arXiv++ Combinatorics

We give new lower bounds for the Shannon capacities of small odd cycles: $Θ(C_7)\geq3.258805369885\ldots$, $Θ(C_{11})\geq5.294502522149\ldots$, $Θ(C_{13})\geq6.302455083464\ldots$, $Θ(C_{15})\geq7.301600534487\ldots$, $Θ(C_{19})\geq9.357192705918\ldots$, $Θ(C_{21})\geq10.342455853338\ldots$, and $Θ(C_{23})\geq11.328224257774\ldots$. The bounds are obtained by an iterative procedure due to Gao (2026) which is based on a method by Itty, Rosin, Carstensen and Reichman (2026). The bounds are fully formalised in Lean.

The Shannon capacity of graphs, introduced by Shannon in 1956 to model zero-error communication, asks for determining the rate of growth of independent sets in strong powers of graphs. Much is still unknown about this parameter, for instance whether it is computable. Recent work has established a dual characterization of the Shannon capacity in terms of the asymptotic spectrum of graphs. A core step in this duality theory is to shift focus from Shannon capacity itself to studying the asymptotic relations between graphs, that is, the asymptotic cohomomorphisms. Towards understanding the structure of Shannon capacity, we study the "combinatorial complexity" of asymptotic cohomomorphism. As our main result, we prove that the asymptotic cohomomorphism order is universal for all countable preorders. That is, we prove that any countable preorder can be order-embedded into the asymptotic cohomomorphism order (i.e. appears as a suborder). Previously this was only known for (non-asymptotic) cohomomorphism. Our proof is based on techniques from asymptotic spectrum duality and convex structure of the asymptotic spectrum of graphs. Our approach in fact leads to a new proof of the universality of (non-asymptotic) cohomomorphism.

We develop a group-theoretic approach to the Shannon capacity problem. Using this approach we extend and recover, in a structured and unified manner, various families of previously known lower bounds on the Shannon capacity. Bohman (2003) proved that, in the limit $p\to\infty$, the Shannon capacity of cycle graphs $Θ(C_p)$ converges to the fractional clique covering number, that is, $\lim_{p \to \infty} p/2 - Θ(C_p) = 0$. We strengthen this result by proving that the same is true for all fraction graphs: $\lim_{p/q \to \infty} p/q - Θ(E_{p/q}) = 0$. Here the fraction graph $E_{p/q}$ is the graph with vertex set $\mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$ in which two distinct vertices are adjacent if and only if their distance mod $p$ is strictly less than $q$. We obtain the limit via the group-theoretic approach. In particular, the independent sets we construct in powers of fraction graphs are subgroups (and, in fact, lattices). Our approach circumvents known barriers for structured ("linear") constructions of independent sets of Calderbank-Frankl-Graham-Li-Shepp (1993) and Guruswami-Riazanov (2021).

Determining the Shannon capacity of graphs is a long-standing open problem in information theory, graph theory and combinatorial optimization. Over decades, a wide range of upper and lower bound methods have been developed to analyze this problem. However, despite tremendous effort, even small instances of the problem have remained open. In recent years, a new dual characterization of the Shannon capacity of graphs, asymptotic spectrum duality, has unified and extended known upper bound methods and structural theorems. In this paper, building on asymptotic spectrum duality, we develop a new theory of graph distance, that we call asymptotic spectrum distance, and corresponding limits (reminiscent of, but different from, the celebrated theory of cut-norm, graphons and flag algebras). We propose a graph limit approach to the Shannon capacity problem: to determine the Shannon capacity of a graph, construct a sequence of easier to analyse graphs converging to it. (1) We give a very general construction of non-trivial converging sequences of graphs (in a family of circulant graphs). (2) We construct Cauchy sequences of finite graphs that do not converge to any finite graph, but do converge to an infinite graph. We establish strong connections between convergence questions of finite graphs and the asymptotic properties of Borsuk-like infinite graphs on the circle. (3) We observe that all best-known lower bound constructions for Shannon capacity of small odd cycles can be obtained from a "finite" version of the graph limit approach. We develop computational and theoretical aspects of this approach and use these to obtain a new Shannon capacity lower bound for the fifteen-cycle. The theory of asymptotic spectrum distance applies not only to Shannon capacity of graphs; indeed, we will develop it for a general class of mathematical objects and their asymptotic properties.

Recent works of Costa-Dalai, Christandl-Gesmundo-Zuiddam, Blatter-Draisma-Rupniewski, and Briët-Christandl-Leigh-Shpilka-Zuiddam have investigated notions of discreteness and gaps in the possible values that asymptotic tensor ranks can take. In particular, it was shown that the asymptotic subrank and asymptotic slice rank of any nonzero 3-tensor is equal to 1, equal to 1.88, or at least 2 (over any field), and that the set of possible values of these parameters is discrete (in several regimes). We determine exactly the next gap, showing that the asymptotic subrank and asymptotic slice rank of any nonzero 3-tensor is equal to 1, equal to 1.88, equal to 2, or at least 2.68.

Tensor parameters that are amortized or regularized over large tensor powers, often called "asymptotic" tensor parameters, play a central role in several areas including algebraic complexity theory (constructing fast matrix multiplication algorithms), quantum information (entanglement cost and distillable entanglement), and additive combinatorics (bounds on cap sets, sunflower-free sets, etc.). Examples are the asymptotic tensor rank, asymptotic slice rank and asymptotic subrank. Recent works (Costa-Dalai, Blatter-Draisma-Rupniewski, Christandl-Gesmundo-Zuiddam) have investigated notions of discreteness (no accumulation points) or "gaps" in the values of such tensor parameters. We prove a general discreteness theorem for asymptotic tensor parameters of order-three tensors and use this to prove that (1) over any finite field (and in fact any finite set of coefficients in any field), the asymptotic subrank and the asymptotic slice rank have no accumulation points, and (2) over the complex numbers, the asymptotic slice rank has no accumulation points. Central to our approach are two new general lower bounds on the asymptotic subrank of tensors, which measures how much a tensor can be diagonalized. The first lower bound says that the asymptotic subrank of any concise three-tensor is at least the cube-root of the smallest dimension. The second lower bound says that any concise three-tensor that is "narrow enough" (has one dimension much smaller than the other two) has maximal asymptotic subrank. Our proofs rely on new lower bounds on the maximum rank in matrix subspaces that are obtained by slicing a three-tensor in the three different directions. We prove that for any concise tensor, the product of any two such maximum ranks must be large, and as a consequence there are always two distinct directions with large max-rank.

The subrank of tensors is a measure of how much a tensor can be ''diagonalized''. This parameter was introduced by Strassen to study fast matrix multiplication algorithms in algebraic complexity theory and is closely related to many central tensor parameters (e.g. slice rank, partition rank, analytic rank, geometric rank, G-stable rank) and problems in combinatorics, computer science and quantum information theory. Strassen (J. Reine Angew. Math., 1988) proved that there is a gap in the subrank when taking large powers under the tensor product: either the subrank of all powers is at most one, or it grows as a power of a constant strictly larger than one. In this paper, we precisely determine this constant for tensors of any order. Additionally, for tensors of order three, we prove that there is a second gap in the possible rates of growth. Our results strengthen the recent work of Costa and Dalai (J. Comb. Theory, Ser. A, 2021), who proved a similar gap for the slice rank. Our theorem on the subrank has wider applications by implying such gaps not only for the slice rank, but for any ``normalized monotone''. In order to prove the main result, we characterize when a tensor has a very structured tensor (the W-tensor) in its orbit closure. Our methods include degenerations in Grassmanians, which may be of independent interest.

There is a large and important collection of Ramsey-type combinatorial problems, closely related to central problems in complexity theory, that can be formulated in terms of the asymptotic growth of the size of the maximum independent sets in powers of a fixed small (directed or undirected) hypergraph, also called the Shannon capacity. An important instance of this is the corner problem studied in the context of multiparty communication complexity in the Number On the Forehead (NOF) model. Versions of this problem and the NOF connection have seen much interest (and progress) in recent works of Linial, Pitassi and Shraibman (ITCS 2019) and Linial and Shraibman (CCC 2021). We introduce and study a general algebraic method for lower bounding the Shannon capacity of directed hypergraphs via combinatorial degenerations, a combinatorial kind of "approximation" of subgraphs that originates from the study of matrix multiplication in algebraic complexity theory (and which play an important role there) but which we use in a novel way. Using the combinatorial degeneration method, we make progress on the corner problem by explicitly constructing a corner-free subset in $F_2^n \times F_2^n$ of size $Ω(3.39^n/poly(n))$, which improves the previous lower bound $Ω(2.82^n)$ of Linial, Pitassi and Shraibman (ITCS 2019) and which gets us closer to the best upper bound $4^{n - o(n)}$. Our new construction of corner-free sets implies an improved NOF protocol for the Eval problem. In the Eval problem over a group $G$, three players need to determine whether their inputs $x_1, x_2, x_3 \in G$ sum to zero. We find that the NOF communication complexity of the Eval problem over $F_2^n$ is at most $0.24n + O(\log n)$, which improves the previous upper bound $0.5n + O(\log n)$.

Strassen (Strassen, J. Reine Angew. Math., 375/376, 1987) introduced the subrank of a tensor as a natural extension of matrix rank to tensors. Subrank measures the largest diagonal tensor that can be obtained by applying linear operations to the different indices (legs) of the tensor (just like the matrix rank measures the largest diagonal matrix that can be obtained using row and column operations). Motivated by problems in combinatorics and complexity theory we introduce the new notion of symmetric subrank of tensors by restricting these linear operations to be the same for each index. We prove precise relations and separations between subrank and symmetric subrank. We prove that for symmetric tensors the subrank and the symmetric subrank are asymptotically equal. This proves the asymptotic subrank analogon of a conjecture known as Comon's conjecture in the theory of tensors. This result allows us to prove a strong connection between the general and symmetric version of an asymptotic duality theorem of Strassen. We introduce a representation-theoretic method to asymptotically bound the symmetric subrank called the symmetric quantum functional in analogy with the quantum functionals (Christandl, Vrana, Zuiddam, J. Amer. Math. Soc., 2021), and we study the relations between these functionals.

Motivated by problems in algebraic complexity theory (e.g., matrix multiplication) and extremal combinatorics (e.g., the cap set problem and the sunflower problem), we introduce the geometric rank as a new tool in the study of tensors and hypergraphs. We prove that the geometric rank is an upper bound on the subrank of tensors and the independence number of hypergraphs. We prove that the geometric rank is smaller than the slice rank of Tao, and relate geometric rank to the analytic rank of Gowers and Wolf in an asymptotic fashion. As a first application, we use geometric rank to prove a tight upper bound on the (border) subrank of the matrix multiplication tensors, matching Strassen's well-known lower bound from 1987.

We compute the asymptotic induced matching number of the $k$-partite $k$-uniform hypergraphs whose edges are the $k$-bit strings of Hamming weight $k/2$, for any large enough even number $k$. Our lower bound relies on the higher-order extension of the well-known Coppersmith-Winograd method from algebraic complexity theory, which was proven by Christandl, Vrana and Zuiddam. Our result is motivated by the study of the power of this method as well as of the power of the Strassen support functionals (which provide upper bounds on the asymptotic induced matching number), and the connections to questions in tensor theory, quantum information theory and theoretical computer science. Phrased in the language of tensors, as a direct consequence of our result, we determine the asymptotic subrank of any tensor with support given by the aforementioned hypergraphs. In the context of quantum information theory, our result amounts to an asymptotically optimal $k$-party stochastic local operations and classical communication (slocc) protocol for the problem of distilling GHZ-type entanglement from a subfamily of Dicke-type entanglement.

We study quantum versions of the Shannon capacity of graphs and non-commutative graphs. We introduce the asymptotic spectrum of graphs with respect to quantum and entanglement-assisted homomorphisms, and we introduce the asymptotic spectrum of non-commutative graphs with respect to entanglement-assisted homomorphisms. We apply Strassen's spectral theorem (J. Reine Angew. Math., 1988) in order to obtain dual characterizations of the corresponding Shannon capacities and asymptotic preorders in terms of their asymptotic spectra. This work extends the study of the asymptotic spectrum of graphs initiated by Zuiddam (Combinatorica, 2019) to the quantum domain. We then exhibit spectral points in the new quantum asymptotic spectra and discuss their relations with the asymptotic spectrum of graphs. In particular, we prove that the (fractional) real and complex Haemers bounds upper bound the quantum Shannon capacity, which is defined as the regularization of the quantum independence number (Mančinska and Roberson, J. Combin. Theory Ser. B, 2016), and that the fractional real and complex Haemers bounds are elements in the quantum asymptotic spectrum of graphs. This is in contrast to the Haemers bounds defined over certain finite fields, which can be strictly smaller than the quantum Shannon capacity. Moreover, since the Haemers bound can be strictly smaller than the Lovász theta function (Haemers, IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory, 1979), we find that the quantum Shannon capacity and the Lovász theta function do not coincide. As a consequence, two well-known conjectures in quantum information theory cannot both be true.

We introduce the asymptotic spectrum of graphs and apply the theory of asymptotic spectra of Strassen (J. Reine Angew. Math. 1988) to obtain a new dual characterisation of the Shannon capacity of graphs. Elements in the asymptotic spectrum of graphs include the Lovász theta number, the fractional clique cover number, the complement of the fractional orthogonal rank and the fractional Haemers bounds.

The asymptotic restriction problem for tensors is to decide, given tensors $s$ and $t$, whether the nth tensor power of $s$ can be obtained from the $(n+o(n))$th tensor power of t by applying linear maps to the tensor legs (this we call restriction), when $n$ goes to infinity. In this context, Volker Strassen, striving to understand the complexity of matrix multiplication, introduced in 1986 the asymptotic spectrum of tensors. Essentially, the asymptotic restriction problem for a family of tensors $X$, closed under direct sum and tensor product, reduces to finding all maps from $X$ to the reals that are monotone under restriction, normalised on diagonal tensors, additive under direct sum and multiplicative under tensor product, which Strassen named spectral points. Strassen created the support functionals, which are spectral points for oblique tensors, a strict subfamily of all tensors. Universal spectral points are spectral points for the family of all tensors. The construction of nontrivial universal spectral points has been an open problem for more than thirty years. We construct for the first time a family of nontrivial universal spectral points over the complex numbers, using quantum entropy and covariants: the quantum functionals. In the process we connect the asymptotic spectrum to the quantum marginal problem and to the entanglement polytope. To demonstrate the asymptotic spectrum, we reprove (in hindsight) recent results on the cap set problem by reducing this problem to computing asymptotic spectrum of the reduced polynomial multiplication tensor, a prime example of Strassen. A better understanding of our universal spectral points construction may lead to further progress on related questions. We additionally show that the quantum functionals characterise asymptotic slice rank for complex tensors.

We present an upper bound on the exponent of the asymptotic behaviour of the tensor rank of a family of tensors defined by the complete graph on $k$ vertices. For $k\geq4$, we show that the exponent per edge is at most 0.77, outperforming the best known upper bound on the exponent per edge for matrix multiplication ($k=3$), which is approximately 0.79. We raise the question whether for some $k$ the exponent per edge can be below $2/3$, i.e. can outperform matrix multiplication even if the matrix multiplication exponent equals 2. In order to obtain our results, we generalise to higher order tensors a result by Strassen on the asymptotic subrank of tight tensors and a result by Coppersmith and Winograd on the asymptotic rank of matrix multiplication. Our results have applications in entanglement theory and communication complexity.

After Bob sends Alice a bit, she responds with a lengthy reply. At the cost of a factor of two in the total communication, Alice could just as well have given the two possible replies without listening and have Bob select which applies to him. Motivated by a conjecture stating that this form of "round elimination" is impossible in exact quantum communication complexity, we study the orthogonal rank and a symmetric variant thereof for a certain family of Cayley graphs. The orthogonal rank of a graph is the smallest number $d$ for which one can label each vertex with a nonzero $d$-dimensional complex vector such that adjacent vertices receive orthogonal vectors. We show an exp$(n)$ lower bound on the orthogonal rank of the graph on $\{0,1\}^n$ in which two strings are adjacent if they have Hamming distance at least $n/2$. In combination with previous work, this implies an affirmative answer to the above conjecture.

We introduce a method for transforming low-order tensors into higher-order tensors and apply it to tensors defined by graphs and hypergraphs. The transformation proceeds according to a surgery-like procedure that splits vertices, creates and absorbs virtual edges and inserts new vertices and edges. We show that tensor surgery is capable of preserving the low rank structure of an initial tensor decomposition and thus allows to prove nontrivial upper bounds on tensor rank, border rank and asymptotic rank of the final tensors. We illustrate our method with a number of examples. Tensor surgery on the triangle graph, which corresponds to the matrix multiplication tensor, leads to nontrivial rank upper bounds for all odd cycle graphs, which correspond to the tensors of iterated matrix multiplication. In the asymptotic setting we obtain upper bounds in terms of the matrix multiplication exponent $ω$ and the rectangular matrix multiplication parameter $α$. These bounds are optimal if $ω$ equals two. We also give examples that illustrate that tensor surgery on general graphs might involve the absorption of virtual hyperedges and we provide an example of tensor surgery on a hypergraph. Besides its relevance in algebraic complexity theory, our work has applications in quantum information theory and communication complexity.