arXiv++ Combinatorics

Kneser's 1955 conjecture -- proven by Lovász in 1978 -- asserts that in any partition of the $k$-subsets of $\{1, 2, \dots, n\}$ into $n-2k-3$ parts, one part contains two disjoint sets. Schrijver showed that one can restrict to significantly fewer $k$-sets and still observe the same intersection pattern. Alon, Frankl, and Lovász proved a different generalization of Kneser's conjecture for $r$ pairwise disjoint sets. Dolnikov generalized Lovász' result to arbitrary set systems, while Kříž did the same for the $r$-fold extension of Kneser's conjecture. Here we prove a common generalization of all of these results. Moreover, we prove additional strengthenings by determining the chromatic number of certain sparse stable Kneser hypergraphs, and further develop a general approach to establishing lower bounds for chromatic numbers of hypergraphs using a combination of methods from equivariant topology and intersection results for convex hulls of points in Euclidean space.

We prove a common strengthening of Bárány's colorful Carathéodory theorem and the KKMS theorem. In fact, our main result is a colorful polytopal KKMS theorem, which extends a colorful KKMS theorem due to Shih and Lee [Math. Ann. 296 (1993), no. 1, 35--61] as well as a polytopal KKMS theorem due to Komiya [Econ. Theory 4 (1994), no. 3, 463--466]. The (seemingly unrelated) colorful Carathéodory theorem is a special case as well. We apply our theorem to establish an upper bound on the piercing number of colorful d-interval hypergraphs, extending earlier results of Tardos [Combinatorica 15 (1995), no. 1, 123--134] and Kaiser [Discrete Comput. Geom. 18 (1997), no. 2, 195--203].

Given the subjective preferences of n roommates in an n-bedroom apartment, one can use Sperner's lemma to find a division of the rent such that each roommate is content with a distinct room. At the given price distribution, no roommate has a strictly stronger preference for a different room. We give a new elementary proof that the subjective preferences of only n-1 of the roommates actually suffice to achieve this envy-free rent division. Our proof, in particular, yields an algorithm to find such a fair division of rent. The techniques also give generalizations of Sperner's lemma including a new proof of a conjecture of the third author.

Recent progress building on the groundbreaking work of Mabillard and Wagner has shown that there are important differences between the affine and continuous theory for Tverberg-type results. These results aim to describe the intersection pattern of convex hulls of point sets in Euclidean space and continuous relaxations thereof. Here we give additional examples of an affine-continuous divide, but our deductions are almost elementary and do not build on the technical work of Mabillard and Wagner. Moreover, these examples show a difference between the affine and continuous theory even asymptotically for arbitrarily large complexes. Along the way we settle the Tverberg admissible-prescribable problem (or AP conjecture) in the negative, give a new, short and elementary proof of the balanced case of the AP conjecture which was recently proven by Jojić, Vrećica, and Živaljević in a series of two papers, provide examples of Tverberg-type results that hold affinely but not continuously without divisibility conditions on the intersection multiplicity, extend a result of Soberón, and show that this extension has a topological generalization if and only if the intersection multiplicity is a prime.

We treat problems of fair division, their various interconnections, and their relations to Sperner's lemma and the KKM theorem as well as their variants. We prove extensions of Alon's necklace splitting result in certain regimes and relate it to hyperplane mass partitions. We show the existence of fair cake division and rental harmony in the sense of Su even in the absence of full information. Furthermore, we extend Sperner's lemma and the KKM theorem to (colorful) quantitative versions for polytopes and pseudomanifolds. For simplicial polytopes our results turn out to be improvements over the earlier work of De Loera, Peterson, and Su on a polytopal version of Sperner's lemma. Moreover, our results extend the work of Musin on quantitative Sperner-type results for PL manifolds.

Reay's relaxed Tverberg conjecture and Conway's thrackle conjecture are open problems about the geometry of pairwise intersections. Reay asked for the minimum number of points in Euclidean d-space that guarantees any such point set admits a partition into r parts, any k of whose convex hulls intersect. Here we give new and improved lower bounds for this number, which Reay conjectured to be independent of k. We prove a colored version of Reay's conjecture for k sufficiently large, but nevertheless k independent of dimension d. Requiring convex hulls to intersect pairwise severely restricts combinatorics. This is a higher-dimensional analog of Conway's thrackle conjecture or its linear special case. We thus study convex-geometric and higher-dimensional analogs of the thrackle conjecture alongside Reay's problem and conjecture (and prove in two special cases) that the number of convex sets in the plane is bounded by the total number of vertices they involve whenever there exists a transversal set for their pairwise intersections. We thus isolate a geometric property that leads to bounds as in the thrackle conjecture. We also establish tight bounds for the number of facets of higher-dimensional analogs of linear thrackles and conjecture their continuous generalizations.

For a collection of convex bodies $P_1,\dots,P_n \subset \mathbb{R}^d$ containing the origin, a Minkowski complex is given by those subsets whose Minkowski sum does not contain a fixed basepoint. Every simplicial complex can be realized as a Minkowski complex and for convex bodies on the real line, this recovers the class of threshold complexes. The purpose of this note is the study of the convex threshold dimension of a complex, that is, the smallest dimension in which it can be realized as a Minkowski complex. In particular, we show that the convex threshold dimension can be arbitrarily large. This is related to work of Chvátal and Hammer (1977) regarding forbidden subgraphs of threshold graphs. We also show that convexity is crucial this context.

The main result is a common generalization of results on lower bounds for the chromatic number of r-uniform hypergraphs and some of the major theorems in Tverberg-type theory, which is concerned with the intersection pattern of faces in a simplicial complex when continuously mapped to Euclidean space. As an application we get a simple proof of a generalization of a result of Kriz for certain parameters. This specializes to a short and simple proof of Kneser's conjecture. Moreover, combining this result with recent work of Mabillard and Wagner we show that the existence of certain equivariant maps yields lower bounds for chromatic numbers. We obtain an essentially elementary proof of the result of Schrijver on the chromatic number of stable Kneser graphs. In fact, we show that every neighborly even-dimensional polytope yields a small induced subgraph of the Kneser graph of the same chromatic number. We furthermore use this geometric viewpoint to give tight lower bounds for the chromatic number of certain small subhypergraphs of Kneser hypergraphs.

Using the authors' 2014 "constraints method," we give a short proof for a 2015 result of Dobbins on representations of a point in a polytope as the barycenter of points in a skeleton, and show that the "r-fold Whitney trick" of Mabillard and Wagner (2014/2015) implies that the Topological Tverberg Conjecture for r-fold intersections fails dramatically for all r that are not prime powers.

The Grünbaum-Hadwiger-Ramos hyperplane mass partition problem was introduced by Grünbaum (1960) in a special case and in general form by Ramos (1996). It asks for the "admissible" triples $(d,j,k)$ such that for any $j$ masses in $\mathbb{R}^d$ there are $k$ hyperplanes that cut each of the masses into $2^k$ equal parts. Ramos' conjecture is that the Avis-Ramos necessary lower bound condition $dk\ge j(2^k-1)$ is also sufficient. We develop a "join scheme" for this problem, such that non-existence of an $G_k$-equivariant map between spheres $(S^d)^{*k} \rightarrow S(W_k\oplus U_k^{\oplus j})$ that extends a test map on the subspace of $(S^d)^{*k}$ where the hyperoctahedral group $G_k$ acts non-freely, implies that $(d,j,k)$ is admissible. For the sphere $(S^d)^{*k}$ we obtain a very efficient regular cell decomposition, whose cells get a combinatorial interpretation with respect to measures on a modified moment curve. This allows us to apply relative equivariant obstruction theory successfully, even in the case when the difference of dimensions of the spheres $(S^d)^{*k}$ and $S(W_k\oplus U_k^{\oplus j})$ is greater than one. The evaluation of obstruction classes leads to counting problems for concatenated Gray codes. Thus we give a rigorous, unified treatment of the previously announced cases of the Grünbaum-Hadwiger-Ramos problem, as well as a number of new cases for Ramos' conjecture.

The "topological Tverberg conjecture" by Bárány, Shlosman and Szűcs (1981) states that any continuous map of a simplex of dimension $(r-1)(d+1)$ to $\mathbb{R}^d$ maps points from $r$ disjoint faces of the simplex to the same point in $\mathbb{R}^d$. This was established for affine maps by Tverberg (1966), for the case when $r$ is a prime by Bárány et al., and for prime power $r$ by Özaydin (1987). We combine the generalized van Kampen theorem announced by Mabillard and Wagner (2014) with the constraint method of Blagojević, Ziegler and the author (2014), and thus prove the existence of counterexamples to the topological Tverberg conjecture for any number $r$ of faces that is not a prime power. However, these counterexamples require that the dimension $d$ of the codomain is sufficiently high: the smallest counterexample we obtain is for a map of the $100$-dimensional simplex to $\mathbb{R}^{19}$, for $r=6$.

We give a short and simple proof of a recent result of Dobbins that any point in an $nd$-polytope is the barycenter of $n$ points in the $d$-skeleton. This new proof builds on the constraint method that we recently introduced to prove Tverberg-type results.

We show that the nerve complex of n arcs in the circle is homotopy equivalent to either a point, an odd-dimensional sphere, or a wedge sum of spheres of the same even dimension. Moreover this homotopy type can be computed in time O(n log n). For the particular case of the nerve complex of evenly-spaced arcs of the same length, we determine the dihedral group action on homology, and we relate the complex to a cyclic polytope with n vertices. We give three applications of our knowledge of the homotopy types of nerve complexes of circular arcs. First, we use the connection to cyclic polytopes to give a novel topological proof of a known upper bound on the distance between successive roots of a homogeneous trigonometric polynomial. Second, we show that the Lovasz bound on the chromatic number of a circular complete graph is either sharp or off by one. Third, we show that the Vietoris--Rips simplicial complex of n points in the circle is homotopy equivalent to either a point, an odd-dimensional sphere, or a wedge sum of spheres of the same even dimension, and furthermore this homotopy type can be computed in time O(n log n).

Many of the strengthenings and extensions of the topological Tverberg theorem can be derived with surprising ease directly from the original theorem: For this we introduce a proof technique that combines a concept of "Tverberg unavoidable subcomplexes" with the observation that Tverberg points that equalize the distance from such a subcomplex can be obtained from maps to an extended target space. Thus we obtain simple proofs for many variants of the topological Tverberg theorem, such as the colored Tverberg theorem of Zivaljevic and Vrecica (1992). We also get a new strengthened version of the generalized van Kampen-Flores theorem by Sarkaria (1991) and Volovikov (1996), an affine version of their "j-wise disjoint" Tverberg theorem, and a topological version of Soberon's (2013) result on Tverberg points with equal barycentric coordinates.