arXiv++ Combinatorics

Expository article on the problem of determining the maximum number of equiangular lines with a fixed angle, and the associated problem of second eigenvalue multiplicity in graphs.

A system of linear equations $L$ is common over $\mathbb{F}_p$ if, as $n\to\infty$, any 2-coloring of $\mathbb{F}_p^n$ gives asymptotically at least as many monochromatic solutions to $L$ as a random 2-coloring. The notion of common linear systems is analogous to that of common graphs, i.e., graphs whose monochromatic density in 2-edge-coloring of cliques is asymptotically minimized by the random coloring. Saad and Wolf initiated a systematic study on identifying common linear systems, built upon the earlier work of Cameron-Cilleruelo-Serra. When $L$ is a single equation, Fox-Pham-Zhao gave a complete characterization of common linear equations. When $L$ consists of two equations, Kamčev-Liebenau-Morrison showed that irredundant $2\times 4$ linear systems are always uncommon. In this work, (1) we determine commonness of all $2\times 5$ linear systems up to a small number of cases, and (2) we show that all $2\times k$ linear systems with $k$ even and girth (minimum number of nonzero coefficients of a nonzero equation spanned by the system) $k-1$ are uncommon, answering a question of Kamčev-Liebenau-Morrison.

In recent work on equiangular lines, Jiang, Tidor, Yuan, Zhang, and Zhao showed that a connected bounded degree graph has sublinear second eigenvalue multiplicity. More generally they show that there cannot be too many eigenvalues near the top of the spectrum. We extend this result to infinite unimodular random graphs. As a corollary, the spectral distribution of the adjacency operator cannot have an atom at the top. For an infinite regular expander, we deduce that the singularity of the spectral measure at the top satisfies $μ_G[(1-θ)ρ,ρ] \lesssim θ^c$ for some constant $c>0$, where $ρ$ is the spectral radius of the adjacency operator of the graph. This implies new general estimates on the return probabilities of random walks.

A spherical $L$-code, where $L \subseteq [-1,\infty)$, consists of unit vectors in $\mathbb{R}^d$ whose pairwise inner products are contained in $L$. Determining the maximum cardinality $N_L(d)$ of an $L$-code in $\mathbb{R}^d$ is a fundamental question in discrete geometry and has been extensively investigated for various choices of $L$. Our understanding in high dimensions is generally quite poor. Equiangular lines, corresponding to $L = \{-α, α\}$, is a rare and notable solved case. Bukh studied an extension of equiangular lines and showed that $N_L(d) = O_L(d)$ for $L = [-1, -β] \cup \{α\}$ with $α,β> 0$ (we call such $L$-codes "uniacute"), leaving open the question of determining the leading constant factor. Balla, Dräxler, Keevash, and Sudakov proved a "uniform bound" showing $\limsup_{d\to\infty} N_L(d)/d \le 2p$ for $L = [-1, -β] \cup \{α\}$ and $p = \lfloor α/β\rfloor + 1$. For which $(α,β)$ is this uniform bound tight? We completely answer this question. We develop a framework for studying uniacute codes, including a global structure theorem showing that the Gram matrix has an approximate $p$-block structure. We also formulate a notion of "modular codes," which we conjecture to be optimal in high dimensions.

Ruzsa asked whether there exist Fourier-uniform subsets of $\mathbb Z/N\mathbb Z$ with density $α$ and 4-term arithmetic progression (4-AP) density at most $α^C$, for arbitrarily large $C$. Gowers constructed Fourier uniform sets with density $α$ and 4-AP density at most $α^{4+c}$ for some small constant $c>0$. We show that an affirmative answer to Ruzsa's question would follow from the existence of an $N^{o(1)}$-coloring of $[N]$ without symmetrically colored 4-APs. For a broad and natural class of constructions of Fourier-uniform subsets of $\mathbb Z/N\mathbb Z$, we show that Ruzsa's question is equivalent to our arithmetic Ramsey question. We prove analogous results for all even-length APs. For each odd $k\geq 5$, we show that there exist $U^{k-2}$-uniform subsets of $\mathbb Z/N\mathbb Z$ with density $α$ and $k$-AP density at most $α^{c_k \log(1/α)}$. We also prove generalizations to arbitrary one-dimensional patterns.

For positive integers $n,r,s$ with $r > s$, the set-coloring Ramsey number $R(n;r,s)$ is the minimum $N$ such that if every edge of the complete graph $K_N$ receives a set of $s$ colors from a palette of $r$ colors, then there is a subset of $n$ vertices where all of the edges between them receive a common color. If $n$ is fixed and $\frac{s}{r}$ is less than and bounded away from $1-\frac{1}{n-1}$, then $R(n;r,s)$ is known to grow exponentially in $r$, while if $\frac{s}{r}$ is greater than and bounded away from $1-\frac{1}{n-1}$, then $R(n;r,s)$ is bounded. Here we prove bounds for $R(n;r,s)$ in the intermediate range where $\frac{s}{r}$ is close to $1 - \frac{1}{n-1}$ by establishing a connection to the maximum size of error-correcting codes near the zero-rate threshold.

We prove that $1-o(1)$ fraction of all $k$-SAT functions on $n$ Boolean variables are unate (i.e., monotone after first negating some variables), for any fixed positive integer $k$ and as $n \to \infty$. This resolves a conjecture by Bollobás, Brightwell, and Leader from 2003.

We show that for a fixed $q$, the number of $q$-ary $t$-error correcting codes of length $n$ is at most $2^{(1 + o(1)) H_q(n,t)}$ for all $t \leq (1 - q^{-1})n - C_q\sqrt{n \log n}$ (for sufficiently large constant $C_q$), where $H_q(n, t) = q^n / V_q(n,t)$ is the Hamming bound and $V_q(n,t)$ is the cardinality of the radius $t$ Hamming ball. This proves a conjecture of Balogh, Treglown, and Wagner, who showed the result for $t = o(n^{1/3} (\log n)^{-2/3})$.

How should we place $n$ great circles on a sphere to minimize the furthest distance between a point on the sphere and its nearest great circle? Fejes Tóth conjectured that the optimum is attained by placing $n$ circles evenly spaced all passing through the north and south poles. This conjecture was recently proved by Jiang and Polyanskii. We present a short simplification of Ortega-Moreno's alternate proof of this conjecture.

Jiang, Tidor, Yao, Zhang, and Zhao recently showed that connected bounded degree graphs have sublinear second eigenvalue multiplicity (always referring to the adjacency matrix). This result was a key step in the solution to the problem of equiangular lines with fixed angles. It led to the natural question: what is the maximum second eigenvalue multiplicity of a connected bounded degree $n$-vertex graph? The best known upper bound is $O(n/\log\log n)$. The previously known best known lower bound is on the order of $n^{1/3}$ (for infinitely many $n$), coming from Cayley graphs on $\text{PSL}(2,q)$. Here we give constructions showing a lower bound on the order of $\sqrt{n/\log n}$. We also construct Cayley graphs with second eigenvalue multiplicity at least $n^{2/5}-1$. Earlier techniques show that there are at most $O(n/\log\log n)$ eigenvalues (counting multiplicities) within $O(1/\log n)$ of the second eigenvalue. We give a construction showing this upper bound on approximate second eigenvalue multiplicity is tight up to a constant factor. This demonstrates a barrier to earlier techniques for upper bounding eigenvalue multiplicities.

How many $k$-SAT functions on $n$ boolean variables are there? What does a typical such function look like? Bollobás, Brightwell, and Leader conjectured that, for each fixed $k \ge 2$, the number of $k$-SAT functions on $n$ variables is $(1+o(1))2^{\binom{n}{k} + n}$, or equivalently: a $1-o(1)$ fraction of all $k$-SAT functions are unate, i.e., monotone after negating some variables. They proved a weaker version of the conjecture for $k=2$. The conjecture was confirmed for $k=2$ by Allen and $k=3$ by Ilinca and Kahn. We show that the problem of enumerating $k$-SAT functions is equivalent to a Turán density problem for partially directed hypergraphs. Our proof uses the hypergraph container method. Furthermore, we confirm the Bollobás--Brightwell--Leader conjecture for $k=4$ by solving the corresponding Turán density problem. Our solution applies a recent result of Füredi and Maleki on the minimum triangular edge density in a graph of given edge density. In an appendix (by Nitya Mani and Edward Yu), we further confirm the $k=5$ case of the conjecture via a brute force computer search.

For which graphs $F$ is there a sparse $F$-counting lemma in $C_4$-free graphs? We are interested in identifying graphs $F$ with the property that, roughly speaking, if $G$ is an $n$-vertex $C_4$-free graph with on the order of $n^{3/2}$ edges, then the density of $F$ in $G$, after a suitable normalization, is approximately at least the density of $F$ in an $ε$-regular approximation of $G$. In recent work, motivated by applications in extremal and additive combinatorics, we showed that $C_5$ has this property. Here we construct a family of graphs with the property.

We study quantitative relationships between the triangle removal lemma and several of its variants. One such variant, which we call the triangle-free lemma, states that for each $ε>0$ there exists $M$ such that every triangle-free graph $G$ has an $ε$-approximate homomorphism to a triangle-free graph $F$ on at most $M$ vertices (here an $ε$-approximate homomorphism is a map $V(G) \to V(F)$ where all but at most $ε|V(G)|^2$ edges of $G$ are mapped to edges of $F$). One consequence of our results is that the least possible $M$ in the triangle-free lemma grows faster than exponential in any polynomial in $ε^{-1}$. We also prove more general results for arbitrary graphs, as well as arithmetic analogues over finite fields, where the bounds are close to optimal.

Ellis, Filmus, and Friedgut proved an old conjecture of Simonovits and Sós showing that the maximum size of a triangle-intersecting family of graphs on $n$ vertices has size at most $2^{\binom{n}{2} - 3}$, with equality for the family of graphs containing some fixed triangle. They conjectured that their results extend to cross-intersecting families, as well to $K_t$-intersecting families. We prove these conjectures for $t \in \{3,4\}$, showing that if $\mathcal F_1$ and $\mathcal F_2$ are families of graphs on $n$ labeled vertices such that for any $G_1 \in \mathcal F_1$ and $G_2 \in \mathcal F_2$, $G_1 \cap G_2$ contains a $K_t$, then $\lvert \mathcal F_1 \rvert \lvert \mathcal F_2 \rvert \le 4^{\binom{n}{2} - \binom{t}{2}}$, with equality if and only if $\mathcal F_1 = \mathcal F_2$ consists of all graphs that contain some fixed $K_t$. We also establish a stability result. More generally, "$G_1 \cap G_2$ contains a $K_t$" can be replaced by "$G_1$ and $G_2$ agree on a non-$(t-1)$-colorable graph."

We show that for every $1 \le k \le d/(\log d)^C$, every finite transitive set of unit vectors in $\mathbb{R}^d$ lies within distance $O(1/\sqrt{\log (d/k)})$ of some codimension $k$ subspace, and this distance bound is best possible. This extends a result of Ben Green, who proved it for $k=1$.

We prove that every $n$-vertex tournament has at most $n\left(\frac{n-1}{2}\right)^k$ walks of length $k$.

We generalize the Guth--Katz joints theorem from lines to varieties. A special case says that $N$ planes (2-flats) in 6 dimensions (over any field) have $O(N^{3/2})$ joints, where a joint is a point contained in a triple of these planes not all lying in some hyperplane. More generally, we prove the same bound when the set of $N$ planes is replaced by a set of 2-dimensional algebraic varieties of total degree $N$, and a joint is a point that is regular for three varieties whose tangent planes at that point are not all contained in some hyperplane. Our most general result gives upper bounds, tight up to constant factors, for joints with multiplicities for several sets of varieties of arbitrary dimensions (known as Carbery's conjecture). Our main innovation is a new way to extend the polynomial method to higher dimensional objects, relating the degree of a polynomial and its orders of vanishing on a given set of points on a variety.

Sometimes, it is possible to represent a complicated polytope as a projection of a much simpler polytope. To quantify this phenomenon, the extension complexity of a polytope $P$ is defined to be the minimum number of facets of a (possibly higher-dimensional) polytope from which $P$ can be obtained as a (linear) projection. This notion is motivated by its relevance to combinatorial optimisation, and has been studied intensively for various specific polytopes associated with important optimisation problems. In this paper we study extension complexity as a parameter of general polytopes, more specifically considering various families of low-dimensional polytopes. First, we prove that for a fixed dimension $d$, the extension complexity of a random $d$-dimensional polytope (obtained as the convex hull of random points in a ball or on a sphere) is typically on the order of the square root of its number of vertices. Second, we prove that any cyclic $n$-vertex polygon (whose vertices lie on a circle) has extension complexity at most $24\sqrt n$. This bound is tight up to the constant factor $24$. Finally, we show that there exists an $n^{o(1)}$-dimensional polytope with at most $n$ vertices and extension complexity $n^{1-o(1)}$. Our theorems are proved with a range of different techniques, which we hope will be of further interest.

We study the problem of determining the maximum size of a spherical two-distance set with two fixed angles (one acute and one obtuse) in high dimensions. Let $N_{α,β}(d)$ denote the maximum number of unit vectors in $\mathbb R^d$ where all pairwise inner products lie in $\{α,β\}$. For fixed $-1\leqβ<0\leqα<1$, we propose a conjecture for the limit of $N_{α,β}(d)/d$ as $d \to \infty$ in terms of eigenvalue multiplicities of signed graphs. We determine this limit when $α+2β<0$ or $(1-α)/(α-β) \in \{1, \sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3}\}$. Our work builds on our recent resolution of the problem in the case of $α= -β$ (corresponding to equiangular lines). It is the first determination of $\lim_{d \to \infty} N_{α,β}(d)/d$ for any nontrivial fixed values of $α$ and $β$ outside of the equiangular lines setting.

Does every $n$-vertex Cayley graph have an orthonormal eigenbasis all of whose coordinates are $O(1/\sqrt{n})$? While the answer is yes for abelian groups, we show that it is no in general. On the other hand, we show that every $n$-vertex Cayley graph (and more generally, vertex-transitive graph) has an orthonormal basis whose coordinates are all $O(\sqrt{\log n / n})$, and that this bound is nearly best possible. Our investigation is motivated by a question of Assaf Naor, who proved that random abelian Cayley graphs are small-set expanders, extending a classic result of Alon--Roichman. His proof relies on the existence of a bounded eigenbasis for abelian Cayley graphs, which we now know cannot hold for general groups. On the other hand, we navigate around this obstruction and extend Naor's result to nonabelian groups.