arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study several $k$-fold generalizations of the Lovász theta function associated with the maximum $k$-colorable induced subgraph problem. The first is the Narasimhan--Manber parameter $\vartheta_k$. We prove that, for graphs whose adjacency matrix belongs to a homogeneous partially coherent algebra, this parameter is recovered by the theta number of the Cartesian product with the complete graph on $k$ vertices. This class includes distance-regular and $1$-walk-regular graphs, and thus our result generalizes a theorem by Sinjorgo and Sotirov (2022) for graphs that are vertex- and edge-transitive. We introduce a new parameter $\varphi_k$ obtained from orthonormal representations of graphs and show the inequality $\varphi_k \leq \vartheta_k$. For both parameters, we study the smallest $k$ for which the parameter is equal to the number of vertices; these saturation parameters yield lower bounds on the chromatic number. We determine which vertex-weighted versions of these parameters are gauges, and discuss a natural definition for the $k$-fold theta body of a graph. We conclude with open questions comparing $\vartheta_k$, $\varphi_k$, $\vartheta(G\square K_k)$, and related convexifications.

We prove a lower bound to quantum Max Cut of a graph in terms of the Lovász theta function of its complement. For a graph with $m$ edges, $\text{qmc}(G) \geq \tfrac{m}{4}\big( 1 + \tfrac{8}{3π}\tfrac{1}{\vartheta(\bar{G}) -1} \big)$, with the bound achieved by a product state. The proof extends a result by Balla, Janzer, and Sudakov on classical Max Cut and is also inspired by the randomized rounding method of Gharibian and Parekh. The bound outperforms the classical bound when applied to quantum Max Cut.

Let $G$ be a graph on $n$ vertices, independence number $α(G)$, Lovász theta function $\vartheta(G)$, and Shannon capacity $Θ(G)$. We define $n_{\ge0}(G)$ to be the minimum number of non-negative eigenvalues taken over all Hermitian weighted adjacency matrices of $G$. It is well known that $α(G) \le Θ(G) \le \vartheta(G)$ and $α(G) \le n_{\ge0}(G)$. Continuing a long line of work, we investigate the relationships between $ α(G) $, $ \vartheta(G) $, $Θ(G)$, and $ n_{\ge 0}(G) $. We prove a conjecture of Kwan and Wigderson, showing that for every integer $k$, there exists a graph $G$ with $α(G) \leq 2$ and $n_{\ge 0}(G) \ge k$. In addition, we prove that for every integer $k$, there exists a graph $G$ with $Θ(G) \leq 3$ and $n_{\ge 0}(G) \ge k$. Both results rely on a new observation: if the complement of $G$ contains a good spectral expander, then $n_{\geq 0}(G)$ must be large. We also show that $\vartheta(G)$ can be exponentially larger than $n_{\ge 0}(G)$, improving a recent result of Ihringer.

A new characterization of the Lovasz theta function is provided by relating it to the (weighted) walk-generating function, thus establishing a relationship between two seemingly quite distinct concepts in algebraic graph theory. An application of this new characterization is given by showing how it straightforwardly entails multiple natural generalizations of the Hoffman upper bound (on both the independence number and Lovasz number) to arbitrary non-regular graphs. These new bounds possess properties that make them advantageous to previously derived such generalizations. It will also be shown that the Lovasz theta function equals a natural relaxation of the independence number, here dubbed the spherical independence number -- the determination of which involves producing a vector corresponding to a generalized maximum independent set which might be significant for the maximum independent set problem. Lastly, the derivation of the new characterization involves proving a certain analysis result which may in itself be of interest.

The Hoffman ratio bound, Lovász theta function and Schrijver theta function are classical upper bounds for the independence number of graphs, which are useful in graph theory, extremal combinatorics and information theory. By using generalized inverses and eigenvalues of graph matrices, we give bounds for independence sets and the independence number of graphs. Our bounds unify the Lovász theta function, Schrijver theta function and Hoffman-type bounds, and we obtain the necessary and sufficient conditions of graphs attaining these bounds. Our work leads to some simple structural and spectral conditions for determining a maximum independent set, the independence number, the Shannon capacity and the Lovász theta function of a graph.

We investigate the effect of the well-known Mycielski construction on the Shannon capacity of graphs and on one of its most prominent upper bounds, the (complementary) Lovász theta number. We prove that if the Shannon capacity of a graph, the distinguishability graph of a noisy channel, is attained by some finite power, then its Mycielskian has strictly larger Shannon capacity than the graph itself. For the complementary Lovász theta function we show that its value on the Mycielskian of a graph is completely determined by its value on the original graph, a phenomenon similar to the one discovered for the fractional chromatic number by Larsen, Propp and Ullman. We also consider the possibility of generalizing our results on the Sperner capacity of directed graphs and on the generalized Mycielsky construction. Possible connections with what Zuiddam calls the asymptotic spectrum of graphs are discussed as well.

We construct a bipartite generalization of Alon and Szegedy's nearly orthogonal vectors, thereby obtaining strong bounds for several extremal problems involving the Lovász theta function, vector chromatic number, minimum semidefinite rank, nonnegative rank, and extension complexity of polytopes. In particular, we derive a couple of general lower bounds for the vector chromatic number which may be of independent interest.

The problems of computing graph colorings and clique covers are central challenges in combinatorial optimization. Both of these are known to be NP-hard, and thus computationally intractable in the worst-case instance. A prominent approach for computing approximate solutions to these problems is the celebrated Lovász theta function $\vartheta(G)$, which is specified as the solution of a semidefinite program (SDP), and hence tractable to compute. In this work, we move beyond the worst-case analysis and set out to understand whether the Lovász theta function recovers clique covers for random instances that have a latent clique cover structure, possibly obscured by noise. We answer this question in the affirmative and show that for graphs generated from the planted clique model we introduce in this work, the SDP formulation of $\vartheta(G)$ has a unique solution that reveals the underlying clique-cover structure with high-probability. The main technical step is an intermediate result where we prove a deterministic condition of recovery based on an appropriate notion of sparsity.

In this short note we prove a lower bound for the MaxCut of a graph in terms of the Lovász theta function of its complement. We combine this with known bounds on the Lovász theta function of complements of $H$-free graphs to recover many known results on the MaxCut of $H$-free graphs. In particular, we give a new, very short proof of a conjecture of Alon, Krivelevich and Sudakov about the MaxCut of graphs with no cycles of length $r$.

We extend upper bounds on the quantum independence number and the quantum Shannon capacity of graphs to their counterparts in the commuting operator model. We introduce a von Neumann algebraic generalization of the fractional Haemers bound (over $\mathbb{C}$) and prove that the generalization upper bounds the commuting quantum independence number. We call our bound the tracial Haemers bound, and we prove that it is multiplicative with respect to the strong product. In particular, this makes it an upper bound on the Shannon capacity. The tracial Haemers bound is incomparable with the Lovász theta function, another well-known upper bound on the Shannon capacity. We show that separating the tracial and fractional Haemers bounds would refute Connes' embedding conjecture. Along the way, we prove that the tracial rank and tracial Haemers bound are elements of the (commuting quantum) asymptotic spectrum of graphs (Zuiddam, Combinatorica, 2019). We also show that the inertia bound (an upper bound on the quantum independence number) upper bounds the commuting quantum independence number.

The diamond is the graph obtained by removing an edge from the complete graph on 4 vertices. A graph is ($P_6$, diamond)-free if it contains no induced subgraph isomorphic to a six-vertex path or a diamond. In this paper we show that the chromatic number of a ($P_6$, diamond)-free graph $G$ is no larger than the maximum of 6 and the clique number of $G$. We do this by reducing the problem to imperfect ($P_6$, diamond)-free graphs via the Strong Perfect Graph Theorem, dividing the imperfect graphs into several cases, and giving a proper colouring for each case. We also show that there is exactly one 6-vertex-critical ($P_6$, diamond, $K_6$)-free graph. Together with the Lovász theta function, this gives a polynomial time algorithm to compute the chromatic number of ($P_6$, diamond)-free graphs.

The Shannon capacity of a graph is a fundamental quantity in zero-error information theory measuring the rate of growth of independent sets in graph powers. Despite being well-studied, this quantity continues to hold several mysteries. Lovász famously proved that the Shannon capacity of $C_5$ (the 5-cycle) is at most $\sqrt{5}$ via his theta function. This bound is achieved by a simple linear code over $\mathbb{F}_5$ mapping $x \mapsto 2x$. This motivates the notion of linear Shannon capacity of graphs, which is the largest rate achievable when restricting oneself to linear codes. We give a simple proof based on the polynomial method that the linear Shannon capacity of $C_5$ is $\sqrt{5}$. Our method applies more generally to Cayley graphs over the additive group of finite fields $\mathbb{F}_q$, giving an upper bound on the linear Shannon capacity. We compare this bound to the Lovász theta function, showing that they match for self-complementary Cayley graphs (such as $C_5$), and that the bound is smaller in some cases. We also exhibit a quadratic gap between linear and general Shannon capacity for some graphs.

We continue the study of the quantum channel version of Shannon's zero-error capacity problem. We generalize the celebrated Haemers bound to noncommutative graphs (obtained from quantum channels). We prove basic properties of this bound, such as additivity under the direct sum and submultiplicativity under the tensor product. The Haemers bound upper bounds the Shannon capacity of noncommutative graphs, and we show that it can outperform other known upper bounds, including noncommutative analogues of the Lovász theta function (Duan-Severini-Winter, IEEE Trans. Inform. Theory, 2013 and Boreland-Todorov-Winter, arXiv, 2019).

The notion of duality is a key element in understanding the interplay between the stability and chromatic numbers of a graph. This notion is a central aspect in the celebrated theory of perfect graphs, and is further and deeply developed in the context of the Lovász theta function and its equivalent characterizations and variants. The main achievement of this paper is the introduction of a new family of norms, providing upper bounds for the stability number, that are obtained from duality from the norms motivated by Hoffman's lower bound for the chromatic number and which achieve the (complementary) Lovász theta function at their optimum. As a consequence, our norms make it formal that Hoffman's bound for the chromatic number and the Delsarte-Hoffman ratio bound for the stability number are indeed dual. Further, we show that our new bounds strengthen the convex quadratic bounds for the stability number studied by Luz and Schrijver, and which achieve the Lovász theta function at their optimum. One of the key observations regarding weighted versions of these bounds is that, for any upper bound for the stability number of a graph which is a positive definite monotone gauge function, its gauge dual is a lower bound on the fractional chromatic number, and conversely. Our presentation is elementary and accessible to a wide audience.

Given a graph $G$ and a positive integer $d$, an orthogonal vector $d$-coloring of $G$ is an assignment $f$ of vectors of $\mathbb{R}^d$ to $V(G)$ in such a way that adjacent vertices receive orthogonal vectors. The orthogonal chromatic number of $G$, denoted by $χ_v(G)$, is the minimum $d$ for which $G$ admits an orthogonal vector $d$-coloring. This notion has close ties with the notions of Lovász Theta Function, quantum chromatic number, and many other problems, and even though this and related metrics have been extensively studied over the years, we have found that there is a gap in the knowledge concerning the edge version of the problem. In this article, we discuss this version and its relation with other insteresting known facts, and pose a question about the orthogonal chromatic index of cubic graphs.

We prove that in sparse Erdős-Rényi graphs of average degree $d$, the vector chromatic number (the relaxation of chromatic number coming from the Lovàsz theta function) is typically $\tfrac{1}{2}\sqrt{d} + o_d(1)$. This fits with a long-standing conjecture that various refutation and hypothesis-testing problems concerning $k$-colorings of sparse Erdős-Rényi graphs become computationally intractable below the `Kesten-Stigum threshold' $d_{KS,k} = (k-1)^2$. Along the way, we use the celebrated Ihara-Bass identity and a carefully constructed non-backtracking random walk to prove two deterministic results of independent interest: a lower bound on the vector chromatic number (and thus the chromatic number) using the spectrum of the non-backtracking walk matrix, and an upper bound dependent only on the girth and universal cover. Our upper bound may be equivalently viewed as a generalization of the Alon-Boppana theorem to irregular graphs

We study quantum versions of the Shannon capacity of graphs and non-commutative graphs. We introduce the asymptotic spectrum of graphs with respect to quantum and entanglement-assisted homomorphisms, and we introduce the asymptotic spectrum of non-commutative graphs with respect to entanglement-assisted homomorphisms. We apply Strassen's spectral theorem (J. Reine Angew. Math., 1988) in order to obtain dual characterizations of the corresponding Shannon capacities and asymptotic preorders in terms of their asymptotic spectra. This work extends the study of the asymptotic spectrum of graphs initiated by Zuiddam (Combinatorica, 2019) to the quantum domain. We then exhibit spectral points in the new quantum asymptotic spectra and discuss their relations with the asymptotic spectrum of graphs. In particular, we prove that the (fractional) real and complex Haemers bounds upper bound the quantum Shannon capacity, which is defined as the regularization of the quantum independence number (Mančinska and Roberson, J. Combin. Theory Ser. B, 2016), and that the fractional real and complex Haemers bounds are elements in the quantum asymptotic spectrum of graphs. This is in contrast to the Haemers bounds defined over certain finite fields, which can be strictly smaller than the quantum Shannon capacity. Moreover, since the Haemers bound can be strictly smaller than the Lovász theta function (Haemers, IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory, 1979), we find that the quantum Shannon capacity and the Lovász theta function do not coincide. As a consequence, two well-known conjectures in quantum information theory cannot both be true.

The minrank of a graph $G$ on the set of vertices $[n]$ over a field $\mathbb{F}$ is the minimum possible rank of a matrix $M\in\mathbb{F}^{n\times n}$ with nonzero diagonal entries such that $M_{i,j}=0$ whenever $i$ and $j$ are distinct nonadjacent vertices of $G$. This notion, over the real field, arises in the study of the Lovász theta function of a graph. We obtain tight bounds for the typical minrank of the binomial random graph $G(n,p)$ over any finite or infinite field, showing that for every field $\mathbb{F}=\mathbb F(n)$ and every $p=p(n)$ satisfying $n^{-1} \leq p \leq 1-n^{-0.99}$, the minrank of $G=G(n,p)$ over $\mathbb{F}$ is $Θ(\frac{n \log (1/p)}{\log n})$ with high probability. The result for the real field settles a problem raised by Knuth in 1994. The proof combines a recent argument of Golovnev, Regev, and Weinstein, who proved the above result for finite fields of size at most $n^{O(1)}$, with tools from linear algebra, including an estimate of Rónyai, Babai, and Ganapathy for the number of zero-patterns of a sequence of polynomials.

Two classical upper bounds on the Shannon capacity of graphs are the $\vartheta$-function due to Lovász and the minrank parameter due to Haemers. We provide several explicit constructions of $n$-vertex graphs with a constant $\vartheta$-function and minrank at least $n^δ$ for a constant $δ>0$ (over various prime order fields). This implies a limitation on the $\vartheta$-function-based algorithmic approach to approximating the minrank parameter of graphs. The proofs involve linear spaces of multivariate polynomials and the method of higher incidence matrices.

Total dual integrality is a powerful and unifying concept in polyhedral combinatorics and integer programming that enables the refinement of geometric min-max relations given by linear programming Strong Duality into combinatorial min-max theorems. The definition of total dual integrality (TDI) revolves around the existence of optimal dual solutions that are integral, and thus naturally applies to a host of combinatorial optimization problems that are cast as integer programs whose LP relaxations have the TDIness property. However, when combinatorial problems are formulated using more general convex relaxations, such as semidefinite programs (SDPs), it is not at all clear what an appropriate notion of integrality in the dual program is, thus inhibiting the generalization of the theory to more general forms of structured convex optimization. (In fact, we argue that the rank-one constraint usually added to SDP relaxations is not adequate in the dual SDP.) In this paper, we propose a notion of total dual integrality for SDPs that generalizes the notion for LPs, by relying on an "integrality constraint" for SDPs that is primal-dual symmetric. A key ingredient for the theory is a generalization to compact convex sets of a result of Hoffman for polytopes, fundamental for generalizing the polyhedral notion of total dual integrality introduced by Edmonds and Giles. We study the corresponding theory applied to SDP formulations for stable sets in graphs using the Lovász theta function and show that total dual integrality in this case corresponds to the underlying graph being perfect. We also relate dual integrality of an SDP formulation for the maximum cut problem to bipartite graphs. Total dual integrality for extended formulations naturally comes into play in this context.