arXiv++ Combinatorics

In the fair allocation problem under conflict constraints, the goal is to partition the vertices of a graph among agents in a fair manner, such that no two adjacent vertices are assigned to the same agent. We study this problem for agents with common preferences through the lens of three fairness criteria: stochastic-dominance envy-freeness up to one item for preference orders (SD-EF1), envy-freeness up to one item for monotone additive valuations (EF1), and envy-freeness up to one item from each side for general additive valuations (EF[1,1]). To do so, we introduce a hierarchy of variants of the strong chromatic number, a graph quantity introduced independently by Alon and Fellows in the early nineties. Our results reveal a close connection between fair allocation under conflict constraints and the first two levels of this hierarchy, providing a unified route to both existential and algorithmic results. For SD-EF1, we fully characterize the number of agents needed to guarantee a fair allocation of a given graph for every common preference order. For EF1 and EF[1,1], we provide analogous sufficient conditions, extending a result on path graphs due to Equbal, Gurjar, Igarashi, Kumar, Manurangsi, Nath, Saxena, Vaish, and Yoneda. We also show that, unlike in the SD-EF1 setting, the sufficient conditions for EF1 and EF[1,1] are not necessary in general. Our framework yields existential and algorithmic consequences in terms of the maximum degree. We obtain that every graph with maximum degree $Δ$ admits SD-EF1, EF1, and EF[1,1] allocations for common preferences whenever the number of agents is at least $3Δ-1$. We further provide, for any $\varepsilon>0$, deterministic polynomial-time algorithms that find such allocations whenever the number of agents is at least $(3+\varepsilon)Δ$. These guarantees strengthen earlier work by Barman and Viswanathan on equitable colorings.

A family of permutations of $[n]$ is called setwise distinguishable if for every permutation in the family there exists a subset of $[n]$ whose image under this permutation differs from its image under any other permutation in the family. We prove that there exists a setwise distinguishable family of $2^{(2-o(1)) \cdot n}$ permutations of $[n]$. The result is optimal up to the $o(1)$ term in the exponent and is achieved through an explicit construction. As an application, we obtain nearly tight conditional lower bounds on the kernelization complexity of graph coloring problems parameterized by the vertex-deletion distance to split graphs. This improves a result of Jansen and Kratsch (Inf. Comput., 2013).

For a field $\mathbb{F}$ and integers $d$ and $k$, a set ${\cal A} \subseteq \mathbb{F}^d$ is called $k$-nearly orthogonal if its members are non-self-orthogonal and every $k+1$ vectors of ${\cal A}$ include an orthogonal pair. We prove that for every prime $p$ there exists some $δ= δ(p)>0$, such that for every field $\mathbb{F}$ of characteristic $p$ and for all integers $k \geq 2$ and $d \geq k$, there exists a $k$-nearly orthogonal set of at least $d^{δ\cdot k/\log k}$ vectors of $\mathbb{F}^d$. The size of the set is optimal up to the $\log k$ term in the exponent. We further prove two extensions of this result. In the first, we provide a large set ${\cal A}$ of non-self-orthogonal vectors of $\mathbb{F}^d$ such that for every two subsets of ${\cal A}$ of size $k+1$ each, some vector of one of the subsets is orthogonal to some vector of the other. In the second extension, every $k+1$ vectors of the produced set ${\cal A}$ include $\ell+1$ pairwise orthogonal vectors for an arbitrary fixed integer $1 \leq \ell \leq k$. The proofs involve probabilistic and spectral arguments and the hypergraph container method.

For a field $\mathbb{F}$ and integers $d$ and $k$, a set of vectors of $\mathbb{F}^d$ is called $k$-nearly orthogonal if its members are non-self-orthogonal and every $k+1$ of them include an orthogonal pair. We prove that for every prime $p$ there exists a positive constant $δ= δ(p)$, such that for every field $\mathbb{F}$ of characteristic $p$ and for all integers $k \geq 2$ and $d \geq k^{1/(p-1)}$, there exists a $k$-nearly orthogonal set of at least $d^{δ\cdot k^{1/(p-1)}/ \log k}$ vectors of $\mathbb{F}^d$. In particular, for the binary field we obtain a set of $d^{Ω( k /\log k)}$ vectors, and this is tight up to the $\log k$ term in the exponent. For comparison, the best known lower bound over the reals is $d^{Ω( \log k / \log \log k)}$ (Alon and Szegedy, Graphs and Combin., 1999). The proof combines probabilistic and spectral arguments.

We show that the Consensus Division theorem implies lower bounds on the chromatic number of Kneser hypergraphs, offering a novel proof for a result of Alon, Frankl, and Lovász (Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 1986) and for its generalization by Kříž (Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 1992). Our approach is applied to study the computational complexity of the total search problem Kneser$^p$, which given a succinct representation of a coloring of a $p$-uniform Kneser hypergraph with fewer colors than its chromatic number, asks to find a monochromatic hyperedge. We prove that for every prime $p$, the Kneser$^p$ problem with an extended access to the input coloring is efficiently reducible to a quite weak approximation of the Consensus Division problem with $p$ shares. In particular, for $p=2$, the problem is efficiently reducible to any non-trivial approximation of the Consensus Halving problem on normalized monotone functions. We further show that for every prime $p$, the Kneser$^p$ problem lies in the complexity class $\mathsf{PPA}$-$p$. As an application, we establish limitations on the complexity of the Kneser$^p$ problem, restricted to colorings with a bounded number of colors.

A subset of $[n] = \{1,2,\ldots,n\}$ is called stable if it forms an independent set in the cycle on the vertex set $[n]$. In 1978, Schrijver proved via a topological argument that for all integers $n$ and $k$ with $n \geq 2k$, the family of stable $k$-subsets of $[n]$ cannot be covered by $n-2k+1$ intersecting families. We study two total search problems whose totality relies on this result. In the first problem, denoted by $\mathsf{Schrijve}r(n,k,m)$, we are given an access to a coloring of the stable $k$-subsets of $[n]$ with $m = m(n,k)$ colors, where $m \leq n-2k+1$, and the goal is to find a pair of disjoint subsets that are assigned the same color. While for $m = n-2k+1$ the problem is known to be $\mathsf{PPA}$-complete, we prove that for $m < d \cdot \lfloor \frac{n}{2k+d-2} \rfloor$, with $d$ being any fixed constant, the problem admits an efficient algorithm. For $m = \lfloor n/2 \rfloor-2k+1$, we prove that the problem is efficiently reducible to the $\mathsf{Kneser}$ problem. Motivated by the relation between the problems, we investigate the family of unstable $k$-subsets of $[n]$, which might be of independent interest. In the second problem, called Unfair Independent Set in Cycle, we are given $\ell$ subsets $V_1, \ldots, V_\ell$ of $[n]$, where $\ell \leq n-2k+1$ and $|V_i| \geq 2$ for all $i \in [\ell]$, and the goal is to find a stable $k$-subset $S$ of $[n]$ satisfying the constraints $|S \cap V_i| \leq |V_i|/2$ for $i \in [\ell]$. We prove that the problem is $\mathsf{PPA}$-complete and that its restriction to instances with $n=3k$ is at least as hard as the Cycle plus Triangles problem, for which no efficient algorithm is known. On the contrary, we prove that there exists a constant $c$ for which the restriction of the problem to instances with $n \geq c \cdot k$ can be solved in polynomial time.

The orthogonality dimension of a graph $G$ over $\mathbb{R}$ is the smallest integer $k$ for which one can assign a nonzero $k$-dimensional real vector to each vertex of $G$, such that every two adjacent vertices receive orthogonal vectors. We prove that for every sufficiently large integer $k$, it is $\mathsf{NP}$-hard to decide whether the orthogonality dimension of a given graph over $\mathbb{R}$ is at most $k$ or at least $2^{(1-o(1)) \cdot k/2}$. We further prove such hardness results for the orthogonality dimension over finite fields as well as for the closely related minrank parameter, which is motivated by the index coding problem in information theory. This in particular implies that it is $\mathsf{NP}$-hard to approximate these graph quantities to within any constant factor. Previously, the hardness of approximation was known to hold either assuming certain variants of the Unique Games Conjecture or for approximation factors smaller than $3/2$. The proofs involve the concept of line digraphs and bounds on their orthogonality dimension and on the minrank of their complement.

The binary rank of a $0,1$ matrix is the smallest size of a partition of its ones into monochromatic combinatorial rectangles. A matrix $M$ is called $(k_1, \ldots, k_m ; n_1, \ldots, n_m)$ circulant block diagonal if it is a block matrix with $m$ diagonal blocks, such that for each $i \in [m]$, the $i$th diagonal block of $M$ is the circulant matrix whose first row has $k_i$ ones followed by $n_i-k_i$ zeros, and all of whose other entries are zeros. In this work, we study the binary rank of these matrices and of their complement. In particular, we compare the binary rank of these matrices to their rank over the reals, which forms a lower bound on the former. We present a general method for proving upper bounds on the binary rank of block matrices that have diagonal blocks of some specified structure and ones elsewhere. Using this method, we prove that the binary rank of the complement of a $(k_1, \ldots, k_m ; n_1, \ldots, n_m)$ circulant block diagonal matrix for integers satisfying $n_i>k_i>0$ for each $i \in [m]$ exceeds its real rank by no more than the maximum of $\gcd(n_i,k_i)-1$ over all $i \in [m]$. We further present several sufficient conditions for the binary rank of these matrices to strictly exceed their real rank. By combining the upper and lower bounds, we determine the exact binary rank of various families of matrices and, in addition, significantly generalize a result of Gregory. Motivated by a question of Pullman, we study the binary rank of $k$-regular $0,1$ matrices and of their complement. As an application of our results on circulant block diagonal matrices, we show that for every $k \geq 2$, there exist $k$-regular $0,1$ matrices whose binary rank is strictly larger than that of their complement. Furthermore, we exactly determine for every integer $r$, the smallest possible binary rank of the complement of a $2$-regular $0,1$ matrix with binary rank $r$.

The Kneser graph $K(n,k)$ is defined for integers $n$ and $k$ with $n \geq 2k$ as the graph whose vertices are all the $k$-subsets of $[n]=\{1,2,\ldots,n\}$ where two such sets are adjacent if they are disjoint. The Schrijver graph $S(n,k)$ is defined as the subgraph of $K(n,k)$ induced by the collection of all $k$-subsets of $[n]$ that do not include two consecutive elements modulo $n$. It is known that the chromatic number of both $K(n,k)$ and $S(n,k)$ is $n-2k+2$. In the computational Kneser and Schrijver problems, we are given an access to a coloring with $n-2k+1$ colors of the vertices of $K(n,k)$ and $S(n,k)$ respectively, and the goal is to find a monochromatic edge. We prove that the problems admit randomized algorithms with running time $n^{O(1)} \cdot k^{O(k)}$, hence they are fixed-parameter tractable with respect to the parameter $k$. The analysis involves structural results on intersecting families and on induced subgraphs of Kneser and Schrijver graphs. We also study the Agreeable-Set problem of assigning a small subset of a set of $m$ items to a group of $\ell$ agents, so that all agents value the subset at least as much as its complement. As an application of our algorithm for the Kneser problem, we obtain a randomized polynomial-time algorithm for the Agreeable-Set problem for instances with $\ell \geq m - O(\frac{\log m}{\log \log m})$. We further show that the Agreeable-Set problem is at least as hard as a variant of the Kneser problem with an extended access to the input coloring.

The Kneser graph $K(n,k)$ is defined for integers $n$ and $k$ with $n \geq 2k$ as the graph whose vertices are all the $k$-subsets of $\{1,2,\ldots,n\}$ where two such sets are adjacent if they are disjoint. A classical result of Lovász asserts that the chromatic number of $K(n,k)$ is $n-2k+2$. In the computational Kneser problem, we are given an oracle access to a coloring of the vertices of $K(n,k)$ with $n-2k+1$ colors, and the goal is to find a monochromatic edge. We present a randomized algorithm for the Kneser problem with running time $n^{O(1)} \cdot k^{O(k)}$. This shows that the problem is fixed-parameter tractable with respect to the parameter $k$. The analysis involves structural results on intersecting families and on induced subgraphs of Kneser graphs. We also study the Agreeable-Set problem of assigning a small subset of a set of $m$ items to a group of $\ell$ agents, so that all agents value the subset at least as much as its complement. As an application of our algorithm for the Kneser problem, we obtain a randomized polynomial-time algorithm for the Agreeable-Set problem for instances that satisfy $\ell \geq m - O(\frac{\log m}{\log \log m})$. We further show that the Agreeable-Set problem is at least as hard as a variant of the Kneser problem with an extended access to the input coloring.

A $0,1$ matrix is said to be regular if all of its rows and columns have the same number of ones. We prove that for infinitely many integers $k$, there exists a square regular $0,1$ matrix with binary rank $k$, such that the Boolean rank of its complement is $k^{\widetildeΩ(\log k)}$. Equivalently, the ones in the matrix can be partitioned into $k$ combinatorial rectangles, whereas the number of rectangles needed for any cover of its zeros is $k^{\widetildeΩ(\log k)}$. This settles, in a strong form, a question of Pullman (Linear Algebra Appl., 1988) and a conjecture of Hefner, Henson, Lundgren, and Maybee (Congr. Numer., 1990). The result can be viewed as a regular analogue of a recent result of Balodis, Ben-David, Göös, Jain, and Kothari (FOCS, 2021), motivated by the clique vs. independent set problem in communication complexity and by the (disproved) Alon-Saks-Seymour conjecture in graph theory. As an application of the produced regular matrices, we obtain regular counterexamples to the Alon-Saks-Seymour conjecture and prove that for infinitely many integers $k$, there exists a regular graph with biclique partition number $k$ and chromatic number $k^{\widetildeΩ(\log k)}$.

A graph $G$ is said to be $k$-subspace choosable over a field $\mathbb{F}$ if for every assignment of $k$-dimensional subspaces of some finite-dimensional vector space over $\mathbb{F}$ to the vertices of $G$, it is possible to choose for each vertex a nonzero vector from its subspace so that adjacent vertices receive orthogonal vectors over $\mathbb{F} $. The subspace choice number of $G$ over $\mathbb{F}$ is the smallest integer $k$ for which $G$ is $k$-subspace choosable over $\mathbb{F}$. This graph parameter, introduced by Haynes, Park, Schaeffer, Webster, and Mitchell (Electron. J. Comb., 2010), is inspired by well-studied variants of the chromatic number of graphs, such as the (color) choice number and the orthogonality dimension. We study the subspace choice number of graphs over various fields. We first prove that the subspace choice number of every graph with average degree $d$ is at least $Ω(\sqrt{d/\ln d})$ over any field. We then focus on bipartite graphs and consider the problem of estimating, for a given integer $k$, the smallest integer $m$ for which the subspace choice number of the complete bipartite graph $K_{k,m}$ over a field $\mathbb{F}$ exceeds $k$. We prove upper and lower bounds on this quantity as well as for several extensions of this problem. Our results imply a substantial difference between the behavior of the choice number and that of the subspace choice number. We also consider the computational aspect of the subspace choice number, and show that for every $k \geq 3$ it is $\mathsf{NP}$-hard to decide whether the subspace choice number of a given bipartite graph over $\mathbb{F}$ is at most $k$, provided that $\mathbb{F}$ is either the real field or any finite field.

An orthogonal representation of a graph $G$ over a field $\mathbb{F}$ is an assignment of a vector $u_v \in \mathbb{F}^t$ to every vertex $v$ of $G$, such that $\langle u_v,u_v \rangle \neq 0$ for every vertex $v$ and $\langle u_v,u_{v'} \rangle = 0$ whenever $v$ and $v'$ are adjacent in $G$. The locality of the orthogonal representation is the largest dimension of a subspace spanned by the vectors associated with a closed neighborhood in the graph. We introduce a novel graph parameter, called the local orthogonality dimension, defined for a given graph $G$ and a given field $\mathbb{F}$, as the smallest possible locality of an orthogonal representation of $G$ over $\mathbb{F}$. We investigate the usefulness of topological methods for proving lower bounds on the local orthogonality dimension. We prove that graphs for which topological methods imply a lower bound of $t$ on their chromatic number have local orthogonality dimension at least $\lceil t/2 \rceil +1$ over every field, strengthening a result of Simonyi and Tardos on the local chromatic number. We show that for certain graphs this lower bound is tight, whereas for others, the local orthogonality dimension over the reals is equal to the chromatic number. More generally, we prove that for every complement of a line graph, the local orthogonality dimension over $\mathbb{R}$ coincides with the chromatic number. This strengthens a recent result by Daneshpajouh, Meunier, and Mizrahi, who proved that the local and standard chromatic numbers of these graphs are equal. As another extension of their result, we prove that the local and standard chromatic numbers are equal for some additional graphs, from the family of Kneser graphs. We also show an $\mathsf{NP}$-hardness result for the local orthogonality dimension and present an application of this graph parameter to the index coding problem from information theory.

The Boolean rank of a $0,1$-matrix $A$, denoted $R_\mathbb{B}(A)$, is the smallest number of monochromatic combinatorial rectangles needed to cover the $1$-entries of $A$. In 1988, de Caen, Gregory, and Pullman asked if the Boolean rank of the Kronecker product $C_n \otimes C_n$ is strictly smaller than the square of $R_\mathbb{B}(C_n)$, where $C_n$ is the $n \times n$ matrix with zeros on the diagonal and ones everywhere else (Carib. Conf. Comb. & Comp., 1988). A positive answer was given by Watts for $n=4$ (Linear Alg. and its Appl., 2001). A result of Karchmer, Kushilevitz, and Nisan, motivated by direct-sum questions in non-deterministic communication complexity, implies that the Boolean rank of $C_n \otimes C_n$ grows linearly in that of $C_n$ (SIAM J. Disc. Math., 1995), and thus $R_\mathbb{B}(C_n \otimes C_n) < R_\mathbb{B}(C_n)^2$ for every sufficiently large $n$. Their proof relies on a probabilistic argument. In this work, we present a general method for proving upper bounds on the Boolean rank of Kronecker products of $0,1$-matrices. We use it to affirmatively settle the question of de Caen et al. for all integers $n \geq 7$. We further provide an explicit construction of a cover of $C_n \otimes C_n$, whose number of rectangles nearly matches the optimal asymptotic bound. Our method for proving upper bounds on the Boolean rank of Kronecker products might find applications in different settings as well. We express its potential applicability by extending it to the wider framework of spanoids, recently introduced by Dvir, Gopi, Gu, and Wigderson (SIAM J. Comput., 2020).

A Maximum Distance Separable code over an alphabet $F$ is defined via an encoding function $C:F^k \rightarrow F^n$ that allows to retrieve a message $m \in F^k$ from the codeword $C(m)$ even after erasing any $n-k$ of its symbols. The minimum possible alphabet size of general (non-linear) MDS codes for given parameters $n$ and $k$ is unknown and forms one of the central open problems in coding theory. The paper initiates the study of the alphabet size of codes in a generalized setting where the coding scheme is required to handle a pre-specified subset of all possible erasure patterns, naturally represented by an $n$-vertex $k$-uniform hypergraph. We relate the minimum possible alphabet size of such codes to the strong chromatic number of the hypergraph and analyze the tightness of the obtained bounds for both the linear and non-linear settings. We further consider variations of the problem which allow a small probability of decoding error.

The orthogonality dimension of a graph $G=(V,E)$ over a field $\mathbb{F}$ is the smallest integer $t$ for which there exists an assignment of a vector $u_v \in \mathbb{F}^t$ with $\langle u_v,u_v \rangle \neq 0$ to every vertex $v \in V$, such that $\langle u_v, u_{v'} \rangle = 0$ whenever $v$ and $v'$ are adjacent vertices in $G$. The study of the orthogonality dimension of graphs is motivated by various applications in information theory and in theoretical computer science. The contribution of the present work is two-fold. First, we prove that there exists a constant $c$ such that for every sufficiently large integer $t$, it is $\mathsf{NP}$-hard to decide whether the orthogonality dimension of an input graph over $\mathbb{R}$ is at most $t$ or at least $3t/2-c$. At the heart of the proof lies a geometric result, which might be of independent interest, on a generalization of the orthogonality dimension parameter for the family of Kneser graphs, analogously to a long-standing conjecture of Stahl (J. Comb. Theo. Ser. B, 1976). Second, we study the smallest possible orthogonality dimension over finite fields of the complement of graphs that do not contain certain fixed subgraphs. In particular, we provide an explicit construction of triangle-free $n$-vertex graphs whose complement has orthogonality dimension over the binary field at most $n^{1-δ}$ for some constant $δ>0$. Our results involve constructions from the family of generalized Kneser graphs and they are motivated by the rigidity approach to circuit lower bounds. We use them to answer a couple of questions raised by Codenotti, Pudlák, and Resta (Theor. Comput. Sci., 2000), and in particular, to disprove their Odd Alternating Cycle Conjecture over every finite field.

In the index coding problem a sender holds a message $x \in \{0,1\}^n$ and wishes to broadcast information to $n$ receivers in a way that enables the $i$th receiver to retrieve the $i$th bit $x_i$. Every receiver has prior side information comprising a subset of the bits of $x$, and the goal is to minimize the length of the information sent via the broadcast channel. Porter and Wootters have recently introduced the model of embedded index coding, where the receivers also play the role of the sender and the goal is to minimize the total length of their broadcast information. An embedded index code is said to be task-based if every receiver retrieves its bit based only on the information provided by one of the receivers. This paper studies the effect of the task-based restriction on linear embedded index coding. It is shown that for certain side information maps there exists a linear embedded index code of length quadratically smaller than that of any task-based embedded index code. The result attains, up to a multiplicative constant, the largest possible gap between the two quantities. The proof is by an explicit construction and the analysis involves spectral techniques.

A $t$-dimensional orthogonal representation of a hypergraph is an assignment of nonzero vectors in $\mathbb{R}^t$ to its vertices, such that every hyperedge contains two vertices whose vectors are orthogonal. The orthogonality dimension of a hypergraph $H$, denoted by $\overlineξ(H)$, is the smallest integer $t$ for which there exists a $t$-dimensional orthogonal representation of $H$. In this paper we study computational aspects of the orthogonality dimension of graphs and hypergraphs. We prove that for every $k \geq 4$, it is $\mathsf{NP}$-hard (resp. quasi-$\mathsf{NP}$-hard) to distinguish $n$-vertex $k$-uniform hypergraphs $H$ with $\overlineξ(H) \leq 2$ from those satisfying $\overlineξ(H) \geq Ω(\log^δn)$ for some constant $δ>0$ (resp. $\overlineξ(H) \geq Ω(\log^{1-o(1)} n)$). For graphs, we relate the $\mathsf{NP}$-hardness of approximating the orthogonality dimension to a variant of a long-standing conjecture of Stahl. We also consider the algorithmic problem in which given a graph $G$ with $\overlineξ(G) \leq 3$ the goal is to find an orthogonal representation of $G$ of as low dimension as possible, and provide a polynomial time approximation algorithm based on semidefinite programming.

A set of integers is sum-free if it contains no solution to the equation $x+y=z$. We study sum-free subsets of the set of integers $[n]=\{1,\ldots,n\}$ for which the integer $2n+1$ cannot be represented as a sum of their elements. We prove a bound of $O(2^{n/3})$ on the number of these sets, which matches, up to a multiplicative constant, the lower bound obtained by considering all subsets of $B_n = \{ \lceil \frac{2}{3}(n+1) \rceil, \ldots, n \}$. A main ingredient in the proof is a stability theorem saying that if a subset of $[n]$ of size close to $|B_n|$ contains only a few subsets that contradict the sum-freeness or the forbidden sum, then it is almost contained in $B_n$. Our results are motivated by the question of counting symmetric complete sum-free subsets of cyclic groups of prime order. The proofs involve Freiman's $3k-4$ theorem, Green's arithmetic removal lemma, and structural results on independent sets in hypergraphs.

An orthogonal representation of a graph is an assignment of nonzero real vectors to its vertices such that distinct non-adjacent vertices are assigned to orthogonal vectors. We prove general lower bounds on the dimension of orthogonal representations of graphs using the Borsuk-Ulam theorem from algebraic topology. Our bounds strengthen the Kneser conjecture, proved by Lovász in 1978, and some of its extensions due to Bárány, Schrijver, Dol'nikov, and Kriz. As applications, we determine the integrality gap of fractional upper bounds on the Shannon capacity of graphs and the quantum one-round communication complexity of certain promise equality problems.