arXiv++ Combinatorics

The quantum chromatic number is a fundamental parameter in the study of nonlocal games, capturing the extent to which entanglement can improve performance in distributed tasks. In this paper, we investigate the quantum chromatic number of generalized Johnson graphs. By constructing modulus-one orthogonal representations, we obtain general upper bounds on their quantum chromatic numbers. We further analyze the smallest eigenvalue of these graphs. Combining the resulting Hoffman-type lower bounds with the upper bounds obtained from orthogonal representations, we determine the exact quantum chromatic numbers of two infinite families of generalized Johnson graphs. Finally, applying a forbidden-distance theorem for binary codes, we show that the classical chromatic numbers of these families grow exponentially with $n$, whereas their quantum chromatic numbers grow linearly. These families exhibit an exponential separation between the classical and quantum chromatic numbers.

We establish a strict logical separation between two distinct phenomena in orthogonality hypergraphs: chromatic completeness, the possibility of assigning a single globally consistent nondegenerate spectrum to all contexts, and geometric coordinatizability, the existence of a faithful orthogonal representation by rays. A strong chromatic number larger than the Hilbert-space dimension obstructs only the former. It does not, by itself, obstruct the existence of a faithful orthogonal representation. We make this separation explicit by comparing two three-dimensional examples with the same strong chromatic number. A completed 25-ray version of the Yu-Oh configuration has strong chromatic number four and nevertheless possesses an explicit faithful orthogonal representation in R^3. Conversely, Greechie's G_{32} hypergraph also has strong chromatic number four, and has a separating and unital set of two-valued states, but we give an elementary algebraic proof that it admits no faithful orthogonal representation in C^3. The obstruction in G_{32} is therefore not chromatic but projective-geometric: the incidence relations force two distinct atoms to collapse onto the same ray.

In 1987 Hiroshi Maehara conjectured that a graph can be represented by vectors considered adjacent when not orthogonal (a faithful orthogonal representation) in codimension the minimum degree of the graph. Without settling the conjecture, Làslò Lovàsz, Michael Saks, and Alexander Schrijver (LSS) showed that a codimension of vertex connectivity both suffices and is best possible under the additional assumption of general position, and gave a probabilistic construction for producing such representations. The present work proves the conjecture of Maehara as well as related conjectures, variants of the Delta Conjecture, that have arisen independently in combinatorial matrix theory. The strongest of these is that minimum degree of G gives a lower bound for the maximum nullity of a positive definite matrix with pattern G that has the Strong Arnold Property (SAP). Such nullity questions are an important subcase of the Inverse Eigenvalue Problem for a Graph (IEPG). The name greedegree is introduced for the largest possible final degree of a maximum cardinality search (MSC) ordering, which is to say an ordering that greedily maximizes adjacencies to previous chosen vertices. The name upper-zero generic is introduced to describe symmetric matrices with nonzero diagonal such that the zeros above the diagonal in any column belong to an independent set of rows, which matrices necessarily have the SAP. The proof technique takes the probabilistic construction of LSS and parametrizes it completely in terms of independent variables, producing large polynomials that are reasoned about using an introduced operad of hanging garden diagrams. In the case of an MSC ordering in codimension greedegree, it is shown that the leading monomial in an appropriate term order has no canceling term, giving a nonzero polynomial. The resulting representation is faithful with upper-zero generic Gram matrix.

Given a finite simple graph $G$ and a positive integer $d$, one can associate to $G$ the Lovász--Saks--Schrijver ideal $L_{G}(d)$, an ideal generated by quadratic polynomials coming from orthogonality conditions. The corresponding variety $\mathbb{V}(L_{G}(d))$, denoted $\mathrm{OR}_{d}(\overline{G})$, is the variety of orthogonal representations of the complement graph $\overline{G}$: its points are maps from the vertex set of $G$ to $\mathbb{K}^{d}$ that send adjacent vertices of $G$ to orthogonal vectors. In this paper we study the irreducible decomposition of $\mathrm{OR}_{d}(\overline{G})$ and the primary decomposition of $L_{G}(d)$. Our main focus is the case in which $G$ is a forest. Under this assumption, we determine the irreducible components of $\mathrm{OR}_{d}(\overline{G})$, compute their dimensions, and describe their defining equations, thereby obtaining the primary decomposition of $L_{G}(d)$. The key ingredient is a matroid-theoretic framework in which we associate to every forest $G$ a paving matroid $\mathcal{M}(G)$.

Quantum coloring finds applications in quantum cryptography and information. In this paper, we study the quantum chromatic numbers of Hamming graphs and a generalization of Hadamard graphs. We investigate the separation between the quantum and classical chromatic numbers of these graphs and determine the quantum chromatic numbers for some of them. For the upper bounds of the quantum chromatic numbers, we develop a linear programming approach over the Hamming scheme to construct modulus-one orthogonal representations. For the lower bounds, we determine the minimum eigenvalues for some of these graphs to derive corresponding spectral lower bounds on their quantum chromatic numbers.

We investigate the open problem of the existence of genuinely unextendible product bases (GUPBs), that is, multipartite unextendible product bases (UPBs) which remain unextendible even with respect to biproduct vectors across all bipartitions of the parties. To this end, we exploit the well-known connection between UPBs and graph theory through orthogonality graphs and orthogonal representations, together with recent progress in this framework, and employ forbidden induced subgraph characterizations to single out the admissible local orthogonality graphs for GUPBs. Using this approach, we establish that GUPBs of size thirteen in three-qutrit systems-the smallest candidate GUPBs-do not exist. We further provide a partial characterization of graphs relevant to larger bases and systems with ququart subsystems.

Every simple finite graph $G$ has an associated Lovász-Saks-Schrijver ring $R_G(d)$ that is related to the $d$-dimensional orthogonal representations of $G$. The study of $R_G(d)$ lies at the intersection between algebraic geometry, commutative algebra and combinatorics. We find a link between algebraic properties such as normality, factoriality and strong $F$-regularity of $R_G(d)$ and combinatorial invariants of the graph $G$. In particular we prove that if $d \geq \text{pmd}(G)+k(G)$ then $R_G(d)$ is $F$-regular in finite characteristic and rational singularity in characteristic $0$ and furthermore if $d \geq \text{pmd}(G)+k(G)+1$ then $R_G(d)$ is UFD. Here $\text{pmd}(G)$ is the positive matching decomposition number of $G$ and $k(G)$ is its degeneracy number.

Let $\mathfrak g$ be a reductive Lie algebra, and $m$ a positive integer. There is a natural density of irreducible representations of $\mathfrak g$, whose degrees are not divisible by $m$. For $\mathfrak g=\mathfrak{gl}_n$, this density decays exponentially to $0$ as $n \to \infty$. Similar results hold for simple Lie algebras and Lie groups, and there are versions for self-dual and orthogonal representations.

In this note, we provide a new proof that a $D$-connected graph $G$ on $n$ vertices has a general position orthogonal representation in $\RR^{n-D}$. Our argument, while based on many of the concepts from the original proof due to Lovász, Saks and Schrijver, does not use the probabilistic method.

We investigate the sparsity of null vectors of real symmetric matrices whose off-diagonal pattern of zero and nonzero entries is described by the adjacencies of a graph. We use the definition of the spark of a matrix, the smallest number of nonzero coordinates of any null vector, to define the spark of a graph as the smallest possible spark of a corresponding matrix. We study connections of graph spark to well-known concepts including minimum rank, forts, orthogonal representations, Parter and Fiedler vertices, and vertex connectivity.

A matching $M$ in a graph $Γ$ is positive if $Γ$ has a vertex-labeling such that $M$ coincides with the set of edges with positive weights. A positive matching decomposition (pmd) of $Γ$ is an edge-partition $M_1,\ldots,M_p$ of $Γ$ such that $M_i$ is a positive matching in $Γ-M_1\cup\cdots\cup M_{i-1}$, for $i=1,\ldots,p$. The pmds of graphs are used to study algebraic properties of the Lovász-Saks-Schrijver ideals arising from orthogonal representations of graphs. We give a characterization of pmds of graphs in terms of alternating closed walks and apply it to study pmds of various classes of graphs including complete multipartite graphs, (regular) bipartite graphs, cacti, generalized Petersen graphs, etc. We further show that computation of pmds of a graph can be reduced to that of its maximum pendant-free subgraph.

Tverberg's theorem states that any set of $t(r,d)=(r-1)(d+1)+1$ points in $\mathbb{R}^d$ can be partitioned into $r$ subsets whose convex hulls have non-empty $r$-fold intersection. Moreover, generic collections of fewer points cannot be so divided. Extending earlier work of the first author, we show that one can nonetheless guarantee inscribed ``polytopal partitions" with specified symmetry conditions in many such circumstances. Namely, for any faithful and full--dimensional orthogonal representation $ρ\colon G\rightarrow O(d)$ of any order $r$ group $G$, we show that a generic set of $t(r,d)-d$ points in $\mathbb{R}^d$ can be partitioned into $r$ subsets so that there are $r$ points, one from each of the resulting convex hulls, which are the vertices of a convex $d$--polytope whose isometry group contains $G$ via the regular action afforded by the representation. As with Tverberg's theorem, the number of points is optimal for this. At one extreme, this gives polytopal partitions for all regular $r$--gons in the plane, as well as for three of the six regular 4--polytopes in $\mathbb{R}^4$. At the other extreme, one has polytopal partitions for $d$-polytopes on $r$ vertices with isometry group equal to $G$ whenever $G$ is the isometry group of a vertex--transitive $d$-polytope.

An orthogonal representation of a graph $G$ over a field $\mathbb{F}$ is an assignment of a vector $u_v \in \mathbb{F}^t$ to every vertex $v$ of $G$, such that $\langle u_v,u_v \rangle \neq 0$ for every vertex $v$ and $\langle u_v,u_{v'} \rangle = 0$ whenever $v$ and $v'$ are adjacent in $G$. The locality of the orthogonal representation is the largest dimension of a subspace spanned by the vectors associated with a closed neighborhood in the graph. We introduce a novel graph parameter, called the local orthogonality dimension, defined for a given graph $G$ and a given field $\mathbb{F}$, as the smallest possible locality of an orthogonal representation of $G$ over $\mathbb{F}$. We investigate the usefulness of topological methods for proving lower bounds on the local orthogonality dimension. We prove that graphs for which topological methods imply a lower bound of $t$ on their chromatic number have local orthogonality dimension at least $\lceil t/2 \rceil +1$ over every field, strengthening a result of Simonyi and Tardos on the local chromatic number. We show that for certain graphs this lower bound is tight, whereas for others, the local orthogonality dimension over the reals is equal to the chromatic number. More generally, we prove that for every complement of a line graph, the local orthogonality dimension over $\mathbb{R}$ coincides with the chromatic number. This strengthens a recent result by Daneshpajouh, Meunier, and Mizrahi, who proved that the local and standard chromatic numbers of these graphs are equal. As another extension of their result, we prove that the local and standard chromatic numbers are equal for some additional graphs, from the family of Kneser graphs. We also show an $\mathsf{NP}$-hardness result for the local orthogonality dimension and present an application of this graph parameter to the index coding problem from information theory.

Subgraph densities have been defined, and served as basic tools, both in the case of graphons (limits of dense graph sequences) and graphings (limits of bounded-degree graph sequences). While limit objects have been described for the "middle ranges", the notion of subgraph densities in these limit objects remains elusive. We define subgraph densities in the orthogonality graphs on the unit spheres in dimension $d$, under appropriate sparsity condition on the subgraphs. These orthogonality graphs exhibit the main difficulties of defining subgraphs the "middle" range, and so we expect their study to serve as a key example to defining subgraph densities in more general Markov spaces. The problem can also be formulated as defining and computing random orthogonal representations of graphs. Orthogonal representations have played a role in information theory, optimization, rigidity theory and quantum physics, so to study random ones may be of interest from the point of view of these applications as well.

Any finite simple graph $G = (V,E)$ can be represented by a collection $\mathscr{C}$ of subsets of $V$ such that $uv\in E$ if and only if $u$ and $v$ appear together in an odd number of sets in $\mathscr{C}$. Let $c_2(G)$ denote the minimum cardinality of such a collection. This invariant is equivalent to the minimum dimension of a faithful orthogonal representation of $G$ over $\mathbb{F}_2$ and is closely connected to the minimum rank of $G$. We show that $c_2(G) = \operatorname{mr}(G,\mathbb{F}_2)$ when $\operatorname{mr}(G,\mathbb{F}_2)$ is odd, or when $G$ is a forest. Otherwise, $\operatorname{mr}(G,\mathbb{F}_2)\leq c_2(G)\leq \operatorname{mr}(G,\mathbb{F}_2)+1$. Furthermore, we show that the following are equivalent for any graph $G$ with at least one edge: i. $c_2(G)=\operatorname{mr}(G,\mathbb{F}_2)+1$; ii. the adjacency matrix of $G$ is the unique matrix of rank $\operatorname{mr}(G,\mathbb{F}_2)$ which fits $G$ over $\mathbb{F}_2$; iii. there is a minimum collection $\mathscr{C}$ as described in which every vertex appears an even number of times; and iv. for every component $G'$ of $G$, $c_2(G') = \operatorname{mr}(G',\mathbb{F}_2) + 1$. We also show that, for these graphs, $\operatorname{mr}(G,\mathbb{F}_2)$ is twice the minimum number of tricliques whose symmetric difference of edge sets is $E$. Additionally, we provide a set of upper bounds on $c_2(G)$ in terms of the order, size, and vertex cover number of $G$. Finally, we show that the class of graphs with $c_2(G)\leq k$ is hereditary and finitely defined. For odd $k$, the sets of minimal forbidden induced subgraphs are the same as those for the property $\operatorname{mr}(G,\mathbb{F}_2)\leq k$, and we exhibit this set for $c_2(G)\leq2$.

In quantum information theory there is a construction for quantum channels, appropriately called a quantum graph, that generalizes the confusability graph construction for classical channels in classical information theory. In this paper, we provide a definition of connectedness for quantum graphs that generalizes the classical definition. This is used to prove a quantum version of a particular case of the classical tree-packing theorem from graph theory. Generalizations for the related notions of $k$-connectedness and of orthogonal representation are also proposed for quantum graphs, and it is shown that orthogonal representations have the same implications for connectedness as they do in the classical case.

A \textit{geometric realization} of an abstract polyhedron $\mathcal{P}$ is a mapping $ρ: \mathcal{P} \to \mathbb{E}^3$ that sends an $i$-face to an open set of dimension $i$. This work adapts a method based on Wythoff construction to generate a full rank realization of a regular abstract polyhedron from its automorphism group $Γ$. The method entails finding a real orthogonal representation of $Γ$ of degree 3 and applying its image to suitably chosen open sets in space. To demonstrate the use of the method, we apply it to the abstract polyhedra whose automorphism groups are isomorphic to the non-crystallographic Coxeter group $H_3$.

A $t$-dimensional orthogonal representation of a hypergraph is an assignment of nonzero vectors in $\mathbb{R}^t$ to its vertices, such that every hyperedge contains two vertices whose vectors are orthogonal. The orthogonality dimension of a hypergraph $H$, denoted by $\overlineξ(H)$, is the smallest integer $t$ for which there exists a $t$-dimensional orthogonal representation of $H$. In this paper we study computational aspects of the orthogonality dimension of graphs and hypergraphs. We prove that for every $k \geq 4$, it is $\mathsf{NP}$-hard (resp. quasi-$\mathsf{NP}$-hard) to distinguish $n$-vertex $k$-uniform hypergraphs $H$ with $\overlineξ(H) \leq 2$ from those satisfying $\overlineξ(H) \geq Ω(\log^δn)$ for some constant $δ>0$ (resp. $\overlineξ(H) \geq Ω(\log^{1-o(1)} n)$). For graphs, we relate the $\mathsf{NP}$-hardness of approximating the orthogonality dimension to a variant of a long-standing conjecture of Stahl. We also consider the algorithmic problem in which given a graph $G$ with $\overlineξ(G) \leq 3$ the goal is to find an orthogonal representation of $G$ of as low dimension as possible, and provide a polynomial time approximation algorithm based on semidefinite programming.

An orthogonal representation of a graph is an assignment of nonzero real vectors to its vertices such that distinct non-adjacent vertices are assigned to orthogonal vectors. We prove general lower bounds on the dimension of orthogonal representations of graphs using the Borsuk-Ulam theorem from algebraic topology. Our bounds strengthen the Kneser conjecture, proved by Lovász in 1978, and some of its extensions due to Bárány, Schrijver, Dol'nikov, and Kriz. As applications, we determine the integrality gap of fractional upper bounds on the Shannon capacity of graphs and the quantum one-round communication complexity of certain promise equality problems.

By finding orthogonal representation for a family of simple connected called $δ$-graphs it is possible to show that $δ$-graphs satisfy delta conjecture. An extension of the argument to graphs of the form $\overline{P_{Δ(G)+2}\sqcup G}$ where $P_{Δ(G)+2}$ is a path and $G$ is a simple connected graph it is possible to find an orthogonal representation of $\overline{P_{Δ(G)+2}\sqcup G}$ in $\mathbb{R}^{Δ(G)+1}$. As a consequence we prove delta conjecture.