arXiv++ Combinatorics

This note proves that only a linear number of holes in a Čech complex of $n$ points in $\mathbb{R}^d$ can persist over an interval of constant length. The proof uses a packing argument supported by relating the Čech complexes with corresponding snap complexes over the cells in a partition of space. The bound also applies to Alpha complexes and Vietoris-Rips complexes.

Redistricting is the act of dividing a region into districts for electoral representation. Motivated by this application, we study two questions. How many ways are there to partition the $n\times n$ grid into $n$ contiguous districts of equal size? How many of these partitions are ``compact"? We give asymptotic bounds on the number of plans: a lower bound of roughly $1.41^{n^2}$ and an upper bound of roughly $3.21^{n^2}$. We then use the lower bound to show that most plans are not compact.

We study the persistent homology of an Erdős--Rényi random clique complex filtration on $n$ vertices. Here, each edge $e$ appears at a time $p_e \in [0,1]$ chosen uniform randomly in the interval, and the \emph{persistence} of a cycle $σ$ is defined as $p_2 / p_1$, where $p_1$ and $p_2$ are the birth and death times of the cycle respectively. We show that for fixed $k \ge 1$, with high probability the maximal persistence of a $k$-cycle is of order roughly $n^{1/k(k+1)}$. These results are in sharp contrast with the random geometric setting where earlier work by Bobrowski, Kahle, and Skraba shows that for random Čech and Vietoris--Rips filtrations, the maximal persistence of a $k$-cycle is much smaller, of order $\left(\log n / \log \log n \right)^{1/k}$.

Let $G_n$ be a random geometric graph, and then for $q,p \in [0,1)$ we construct a "$(q,p)$-perturbed noisy random geometric graph" $G_n^{q,p}$ where each existing edge in $G_n$ is removed with probability $q$, while and each non-existent edge in $G_n$ is inserted with probability $p$. We give asymptotically tight bounds on the clique number $ω\left(G_n^{q,p}\right)$ for several regimes of parameter.

We study configuration spaces $C(n; p, q)$ of $n$ ordered unit squares in a $p$ by $q$ rectangle. Our goal is to estimate the Betti numbers for large $n$, $j$, $p$, and $q$. We consider sequences of area-normalized coordinates, where $(\frac{n}{pq}, \frac{j}{pq})$ converges as $n$, $j$, $p$, and $q$ approach infinity. For every sequence that converges to a point in the "feasible region" in the $(x,y)$-plane, we show that the factorial growth rate of the Betti numbers is the same as the factorial growth rate of $n!$. This implies that (1) the Betti numbers are vastly larger than for the configuration space of $n$ ordered points in the plane, which have the factorial growth rate of $j!$, and (2) every point in the feasible region is eventually in the homological liquid regime.

Symmetric edge polytopes are lattice polytopes associated with finite simple graphs that are of interest in both theory and applications. We investigate the facet structure of symmetric edge polytopes for various models of random graphs. For an Erdős-Renyi random graph, we identify a threshold probability at which with high probability the symmetric edge polytope shares many facet-supporting hyperplanes with that of a complete graph. We also investigate the relationship between the average local clustering, also known as the Watts-Strogatz clustering coefficient, and the number of facets for graphs with either a fixed number of edges or a fixed degree sequence. We use well-known Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling methods to generate empirical evidence that for a fixed degree sequence, higher average local clustering in a connected graph corresponds to higher facet numbers in the associated symmetric edge polytope.

We study ordered configuration spaces $C(n;p,q)$ of $n$ hard squares in a $p \times q$ rectangle, a generalization of the well-known "15 Puzzle". Our main interest is in the topology of these spaces. Our first result is to describe a cubical cell complex and prove that is homotopy equivalent to the configuration space. We then focus on determining for which $n$, $j$, $p$, and $q$ the homology group $H_j [ C(n;p,q) ]$ is nontrivial. We prove three homology-vanishing theorems, based on discrete Morse theory on the cell complex. Then we describe several explicit families of nontrivial cycles, and a method for interpolating between parameters to fill in most of the picture for "large-scale" nontrivial homology.

A hypertree, or $\mathbb{Q}$-acyclic complex, is a higher-dimensional analogue of a tree. We study random $2$-dimensional hypertrees according to the determinantal measure suggested by Lyons. We are especially interested in their topological and geometric properties. We show that with high probability, a random $2$-dimensional hypertree $T$ is apsherical, i.e. that it has a contractible universal cover. We also show that with high probability the fundamental group $π_1(T)$ is hyperbolic and has cohomological dimension $2$.

Suppose that $n \ge 2$, and we wish to plant $k$ different types of trees in the squares of an $n \times n$ square grid. We can have as many of each type as we want. The only rule is that every pair of types must occur in an adjacent pair of squares somewhere in the grid. The question is: given $n$, what is the largest that $k$ can be? Denote this number by $Γ(n)$, and call this the *complete coloring number* of the $n \times n$ grid. A little thought shows that $Γ(n) \le 2n-1$. The main question we are interested in is whether $Γ(n) = 2n-1$ for every $n \ge 2$.

We study a natural model of random 2-dimensional cubical complex which is a subcomplex of an n-dimensional cube, and where every possible square $2$-face is included independently with probability p. Our main result is to exhibit a sharp threshold p=1/2 for homology vanishing as $n \to \infty$. This is a 2-dimensional analogue of the Burtin and Erdős-Spencer theorems characterizing the connectivity threshold for random cubical graphs. Our main result can also be seen as a cubical counterpart to the Linial--Meshulam theorem for random 2-dimensional simplicial complexes. However, the models exhibit strikingly different behaviors. We show that if $p > 1 - \sqrt{1/2} \approx 0.2929$, then with high probability the fundamental group is a free group with one generator for every maximal $1$-dimensional face. As a corollary, homology vanishing and simple connectivity have the same threshold, even in the strong "hitting time" sense. This is in contrast with the simplicial case, where the thresholds are far apart. The proof depends on an iterative algorithm for contracting cycles -- we show that with high probability the algorithm rapidly and dramatically simplifies the fundamental group, converging after only a few steps.

We study the topology of the configuration spaces $C(n,w)$ of $n$ hard disks of unit diameter in an infinite strip of width $w$. We describe ranges of parameter or "regimes", where homology $H_j [C(n,w)]$ behaves in qualitatively different ways. We show that if $w \ge j+2$, then the homology $H_j[C(n, w)]$ is isomorphic to the homology of the configuration space of points in the plane, $H_j[C(n, \mathbb{R}^2)]$. The Betti numbers of $C(n, \mathbb{R}^2) $ were computed by Arnold, and so as a corollary of the isomorphism, $β_j[C(n,w)]$ is a polynomial in $n$ of degree $2j$. On the other hand, we show that if $2 \le w \le j+1$, then $β_j [ C(n,w) ]$ grows exponentially with $n$. Most of our work is in carefully estimating $β_j [ C(n,w) ]$ in this regime. We also illustrate, for every $n$, the homological "phase portrait" in the $(w,j)$-plane--- the parameter values where homology $H_j [C(n,w)]$ is trivial, nontrivial, and isomorphic with $H_j [C(n, \mathbb{R}^2)]$. Motivated by the notion of phase transitions for hard-spheres systems, we discuss these as the "homological solid, liquid, and gas" regimes.

We study a model of random graph where vertices are $n$ i.i.d. uniform random points on the unit sphere $S^d$ in $\mathbb{R}^{d+1}$, and a pair of vertices is connected if the Euclidean distance between them is at least $2- ε$. We are interested in the chromatic number of this graph as $n$ tends to infinity. It is not too hard to see that if $ε> 0$ is small and fixed, then the chromatic number is $d+2$ with high probability. We show that this holds even if $ε\to 0$ slowly enough. We quantify the rate at which $ε$ can tend to zero and still have the same chromatic number. The proof depends on combining topological methods (namely the Lyusternik--Schnirelman--Borsuk theorem) with geometric probability arguments. The rate we obtain is best possible, up to a constant factor --- if $ε\to 0$ faster than this, we show that the graph is $(d+1)$-colorable with high probability.

This survey article collects a few of my favorite open problems of Branko Grünbaum.

What is the maximum number of holes that a polyomino with $n$ tiles can enclose? Call this number $f(n)$. We show that if $n_k = \left( 2^{2k+1} + 3 \cdot 2^{k+1}+4 \right) / 3$ and $h_k = \left( 2^{2k}-1 \right) /3$, then $f(n_k) = h_k$ for $k \ge 1$. We also give nearly matching upper and lower bounds for large $n$, showing as a corollary that $f(n) \approx n/2$.

We study torsion in homology of the random $d$-complex $Y \sim Y_d(n,p)$ experimentally. Our experiments suggest that there is almost always a moment in the process where there is an enormous burst of torsion in homology $H_{d-1}(Y)$. This moment seems to coincide with the phase transition studied in \cite{AL,LP,LP3} , where cycles in $H_d(Y)$ first appear with high probability. Our main study is the limiting distribution on the $q$-part of the torsion subgroup of $H_{d-1}(Y)$ for small primes $q$. We find strong evidence for a limiting Cohen--Lenstra distribution, where the probability that the $q$-part is isomorphic to a given $q$-group $H$ is inversely proportional to the order of the automorphism group $|\mbox{Aut}(H)|$. We also study the torsion in homology of the uniform random $\Q$-acyclic $2$-complex. This model is analogous to a uniform spanning tree on a complete graph, but more complicated topologically since Kalai showed that the expected order of the torsion group is exponentially large in $n^2$ \cite{Kalai}. We give experimental evidence that in this model also, the torsion is Cohen--Lenstra distributed in the limit.

Random shapes arise naturally in many contexts. The topological and geometric structure of such objects is interesting for its own sake, and also for applications. In physics, for example, such objects arise naturally in quantum gravity, in material science, and in other settings. Stochastic topology may also be considered as a null hypothesis for topological data analysis. In this chapter we overview combinatorial aspects of stochastic topology. We focus on the topological and geometric properties of random simplicial complexes. We introduce a few of the fundamental models in Section 23.1. We review high-dimensional expander-like properties of random complexes in Section 23.2. We discuss threshold behavior and phase transitions in Section 23.3, and Betti numbers and persistent homology in Section 23.4.

We initiate the study of persistent homology of random geometric simplicial complexes. Our main interest is in maximally persistent cycles of degree-$k$ in persistent homology, for a either the \cech or the Vietoris--Rips filtration built on a uniform Poisson process of intensity $n$ in the unit cube $[0,1]^d$. This is a natural way of measuring the largest "$k$-dimensional hole" in a random point set. This problem is in the intersection of geometric probability and algebraic topology, and is naturally motivated by a probabilistic view of topological inference. We show that for all $d \ge 2$ and $1 \le k \le d-1$ the maximally persistent cycle has (multiplicative) persistence of order $$ Θ\left(\left(\frac{\log n}{\log \log n} \right)^{1/k} \right),$$ with high probability, characterizing its rate of growth as $n \to \infty$. The implied constants depend on $k$, $d$, and on whether we consider the Vietoris--Rips or \cech filtration.

The 2-girth of a 2-dimensional simplicial complex $X$ is the minimum size of a non-zero 2-cycle in $H_2(X, \mathbb{Z}/2)$. We consider the maximum possible girth of a complex with $n$ vertices and $m$ 2-faces. If $m = n^{2 + α}$ for $α< 1/2$, then we show that the 2-girth is at most $4 n^{2 - 2 α}$ and we prove the existence of complexes with 2-girth at least $c_{α, ε} n^{2 - 2 α- ε}$. On the other hand, if $α> 1/2$, the 2-girth is at most $C_α$. So there is a phase transition as $α$ passes 1/2. Our results depend on a new upper bound for the number of combinatorial types of triangulated surfaces with $v$ vertices and $f$ faces.

We correct the proofs of the main theorems in our paper "Limit theorems for Betti numbers of random simplicial complexes".

We improve the best lower bounds on the chromatic number of Euclidean space in small dimensions. The new results depend on extensive computations in Sage.