arXiv++ Combinatorics

In two dimensions, Gallagher's theorem is a strengthening of the Littlewood conjecture that holds for almost all pairs of real numbers. We prove an inhomogeneous fibre version of Gallagher's theorem, sharpening and making unconditional a result recently obtained conditionally by Beresnevich, Haynes and Velani. The idea is to find large generalised arithmetic progressions within inhomogeneous Bohr sets, extending a construction given by Tao. This precise structure enables us to verify the hypotheses of the Duffin--Schaeffer theorem for the problem at hand, via the geometry of numbers.

Ellenberg and Gijswijt gave recently a new exponential upper bound for the size of three-term arithmetic progression free sets in $({\mathbb Z_p})^n$, where $p$ is a prime. Petrov summarized their method and generalized their result to linear forms. In this short note we use Petrov's result to give new exponential upper bounds for the Erdős-Ginzburg-Ziv constant of finite Abelian groups of high rank. Our main results depend on a conjecture about Property D.

We study the upper tail of the number of arithmetic progressions of a given length in a random subset of {1,...,n}, establishing exponential bounds which are best possible up to constant factors in the exponent. The proof also extends to Schur triples, and, more generally, to the number of edges in random induced subhypergraphs of `almost linear' k-uniform hypergraphs.

In the late 1990s, Kim and Vu pioneered an inductive method for showing concentration of certain random variables X. Shortly afterwards, Janson and Ruci{ń}ski developed an alternative inductive approach, which often gives comparable results for the upper tail Pr(X \ge (1+\eps) E[X]). In some cases, both methods yield upper tail estimates which are best possible up to a logarithmic factor in the exponent, but closing this narrow gap has remained a technical challenge. In this paper we present a BK-inequality based combinatorial sparsification idea that can recover this missing logarithmic term in the upper tail. As an illustration, we consider random subsets of the integers {1,...,n}, and prove sharp upper tail estimates for various objects of interest in additive combinatorics. Examples include the number of arithmetic progressions, Schur triples, additive quadruples, and (r,s)-sums.

Recently, Croot, Lev, and Pach (Ann. of Math., 185:331--337, 2017.) and Ellenberg and Gijswijt (Ann. of Math., 185:339--443, 2017.) developed a new polynomial method and used it to prove upper bounds for three-term arithmetic progression free sets in $\mathbb{Z}_4^n$ and $\mathbb{F}_3^n$, respectively. Their approach was later summarized by Tao and is now known as the slice rank method. In this paper, we apply this method to obtain a new upper bound on the cardinality of subsets of $\mathbb{F}^n_q$ which contain no right angles. More precisely, let $q$ be a fixed odd prime power and $x\cdot y$ be the standard inner product of two vectors $x,y\in\mathbb{F}_q^n$, we prove that the maximum cardinality of a subset $A\subseteq\mathbb{F}_q^n$ without three distinct elements $x,y,z\in A$ satisfying $(z-x)\cdot (y-x)=0$ is at most $\binom{n+q}{q-1}+3$. For sufficiently large $n$, our result significantly improves the previous upper bound of Bennett (European J. Combin., 70:155--163, 2018.), who showed that $|A|=\mathcal{O}(q^{\frac{n+2}{3}})$.

We show that an arbitrary nilprogression can be approximated by a proper coset nilprogression in upper-triangular form. This can be thought of as a nilpotent version of the Freiman-Bilu result that a generalised arithmetic progression can be efficiently contained in a proper generalised arithmetic progression, and indeed an important ingredient in the proof is a Lie-algebra version of the geometry-of-numbers argument at the centre of that result. We also present some applications. We verify a conjecture of Benjamini that if $S$ is a symmetric generating set for a group such that $1\in S$ and $|S^n|\le Mn^D$ at some sufficiently large scale $n$ then $S$ exhibits polynomial growth of the same degree $D$ at all subsequent scales, in the sense that $|S^r|\ll_{M,D}r^D$ for every $r\ge n$. Our methods also provide an important ingredient in a forthcoming companion paper in which we reprove and sharpen a result about scaling limits of vertex-transitive graphs of polynomial growth due to Benjamini, Finucane and the first author. We also note that our arguments imply that every approximate group has a large subset with a large quotient that is Freiman isomorphic to a subset of a torsion-free nilpotent group of bounded rank and step.

The Polynomial Freiman-Ruzsa conjecture is one of the central open problems in additive combinatorics. If true, it would give tight quantitative bounds relating combinatorial and algebraic notions of approximate subgroups. In this note, we restrict our attention to subsets of Euclidean space. In this regime, the original conjecture considers approximate algebraic subgroups as the set of lattice points in a convex body. Green asked in 2007 whether this can be simplified to a generalized arithmetic progression, while not losing more than a polynomial factor in the underlying parameters. We give a negative answer to this question, based on a recent reverse Minkowski theorem combined with estimates for random lattices.

We estimate Gowers uniformity norms for some classical automatic sequences, such as the Thue-Morse and Rudin-Shapiro sequences. The methods can also be extended to other automatic sequences. As an application, we asymptotically count arithmetic progressions in the set of integers $\leq N$ where the Thue-Morse (resp. Rudin-Shapiro) sequence takes the value $+1$.

Let $q$ be an odd prime power. Combining the discussion of Varnavides and a recent theorem of Ellenberg and Gijswijt, we show that a subset $A\subset{\mathbb F}_q^n$ will contain many non-trivial three-term arithmetic progressions, whenever $|A|\geq (c_q q)^n$ for some constant $c_q>0$. After the first version of our manuscript was uploaded in the arXiv, we learned from Professors Jacob Fox and Terence Tao that our result is a special case of a result of Fox and Lovasz [1, Theorem 3]. In fact, [1, Theorem 3] gives a much better bound than ours. For example, when $q=3$, the lower bound given by Fox and Lovasz is $|A|^{2}\cdot (|A|q^{-n})^{11.901}$, while our bound is $|A|^{2}\cdot (|A|q^{-n})^{25.803}$. We thank Professors Jacob Fox and Terence Tao for their helpful comments on our manuscript. [1] Jacob Fox, László Miklós Lovász, A tight bound for Green's arithmetic triangle removal lemma in vector spaces, preprint, arXiv:1606.01230.

When defining the amount of additive structure on a set it is often convenient to consider certain sumsets; Calculating the cardinality of these sumsets can elucidate the set's underlying structure. We begin by investigating finite sets of perfect squares and associated sumsets. We reveal how arithmetic progressions efficiently reduce the cardinality of sumsets and provide estimates for the minimum size, taking advantage of the additive structure that arithmetic progressions provide. We then generalise the problem to arbitrary rings and achieve satisfactory estimates for the case of squares in finite fields of prime order. Finally, for sufficiently small finite fields we computationally calculate the minimum for all prime orders.

In their proof of the IP Szemerédi theorem, a far reaching extension of the classic theorem of Szemerédi on arithmetic progressions, Furstenberg and Katznelson introduced an important class of additively large sets called $\text{IP}_{\text{r}}^*$ sets which underlies recurrence aspects in dynamics and is instrumental to enhanced formulations of combinatorial results. The authors recently showed that additive $\text{IP}_{\text{r}}^*$ subsets of $\mathbb{Z}^d$ are multiplicatively rich with respect to every multiplication on $\mathbb{Z}^d$ without zero divisors (e.g. multiplications induced by degree $d$ number fields). In this paper, we explain the relationships between classes of multiplicative largeness with respect to different multiplications on $\mathbb{Z}^d$. We show, for example, that in contrast to the case for $\mathbb{Z}$, there are infinitely many different notions of multiplicative piecewise syndeticity for subsets of $\mathbb{Z}^d$ when $d \geq 2$. This is accomplished by using the associated algebra representations to prove the existence of sets which are large with respect to some multiplications while small with respect to others. In the process, we give necessary and sufficient conditions for a linear transformation to preserve a class of multiplicatively large sets. One consequence of our results is that additive $\text{IP}_{\text{r}}^*$ sets are multiplicatively rich in infinitely many genuinely different ways. We conclude by cataloging a number of sources of additive $\text{IP}_{\text{r}}^*$ sets from combinatorics and dynamics.

Many natural notions of additive and multiplicative largeness arise from results in Ramsey theory. In this paper, we explain the relationships between these notions for subsets of $\mathbb{N}$ and in more general ring-theoretic structures. We show that multiplicative largeness begets additive largeness in three ways and give a collection of examples demonstrating the optimality of these results. We also give a variety of applications arising from the connection between additive and multiplicative largeness. For example, we show that given any $n, k \in \mathbb{N}$, any finite set with fewer than $n$ elements in a sufficiently large finite field can be translated so that each of its elements becomes a non-zero $k^{\text{th}}$ power. We also prove a theorem concerning Diophantine approximation along multiplicatively syndetic subsets of $\mathbb{N}$ and a theorem showing that subsets of positive upper Banach density in certain multiplicative sub-semigroups of $\mathbb{N}$ of zero density contain arbitrarily long arithmetic progressions. Along the way, we develop a new characterization of upper Banach density in a wide class of amenable semigroups and make explicit the uniformity in recurrence theorems from measure theoretic and topological dynamics. This in turn leads to strengthened forms of classical theorems of Szemerédi and van der Waerden on arithmetic progressions.

We generalize a result by Cook, Magyar, and Pramanik [3] on three-term arithmetic progressions in subsets of $\mathbb{R}^d$ to corners in subsets of $\mathbb{R}^d\times\mathbb{R}^d$. More precisely, if $1<p<\infty$, $p\neq 2$, and $d$ is large enough, we show that an arbitrary measurable set $A\subseteq\mathbb{R}^d\times\mathbb{R}^d$ of positive upper Banach density contains corners $(x,y)$, $(x+s,y)$, $(x,y+s)$ such that the $\ell^p$-norm of the side $s$ attains all sufficiently large real values. Even though we closely follow the basic steps from [3], the proof diverges at the part relying on harmonic analysis. We need to apply a higher-dimensional variant of a multilinear estimate from [5], which we establish using the techniques from [5] and [6].

In 2007, Alexander Shapovalov posed an old twist on the classical coin weighing problem by asking for strategies that manage to conceal the identities of specific coins while providing general information on the number of fake coins. In 2015, Diaco and Khovanova studied various cases of these "discreet strategies" and introduced the revealing factor, a measure of the information that is revealed. In this paper we discuss a natural coin weighing strategy which we call the sorting strategy: divide the coins into equal piles and sort them by weight. We study the instances when the strategy is discreet, and given an outcome of the sorting strategy, the possible number of fake coins. We prove that in many cases, the number of fake coins can be any value in an arithmetic progression whose length depends linearly on the number of coins in each pile. We also show the strategy can be discreet when the number of fake coins is any value within an arithmetic subsequence whose length also depends linearly on the number of coins in each pile. We arrive at these results by connecting our work to the classic Frobenius coin problem. In addition, we calculate the revealing factor for the sorting strategy.

In Ellenberg and Gijswijt's groundbreaking work, the authors show that a subset of $\mathbb{Z}_3^{n}$ with no arithmetic progression of length 3 must be of size at most $2.755^n$ (no prior upper bound was known of $(3-ε)^n)$), and provide for any prime $p$ a value $λ_p<p$ such that any subset of $\mathbb{Z}_p^{n}$ with no arithmetic progression of length 3 must be of size at most $λ_p^n$. Blasiak et al showed that the same bounds apply to tri-coloured sum-free sets, which are triples $\{(a_i,b_i,c_i):a_i,b_i,c_i\in\mathbb{Z}_p^{n}\}$ with $a_i+b_j+c_k=0$ if and only if $i=j=k$. Building on this work, Kleinberg, Sawin and Speyer gave a description of a value $μ_p$ such that no tri-coloured sum-free sets of size $e^{μ_p n}$ exist in $\mathbb{Z}_p^{n}$, but for any $ε>0$, such sets of size $e^{(μ_p-ε) n}$ exist for all sufficiently large $n$. The value of $μ_p$ was left open, but a conjecture was stated which would imply that $e^{μ_p}=λ_p$, i.e. the Ellenberg-Gijswijt bound is correct for the sum-free set problem. The purpose of this note is to close that gap. The conjecture of Kleinberg, Sawin and Speyer is true, and the Ellenberg-Gijswijt bound is the correct exponent for the sum-free set problem.

The well--known Freiman--Ruzsa Theorem provides a structural description of a set $A$ of integers with $|2A|\le c|A|$ as a subset of a $d$--dimensional arithmetic progression $P$ with $|P|\le c'|A|$, where $d$ and $c'$ depend only on $c$. The estimation of the constants $d$ and $c'$ involved in the statement has been the object of intense research. Freiman conjectured in 2008 a formula for the largest volume of such a set. In this paper we prove the conjecture for a general class of sets called chains.

Inspired by the Croot-Lev-Pach breakthrough, Jordan Ellenberg and Dion Gijswijt have recently amazed the combinatorial world by proving that the largest size of a subset of $F_3^n$ with no 3-term arithmetic progressions is exponentially less than the size, $3^n$ of $F_3^n$ (and, more generally, $q^n$ for $F_q^n$). Here we give a motivated, top-down, rendition of their beautiful proof, that aims to make it appreciated by a wider audience.

Magyar has shown that if $B \subset \mathbb{Z}^d$ has positive upper density $(d \geq 5)$, then the set of squared distances $\{ \|b_1-b_2 \|^2 \text{ }: \text{ } b_1,b_2 \in B \}$ contains an infinitely long arithmetic progression, whose period depends only on the upper density of $B$. We extend this result by showing that $B$ contains locally isometrically embedded copies of every tree with edge lengths in some given arithmetic progression (whose period depends only on the upper density of $B$ and the number of vertices of the sought tree). In particular, $B$ contains all chains of elements with gaps in some given arithmetic progression (which depends on the length of the sought chain). This is a discrete analogue of a result obtained recently by Bennet, Iosevich and Taylor on chains with prescribed gaps in sets of large Haussdorf dimension. Our techniques are Ergodic theoretic and may be of independent interest to Ergodic theorists. In particular, we obtain Ergodic theoretic analogues of recent \textit{optimal spherical distribution} results of Lyall and Magyar which, via Furstenberg's correspondence principle, recover their combinatorial results.

Given a filter $Δ$ in the poset of compositions of $n$, we form the filter $Π^{*}_Δ$ in the partition lattice. We determine all the reduced homology groups of the order complex of $Π^{*}_Δ$ as ${\mathfrak S}_{n-1}$-modules in terms of the reduced homology groups of the simplicial complex $Δ$ and in terms of Specht modules of border shapes. We also obtain the homotopy type of this order complex. These results generalize work of Calderbank--Hanlon--Robinson and Wachs on the $d$-divisible partition lattice. Our main theorem applies to a plethora of examples, including filters associated to integer knapsack partitions and filters generated by all partitions having block sizes $a$ or~$b$. We also obtain the reduced homology groups of the filter generated by all partitions having block sizes belonging to the arithmetic progression $a, a + d, \ldots, a + (a-1) \cdot d$, extending work of Browdy.

In this note, we show that the method of Croot, Lev, and Pach can be used to bound the size of a subset of $F_q^n$ with no three terms in arithmetic progression by $c^n$ with $c < q$. For $q=3$, the problem of finding the largest subset with no three terms in arithmetic progression is called the `cap problem'. Previously the best known upper bound for the cap problem, due to Bateman and Katz, was $O(3^n / n^{1+ε})$.