arXiv++ Combinatorics

A celebrated and deep result of Green and Tao states that the primes contain arbitrarily long arithmetic progressions. In this note I provide a straightforward argument demonstrating that the primes get arbitrarily close to arbitrarily long arithmetic progressions. The argument also applies to `large sets' in the sense of Erdős-Turán. The proof is short, completely self-contained, and aims to give a heuristic explanation of why the primes, and other large sets, possess arithmetic structure.

A conjecture of Freiman gives an exact formula for the largest volume of a finite set $A$ of integers with given cardinality $k = |A|$ and doubling $T = |2A|$. The formula is known to hold when $T \le 3k-4$, for some small range over $3k-4$ and for families of structured sets called chains. In this paper we extend the formula to sets of every dimension and prove it for sets composed of three segments, giving structural results for the extremal case. A weaker extension to sets composed of a bounded number of segments is also discussed.

We present a self-contained proof of a strong version of van der Waerden's Theorem. By using translation invariant filters that are maximal with respect to inclusion, a simple inductive argument shows the existence of "piecewise syndetically"-many monochromatic arithmetic progressions of any length k in every finite coloring of the natural numbers. All the presented constructions are constructive in nature, in the sense that the involved maximal filters are defined by recurrence on suitable countable algebras of sets. No use of the axiom of choice or of Zorn's Lemma is needed.

We say a pair of integers $(a, b)$ is findable if the following is true. For any $δ> 0$ there exists a $p_0$ such that for any prime $p \ge p_0$ and any red-blue colouring of $\mathbb{Z} /p\mathbb{Z}$ in which each colour has density at least $δ$, we can find an arithmetic progression of length $a+b$ inside $\mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$ whose first $a$ elements are red and whose last $b$ elements are blue. Szemerédi's Theorem on arithmetic progressions implies that $(0,k)$ and $(1,k)$ are findable for any $k$. We prove that $(2, k)$ is also findable for any $k$. However, the same is not true of $(3, k)$. Indeed, we give a construction showing that $(3, 30000)$ is not findable. We also show that $(14, 14)$ is not findable.

Freiman's 2.4-Theorem states that any set $A \subset \mathbb{Z}_p$ satisfying $|2A| \leq 2.4|A| - 3 $ and $|A| < p/35$ can be covered by an arithmetic progression of length at most $|2A| - |A| + 1$. A more general result of Green and Ruzsa implies that this covering property holds for any set satisfying $|2A| \leq 3|A| - 4$ as long as the rather strong density requirement $|A| < p/10^{215}$ is satisfied. We present a version of this statement that allows for sets satisfying $|2A| \leq 2.48|A| - 7$ with the more modest density requirement of $|A| < p/10^{10}$.

The Van der Waerden number $W(k,r)$ denotes the smallest $n$ such that whenever $[n]$ is $r$--colored there exists a monochromatic arithmetic progression of length $k$. Similarly, the Hilbert cube number $h(k,r)$ denotes the smallest $n$ such that whenever $[n]$ is $r$--colored there exists a monochromatic affine $k$--cube, that is, a set of the form$$\left\{x_0 + \sum_{b \in B} b : B \subseteq A\right\}$$ for some $|A|=k$ and $x_0 \in \mathbb{Z}$. We show the following relation between the Hilbert cube number and the Van der Waerden number. Let $k \geq 3$ be an integer. Then for every $ε>0$, there is a $c > 0$ such that $$h(k,4) \ge \min\{W(\lfloor c k^2\rfloor, 2), 2^{k^{2.5-ε}}\}.$$ Thus we improve upon state of the art lower bounds for $h(k,4)$ conditional on $W(k,2)$ being significantly larger than $2^k$. In the other direction, this shows that the if the Hilbert cube number is close its state of the art lower bounds, then $W(k,2)$ is at most doubly exponential in $k$. We also show the optimal result that for any Sidon set $A \subset \mathbb{Z}$, one has $$\left|\left\{\sum_{b \in B} b : B \subseteq A\right\}\right| = Ω( |A|^3) .$$

The study of substructures in random objects has a long history, beginning with Erdős and Rényi's work on subgraphs of random graphs. We study the existence of certain substructures in random subsets of vector spaces over finite fields. First we provide a general framework which can be applied to establish coarse threshold results and prove a limiting Poisson distribution at the threshold scale. To illustrate our framework we apply our results to $k$-term arithmetic progressions, sums, right triangles, parallelograms and affine planes. We also find coarse thresholds for the property that a random subset of a finite vector space is sum-free, or is a Sidon set.

Consider the sequence $\mathcal{V}(2,n)$ constructed in a greedy fashion by setting $a_1 = 2$, $a_2 = n$ and defining $a_{m+1}$ as the smallest integer larger than $a_m$ that can be written as the sum of two (not necessarily distinct) earlier terms in exactly one way; the sequence $\mathcal{V}(2,3)$, for example, is given by $$ \mathcal{V}(2,3) = 2,3,4,5,9,10,11,16,22,\dots$$ We prove that if $n \geqslant 5$ is odd, then the sequence $\mathcal{V}(2,n)$ has exactly two even terms $\left\{2,2n\right\}$ if and only if $n-1$ is not a power of 2. We also show that in this case, $\mathcal{V}(2,n)$ eventually becomes a union of arithmetic progressions. If $n-1$ is a power of 2, then there is at least one more even term $2n^2 + 2$ and we conjecture there are no more even terms. In the proof, we display an interesting connection between $\mathcal{V}(2,n)$ and Sierpinski Triangle. We prove several other results, discuss a series of striking phenomena and pose many problems. This relates to existing results of Finch, Schmerl & Spiegel and a classical family of sequences defined by Ulam.

Permutations of the positive integers avoiding arithmetic progressions of length $5$ were constructed in (Davis et al, 1977), implying the existence of permutations of the integers avoiding arithmetic progressions of length $7$. We construct a permutation of the integers avoiding arithmetic progressions of length $6$. We also prove a lower bound of $\frac{1}{2}$ on the lower density of subsets of positive integers that can be permuted to avoid arithmetic progressions of length $4$, sharpening the lower bound of $\frac{1}{3}$ from (LeSaulnier and Vijay, 2011). In addition, we generalize several results about forbidden arithmetic progressions to construct permutations avoiding generalized arithmetic progressions.

We introduce CUT, the class of 2-player partition games. These are NIM type games, played on a finite number of heaps of beans. The rules are given by a set of positive integers, which specifies the number of allowed splits a player can perform on a single heap. In normal play, the player with the last move wins, and the famous Sprague-Grundy theory provides a solution. We prove that several rulesets have a periodic or an arithmetic periodic Sprague-Grundy sequence (i.e. they can be partitioned into a finite number of arithmetic progressions of the same common difference). This is achieved directly for some infinite classes of games, and moreover we develop a computational testing condition, demonstrated to solve a variety of additional games. Similar results have previously appeared for various classes of games of take-and-break, for example octal and hexadecimal; see e.g. Winning Ways by Berlekamp, Conway and Guy (1982). In this context, our contribution consists of a systematic study of the subclass `break-without-take'.

Let $\text{ac}(n,k)$ denote the smallest positive integer with the property that there exists an $n$-colouring $f$ of $\{1,\dots,\text{ac}(n,k)\}$ such that for every $k$-subset $R \subseteq \{1, \dots, n\}$ there exists an (arithmetic) $k$-progression $A$ in $\{1,\dots,\text{ac}(n,k)\}$ with $\{f(a) : a \in A\} = R$. Determining the behaviour of the function $\text{ac}(n,k)$ is a previously unstudied problem. We use the first moment method to give an asymptotic upper bound for $\text{ac}(n,k)$ for the case $k = o(n^{1/{5}})$.

Let $r$ and $k$ be positive integers with $r \mid k$. Denote by $w_{\mathrm{\mathfrak{z}}}(k;r)$ the minimum integer such that every coloring $χ:[1,w_{\mathrm{\mathfrak{z}}}(k;r)] \rightarrow \{0,1,\dots,r-1\}$ admits a $k$-term arithmetic progression $a,a+d,\dots,a+(k-1)d$ with $\sum_{j=0}^{k-1} χ(a+jd) \equiv 0 \,(\mathrm{mod }\,r)$. We investigate these numbers as well as a "mixed" monochromatic/zero-sum analogue. We also present an interesting reciprocity between the van der Waerden numbers and $w_{\mathrm{\mathfrak{z}}}(k;r)$.

Let $p_n$ denote the $n$-th prime. For any $m\geq 1$, there exist infinitely many $n$ such that $p_{n}-p_{n-m}\leq C_m$ for some large constant $C_m>0$, and $$p_{n+1}-p_n\geq \frac{c_m\log n\log\log n\log\log\log\log n}{\log\log\log n}, $$ for some small constant $c_m>0$. Furthermore, we also obtain a related result concerning the least primes in arithmetic progressions.

In this paper arithmetic progressions on the integers and the integers modulo n are extended to graphs. This allows for the definition of the anti-van der Waerden number of a graph. Much of the focus of this paper is on 3-term arithmetic progressions for which general bounds are obtained based on the radius and diameter of a graph. The general bounds are improved for trees and Cartesian products and exact values are determined for some classes of graphs. Larger k-term arithmetic progressions are considered and a connection between the Ramsey number of paths and the anti-van der Waerden number of graphs is established.

A set of vertices $S$ resolves a graph if every vertex is uniquely determined by its vector of distances to the vertices in $S$. The metric dimension of a graph is the minimum cardinality of a resolving set of the graph. Fix a connected graph $G$ on $q \ge 2$ vertices, and let $M$ be the distance matrix of $G$. We prove that if there exists $w \in \mathbb{Z}^q$ such that $\sum_i w_i = 0$ and the vector $Mw$, after sorting its coordinates, is an arithmetic progression with nonzero common difference, then the metric dimension of the Cartesian product of $n$ copies of $G$ is $(2+o(1))n/\log_q n$. In the special case that $G$ is a complete graph, our results close the gap between the lower bound attributed to Erdős and Rényi and the upper bounds developed subsequently by Lindström, Chvátal, Kabatianski, Lebedev and Thorpe.

Let $θ(n)$ denote the number of permutations of $\{1,2,\ldots,n\}$ that do not contain a 3-term arithmetic progression as a subsequence. Such permutations are known as 3-free permutations. We present a dynamic programming algorithm to count all 3-free permutations of $\{1,2,\ldots,n\}$. We use the output to extend and correct enumerative results in the literature for $θ(n)$ from $n=20$ out to $n=90$ and use the new values to inductively improve existing bounds on $θ(n)$.

Weighted sums of left and right hand Kronecker products of Integer Sequence Doubly Affine (ISDA) as well as Generalized Arithmetic Progression Doubly Affine (GAPDA) arrays are used to generate larger ISDA arrays of multiplicative order (compound squares) from pairs of smaller ones. In two dimensions we find general expressions for the eigenvalues (EVs) and singular values (SVs) of the larger arrays in terms of the EVs and SVs of their constituent matrices, leading to a simple result for the rank of these highly singular compound matrices. Since the critical property of the smaller constituent matrices involves only identical row and column sums (often called semi-magic), the eigenvalue and singular value results can be applied to both magic squares and Latin squares. Additionally, the compounding process works in arbitrary dimensions due to the generality of the Kronecker product, providing a simple method to generate large order ISDA cubes and hypercubes. The first examples of compound magic squares are found in manuscripts that date back to the 10th century CE, and other representative applications are outlined through judicious examples.

Given a hypergraph $Γ=(Ω,\mathcal{X})$ and a sequence $\mathbf{p} = (p_ω)_{ω\in Ω}$ of values in $(0,1)$, let $Ω_{\mathbf{p}}$ be the random subset of $Ω$ obtained by keeping every vertex $ω$ independently with probability $p_ω$. We investigate the general question of deriving fine (asymptotic) estimates for the probability that $Ω_{\mathbf{p}}$ is an independent set in $Γ$, which is an omnipresent problem in probabilistic combinatorics. Our main result provides a sequence of upper and lower bounds on this probability, each of which can be evaluated explicitly in terms of the joint cumulants of small sets of edge indicator random variables. Under certain natural conditions, these upper and lower bounds coincide asymptotically, thus giving the precise asymptotics of the probability in question. We demonstrate the applicability of our results with two concrete examples: subgraph containment in random (hyper)graphs and arithmetic progressions in random subsets of the integers.

Motivated by problems on random differences in Szemerédi's theorem and on large deviations for arithmetic progressions in random sets, we prove upper bounds on the Gaussian width of point sets that are formed by the image of the $n$-dimensional Boolean hypercube under a mapping $ψ:\mathbb{R}^n\to\mathbb{R}^k$, where each coordinate is a constant-degree multilinear polynomial with 0-1 coefficients. We show the following applications of our bounds. Let $[\mathbb{Z}/N\mathbb{Z}]_p$ be the random subset of $\mathbb{Z}/N\mathbb{Z}$ containing each element independently with probability $p$. $\bullet$ A set $D\subseteq \mathbb{Z}/N\mathbb{Z}$ is $\ell$-intersective if any dense subset of $\mathbb{Z}/N\mathbb{Z}$ contains a proper $(\ell+1)$-term arithmetic progression with common difference in $D$. Our main result implies that $[\mathbb{Z}/N\mathbb{Z}]_p$ is $\ell$-intersective with probability $1 - o(1)$ provided $p \geq ω(N^{-β_\ell}\log N)$ for $β_\ell = (\lceil(\ell+1)/2\rceil)^{-1}$. This gives a polynomial improvement for all $\ell \ge 3$ of a previous bound due to Frantzikinakis, Lesigne and Wierdl, and reproves more directly the same improvement shown recently by the authors and Dvir. $\bullet$ Let $X_k$ be the number of $k$-term arithmetic progressions in $[\mathbb{Z}/N\mathbb{Z}]_p$ and consider the large deviation rate $ρ_k(δ) = \log\Pr[X_k \geq (1+δ)\mathbb{E}X_k]$. We give quadratic improvements of the best-known range of $p$ for which a highly precise estimate of $ρ_k(δ)$ due to Bhattacharya, Ganguly, Shao and Zhao is valid for all odd $k \geq 5$. We also discuss connections with error correcting codes (locally decodable codes) and the Banach-space notion of type for injective tensor products of $\ell_p$-spaces.

Let $r_k(n)$ denote the maximum cardinality of a set $A \subset \{1,2, \dots, n \}$ such that $A$ does not contain a $k$-term arithmetic progression. In this paper, we give a method of constructing such a set and prove the lower bound $n^{1-\frac{c_k}{k \ln k}} < r_k(n)$ where $k$ is prime, and $c_k \rightarrow 1$ as $k \rightarrow \infty$. This bound is the best known for an increasingly large interval of $n$ as we choose larger and larger $k$. We also demonstrate that one can prove or disprove a conjecture of Erdős on arithmetic progressions in large sets once tight enough bounds on $r_k(n)$ are obtained.