arXiv++ Combinatorics

The inverse eigenvalue problem of a graph $G$ studies the possible spectra of matrices associated with $G$, including as an important subproblem the possible nullities of such a matrix. Much research in this area to date has focused only on the spectrum of the matrix itself, but there are applications of inverse eigenvalue problems that also involve the interaction between that spectrum and the spectrum of some maximal proper principal submatrix, or in other words the interlacing spectrum that results from crossing out any one row and the same column. Motivated by this refined information, given a graph $G$ on $n$ vertices with a designated root vertex, we investigate all possible nullity pairs where the first nullity is that of an $n \times n$ symmetric matrix associated to $G$ and the second nullity is that of the principal submatrix of size $(n - 1) \times (n - 1)$ that results from deleting the row and column associated to the root vertex. We define a new parameter $ξξ(G,i)$ for rooted graphs $(G,i)$ equipped with the strong nullity interlacing property that coordinates the two values of a nullity pair, and we show that this graph parameter is minor monotone. Moreover, we prove a bifurcation lemma for the strong nullity interlacing property. We use these new tools to characterize the rooted graphs with $ξξ(G,i) \geq s$ for $s \in \{ 0,1,2,3,4, 5\}$ by finding the minimal minors for each of these families. These families turn out to have strong connections to the minimal minors for $ξ(G) \geq k$.

In 1987 Hiroshi Maehara conjectured that a graph can be represented by vectors considered adjacent when not orthogonal (a faithful orthogonal representation) in codimension the minimum degree of the graph. Without settling the conjecture, Làslò Lovàsz, Michael Saks, and Alexander Schrijver (LSS) showed that a codimension of vertex connectivity both suffices and is best possible under the additional assumption of general position, and gave a probabilistic construction for producing such representations. The present work proves the conjecture of Maehara as well as related conjectures, variants of the Delta Conjecture, that have arisen independently in combinatorial matrix theory. The strongest of these is that minimum degree of G gives a lower bound for the maximum nullity of a positive definite matrix with pattern G that has the Strong Arnold Property (SAP). Such nullity questions are an important subcase of the Inverse Eigenvalue Problem for a Graph (IEPG). The name greedegree is introduced for the largest possible final degree of a maximum cardinality search (MSC) ordering, which is to say an ordering that greedily maximizes adjacencies to previous chosen vertices. The name upper-zero generic is introduced to describe symmetric matrices with nonzero diagonal such that the zeros above the diagonal in any column belong to an independent set of rows, which matrices necessarily have the SAP. The proof technique takes the probabilistic construction of LSS and parametrizes it completely in terms of independent variables, producing large polynomials that are reasoned about using an introduced operad of hanging garden diagrams. In the case of an MSC ordering in codimension greedegree, it is shown that the leading monomial in an appropriate term order has no canceling term, giving a nonzero polynomial. The resulting representation is faithful with upper-zero generic Gram matrix.

Zero forcing in a graph refers to the evolution of vertex states under repeated application of a color change rule. Typically the states are chosen to be blue and white, and a forcing set is an initial set of blue vertices such that all of the vertices are blue at the end of the process. In this context, the propagation time of a set in a graph is the number of iterations of the color change rule required to have all vertices blue, performing independent color changes simultaneously. Different minimal forcing sets need not have the same propagation time, and we study the realizability of specific integers as propagation times of minimal forcing sets in graphs for two of the most well-studied color change rules (standard and positive semidefinite). Particular attention is paid to the case where all minimal forcing sets have the same propagation time, and we term this phenomenon fixed propagation time. For each of the two variants, we present a general form of graphs all of which have fixed propagation time equal to one. We conjecture that these are the only such graphs and prove the conjectures for joins of graphs. Families of graphs with longer fixed propagation time for standard forcing are exhibited, and it is shown that such graphs do not exist for positive semidefinite forcing.

The inverse eigenvalue problem studies the possible spectra among matrices whose off-diagonal entries have their zero-nonzero patterns described by the adjacency of a graph $G$. In this paper, we refer to the $i$-nullity pair of a matrix $A$ as $(\operatorname{null}(A), \operatorname{null}(A(i))$, where $A(i)$ is the matrix obtained from $A$ by removing the $i$-th row and column. The inverse $i$-nullity pair problem is considered for complete graphs, cycles, and trees. The strong nullity interlacing property is introduced, and the corresponding supergraph lemma and decontraction lemma are developed as new tools for constructing matrices with a given nullity pair.

If $G$ is a graph and $\mathbf{m}$ is an ordered multiplicity list which is realizable by at least one symmetric matrix with graph $G$, what can we say about the eigenvalues of all such realizing matrices for $\mathbf{m}$? It has sometimes been tempting to expect, especially in the case that $G$ is a tree, that any spacing of the multiple eigenvalues should be realizable. In 2004, however, F. Barioli and S. Fallat produced the first counterexample: a tree on 16 vertices and an ordered multiplicity list for which every realizing set of eigenvalues obeys a nontrivial linear constraint. We extend this by giving an infinite family of trees and ordered multiplicity lists whose sets of realizing eigenvalues are very highly constrained, with at most 5 degrees of freedom, regardless of the size of the tree in this family. In particular, we give the first examples of multiplicity lists for a tree which impose nontrivial nonlinear eigenvalue constraints and produce an ordered multiplicity list which is achieved by a unique set of eigenvalues, up to shifting and scaling.

The smallest possible number of distinct eigenvalues of a graph $G$, denoted by $q(G)$, has a combinatorial bound in terms of unique shortest paths in the graph. In particular, $q(G)$ is bounded below by $k$, where $k$ is the number of vertices of a unique shortest path joining any pair of vertices in $G$. Thus, if $n$ is the number of vertices of $G$, then $n-q(G)$ is bounded above by the size of the complement (with respect to the vertex set of $G$) of the vertex set of the longest unique shortest path joining any pair of vertices of $G$. The purpose of this paper is to commence the study of the minor-monotone floor of $n-k$, which is the minimum of $n-k$ among all graphs of which $G$ is a minor. Accordingly, we prove some results about this minor-monotone floor.

In this article, we extend the notion of the Laplacian spread to simple directed graphs (digraphs) using the restricted numerical range. First, we provide Laplacian spread values for several families of digraphs. Then, we prove sharp upper bounds on the Laplacian spread for all polygonal and balanced digraphs. In particular, we show that the validity of the Laplacian spread bound for balanced digraphs is equivalent to the Laplacian spread conjecture for simple undirected graphs, which was conjectured in 2011 and proven in 2021. Moreover, we prove an equivalent statement for weighted balanced digraphs with weights between $0$ and $1$. Finally, we state several open conjectures that are motivated by empirical data.

We conjecture a new lower bound on the algebraic connectivity of a graph that involves the number of vertices of high eccentricity in a graph. We prove that this lower bound implies a strengthening of the Laplacian Spread Conjecture. We discuss further conjectures, also strengthening the Laplacian Spread Conjecture, that include a conjecture for simple graphs and a conjecture for weighted graphs.

The inverse eigenvalue problem of a graph studies the real symmetric matrices whose off-diagonal pattern is prescribed by the adjacencies of the graph. The strong spectral property (SSP) is an important tool for this problem. This note establishes the bifurcation lemma, which states that if a spectrum can be realized by a matrix with the SSP for some graph, then all the nearby spectra can also be realized by matrices with the SSP for the same graph. The idea of the bifurcation lemma also works for other strong properties and for not necessarily symmetric matrices. This is used to develop new techniques for verifying a spectrally arbitrary pattern or inertially arbitrary pattern. The bifurcation lemma provides a unified theoretical foundation for several known results, such as the stable northeast lemma and the nilpotent-centralizer method.

In 2020, Cameron et al. introduced the restricted numerical range of a digraph (directed graph) as a tool for characterizing digraphs and studying their algebraic connectivity. In particular, digraphs with a restricted numerical range of a single point, a horizontal line segment, and a vertical line segment were characterized as $k$-imploding stars, directed joins of bidirectional digraphs, and regular tournaments, respectively. In this article, we extend these results by investigating digraphs whose restricted numerical range is a convex polygon in the complex plane. We provide computational methods for identifying these polygonal digraphs and show that these digraphs can be broken into three disjoint classes: normal, restricted-normal, and pseudo-normal digraphs, all of which are closed under the digraph complement. We prove sufficient conditions for normal digraphs and show that the directed join of two normal digraphs results in a restricted-normal digraph. Also, we prove that directed joins are the only restricted-normal digraphs when the order is square-free or twice a square-free number. Finally, we provide methods to construct restricted-normal digraphs that are not directed joins for all orders that are neither square-free nor twice a square-free number.

Zero forcing is a combinatorial game played on a graph where the goal is to start with all vertices unfilled and to change them to filled at minimal cost. In the original variation of the game there were two options. Namely, to fill any one single vertex at the cost of a single token; or if any currently filled vertex has a unique non-filled neighbor, then the neighbor is filled for free. This paper investigates a $q$-analogue of zero forcing which introduces a third option involving an oracle. Basic properties of this game are established including determining all graphs which have minimal cost $1$ or $2$ for all possible $q$, and finding the zero forcing number for all trees when $q=1$.

Connections between vital linkages and zero forcing are established. Specifically, the notion of a rigid linkage is introduced as a special kind of unique linkage and it is shown that spanning forcing paths of a zero forcing process form a spanning rigid linkage and thus a vital linkage. A related generalization of zero forcing that produces a rigid linkage via a coloring process is developed. One of the motivations for introducing zero forcing is to provide an upper bound on the maximum multiplicity of an eigenvalue among the real symmetric matrices described by a graph. Rigid linkages and a related notion of rigid shortest linkages are utilized to obtain bounds on the multiplicities of eigenvalues of this family of matrices.

The Heawood graph is the point-block incidence graph of the Fano plane (the unique Steiner triple system of order 7). We show that the minimum semidefinite rank of this graph is 10. That is, 10 is the smallest number of complex dimensions in which this graph has a faithful orthogonal representation, i.e., an assignment of a vector to each vertex such that the edges occur between precisely those vertices given non-orthogonal pairs. Some of our techniques extend to the incidence graphs of Steiner triple systems of larger order, and we include some observations and questions about the more general case.

The inverse eigenvalue problem of a given graph $G$ is to determine all possible spectra of real symmetric matrices whose off-diagonal entries are governed by the adjacencies in $G$. Barrett et al. introduced the Strong Spectral Property (SSP) and the Strong Multiplicity Property (SMP) in [8]. In that paper it was shown that if a graph has a matrix with the SSP (or the SMP) then a supergraph has a matrix with the same spectrum (or ordered multiplicity list) augmented with simple eigenvalues if necessary, that is, subgraph monotonicity. In this paper we extend this to a form of minor monotonicity, with restrictions on where the new eigenvalues appear. These ideas are applied to solve the inverse eigenvalue problem for all graphs of order five, and to characterize forbidden minors of graphs having at most one multiple eigenvalue.

For a given graph G and an associated class of real symmetric matrices whose off-diagonal entries are governed by the adjacencies in G, the collection of all possible spectra for such matrices is considered. Building on the pioneering work of Colin de Verdiere in connection with the Strong Arnold Property, two extensions are devised that target a better understanding of all possible spectra and their associated multiplicities. These new properties are referred to as the Strong Spectral Property and the Strong Multiplicity Property. Finally, these ideas are applied to the minimum number of distinct eigenvalues associated with G, denoted by q(G). The graphs for which q(G) is at least the number of vertices of G less one are characterized.

Zero forcing is a combinatorial game played on a graph with a goal of turning all of the vertices of the graph black while having to use as few "unforced" moves as possible. This leads to a parameter known as the zero forcing number which can be used to give an upper bound for the maximum nullity of a matrix associated with the graph. We introduce a new variation on the zero forcing game which can be used to give an upper bound for the maximum nullity of a matrix associated with a graph that has $q$ negative eigenvalues. This gives some limits to the number of positive eigenvalues that such a graph can have and so can be used to form lower bounds for the inertia set of a graph.

The zero forcing number Z(G), which is the minimum number of vertices in a zero forcing set of a graph G, is used to study the maximum nullity / minimum rank of the family of symmetric matrices described by G. It is shown that for a connected graph of order at least two, no vertex is in every zero forcing set. The positive semidefinite zero forcing number Z_+(G) is introduced, and shown to be equal to |G|-OS(G), where OS(G) is the recently defined ordered set number that is a lower bound for minimum positive semidefinite rank. The positive semidefinite zero forcing number is applied to the computation of positive semidefinite minimum rank of certain graphs. An example of a graph for which the real positive symmetric semidefinite minimum rank is greater than the complex Hermitian positive semidefinite minimum rank is presented.

Considered is the multiplicative semigroup of ratios of products of principal minors bounded over all positive definite matrices. A long history of literature identifies various elements of this semigroup, all of which lie in a sub-semigroup generated by Hadamard-Fischer inequalities. Via cone-theoretic techniques and the patterns of nullity among positive semidefinite matrices, a semigroup containing all bounded ratios is given. This allows the complete determination of the semigroup of bounded ratios for 4-by-4 positive definite matrices, whose 46 generators include ratios not implied by Hadamard-Fischer and ratios not bounded by 1. For n > 4 it is shown that the containment of semigroups is strict, but a generalization of nullity patterns, of which one example is given, is conjectured to provide a finite determination of all bounded ratios.

Let G be an undirected graph on n vertices and let S(G) be the set of all real symmetric n x n matrices whose nonzero off-diagonal entries occur in exactly the positions corresponding to the edges of G. The inverse inertia problem for G asks which inertias can be attained by a matrix in S(G). We give a complete answer to this question for trees in terms of a new family of graph parameters, the maximal disconnection numbers of a graph. We also give a formula for the inertia set of a graph with a cut vertex in terms of inertia sets of proper subgraphs. Finally, we give an example of a graph that is not inertia-balanced, and investigate restrictions on the inertia set of any graph.

A meander of order n is a simple closed curve in the plane which intersects a horizontal line transversely at 2n points. (Meanders which differ by an isotopy of the line and plane are considered equivalent.) Let Gamma_n be the Cayley graph of the symmetric group S_n as generated by all (n choose 2) transpositions. Let Lambda_n be any interval of maximal length in Gamma_n; this graph is the Hasse diagram of the lattice of noncrossing partitions. The meanders of order n are in one-to-one correspondence with ordered pairs of maximally separated vertices of Lambda_n.