arXiv++ Combinatorics

A set $\mathcal{A}$ of nonnegative integers is a $B_h$-set if the sums $a_1+\cdots+a_h$ with $a_1\le\cdots\le a_h$ and $a_i\in\mathcal{A}$ are distinct; a $B_2$-set is a Sidon set. We prove that for every even $h$ and every $B_h$-set $\mathcal{A}$, \[ \liminf_{n\to\infty} \frac{ | \mathcal{A}\cap[0,n) | }{\sqrt[h]{n/\log n}} \le \left(\fracπ{\log 2} \cdot \frac{Γ(1+h/2)^2}{Γ(1+1/h)^{h}}\right)^{1/h}. \]

Let $γ\ge 1$. A set $A$ of nonnegative integers is a Sidon set if for each $d>0$ there is at most one pair $(a,b) \in A \times A$ with $d=a-b$. If there are at most $γ$ pairs, then $A$ is a $γ$-Golomb ruler. We prove that if $A$ is a $γ$-Golomb ruler, then \[\liminf_{n\to\infty} \frac{|A\cap[0,n)|}{\sqrt{n/\log n}} \le \frac{2}{\sqrt{\log 2}} \sqrtγ.\] There is a $γ$-Golomb ruler $G$ with \[ \limsup_{n\to\infty} \frac{|G\cap[0,n)|}{\sqrt n} \ge \frac{1}{\sqrt2} \sqrtγ.\]

A set $\mathcal{G}$ of integers is called a $g$-Golomb ruler of length $n$ if the difference between any two distinct elements of $\mathcal{G}$ is repeated at most $g$ times. If $g=1$, these are also called $B_2$-sets, Sidon sets, and Babcock sets. We define $G(g,n)$ to represent the minimum diameter of a $g$-Golomb Ruler. In this paper, we prove that for all $b\ge 1$, if $g \ge \frac{7}{4}\left(b^{3/2} -b\right)+1,$ then $G(g,g+b)=g+2b-2$. Sharper bounds are given for $b\le 18$. The main technique is through an arithmetic property of the integers that are \emph{not} in a $g$-Golomb ruler, leading us to introduce LM rulers, a new class of rulers where every distance $d$ occurs as a difference at most $d-1$ times. We show that the minimum diameter of an $n$-element LM ruler $L(n)$ is $\sqrt{8/9} \cdot (n-1)^{3/2} \le L(n) \le \frac{7}{4}\left((n+1)^{3/2}-(n+1)\right).$

For a finite set $A\subseteq \mathbb{Z}$, the $h$-fold sumset is $hA :=\{x_1+\dots+x_h:x_i\in A\}$. We interpret the beginning of the sequence of sumset sizes $(|hA|)_{h=1}^\infty$ in terms of the successive $L^1$-minima of a lattice (specifically, the points in $\mathbb{Z}^{|A|}$ whose coordinates sum to 0 and which are perpendicular to $\langle a_1,\dots,a_{|A|}\rangle$). In particular, if $h_1,h_2$ are the first and second minima, and $1\le h<h_1$, then $|hA|=\binom{h+|A|-1}{|A|-1}$, while if $h_1\le h <h_2$, then $|hA|=\binom{h+|A|-1}{|A|-1}-\binom{h-h_1+|A|-1}{|A|-1}$. This explains the appearance of triangular numbers in the sequence of sumset sizes, an observation related to a recent experiment of Nathanson.

Let $SPP(n)$ be the set $\left\{\big(|A+A|,|A A|\big) : A\subseteq {\mathbb N}, |A|=n\right\}$ of sum-product pairs, where $A+A$ is the sumset $\{a+b : a,b\in A\}$ and $A A$ is the product set $\{ab:a,b\in A\}$. We construct a dataset consisting of 1162868 sets whose sum-product pairs are at least $84\%$ of $SPP(n)$ for each $n\le 32$. Notably, we do **not** see evidence in favor of Erdős's Sum-Product Conjecture in our dataset. For $n\le 6$, we prove the exact value of $SPP(n)$. We include a number of conjectures, open problems, and observations motivated by this dataset, a large number of color visualizations.

A set $A$ of nonnegative integers is called a $B_h$-set if every solution to $a_1+\dots+a_h = b_1+\dots+b_h$, where $a_i,b_i \in A$, has $\{a_1,\dots,a_h\}=\{b_1,\dots,b_h\}$ (as multisets). Let $γ_k(h)$ be the $k$-th positive element of the greedy $B_h$-set. We give a nontrivial lower bound on $γ_5(h)$, and a nontrivial upper bound on $γ_k(h)$ for $k\ge 5$. Specifically, $\frac 18 h^4 +\frac12 h^3 \le γ_5(h) \le 0.467214 h^4+O(h^3)$, although we conjecture that $γ_5(h)=\frac13 h^4 +O(h^3)$. We show that $γ_k(h) \ge \frac{1}{k!} h^{k-1} + O(h^{k-2})$ for $k\ge 1$ and $γ_k(h) \le α_k h^{k-1}+O(h^{k-2})$, where $α_6 := 0.382978$, $α_7 := 0.269877$, and for $k\ge 7$, $α_{k+1} := \frac{1}{2^k k!} \sum_{j=0}^{k-1} \binom{k-1}j\binom kj 2^j$. This work begins with a thorough introduction and concludes with a section of open problems.

For $h \geq 1$, a $B_h$-set is a set of integers such that every integer $n$ has at most one representation in the form $n = a_{i_1} + \cdots + a_{i_h}$, where $a_{i_r} \in A$ for all $r = 1,\ldots, h$ and $a_{i_1} \leq \ldots \leq a_{i_h}$. The greedy $B_h$-set is the infinite set of nonnegative integers $\{a_0(h), a_1(h), a_2(h), \ldots \}$ constructed as follows: If $a_0(h) = 0$ and $\{a_0(h), a_1(h), a_2(h), \ldots, a_k(h) \}$ is a $B_h$-set, then $a_{k+1}(h)$ is the least positive integer such that $\{a_0(h), a_1(h), a_2(h), \ldots, a_k(h), a_{k+1}(h) \}$ is a $B_h$-set. Then $a_1(h) = 1$, $a_2(h) = h+1$, and $a_3(h) = h^2+h+1$ for all $h$. This paper proves that $a_4(h)$, the fourth term of the greedy $B_h$-set is $\left( h^3 + 3h^2 + 3h + 1\right) /2$ if $h$ is odd and $\left( h^3 + 2h^2 + 3h + 2\right) /2$ if $h$ is even.

We prove that the diameter of a Sidon set (also known as a Babcock sequence, Golomb ruler, or $B_2$ set) with $k$ elements is at least $k^2-b k^{3/2}-O(k)$ where $b\le 1.96365$, a comparatively large improvement on past results. Equivalently, a Sidon set with diameter $n$ has at most $n^{1/2}+0.98183n^{1/4}+O(1)$ elements. The proof is conceptually simple but very computationally intensive, and the proof uses substantial computer assistance. We also provide a proof of $b\le 1.99058$ that can be verified by hand, which still improves on past results. Finally, we prove that $g$-thin Sidon sets (aka $g$-Golomb rulers) with $k$ elements have diameter at least $g^{-1} k^2 - (2-\varepsilon)g^{-1}k^{3/2} - O(k)$, with $\varepsilon\ge 0.02g^{-2}$.

A subset $A$ of a commutative semigroup $X$ is called a $B_h$ set in $X$ if the only solutions to $a_1+\dots+a_h = b_1 + \cdots +b_h$ (with $a_i,b_i \in A$) are the trivial solutions $\{a_1,\dots,a_h\} = \{b_1,\dots,b_h\}$ (as multisets). With $h=2$ and $X={\mathbb Z}$, these sets are also known as Sidon sets, Golomb Rulers, and Babcock sets. In this work, we generalize constructions of Bose-Chowla and Singer and give the resultant bounds on the diameter of a $k$ element $B_h$ set in $\mathbb Z$ for small $k$. We conclude with a list of open problems.

A Sidon set is a set of integers containing no nontrivial solutions to the equation $a+b=c+d$. We improve on the lower bound on the diameter of a Sidon set with $k$ elements: if $k$ is sufficiently large and ${\cal A}$ is a Sidon set with $k$ elements, then $diam({\cal A})\ge k^2-1.99405 k^{3/2}$. Alternatively, if $n$ is sufficiently large, then the largest subset of $\{1,2,\dots,n\}$ that is a Sidon set has cardinality at most $n^{1/2}+0.99703 n^{1/4}$. While these are only slight numerical improvements on Balogh-Füredi-Roy (arXiv:2103:15850v2), we use a method that is logically simpler.

For a polynomial $P$ of degree $n$ and an $m$-tuple $Λ=(λ_1,\dots,λ_m)$ of distinct complex numbers, the dope matrix of $P$ with respect to $Λ$ is $D_P(Λ)=(δ_{ij})_{i\in [1,m],j\in[0,n]}$, where $δ_{ij}=1$ if $P^{(j)}(λ_i)=0$, and $δ_{ij}=0$ otherwise. Our first result is a combinatorial characterization of the $2$-row dope matrices (for all pairs $Λ$); using this characterization, we solve the associated enumeration problem. We also give upper bounds on the number of $m\times(n+1)$ dope matrices, and we show that the number of $m \times (n+1)$ dope matrices for a fixed $m$-tuple $Λ$ is maximized when $Λ$ is generic. Finally, we resolve an ``extension'' problem of Nathanson and present several open problems.

Fix $A$, a family of subsets of natural numbers, and let $G_A(n)$ be the maximum cardinality of a subset of $\{1,2,..., n\}$ that does not have any subset in $A$. We consider the general problem of giving upper bounds on $G_A(n)$ and give some new upper bounds on some families that are closed under dilation. Specific examples include sets that do not contain any geometric progression of length $k$ with integer ratio, sets that do not contain any geometric progression of length $k$ with rational ratio, and sets of integers that do not contain multiplicative squares, i.e., nontrivial sets of the form $\{a, ar, as, ars\}$.

An improved upper bound is obtained for the density of sequences of positive integers that contain no k-term geometric progression.

We adapt the construction of subsets of {1, 2, ..., N} that contain no k-term arithmetic progressions to give a relatively thick subset of an arbitrary set of N integers. Particular examples include a thick subset of {1, 4, 9, ..., N^2} that does not contain a 3-term AP, and a positive relative density subset of a random set (contained in {1, 2, ..., n} and having density c n^{-1/(k-1)}) that is free of k-term APs.

In 1946, Behrend gave a construction of dense finite sets of integers that do not contain 3-term arithmetic progressions. In 1961, Rankin generalized Behrend's construction to sets avoiding k-term arithmetic progressions, and in 2008 Elkin refined Behrend's 3-term construction. In this work, we combine Elkin's refinement and Rankin's generalization. Arithmetic progressions are handled as a special case of polynomial progressions. In 1946, Behrend gave a construction of dense finite sets of integers that do not contain a 3-term arithmetic progression (AP). In 1961, Rankin generalized Behrend's construction to sets avoiding k-term APs. In 2008, Elkin refined Behrend's 3-term construction, and later in 2008, Green & Wolf found a distinct approach (albeit morally similar) that is technically more straightforward. This work combines Elkin's refinement and Rankin's generalization in the Green & Wolf framework. A curious aspect of the construction is that we induct through sets that do not contain a long polynomial progression in order to construct a set without a long AP. The bounds for r_k(N), the largest size of a subset of {1,2,...,N} that does not contain a k element AP, are (where \log=\log_2, for sufficiently large N, with n=\ceiling{\log k}): r_3(N) > N (\sqrt{360}/(e π^{3/2})-ε) \sqrt[4]{2\log N} * 4^{-\sqrt{2 \log N}}, r_k(N) > CN 2^{-n 2^{(n-1)/2} \sqrt[n]{\log N}+\frac{1}{2n}\log\log N}. The improvement over earlier work is in the simplification of the construction, the explicitness of the bound for r_3, and in the \log\log term for general k.

We adapt a number-theoretic technique of Yu to prove a purely analytic theorem: if f(x) is in L^1 and L^2, is nonnegative, and is supported on an interval of length I, then the supremum of the convolution f*f is at least 0.631 \| f \|_1^2 / I. This improves the previous bound of 0.591389 \| f \|_1^2 / I. Consequently, we improve the known bounds on several related number-theoretic problems. For a subset A of {1,2, ..., n}, let g be the maximum multiplicity of any element of the multiset {a+b: a,b in A}. Our main corollary is the inequality gn>0.631|A|^2, which holds uniformly for all g, n, and A.

Let A be a finite set of integers. For a polynomial f(x_1,...,x_n) with integer coefficients, let f(A) = {f(a_1,...,a_n) : a_1,...,a_n \in A}. In this paper it is proved that for every pair of normalized binary linear forms f(x,y)=u_1x+v_1y and g(x,y)=u_2x+v_2y with integral coefficients, there exist arbitrarily large finite sets of integers A and B such that |f(A)| > |g(A)| and |f(B)| < |g(B)|.

A binary word is a map W : N --> {0,1}, and the set of factors of W with length n is F_n(W):={(W(i),W(i+1),...,W(i+n-1)) : i >= 0}. A word is Sturmian if |F_n(W)|=n+1 for every n>0. We show that the sum of the heights (also known as hamming weights) of the n+1 factors with length n of a binary Sturmian word has the same parity as n, independent of W.

Since addition is commutative but subtraction is not, the sumset S+S of a finite set S is predisposed to be smaller than the difference set S-S. In this paper, however, we show that each of the three possibilities (|S+S|>|S-S|, |S+S|=|S-S|, |S+S|<|S-S|) occur for a positive proportion of the subsets of {0, 1, ..., n-1}. We also show that the difference |S+S| - |S-S| can take any integer value, and we show that the expected number of omitted differences is asymptotically 6 while the expected number of missing sums is asymptotically 10. Other data and conjectures on the distribution of these quantities are also given.

If A is a set of nonnegative integers containing 0, then there is a unique nonempty set B of nonnegative integers such that every positive integer can be written in the form a+b, where a\in A and b\in B, in an even number of ways. We compute the natural density of B for several specific sets A, including the Prouhet-Thue-Morse sequence, {0} \cup {2^n : n \geq 0}, and random sets, and we also study the distribution of densities of B for finite sets A. This problem is motivated by Euler's observation that if A is the set of n that have an odd number of partitions, then B is the set of pentagonal numbers {n(3n+1)/2 : n \in Z}. We also elaborate the connection between this problem and the theory of de Bruijn sequences and linear shift registers.