arXiv++ Combinatorics

In this paper, we study a bootstrap percolation process on the finite triangular grid $\mathfrak{T}_n$ of side length $n$. We say that a subset $η$ of points in $\mathfrak{T}_n$ percolates if the final configuration, starting from $η$, is the whole grid $\mathfrak{T}_n$. A basis of size $n$ is then a subset of points of $\mathfrak{T}_n$ of minimum cardinality which percolates. In this paper, we first prove that the generating function counting bases satisfies an algebraic differential equation. Then, by analysing a modified version of this equation, we prove that the number $t_n$ of bases of size $n$ exhibits a stretched exponential asymptotic behaviour. More precisely, we show that $t_n \sim c n!e^{\sqrt{12n}}n^{5/12}$, for some constant $c>0$. These bases were recently shown by the second author to be in bijection with $3$-permutations avoiding the patterns $(12, 12)$ and $(231, 312)$, so this represents to our knowledge the first proven example of an asymptotic stretched exponential appearing in the study of pattern avoiding permutations.

In the study of walks with small steps confined to multidimensional orthants, a certain group of transformations plays a central role. In particular, several techniques to potentially compute the generating function, including the orbit sum method, can only be applied when this group is finite. In this note, we present three new results concerning this group. First, in two dimensions, we provide a complete characterization of the weight parameters that yield a finite group. In higher dimensions, we show that whenever the group is finite, it must necessarily be isomorphic to a simpler reflection group. Finally, in dimension three, we give a full classification of the parameters leading to a finite group that also satisfies an additional Weyl property.

We obtain bivariate asymptotics for the number of (unicellular) combinatorial maps (a model of discrete surfaces) as both the size and the genus grow. This work is related to two research topics that have been very active recently: multivariate asymptotics and large genus geometry. Our method consists in studying a linear recurrence for these numbers, and in fact it can be applied to many other linear recurrences. We discuss briefly the generality of our method and future research directions.

We address the enumeration of Eulerian orientations of 4-valent planar maps according to three parameters: the number of vertices, the number of alternating vertices (having in/out/in/out incident edges), and the number of clockwise oriented faces. This is a refinement of the six vertex model studied by Kostov, then Zinn-Justin and Elvey Price, where one only considers the first two parameters. Via a bijection of Ambjorn and Budd, our problem is equivalent to the enumeration of Eulerian partial orientations of general planar maps, counted by the number of edges, the number of undirected edges, and the number of vertices. We first derive from combinatorial arguments a system of functional equations characterising the associated trivariate series $Q(t,ω,v)$. We then derive from this system a compact characterisation of this series. We use it to determine $Q(t,ω,v)$ in three two-parameter cases. The first two cases correspond to setting the variable $ω$ counting alternating vertices (or undirected edges after the AB bijection) to $0$ or $1$: when $ω=0$ we count Eulerian orientations of general planar maps by edges and vertices, and when $ω=1$ we count Eulerian orientations of quartic maps by vertices and clockwise faces. The final forms of these two series, namely $Q(t,0, v)$ and $Q(t,1,v)$, refine those obtained by the authors in an earlier paper for $v=1$. The third case that we solve, namely $v=1$ (but $ω$ arbitrary), is the standard six-vertex model, for which we provide a new proof of the formula of Elvey Price and Zinn-Justin involving Jacobi theta functions. This new derivation remains purely in the world of formal power series, not relying on complex analysis. Our results also use a more direct approach to solving the functional equations, in contrast to the guess and check approaches used in previous work.

In the field of enumeration of weighted walks confined to the quarter plane, it is known that the generating functions behave very differently depending on the chosen step set; in practice, the techniques used in the literature depend on the complexity of the counting series. In this paper we introduce a unified approach based on the theory of elliptic functions, which allows us to have a common proof of the characterisation of the algebraicity and D-finiteness of the generating functions.

We address the enumeration of walks with small steps confined to a two-dimensional cone, for example the quarter plane, three-quarter plane or the slit plane. In the quarter plane case, the solutions for unweighted step-sets are already well understood, in the sense that it is known precisely for which cases the generating function is algebraic, D-finite or D-algebraic, and exact integral expressions are known in all cases. We derive similar results in a much more general setting: we enumerate walks on an $M$-quadrant cone for any positive integer $M$, with weighted steps starting at any point. The main breakthrough in this work is the derivation of an analytic functional equation which characterises the generating function of these walks, which is analogous to one now used widely for quarter-plane walks. In the case $M=3$, which corresponds to walks avoiding a quadrant, we provide exact integral-expression solutions for walks with weighted small steps which determine the generating function ${\sf C}(x,y;t)$ counting these walks. Moreover, for each step-set and starting point of the walk we determine whether the generating function ${\sf C}(x,y;t)$ is algebraic, D-finite or D-algebraic as a function of $x$ and $y$. In fact we provide results of this type for any $M$-quadrant cone, showing that this nature is the same for any odd $M$. For $M$ even we find that the generating functions counting these walks are D-finite in $x$ and $y$, and algebraic if and only if the starting point of the walk is on the same axis as the boundaries of the cone.

Pattern-avoiding ascent sequences have recently been related to set-partition problems and stack-sorting problems. While the generating functions for several length-3 pattern-avoiding ascent sequences are known, those avoiding 000, 100, 110, 120 are not known. We have generated extensive series expansions for these four cases, and analysed them in order to conjecture the asymptotic behaviour. We provide polynomial time algorithms for the 000 and 110 cases, and exponential time algorithms for the 100 and 120 cases. We also describe how the 000 polynomial time algorithm was detected somewhat mechanically given an exponential time algorithm. For 120-avoiding ascent sequences we find that the generating function has stretched-exponential behaviour and prove that the growth constant is the same as that for 201-avoiding ascent sequences, which is known. The other three generating functions have zero radius of convergence, which we also prove. For 000-avoiding ascent sequences we give what we believe to be the exact growth constant. We give the conjectured asymptotic behaviour for all four cases.

We derive a simple functional equation with two catalytic variables characterising the generating function of 3-stack-sortable permutations. Using this functional equation, we extend the 174-term series to 1000 terms. From this series, we conjecture that the generating function behaves as $$W(t) \sim C_0(1-μ_3 t)^α\cdot \log^β(1-μ_3 t), $$ so that $$[t^n]W(t)=w_n \sim \frac{c_0μ_3^n}{ n^{(α+1)}\cdot \log^λ{n}} ,$$ where $μ_3 = 9.69963634535(30),$ $α= 2.0 \pm 0.25.$ If $α= 2$ exactly, then $λ= -β+1$, and we estimate $β\approx -3.$ If $α$ is not an integer, then $λ=-β$, but we cannot give a useful estimate of $β$. The growth constant estimate (just) contradicts a conjecture of the first author that $$9.702 < μ_3 \le 9.704.$$ We also prove a new rigorous lower bound of $μ_3\geq 9.4854$, allowing us to disprove a conjecture of Bóna. We then further extend the series using differential-approximants to obtain approximate coefficients $O(t^{2000}),$ expected to be accurate to $20$ significant digits, and use the approximate coefficients to provide additional evidence supporting the results obtained from the exact coefficients.

This paper solves an open question of Mortimer and Prellberg asking for an explicit bijection between two families of walks. The first family is formed by what we name triangular walks, which are two-dimensional walks moving in six directions (0°, 60°, 120°, 180°, 240°, 300°) and confined within a triangle. The other family is comprised of two-colored Motzkin paths with bounded height, in which the horizontal steps may be forbidden at maximal height. We provide several new bijections. The first one is derived from a simple inductive proof, taking advantage of a $2^n$-to-one function from generic triangular walks to triangular walks only using directions 0°, 120°, 240°. The second is based on an extension of Mortimer and Prellberg's results to triangular walks starting not only at a corner of the triangle, but at any point inside it. It has a linear-time complexity and is in fact adjustable: by changing some set of parameters called a scaffolding, we obtain a wide range of different bijections. Finally, we extend our results to higher dimensions. In particular, by adapting the previous proofs, we discover an unexpected bijection between three-dimensional walks in a pyramid and two-dimensional simple walks confined in a bounded domain shaped like a waffle.

We address the six vertex model on a random lattice, which in combinatorial terms corresponds to the enumeration of weighted 4-valent planar maps equipped with an Eulerian orientation. This problem was exactly, albeit non-rigorously solved by Ivan Kostov in 2000 using matrix integral techniques. We convert Kostov's work to a combinatorial argument involving functional equations coming from recursive decompositions of the maps, which we solve rigorously using complex analysis. We then investigate modular properties of the solution, which lead to simplifications in certain special cases. In particular, in two special cases of combinatorial interest we rederive the formulae discovered by Bousquet-Mélou and the first author.

We address the problem of counting walks by winding angle on the Kreweras lattice, an oriented version of the triangular lattice. Our method uses a new decomposition of the lattice, which allows us to write functional equations characterising a generating function of walks counted by length, endpoint and winding angle. We then solve these functional equations in terms of Jacobi theta functions. By using this result in conjunction with the reflection principle, we count walks confined to a cone of opening angle any multiple of $\fracπ{3}$, allowing us to extract asymptotic and algebraic information for these walks. Our method and results extend analogously to three other lattices, including the square lattice and triangular lattice. On the square lattice, most of our results were derived by Timothy Budd in 2017, so the current work can be seen as an extension of Budd's results to the three other lattices that we consider. Budd's method of deducing these results was very different, as it was based on an explicit eigenvalue decomposition of certain matrices counting paths in the lattice.

We find a Thron-type continued fraction (T-fraction) for the ordinary generating function of the Ward polynomials, as well as for some generalizations employing a large (indeed infinite) family of independent indeterminates. Our proof is based on a bijection between super-augmented perfect matchings and labeled Schröder paths, which generalizes Flajolet's bijection between perfect matchings and labeled Dyck paths.

A small set of combinatorial sequences have coefficients that can be represented as moments of a nonnegative measure on $[0, \infty)$. Such sequences are known as Stieltjes moment sequences. This article focuses on some classical sequences in enumerative combinatorics, denoted $Av(\mathcal{P})$, and counting permutations of $\{1, 2, \ldots, n \}$ that avoid some given pattern $\mathcal{P}$. For increasing patterns $\mathcal{P}=(12\ldots k)$, we recall that the corresponding sequences, $Av(123\ldots k)$, are Stieltjes moment sequences, and we explicitly find the underlying density function, either exactly or numerically, by using the Stieltjes inversion formula as a fundamental tool. We show that the generating functions of the sequences $\, Av(1234)$ and $\, Av(12345)$ correspond, up to simple rational functions, to an order-one linear differential operator acting on a classical modular form given as a pullback of a Gaussian $\, _2F_1$ hypergeometric function, respectively to an order-two linear differential operator acting on the square of a classical modular form given as a pullback of a $\, _2F_1$ hypergeometric function. We demonstrate that the density function for the Stieltjes moment sequence $Av(123\ldots k)$ is closely, but non-trivially, related to the density attached to the distance traveled by a walk in the plane with $k-1$ unit steps in random directions. Finally, we study the challenging case of the $Av(1324)$ sequence and give compelling numerical evidence that this too is a Stieltjes moment sequence. Accepting this, we show how rigorous lower bounds on the growth constant of this sequence can be constructed, which are stronger than existing bounds. A further unproven assumption leads to even better bounds, which can be extrapolated to give an estimate of the (unknown) growth constant.

Recently Albert and Bousquet-Mélou obtained the solution to the long-standing problem of the enumeration of permutations sortable by two stacks in parallel (2sip). Their solution was expressed in terms of functional equations. E.P. and Guttmann then showed that the equally long-standing problem of the number of permutations sortable by a double ended queue (deque) can be simply related to the solution of the same functional equations. They then conjectured that the radius of convergence of both generating functions is the same, and reduced this conjecture to a series of conjectures of Albert and Bousquet-Mélou regarding a generating function for quarter-plane loops. In this note we prove that the two growth rates are equal, using a combinatorial argument on certain lattice paths which are in bijection with the two classes. As a corollary we prove that the generating function P(t) for permutations sortable by two stacks in parallel satisfies an inequality which was conjectured by Albert and Bousquet-Mélou.

A compacted binary tree is a directed acyclic graph encoding a binary tree in which common subtrees are factored and shared, such that they are represented only once. We show that the number of compacted binary trees of size $n$ grows asymptotically like $$Θ\left( n! \, 4^n e^{3a_1n^{1/3}} n^{3/4} \right),$$ where $a_1\approx-2.338$ is the largest root of the Airy function. Our method involves a new two parameter recurrence which yields an algorithm of quadratic arithmetic complexity. We use empirical methods to estimate the values of all terms defined by the recurrence, then we prove by induction that these estimates are sufficiently accurate for large $n$ to determine the asymptotic form. Our results also lead to new bounds on the number of minimal finite automata recognizing a finite language on a binary alphabet. As a consequence, these also exhibit a stretched exponential.

We address the enumeration of planar 4-valent maps equipped with an Eulerian orientation by two different methods, and compare the solutions we thus obtain. With the first method we enumerate these orientations as well as a restricted class which we show to be in bijection with general Eulerian orientations. The second method, based on the work of Kostov, allows us to enumerate these 4-valent orientations with a weight on some vertices, corresponding to the six vertex model. We prove that this result generalises both results obtained using the first method, although the equivalence is not immediately clear.

The enumeration of planar maps equipped with an Eulerian orientation has attracted attention in both combinatorics and theoretical physics since at least 2000. The case of 4-valent maps is particularly interesting: these orientations are in bijection with properly 3-coloured quadrangulations, while in physics they correspond to configurations of the ice model. We solve both problems -- namely the enumeration of planar Eulerian orientations and of 4-valent planar Eulerian orientations -- by expressing the associated generating functions as the inverses (for the composition of series) of simple hypergeometric series. Using these expressions, we derive the asymptotic behaviour of the number of planar Eulerian orientations, thus proving earlier predictions of Kostov, Zinn-Justin, Elvey Price and Guttmann. This behaviour, $μ^n /(n \log n)^2$, prevents the associated generating functions from being D-finite. Still, these generating functions are differentially algebraic, as they satisfy non-linear differential equations of order $2$. Differential algebraicity has recently been proved for other map problems, in particular for maps equipped with a Potts model. Our solutions mix recursive and bijective ingredients. In particular, a preliminary bijection transforms our oriented maps into maps carrying a height function on their vertices. In the 4-valent case, we also observe an unexpected connection with the enumeration of maps equipped with a spanning tree that is internally inactive in the sense of Tutte. This connection remains to be explained combinatorially.

We establish an improved lower bound of 10.271 for the exponential growth rate of the class of permutations avoiding the pattern 1324, and an improved upper bound of 13.5. These results depend on a new exact structural characterisation of 1324-avoiders as a subclass of an infinite staircase grid class, together with precise asymptotics of a small domino subclass whose enumeration we relate to West-two-stack-sortable permutations and planar maps. The bounds are established by carefully combining copies of the dominoes in particular ways consistent with the structural characterisation. The lower bound depends on concentration results concerning the substructure of a typical domino, the determination of exactly when dominoes can be combined in the fewest distinct ways, and technical analysis of the resulting generating function.

Inspired by the paper of Bonichon, Bousquet-Mélou, Dorbec and Pennarun, we give a system of functional equations which characterise the ordinary generating function, $U(x),$ for the number of planar Eulerian orientations counted by edges. We also characterise the ogf $A(x)$, for 4-valent planar Eulerian orientations counted by vertices in a similar way. The latter problem is equivalent to the 6-vertex problem on a random lattice, widely studied in mathematical physics. While unable to solve these functional equations, they immediately provide polynomial-time algorithms for computing the coefficients of the generating function. From these algorithms we have obtained 100 terms for $U(x)$ and 90 terms for $A(x).$ Analysis of these series suggests that they both behave as $const\cdot (1 - μx)/\log(1 - μx),$ where we conjecture that $μ= 4π$ for Eulerian orientations counted by edges and $μ=4\sqrt{3}π$ for 4-valent Eulerian orientations counted by vertices.

We have developed polynomial-time algorithms to generate terms of the cogrowth series for groups $\mathbb{Z}\wr \mathbb{Z},$ the lamplighter group, $(\mathbb{Z}\wr \mathbb{Z})\wr \mathbb{Z}$ and the Navas-Brin group $B.$ We have also given an improved algorithm for the coefficients of Thompson's group $F,$ giving 32 terms of the cogrowth series. We develop numerical techniques to extract the asymptotics of these various cogrowth series. We present improved rigorous lower bounds on the growth-rate of the cogrowth series for Thompson's group $F$ using the method from \cite{HHR15} applied to our extended series. We also generalise their method by showing that it applies to loops on any locally finite graph. Unfortunately, lower bounds less than 16 do not help in determining amenability. Again for Thompson's group $F$ we prove that, if the group is amenable, there cannot be a sub-dominant stretched exponential term in the asymptotics\footnote{ }. Yet the numerical data provides compelling evidence for the presence of such a term. This observation suggests a potential path to a proof of non-amenability: If the universality class of the cogrowth sequence can be determined rigorously, it will likely prove non-amenability. We estimate the asymptotics of the cogrowth coefficients of $F$ to be $$ c_n \sim c \cdot μ^n \cdot κ^{n^σ\log^δ{n}} \cdot n^g,$$ where $μ\approx 15,$ $κ\approx 1/e,$ $σ\approx 1/2,$ $δ\approx 1/2,$ and $g \approx -1.$ The growth constant $μ$ must be 16 for amenability. These two approaches, plus a third based on extrapolating lower bounds, support the conjecture \cite{ERvR15, HHR15} that the group is not amenable.