arXiv++ Combinatorics

This is a short survey article written for the Erdős centennial conference in Budapest in 2013. The main two topics covered are Szemerédi's theorem and its ramifications, and the Erdős discrepancy problem. There is an emphasis on what we do not yet know, so much of the article is somewhat speculative.

There has been extensive research on cycle lengths in graphs with large minimum degree. In this paper, we obtain several new and tight results in this area. Let $G$ be a graph with minimum degree at least $k+1$. We prove that if $G$ is bipartite, then there are $k$ cycles in $G$ whose lengths form an arithmetic progression with common difference two. For general graph $G$, we show that $G$ contains $\lfloor k/2\rfloor$ cycles with consecutive even lengths and $k-3$ cycles whose lengths form an arithmetic progression with common difference one or two. In addition, if $G$ is 2-connected and non-bipartite, then $G$ contains $\lfloor k/2\rfloor$ cycles with consecutive odd lengths. Thomassen (1983) made two conjectures on cycle lengths modulo a fixed integer $k$: (1) every graph with minimum degree at least $k+1$ contains cycles of all even lengths modulo $k$; (2) every 2-connected non-bipartite graph with minimum degree at least $k+1$ contains cycles of all lengths modulo $k$. These two conjectures, if true, are best possible. Our results confirm both conjectures when $k$ is even. And when $k$ is odd, we show that minimum degree at least $k+4$ suffices. This improves all previous results in this direction. Moreover, our results derive new upper bounds of the chromatic number in terms of the longest sequence of cycles with consecutive (even or odd) lengths.

Chang's Lemma is a widely employed result in additive combinatorics. It gives bounds on the dimension of the large spectrum of probability distributions on finite abelian groups. Recently, Bloom (2016) presented a powerful variant of Chang's Lemma that yields the strongest known quantitative version of Roth's theorem on 3-term arithmetic progressions in dense subsets of the integers. In this note, we show how such theorems can be derived from the approximation of probability measures via entropy maximization.

Consider a finite sequence of permutations of the elements 1,...,n, with the property that each element changes its position by at most 1 from any permutation to the next. We call such a sequence a tangle, and we define a move of element i to be a maximal subsequence of at least two consecutive permutations during which its positions form an arithmetic progression of common difference +1 or -1. We prove that for any initial and final permutations, there is a tangle connecting them in which each element makes at most 5 moves, and another in which the total number of moves is at most 4n. On the other hand, there exist permutations that require at least 3 moves for some element, and at least 2n-2 moves in total. If we further require that every pair of elements exchange positions at most once, then any two permutations can be connected by a tangle with at most O(log n) moves per element, but we do not know whether this can be reduced to O(1) per element, or to O(n) in total. A key tool is the introduction of certain restricted classes of tangle that perform pattern-avoiding permutations.

We show that any subset of the natural numbers with positive logarithmic Banach density contains a set that is within a factor of two of a geometric progression, improving the bound on a previous result of the authors. Density conditions on subsets of the natural numbers that imply the existence of approximate powers of arithmetic progressions are developed and explored.

Consider a set $A$ with no $p$-term arithmetic progressions for $p$ prime. The $p$-Stanley sequence of a set $A$ is generated by greedily adding successive integers that do not create a $p$-term arithmetic progression. For $p>3$ prime, we give two distinct constructions for $p$-Stanley sequences which have a regular structure and satisfy certain conditions in order to be modular $p$-Stanley sequences, a set of particularly nice sequences defined by Moy and Rolnick which always have a regular structure. Odlyzko and Stanley conjectured that the 3-Stanley sequence generated by $\{0,n\}$ only has a regular structure if $n=3^k$ or $n=2\cdot 3^k$. For $p>3$ we find a substantially larger class of integers $n$ such that the $p$-Stanley sequence generated from $\{0,n\}$ is a modular $p$-Stanley sequence and numerical evidence given by Moy and Rolnick suggests that these are the only $n$ for which the $p$-Stanley sequence generated by $\{0,n\}$ is a modular $p$-Stanley sequence. Our second class is a generalization of a construction of Rolnick for $p=3$ and is thematically similar to the analogous construction by Rolnick.

A permutation πof an abelian group G is said to destroy arithmetic progressions (APs) if, whenever (a,b,c) is a non-trivial 3-term AP in G, that is c-b=b-a and a,b,c are not all equal, then (π(a),π(b),π(c)) is not an AP. In a paper from 2004, the first author conjectured that such a permutation exists of Z/nZ, for all n except 2,3,5 and 7. Here we prove, as a special case of a more general result, that such a permutation exists for all n >= n_0, for some explcitly constructed number n_0 \approx 1.4 x 10^{14}. We also construct such a permutation of Z/pZ for all primes p > 3 such that p = 3 (mod 8).

In this paper we prove that every set $A\subset\mathbb{Z}$ satisfying the inequality $\sum_{x}\min(1_A*1_A(x),t)\le(2+δ)t|A|$ for $t$ and $δ$ in suitable ranges, then $A$ must be very close to an arithmetic progression. We use this result to improve the estimates of Green and Morris for the probability that a random subset $A\subset\mathbb{N}$ satisfies $|\mathbb{N}\setminus(A+A)|\ge k$; specifically we show that $\mathbb{P}(|\mathbb{N}\setminus(A+A)|\ge k)=Θ(2^{-k/2})$.

We prove that every set $A\subset\mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$ with $\mathbb{E}_x\min(1_A*1_A(x),t)\le(2+δ)t\mathbb{E}_x 1_A(a)$ is very close to an arithmetic progression. Here $p$ stands for a large prime and $δ,t$ are small real numbers. This shows that the Vosper theorem is stable in the case of a single set.

We define the notion of infinite friezes of positive integers as a variation of Conway-Coxeter frieze patterns and study their properties. We introduce useful gluing and cutting operations on infinite friezes. It turns out that triangulations of once-punctured discs give rise to periodic infinite friezes having special properties, a notable example being that each diagonal consists of a collection of arithmetic progressions. Furthermore, we work out a combinatorial interpretation of the entries of infinite friezes associated to triangulations of once-punctured discs via matching numbers for certain combinatorial objects, namely periodic triangulations of strips. Alternatively, we consider a known algorithm that as we show computes as well these entries.

We find arbitrarily large configurations of irreducible polynomials over finite fields that are separated by low degree polynomials. Our proof adapts an argument of Pintz from the integers, in which he combines the methods of Goldston-Pintz-Yıldırım and Green-Tao to find arbitrarily long arithmetic progressions of generalized twin primes.

Given a set of integers with no three in arithmetic progression, we construct a Stanley sequence by adding integers greedily so that no arithmetic progression is formed. This paper offers two main contributions to the theory of Stanley sequences. First, we characterize well-structured Stanley sequences as solutions to constraints in modular arithmetic, defining the modular Stanley sequences. Second, we introduce the basic Stanley sequences, where elements arise as the sums of subsets of a basis sequence, which in the simplest case is the powers of 3. Applications of our results include the construction of Stanley sequences with arbitrarily large gaps between terms, answering a weak version of a problem by Erdős et al. Finally, we generalize many results about Stanley sequences to $p$-free sequences, where $p$ is any odd prime.

We study $ν_k(n)$, the number of partitions of $n$ into $k$ part sizes, and find numerous arithmetic progressions where $ν_2$ and $ν_3$ take on values divisible by 2 and 4. Expanding earlier work, we show $ν_2(An+B) \equiv 0 \pmod{4}$ for (A,B) = (36,30), (72,42), (252,114), (196,70), and likely many other progressions for which our method should easily generalize. Of some independent interest, we prove that the overpartition function $\bar{p}(n) \equiv 0 \pmod{16}$ in the first three progressions (the fourth is known), and thereby show that $ν_3(An+B) \equiv 0 \pmod{2}$ in each of these progressions as well, and discuss the relationship between these congruences in more generality. We end with open questions in this area.

New bounds on the number of similar or directly similar copies of a pattern within a finite subset of the line or the plane are proved. The number of equilateral triangles whose vertices all lie within an $n$-point subset of the plane is shown to be no more than $\lfloor{(4 n-1)(n-1)/18}\rfloor$. The number of $k$-term arithmetic progressions that lie within an $n$-point subset of the line is shown to be at most $(n-r)(n+r-k+1)/(2 k-2)$, where $r$ is the remainder when $n$ is divided by $k-1$. This upper bound is achieved when the $n$ points themselves form an arithmetic progression, but for some values of $k$ and $n$, it can also be achieved for other configurations of the $n$ points, and a full classification of such optimal configurations is given. These results are achieved using a new general method based on ordering relations.

In this short survey article, we present an elementary, yet quite powerful, method of enumerating independent sets in graphs. This method was first employed more than three decades ago by Kleitman and Winston and has subsequently been used numerous times by many researchers in various contexts. Our presentation of the method is illustrated with several applications of it to `real-life' combinatorial problems. In particular, we derive bounds on the number of independent sets in regular graphs, sum-free subsets of $\{1, \ldots, n\}$, and $C_4$-free graphs and give a short proof of an analogue of Roth's theorem on $3$-term arithmetic progressions in sparse random sets of integers which was originally formulated and proved by Kohayakawa, Łuczak, and Rödl.

We prove a new upper bound on the number of $r$-rich lines (lines with at least $r$ points) in a `truly' $d$-dimensional configuration of points $v_1,\ldots,v_n \in \mathbb{C}^d$. More formally, we show that, if the number of $r$-rich lines is significantly larger than $n^2/r^d$ then there must exist a large subset of the points contained in a hyperplane. We conjecture that the factor $r^d$ can be replaced with a tight $r^{d+1}$. If true, this would generalize the classic Szemerédi-Trotter theorem which gives a bound of $n^2/r^3$ on the number of $r$-rich lines in a planar configuration. This conjecture was shown to hold in $\mathbb{R}^3$ in the seminal work of Guth and Katz \cite{GK10} and was also recently proved over $\mathbb{R}^4$ (under some additional restrictions) \cite{SS14}. For the special case of arithmetic progressions ($r$ collinear points that are evenly distanced) we give a bound that is tight up to low order terms, showing that a $d$-dimensional grid achieves the largest number of $r$-term progressions. The main ingredient in the proof is a new method to find a low degree polynomial that vanishes on many of the rich lines. Unlike previous applications of the polynomial method, we do not find this polynomial by interpolation. The starting observation is that the degree $r-2$ Veronese embedding takes $r$-collinear points to $r$ linearly dependent images. Hence, each collinear $r$-tuple of points, gives us a dependent $r$-tuple of images. We then use the design-matrix method of \cite{BDWY12} to convert these 'local' linear dependencies into a global one, showing that all the images lie in a hyperplane. This then translates into a low degree polynomial vanishing on the original set.

We obtain quantitative bounds in the polynomial Szemerédi theorem of Bergelson and Leibman, provided the polynomials are homogeneous and of the same degree. Such configurations include arithmetic progressions with common difference equal to a perfect kth power.

The paper deals with extremal problems concerning colorings of hypergraphs. By using a random recoloring algorithm we show that any $n$-uniform simple (i.e. every two distinct edges share at most one vertex) hypergraph $H$ with maximum edge degree at most \[ Δ(H)\leq c\cdot nr^{n-1}, \] is $r$-colorable, where $c>0$ is an absolute constant. %We prove also that similar result holds for $b$-simple hypergraphs. As an application of our proof technique we establish a new lower bound for Van der Waerden number $W(n,r)$, the minimum $N$ such that in any $r$-coloring of the set $\{1,...,N\}$ there exists a monochromatic arithmetic progression of length $n$. We show that \[ W(n,r)>c\cdot r^{n-1}, \] for some absolute constant $c>0$.

We prove that if $A$ is any set of prime numbers satisfying \[ \sum_{a\in A}\frac{1}{a}=\infty, \] then $A$ must contain a $3$-term arithmetic progression. This is accomplished by combining the transference principle with a density increment argument, exploiting the structure of the primes to obtain a large density increase at each step of the iteration. The argument shows that for any $B>0$, and $N>N_{0}(B)$, if $A$ is a subset of primes contained in $\{1,\dots,N\}$ with relative density $α(N)=(|A|\log N)/N$ at least \[ α(N)\gg_{B}\left(\log\log N\right)^{-B} \] then $A$ contains a $3$-term arithmetic progression.

A set is said to be \emph{3-free} if no three elements form an arithmetic progression. Given a 3-free set $A$ of integers $0=a_0<a_1<\cdots<a_t$, the \emph{Stanley sequence} $S(A)=\{a_n\}$ is defined using the greedy algorithm: For each successive $n>t$, we pick the smallest possible $a_n$ so that $\{a_0,a_1,\ldots,a_n\}$ is 3-free and increasing. Work by Odlyzko and Stanley indicates that Stanley sequences may be divided into two classes. Sequences of Type 1 are highly structured and satisfy $αn^{\log_2 3}/2\le a_n\le αn^{\log_2 3}$, for some constant $α$, while those of Type 2 are chaotic and satisfy $Θ(n^2/\log n)$. In this paper, we consider the possible values for $α$ in the growth of Type 1 Stanley sequences. Whereas Odlyzko and Stanley assumed $α=1$, we show that $α$ can be any rational number which is at least 1 and for which the denominator, in lowest terms, is a power of 3.