arXiv++ Combinatorics

We verify a key component of the replica symmetry breaking hypothesis put forward in the physics literature [Mézard and Montanari 2009] on random factor graph models. For a broad class of these models we verify that the Gibbs measure can be decomposed into a moderate number of Bethe states, subsets of the state space in which both short and long range correlations of the measure take a simple form. Moreover, we show that the marginals of these Bethe states can be obtained from fixed points of the Belief Propagation operator. We derive these results from a new result on the approximation of general probability measures on discrete cubes by convex combinations of product measures.

In this paper we propose an algorithm for enumerating diagonal Latin squares of small order. It relies on specific properties of diagonal Latin squares to employ symmetry breaking techniques, and on several heuristic optimizations and bit arithmetic techniques to make use of computational power of state-of-the-art CPUs. Using this approach we enumerated diagonal Latin squares of order at most 9, and vertically symmetric diagonal Latin squares of order at most 10.

Our general subject is the emergence of phases, and phase transitions, in large networks subjected to a few variable constraints. Our main result is the analysis, in the model using edge and triangle subdensities for constraints, of a sharp transition between two phases with different symmetries, analogous to the transition between a fluid and a crystalline solid.

The main result of this paper is to show that all binomial identities are orderable. This is a natural statement in the combinatorial theory of finite sets, which can also be applied in distributed computing to derive new strong bounds on the round complexity of the weak symmetry breaking task. Furthermore, we introduce the notion of a fundamental binomial identity and find an infinite family of values, other than the prime powers, for which no fundamental binomial identity can exist.

This paper is devoted to advancing the theoretical understanding of the iterated immediate snapshot (IIS) complexity of the Weak Symmetry Breaking task (WSB). Our rather unexpected main theorem states that there exist infinitely many values of n, such that WSB for n~processes is solvable by a certain explicitly constructed 3-round IIS protocol. In particular, the minimal number of rounds, which an IIS protocol needs in order to solve the WSB task, does not go to infinity, when the number of processes goes to infinity. Our methods can also be used to generate such values of n. We phrase our proofs in combinatorial language, while avoiding using topology. To this end, we study a~certain class of graphs, which we call flip graphs. These graphs encode adjacency structure in certain subcomplexes of iterated standard chromatic subdivisions of a simplex. While keeping the geometric background in mind for an additional intuition, we develop the structure theory of matchings in flip graphs in a purely combinatorial way. Our bound for the IIS complexity is then a corollary of this general theory. As an afterthought of our result, we suggest to change the overall paradigm. Specifically, we think, that the bounds on the IIS complexity of solving WSB for n processes should be formulated in terms of the size of the solutions of the associated Diophantine equation, rather than in terms of the value n itself.

In this paper we study a family of discrete configuration spaces, the so-called protocol complexes, which are of utmost importance in theoretical distributed computing. Specifically, we consider questions of the existance of compliant binary labelings on the vertices of iterated standard chromatic subdivisions of an n-simplex. The existance of such labelings is equivalent to the existance of distributed protocols solving Weak Symmetry Breaking task in the standard computational model. As a part of our formal model, we introduce function sb(n), defined for natural numbers n, called the symmetry breaking function. From the geometric point of view sb(n) denotes the minimal number of iterations of the standard chromatic subdivision of an (n-1)-simplex, which is needed for the compliant binary labeling to exist. From the point of distributed computing, the function sb(n) measures the minimal number of rounds in a protocol solving the Weak Symmetry Breaking task. In addition to the development of combinatorial topology, which is applicable in a broader context, our main contribution is the proof of new bounds for the function sb(n). Accordingly, the bulk of the paper is taken up by in-depth analysis of the structure of adjacency graph on the set of n-simplices in iterated standard chromatic subdivision of an n-simplex. On the algorithmic side, we provide the first distributed protocol solving Weak Symmetry Breaking task in the layered immediate snapshot computational model for some number of processes. It is well known, that the smallest number of processes for which Weak Symmetry Breaking task is solvable is 6. Based on our analysis, we are able to find a very fast explicit protocol, solving the Weak Symmetry Breaking for 6 processes using only 3 rounds. Furthermore, we show that no protocol can solve Weak Symmetry Breaking in fewer than 2 rounds.

Motivated by questions in theoretical distributed computing, we develop the combinatorial theory of abstract simplex path subdivisions. Our main application is a short and structural proof of the theorem of Castaneda and Rajsbaum. This theorem in turn implies the solvability of the weak symmetry breaking task in the immediate snapshot wait-free model in the case when the number of processes is not a power of a prime number.

We derive formulas for counting certain classes of vacua in the string/M theory landscape. We do so in the context of the moduli space of M-theory compactifications on singular manifolds with G_2 holonomy. Particularly, we count the numbers of gauge theories with different gauge groups but equal numbers of U(1) factors which are dual to each other. The vacua correspond to various symmetry breaking patterns of grand unified theories. Counting these dual vacua is equivalent to counting the number of conjugacy classes of elements of finite order inside Lie groups. We also point out certain cases where the conventional expectation is that symmetry breaking patterns by Wilson lines and Higgs fields are the same, but we show they are in fact different.

The following question is due to Chatterjee and Varadhan (2011). Fix $0<p<r<1$ and take $G\sim G(n,p)$, the Erdős-Rényi random graph with edge density $p$, conditioned to have at least as many triangles as the typical $G(n,r)$. Is $G$ close in cut-distance to a typical $G(n,r)$? Via a beautiful new framework for large deviation principles in $G(n,p)$, Chatterjee and Varadhan gave bounds on the replica symmetric phase, the region of $(p,r)$ where the answer is positive. They further showed that for any small enough $p$ there are at least two phase transitions as $r$ varies. We settle this question by identifying the replica symmetric phase for triangles and more generally for any fixed $d$-regular graph. By analyzing the variational problem arising from the framework of Chatterjee and Varadhan we show that the replica symmetry phase consists of all $(p,r)$ such that $(r^d,h_p(r))$ lies on the convex minorant of $x\mapsto h_p(x^{1/d})$ where $h_p$ is the rate function of a binomial with parameter $p$. In particular, the answer for triangles involves $h_p(\sqrt{x})$ rather than the natural guess of $h_p(x^{1/3})$ where symmetry was previously known. Analogous results are obtained for linear hypergraphs as well as the setting where the largest eigenvalue of $G\sim G(n,p)$ is conditioned to exceed the typical value of the largest eigenvalue of $G(n,r)$. Building on the work of Chatterjee and Diaconis (2012) we obtain additional results on a class of exponential random graphs including a new range of parameters where symmetry breaking occurs. En route we give a short alternative proof of a graph homomorphism inequality due to Kahn (2001) and Galvin and Tetali (2004).

We use the nested loop approach to investigate loop models on random planar maps where the domains delimited by the loops are given two alternating colors, which can be assigned different local weights, hence allowing for an explicit Z_2 domain symmetry breaking. Each loop receives a non local weight n, as well as a local bending energy which controls loop turns. By a standard cluster construction that we review, the Q = n^2 Potts model on general random maps is mapped to a particular instance of this problem with domain-non-symmetric weights. We derive in full generality a set of coupled functional relations for a pair of generating series which encode the enumeration of loop configurations on maps with a boundary of a given color, and solve it by extending well-known complex analytic techniques. In the case where loops are fully-packed, we analyze in details the phase diagram of the model and derive exact equations for the position of its non-generic critical points. In particular, we underline that the critical Potts model on general random maps is not self-dual whenever Q \neq 1. In a model with domain-symmetric weights, we also show the possibility of a spontaneous domain symmetry breaking driven by the bending energy.

We describe a technique to obtain linear descriptions for polytopes from extended formulations. The simple idea is to first define a suitable lifting function and then to find linear constraints that are valid for the polytope and guarantee lifted points to be contained in the extension. We explain the technique at an example from the literature (matching polytopes), obtain new simple proofs of results on path-set polytopes and small-cliques polytopes, and finally exploit the technique in order to derive linear descriptions of orbisacks, which are special Knapsack polytopes arising in the context of symmetry breaking in integer programming problems.

Boolean Satisfiability solvers have gone through dramatic improvements in their performances and scalability over the last few years by considering symmetries. It has been shown that by using graph symmetries and generating symmetry breaking predicates (SBPs) it is possible to break symmetries in Conjunctive Normal Form (CNF). The SBPs cut down the search space to the nonsymmetric regions of the space without affecting the satisfiability of the CNF formula. The symmetry breaking predicates are created by representing the formula as a graph, finding the graph symmetries and using some symmetry extraction mechanism (Crawford et al.). Here in this paper we take one non-trivial CNF and explore its symmetries. Finally, we generate the SBPs and adding it to CNF we show how it helps to prune the search tree, so that SAT solver would take short time. Here we present the pruning procedure of the search tree from scratch, starting from the CNF and its graph representation. As we explore the whole mechanism by a non-trivial example, it would be easily comprehendible. Also we have given a new idea of generating symmetry breaking predicates for breaking symmetry in CNF, not derived from Crawford's conditions. At last we propose a backtrack SAT solver with inbuilt SBP generator.