworks where some vertices are constrained to move on fixed affine subspaces. Streinu and Theran characterised exactly which linearly constrained frameworks are generically rigid in 2-dimensional space. In this article we extend their characterisation to symmetric frameworks. In particular necessary combinatorial conditions are given for a symmetric linearly constrained framework in the plane to be isostatic (i.e. minimally infinitesimally rigid) under any finite point group symmetry. In the case of rotation symmetry groups whose order is either 2 or odd, these conditions are then shown to be sufficient under suitable genericity assumptions, giving precise combinatorial descriptions of symmetric isostatic graphs in these contexts.
A differential approach to Maxwell-Cremona liftings
In 1864, J. C. Maxwell introduced a link between self-stressed frameworks in the plane and piecewise linear liftings to 3-space. This connection has found numerous applications in areas such as discrete geometry, control theory and structural engineering. While there are some generalisations of this theory to liftings of $d$-complexes in $d$-space, extensions for liftings of frameworks in $d$-space for $d\geq 3$ have been missing. In this paper, we introduce and study differential liftings on general graphs using differential forms associated with the elements of the homotopy groups of the complements to the frameworks. Such liftings play the role of integrands for the classical notion of liftings for planar frameworks. We show that these differential liftings have a natural extension to self-stressed frameworks in higher dimensions. As a result we generalise the notion of classical liftings to both graphs and multidimensional $k$-complexes in $d$-space ($k=2,\ldots, d$). Finally we discuss a natural representation of generalised liftings as real-valued functions on Grassmannians.
Mobility of geometric constraint systems with extrusion symmetry
If we take a (bar-joint) framework, prepare an identical copy of this framework, translate it by some vector $τ$, and finally join corresponding points of the two copies, then we obtain a framework with `extrusion' symmetry in the direction of $τ$. This process may be repeated $t$ times to obtain a framework whose underlying graph has $\mathbb{Z}_2^t$ as a subgroup of its automorphism group and which has `$t$-fold extrusion' symmetry. We show that while $t$-fold extrusion symmetry is not a point-group symmetry, the rigidity matrix of a framework with $t$-fold extrusion symmetry can still be transformed into a block-decomposed form in the analogous way as for point-group symmetric frameworks. This allows us to use Fowler-Guest-type character counts to analyse the mobility of such frameworks. We show that this entire theory also extends to the more general point-hyperplane frameworks with $t$-fold extrusion symmetry. Moreover, we show that under suitable regularity conditions the infinitesimal flexes we detect with our symmetry-adapted counts extend to finite (continuous) motions. Finally, we establish an algorithm that checks for finite motions via linearly displacing framework points along velocity vectors of infinitesimal motions.
Rigidity of symmetric frameworks on the cylinder
Published
• View Publication
• BIB
A bar-joint framework $(G,p)$ is the combination of a finite simple graph $G=(V,E)$ and a placement $p:V\rightarrow \mathbb{R}^d$. The framework is rigid if the only edge-length preserving continuous deformations of the vertices arise from isometries of the space. This article combines two recent extensions of the generic theory of rigid and flexible graphs by considering symmetric frameworks in $\mathbb{R}^3$ restricted to move on a surface. In particular necessary combinatorial conditions are given for a symmetric framework on the cylinder to be isostatic (i.e. minimally infinitesimally rigid) under any finite point group symmetry. In every case when the symmetry group is cyclic, which we prove restricts the group to being inversion, half-turn or reflection symmetry, these conditions are then shown to be sufficient under suitable genericity assumptions, giving precise combinatorial descriptions of symmetric isostatic graphs in these contexts.
Braced triangulations and rigidity
Published
• View Publication
• BIB
We consider the problem of finding an inductive construction, based on vertex splitting, of triangulated spheres with a fixed number of additional edges (braces). We show that for any positive integer $b$ there is such an inductive construction of triangulations with $b$ braces, having finitely many base graphs. In particular we establish a bound for the maximum size of a base graph with $b$ braces that is linear in $b$. In the case that $b=1$ or $2$ we determine the list of base graphs explicitly. Using these results we show that doubly braced triangulations are (generically) minimally rigid in two distinct geometric contexts arising from a hypercylinder in $\mathbb{R}^4$ and a class of mixed norms on $\mathbb{R}^3$.
Symmetric contact systems of segments, pseudotriangulations and inductive constructions for corresponding surface graphs
We characterise the quotient surface graphs arising from symmetric contact systems of line segments in the plane and also from symmetric pointed pseudotriangulations in the case where the group of symmetries is generated by a translation or a rotation of finite order. These results generalise well known results of Thomassen, in the case of line segments, and of Streinu and Haas et al., in the case of pseudotriangulations. Our main tool is a new inductive characterisation of the appropriate classes of surface graphs. We also discuss some consequences of our results in the area of geometric rigidity theory.
Pairing symmetries for Euclidean and spherical frameworks
In this paper we consider the effect of symmetry on the rigidity of bar-joint frameworks, spherical frameworks and point-hyperplane frameworks in $\mathbb{R}^d$. In particular we show that, under forced or incidental symmetry, infinitesimal rigidity for spherical frameworks with vertices in $X$ on the equator and point-hyperplane frameworks with the vertices in $X$ representing hyperplanes are equivalent. We then show, again under forced or incidental symmetry, that infinitesimal rigidity properties under certain symmetry groups can be paired, or clustered, under inversion on the sphere so that infinitesimal rigidity with a given group is equivalent to infinitesimal rigidity under a paired group. The fundamental basic example is that mirror symmetric rigidity is equivalent to half-turn symmetric rigidity on the 2-sphere. With these results in hand we also deduce some combinatorial consequences for the rigidity of symmetric bar-joint and point-line frameworks.
Rigidity of symmetric frameworks in normed spaces
Published
• View Publication
• BIB
We develop a combinatorial rigidity theory for symmetric bar-joint frameworks in a general finite dimensional normed space. In the case of rotational symmetry, matroidal Maxwell-type sparsity counts are identified for a large class of $d$-dimensional normed spaces (including all $\ell^p$ spaces with $p\not=2$). Complete combinatorial characterisations are obtained for half-turn rotation in the $\ell^1$ and $\ell^\infty$-plane. As a key tool, a new Henneberg-type inductive construction is developed for the matroidal class of $(2,2,0)$-gain-tight graphs.
Frameworks with coordinated edge motions
Published
• View Publication
• BIB
We develop a rigidity theory for bar-joint frameworks in Euclidean $d$-space in which specified classes of edges are allowed to change length in a coordinated fashion that requires differences of lengths to be preserved within each class. Rigidity for these coordinated frameworks is a generic property, and we characterize the rigid graphs in terms of redundant rigidity in the standard $d$-dimensional rigidity matroid. We also interpret our main results in terms of matroid unions.
Sufficient connectivity conditions for rigidity of symmetric frameworks
Published
• View Publication
• BIB
It is a famous result of Lovasz and Yemini (1982) that 6-connected graphs are rigid in the plane. This was recently improved by Jackson and Jordan (2009) who showed that 6-mixed connectivity is also sufficient for rigidity. Here we give sufficient graph connectivity conditions for both `forced symmetric' and `incidentally symmetric' infinitesimal rigidity in the plane.
Sufficient conditions for the global rigidity of periodic graphs
Published
• View Publication
• BIB
Tanigawa (2016) showed that vertex-redundant rigidity of a graph implies its global rigidity in arbitrary dimension. We extend this result to periodic graphs under fixed lattice representations. A periodic graph is vertex-redundantly rigid if the deletion of a single vertex orbit under the periodicity results in a periodically rigid graph. Our proof is similar to the one of Tanigawa, but there are some added difficulties. First, it is not known whether periodic global rigidity is a generic property. This issue is resolved via a slight modification of a recent result of Kaszanitzy, Schulze and Tanigawa (2016). Secondly, while the rigidity of finite graphs in $\mathbb{R}^d$ on at most $d$ vertices obviously implies their global rigidity, it is non-trivial to prove a similar result for periodic graphs. This is accomplished by extending a result of Bezdek and Connelly (2002) on the existence of a continuous movement between two equivalent $d$-dimensional realisations of a single graph in $\mathbb{R}^{2d}$ to periodic frameworks.
As an application of our result, we give a necessary and sufficient condition for the global rigidity of generic periodic body-bar frameworks in arbitrary dimension. This provides a periodic counterpart to a result of Connelly, Jordan and Whiteley (2013) regarding the global rigidity of generic finite body-bar frameworks.