arXiv++ Combinatorics

We give new lower bounds for the Shannon capacities of small odd cycles: $Θ(C_7)\geq3.258805369885\ldots$, $Θ(C_{11})\geq5.294502522149\ldots$, $Θ(C_{13})\geq6.302455083464\ldots$, $Θ(C_{15})\geq7.301600534487\ldots$, $Θ(C_{19})\geq9.357192705918\ldots$, $Θ(C_{21})\geq10.342455853338\ldots$, and $Θ(C_{23})\geq11.328224257774\ldots$. The bounds are obtained by an iterative procedure due to Gao (2026) which is based on a method by Itty, Rosin, Carstensen and Reichman (2026). The bounds are fully formalised in Lean.

We develop a group-theoretic approach to the Shannon capacity problem. Using this approach we extend and recover, in a structured and unified manner, various families of previously known lower bounds on the Shannon capacity. Bohman (2003) proved that, in the limit $p\to\infty$, the Shannon capacity of cycle graphs $Θ(C_p)$ converges to the fractional clique covering number, that is, $\lim_{p \to \infty} p/2 - Θ(C_p) = 0$. We strengthen this result by proving that the same is true for all fraction graphs: $\lim_{p/q \to \infty} p/q - Θ(E_{p/q}) = 0$. Here the fraction graph $E_{p/q}$ is the graph with vertex set $\mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$ in which two distinct vertices are adjacent if and only if their distance mod $p$ is strictly less than $q$. We obtain the limit via the group-theoretic approach. In particular, the independent sets we construct in powers of fraction graphs are subgroups (and, in fact, lattices). Our approach circumvents known barriers for structured ("linear") constructions of independent sets of Calderbank-Frankl-Graham-Li-Shepp (1993) and Guruswami-Riazanov (2021).

Let $K_q(n,r)$ denote the minimum size of a $q$-ary covering code of word length $n$ and covering radius $r$. In other words, $K_q(n,r)$ is the minimum size of a set of $q$-ary codewords of length $n$ such that the Hamming balls of radius $r$ around the codewords cover the Hamming space $\{0,\ldots,q-1\}^n$. The special case $K_3(n,1)$ is often referred to as the football pool problem, as it is equivalent to finding a set of forecasts on $n$ football matches that is guaranteed to contain a forecast with at most one wrong outcome. In this paper, we build and expand upon the work of Gijswijt (2005), who introduced a semidefinite programming lower bound on $K_q(n,r)$ via matrix cuts. We develop techniques that strengthen this bound, by introducing new semidefinite constraints inspired by Lasserre's hierarchy for 0-1 programs and symmetry reduction methods, and a more powerful objective function. The techniques lead to sharper lower bounds, setting new records across a broad range of values of $q$, $n$, and $r$.

We investigate some graph parameters dealing with biindependent pairs $(A,B)$ in a bipartite graph $G=(V_1\cup V_2,E)$, i.e., pairs $(A,B)$ where $A\subseteq V_1$, $B\subseteq V_2$ and $A\cup B$ is independent. These parameters also allow to study bicliques in general graphs. When maximizing the cardinality $|A\cup B|$ one finds the stability number $α(G)$, well-known to be polynomial-time computable. When maximizing the product $|A|\cdot |B|$ one finds the parameter $g(G)$, shown to be NP-hard by Peeters (2003), and when maximizing the ratio $|A|\cdot |B|/|A\cup B|$ one finds $h(G)$, introduced by Vallentin (2020) for bounding product-free sets in finite groups. We show that $h(G)$ is an NP-hard parameter and, as a crucial ingredient, that it is NP-complete to decide whether a bipartite graph $G$ has a balanced maximum independent set. These hardness results motivate introducing semidefinite programming bounds for $g(G)$, $h(G)$, and $α_{\text{bal}}(G)$ (the maximum cardinality of a balanced independent set). We show that these bounds can be seen as natural variations of the Lovász $\vartheta$-number, a well-known semidefinite bound on $α(G)$. In addition we formulate closed-form eigenvalue bounds and we show relationships among them as well as with earlier spectral parameters by Hoffman, Haemers (2001) and Vallentin (2020).

In this paper, we use semidefinite programming and representation theory to compute new lower bounds on the crossing number of the complete bipartite graph $K_{m,n}$, extending a method from de Klerk et al. [SIAM J. Discrete Math. 20 (2006), 189--202] and the subsequent reduction by De Klerk, Pasechnik and Schrijver [Math. Prog. Ser. A and B, 109 (2007) 613--624]. We exploit the full symmetry of the problem using a novel decomposition technique. This results in a full block-diagonalization of the underlying matrix algebra, which we use to improve bounds on several concrete instances. Our results imply that $\text{cr}(K_{10,n}) \geq 4.87057 n^2 - 10n$, $\text{cr}(K_{11,n}) \geq 5.99939 n^2-12.5n$, $\text{cr}(K_{12,n}) \geq 7.25579 n^2 - 15n$, $\text{cr}(K_{13,n}) \geq 8.65675 n^2-18n$ for all $n$. The latter three bounds are computed using a new and well-performing relaxation of the original semidefinite programming bound. This new relaxation is obtained by only requiring one small matrix block to be positive semidefinite.

A code $\mathcal{C} \subseteq \{0, 1, 2\}^n$ is said to be trifferent with length $n$ when for any three distinct elements of $\mathcal{C}$ there exists a coordinate in which they all differ. Defining $\mathcal{T}(n)$ as the maximum cardinality of trifferent codes with length $n$, $\mathcal{T}(n)$ is unknown for $n \ge 5$. In this note, we use an optimized search algorithm to show that $\mathcal{T}(5) = 10$ and $\mathcal{T}(6) = 13$.

For given integers $n$ and $d$, both at least 2, we consider a homogeneous multivariate polynomial $f_d$ of degree $d$ in variables indexed by the edges of the complete graph on $n$ vertices and coefficients depending on cardinalities of certain unions of edges. Cardinaels, Borst and Van Leeuwaarden (arXiv:2111.05777, 2021) asked whether $f_d$, which arises in a model of job-occupancy in redundancy scheduling, attains its minimum over the standard simplex at the uniform probability vector. Brosch, Laurent and Steenkamp [SIAM J. Optim. 31 (2021), 2227--2254] proved that $f_d$ is convex over the standard simplex if $d=2$ and $d=3$, implying the desired result for these $d$. We give a symmetry reduction to show that for fixed $d$, the polynomial is convex over the standard simplex (for all $n\geq 2$) if a constant number of constant matrices (with size and coefficients independent of $n$) are positive semidefinite. This result is then used in combination with a computer-assisted verification to show that the polynomial $f_d$ is convex for $d\leq 9$.

In this thesis we present several results in coding theory, concerning error-correcting codes and the Shannon capacity. 1. We give a general symmetry reduction of matrices occuring in semidefinite programs in coding theory. 2. We apply the symmetry reduction to efficiently compute semidefinite programming upper bounds for nonbinary error-correcting codes equipped with the Hamming distance (joint work with Bart Litjens and Lex Schrijver), with the Lee distance and for binary constant weight codes. 3. We explore other methods to find new upper bounds for nonbinary codes with the Hamming distance, based on combinatorial divisibility arguments. 4. We study uniqueness and classification of codes, using the output of the semidefinite programming solver. Most of our classification results are related to subcodes of the binary Golay code. This is joint work with Andries Brouwer. 5. We consider the Shannon capacity of circular graphs. The circular graph $C_{d,q}$ is the graph with vertex set $\mathbb{Z}_q$ (the cyclic group of order q) in which two distinct vertices are adjacent if and only if their distance (mod $q$) is strictly less than $d$. The Shannon capacity of $C_{d,q}$ can be seen to only depend on the fraction q/d. We prove that the function which assigns to each rational number $q/d$ the Shannon capacity of $C_{d,q}$ is continuous at integer points $q/d$. Moreover, we give a new lower bound on the Shannon capacity of the $7$-cycle. This is joint work with Lex Schrijver. This thesis was written at the University of Amsterdam under supervision of Lex Schrijver.

For $q,n,d \in \mathbb{N}$, let $A_q^L(n,d)$ denote the maximum cardinality of a code $C \subseteq \mathbb{Z}_q^n$ with minimum Lee distance at least $d$, where $\mathbb{Z}_q$ denotes the cyclic group of order $q$. We consider a semidefinite programming bound based on triples of codewords, which bound can be computed efficiently using symmetry reductions, resulting in several new upper bounds on $A_q^L(n,d)$. The technique also yields an upper bound on the independent set number of the $n$-th strong product power of the circular graph $C_{d,q}$, which number is related to the Shannon capacity of $C_{d,q}$. Here $C_{d,q}$ is the graph with vertex set $\mathbb{Z}_q$, in which two vertices are adjacent if and only if their distance (mod $q$) is strictly less than $d$. The new bound does not seem to improve significantly over the bound obtained from Lovász theta-function, except for very small $n$.

We give an independent set of size $367$ in the fifth strong product power of $C_7$, where $C_7$ is the cycle on $7$ vertices. This leads to an improved lower bound on the Shannon capacity of $C_7$: $Θ(C_7)\geq 367^{1/5} > 3.2578$. The independent set is found by computer, using the fact that the set $\{t \cdot (1,7,7^2,7^3,7^4) \,\, | \,\, t \in \mathbb{Z}_{382}\} \subseteq \mathbb{Z}_{382}^5$ is independent in the fifth strong product power of the circular graph $C_{108,382}$. Here the circular graph $C_{k,n}$ is the graph with vertex set $\mathbb{Z}_{n}$, the cyclic group of order $n$, in which two distinct vertices are adjacent if and only if their distance (mod $n$) is strictly less than $k$.

Let $n,k,r$ be positive integers with $n \geq rk$ and $r \geq 2$. Consider a circle $C$ with~$n$ points~$1,\ldots,n$ in clockwise order. The $r$-stable \emph{interlacing graph} $\text{IG}_{n,k}^{(r)}$ is the graph with vertices corresponding to $k$-subsets $S$ of $\{1,...,n\}$ such that any two distinct points in~$S$ have distance at least~$r$ around the circle, and edges between~$k$-subsets $P$ and $Q$ if they \emph{interlace}: after removing the points in~$P$ from $C$, the points in~$Q$ are in different connected components. In this paper we prove that the circular chromatic number of $\text{IG}_{n,k}^{(r)}$ is equal to $ n/k $ (hence the chromatic number is $\lceil n/k \rceil$) and that its circular clique number is also $ n/k $. Furthermore, we show that its independence number is $\binom{n-(r-1)k-1}{k-1}$, thereby strengthening a result by Talbot.

Inspired by a famous characterization of perfect graphs due to Lovász, we define a graph $G$ to be sum-perfect if for every induced subgraph $H$ of $G$, $α(H) + ω(H) \geq |V(H)|$. (Here $α$ and $ω$ denote the stability number and clique number, respectively.) We give a set of $27$ graphs and we prove that a graph $G$ is sum-perfect if and only if $G$ does not contain any of the graphs in the set as an induced subgraph.

For nonnegative integers $n,d,w$, let $A(n,d,w)$ be the maximum size of a code $C \subseteq \mathbb{F}_2^n$ with constant weight $w$ and minimum distance at least $d$. We consider two semidefinite programs based on quadruples of code words that yield several new upper bounds on $A(n,d,w)$. The new upper bounds imply that $A(22,8,10)=616$ and $A(22,8,11)=672$. Lower bounds on $A(22,8,10)$ and $A(22,8,11)$ are obtained from the $(n,d)=(22,7)$ shortened Golay code of size $2048$. It can be concluded that the shortened Golay code is a union of constant weight $w$ codes of sizes $A(22,8,w)$.

For nonnegative integers $n$ and $d$, let $A(n,d)$ be the maximum cardinality of a binary code of length $n$ and minimum distance at least $d$. We consider a slight sharpening of the semidefinite programming bound of Gijswijt, Mittelmann and Schrijver, and obtain that $A(18,8)\leq 70$.

For $q,n,d \in \mathbb{N}$, let $A_q(n,d)$ be the maximum size of a code $C \subseteq [q]^n$ with minimum distance at least $d$. We give a divisibility argument resulting in the new upper bounds $A_5(8,6) \leq 65$, $A_4(11,8)\leq 60$ and $A_3(16,11) \leq 29$. These in turn imply the new upper bounds $A_5(9,6) \leq 325$, $A_5(10,6) \leq 1625$, $A_5(11,6) \leq 8125$ and $A_4(12,8) \leq 240$. Furthermore, we prove that for $μ,q \in \mathbb{N}$, there is a 1-1-correspondence between symmetric $(μ,q)$-nets (which are certain designs) and codes $C \subseteq [q]^{μq}$ of size $μq^2$ with minimum distance at least $μq - μ$. We derive the new upper bounds $A_4(9,6) \leq 120$ and $A_4(10,6) \leq 480$ from these `symmetric net' codes.

For nonnegative integers $q,n,d$, let $A_q(n,d)$ denote the maximum cardinality of a code of length $n$ over an alphabet $[q]$ with $q$ letters and with minimum distance at least $d$. We consider the following upper bound on $A_q(n,d)$. For any $k$, let $\CC_k$ be the collection of codes of cardinality at most $k$. Then $A_q(n,d)$ is at most the maximum value of $\sum_{v\in[q]^n}x(\{v\})$, where $x$ is a function $\CC_4\to R_+$ such that $x(\emptyset)=1$ and $x(C)=0$ if $C$ has minimum distance less than $d$, and such that the $\CC_2\times\CC_2$ matrix $(x(C\cup C'))_{C,C'\in\CC_2}$ is positive semidefinite. By the symmetry of the problem, we can apply representation theory to reduce the problem to a semidefinite programming problem with order bounded by a polynomial in $n$. It yields the new upper bounds $A_4(6,3)\leq 176$, $A_4(7,4)\leq 155$, $A_5(7,4)\leq 489$, and $A_5(7,5)\leq 87$.