arXiv++ Combinatorics

More than 40 years ago, Galvin, Rival and Sands showed that every $K_{s, s}$-free graph containing an $n$-vertex path must contain an induced path of length $f(n)$, where $f(n)\to \infty$ as $n\to \infty$. Recently, it was shown by Duron, Esperet and Raymond that one can take $f(n)=(\log \log n)^{1/5-o(1)}$. In this note, we give a short self-contained proof that a $K_{s, s}$-free graphs with an $n$-vertex path contains an induced path of length at least $(\log \log n)^{1-o(1)}$. Combined with the recent remarkable example of Couëtoux, Defrain, and Raymond, which provides an upper bound of $O((\log \log n)^{1+o(1)})$, this essentially resolves this old problem.

We study and solve several problems in two closely related settings: set families in $2^{[n]}$ with many disjoint pairs of sets and low rank matrices with many zero entries. - More than 40 years ago, Daykin and Erdős asked for the maximum number of disjoint pairs of sets in a family $F\subseteq 2^{[n]}$ of size $2^{(1/2+δ)n}$ and conjectured it contains at most $o(|F|^2)$ such pairs. This was proven by Alon and Frankl in 1985. In this paper we completely resolve this problem, proving an optimal dependence of the number of disjoint pairs on the size of family $F$. We also prove the natural variant of the Daykin-Erdős conjecture in which disjoint pairs are replaced by pairs with intersection $λ\neq 0$. - Motivated by a conjecture of Lovett related to the famous log-rank conjecture, Singer and Sudan asked to show that for two families $A, B \subseteq 2^{[n]}$ with a positive constant fraction of set pairs $(a,b)\in A\times B$ being disjoint, there are $R\subset A$ and $S\subset B$ such that all set pairs $(r, s)\in R\times S$ are disjoint, and $|R|\geq 2^{-O(\sqrt{n})}|A|$ and $|S|\geq 2^{-O(\sqrt{n})}|B|$. We prove this conjecture in a strong quantitative form. - We prove the following generalizations of the best known bounds for the log-rank conjecture. If $M$ is an $n\times n$ non-negative integer matrix of rank $r$ in which the average of the entries is $\varepsilon\leq 1/2$, then $M$ contains an all-zero submatrix of size at least $2^{-O(\sqrt{\varepsilon r})}n$. Unlike the known bounds for the log-rank conjecture, this result is optimal. Moreover, using similar methods, we also prove that any $n\times n$ matrix of rank $r$ with entries from $\{0,\dots,t\}$ contains a constant submatrix of size at least $2^{-O(t\sqrt{r})}n$. Our proofs use probabilistic, entropy and discrepancy methods and explore connections to additive combinatorics and coding theory.

The canonical Ramsey theorem of Erdős and Rado implies that for any graph $H$, any edge-coloring (with an arbitrary number of colors) of a sufficiently large complete graph $K_N$ contains a monochromatic, lexicographic, or rainbow copy of $H$. The least such $N$ is called the Erdős-Rado number of $H$, denoted by $ER(H)$. Erdős-Rado numbers of cliques have received considerable attention, and in this paper we extend this line of research by studying Erdős-Rado numbers of sparse graphs. For example, we prove that if $H$ has bounded degree, then $ER(H)$ is polynomial in $|V(H)|$ if $H$ is bipartite, but exponential in general. We also study the closely-related problem of constrained Ramsey numbers. For a given tree $S$ and given path $P_t$, we study the minimum $N$ such that every edge-coloring of $K_N$ contains a monochromatic copy of $S$ or a rainbow copy of $P_t$. We prove a nearly optimal upper bound for this problem, which differs from the best known lower bound by a function of inverse-Ackermann type.

In 1992, Erdős and Hajnal posed the following natural problem: Does there exist, for every $r\in \mathbb{N}$, an integer $F(r)$ such that every graph with chromatic number at least $F(r)$ contains $r$ edge-disjoint cycles on the same vertex set? We solve this problem in a strong form, by showing that there exist $n$-vertex graphs with fractional chromatic number $Ω\left(\frac{\log \log n}{\log \log \log n}\right)$ that do not even contain a $4$-regular subgraph. This implies that no such number $F(r)$ exists for $r\ge 2$. We show that assuming a conjecture of Harris, the bound on the fractional chromatic number in our result cannot be improved.

For two graphs $F,H$ and a positive integer $n$, the function $f_{F,H}(n)$ denotes the largest $m$ such that every $H$-free graph on $n$ vertices contains an $F$-free induced subgraph on $m$ vertices. This function has been extensively studied in the last 60 years when $F$ and $H$ are cliques and became known as the Erdős-Rogers function. Recently, Balogh, Chen and Luo, and Mubayi and Verstraëte initiated the systematic study of this function in the case where $F$ is a general graph. Answering, in a strong form, a question of Mubayi and Verstraëte, we prove that for every positive integer $r$ and every $K_{r-1}$-free graph $F$, there exists some $\varepsilon_F>0$ such that $f_{F,K_r}(n)=O(n^{1/2-\varepsilon_F})$. This result is tight in two ways. Firstly, it is no longer true if $F$ contains $K_{r-1}$ as a subgraph. Secondly, we show that for all $r\geq 4$ and $\varepsilon>0$, there exists a $K_{r-1}$-free graph $F$ for which $f_{F,K_r}(n)=Ω(n^{1/2-\varepsilon})$. Along the way of proving this, we show in particular that for every graph $F$ with minimum degree $t$, we have $f_{F,K_4}(n)=Ω(n^{1/2-6/\sqrt{t}})$. This answers (in a strong form) another question of Mubayi and Verstraëte. Finally, we prove that there exist absolute constants $0<c<C$ such that for each $r\geq 4$, if $F$ is a bipartite graph with sufficiently large minimum degree, then $Ω(n^{\frac{c}{\log r}})\leq f_{F,K_r}(n)\leq O(n^{\frac{C}{\log r}})$. This shows that for graphs $F$ with large minimum degree, the behaviour of $f_{F,K_r}(n)$ is drastically different from that of the corresponding off-diagonal Ramsey number $f_{K_2,K_r}(n)$.

A graph $G$ is said to be $p$-locally dense if every induced subgraph of $G$ with linearly many vertices has edge density at least $p$. A famous conjecture of Kohayakawa, Nagle, Rödl, and Schacht predicts that locally dense graphs have, asymptotically, at least as many copies of any fixed graph $H$ as are found in a random graph of edge density $p$. In this paper, we prove several results around the KNRS conjecture. First, we prove that certain natural gluing operations on $H$ preserve this property, thus proving the conjecture for many graphs $H$ for which it was previously unknown. Secondly, we study a stability version of this conjecture, and prove that for many graphs $H$, approximate equality is attained in the KNRS conjecture if and only if the host graph $G$ is quasirandom. Finally, we introduce a weakening of the KNRS conjecture, which requires the host graph to be nearly degree-regular, and prove this conjecture for a larger family of graphs. Our techniques reveal a surprising connection between these questions, semidefinite optimization, and the study of copositive matrices.

The celebrated Erdős-Hajnal conjecture says that any graph without a fixed induced subgraph $H$ contains a very large homogeneous set. A direct analog of this conjecture is not true for hypergraphs. In this paper we present two natural variants of this problem which do hold for hypergraphs. We show that for every $r \geq 3$, $m \geq m_0(r)$ and $0 \leq f \leq \binom{m}{r}$, if an $r$-graph $G$ does not contain $m$ vertices spanning exactly $f$ edges, then $G$ contains much bigger homogeneous sets than what is guaranteed to exist in general $r$-graphs. We also prove that if a $3$-graph $G$ does not contain homogeneous sets of polynomial size, then for every $m \geq 3$ there are $Ω(m^3)$ values of $f$ such that $G$ contains $m$ vertices spanning exactly $f$ edges. This makes progress on a problem of Axenovich, Bradač, Gishboliner, Mubayi and Weber.

We show that the edges of any $d$-regular graph can be almost decomposed into paths of length roughly $d$, giving an approximate solution to a problem of Kotzig from 1957. Along the way, we show that almost all of the vertices of a $d$-regular graph can be partitioned into $n/(d+1)$ paths, asymptotically confirming a conjecture of Magnant and Martin from 2009.

The induced $q$-color size-Ramsey number $\hat{r}_{\text{ind}}(H;q)$ of a graph $H$ is the minimal number of edges a host graph $G$ can have so that every $q$-edge-coloring of $G$ contains a monochromatic copy of $H$ which is an induced subgraph of $G$. A natural question, which in the non-induced case has a very long history, asks which families of graphs $H$ have induced Ramsey numbers that are linear in $|H|$. We prove that for every $k,w,q$, if $H$ is an $n$-vertex graph with maximum degree $k$ and treewidth at most $w$, then $\hat{r}_{\text{ind}}(H;q) = O_{k,w,q}(n)$. This extends several old and recent results in Ramsey theory. Our proof is quite simple and relies upon a novel reduction argument.

We prove the following variant of Helly's classical theorem for Hamming balls with a bounded radius. For $n>t$ and any (finite or infinite) set $X$, if in a family of Hamming balls of radius $t$ in $X^n$, every subfamily of at most $2^{t+1}$ balls have a common point, so do all members of the family. This is tight for all $|X|>1$ and all $n>t$. The proof of the main result is based on a novel variant of the so-called dimension argument, which allows one to prove upper bounds that do not depend on the dimension of the ambient space. We also discuss several related questions and connections to problems and results in extremal finite set theory and graph theory.

Let $K^r_n$ be the complete $r$-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices, that is, the hypergraph whose vertex set is $[n]:=\{1,2,...,n\}$ and whose edge set is $\binom{[n]}{r}$. We form $G^r(n,p)$ by retaining each edge of $K^r_n$ independently with probability $p$. An $r$-uniform hypergraph $H\subseteq G$ is $F$-saturated if $H$ does not contain any copy of $F$, but any missing edge of $H$ in $G$ creates a copy of $F$. Furthermore, we say that $H$ is weakly $F$-saturated in $G$ if $H$ does not contain any copy of $F$, but the missing edges of $H$ in $G$ can be added back one-by-one, in some order, such that every edge creates a new copy of $F$. The smallest number of edges in an $F$-saturated hypergraph in $G$ is denoted by $sat(G,F)$, and in a weakly $F$-saturated hypergraph in $G$ by $wsat(G,F)$. In 2017, Korándi and Sudakov initiated the study of saturation in random graphs, showing that for constant $p$, with high probability $sat(G(n,p),K_s)=(1+o(1))n\log_{\frac{1}{1-p}}n$, and $wsat(G(n,p),K_s)=wsat(K_n,K_s)$. Generalising their results, in this paper, we solve the suturation problem for random hypergraphs for every $2\le r < s$ and constant $p$.

In this paper we study the number of incidences between $m$ points and $n$ varieties in $\mathbb{F}^d$, where $\mathbb{F}$ is an arbitrary field, assuming the incidence graph contains no copy of $K_{s,s}$. We also consider the analogous problem for algebraically defined graphs and unit distance graphs. First, we prove that if $\mathcal{P}$ is a set of $m$ points and $\mathcal{V}$ is a set of $n$ varieties in $\mathbb{F}^{D}$, each of dimension $d$ and degree at most $Δ$, and in addition the incidence graph is $K_{s,s}$-free, then the number of incidences satisfies $I(\mathcal{P}, \mathcal{V})\leq O_{d,Δ, s}(m^{\frac{d}{d+1}} n+m)$. This bound is tight when $s,Δ$ are sufficiently large with respect to $d$, with an appropriate choice of $\mathbb{F}=\mathbb{F}(m,n)$. We give two proofs of this upper bound, one based on the framework of the induced Turán problems and the other based on VC-dimension theory. In the second proof, we extend the celebrated result of Rónyai, Babai and Ganapathy on the number of zero-patterns of polynomials to the context of varieties, which might be of independent interest. We also resolve the problem of finding the maximum number of unit distances which can be spanned by a set of $n$ points $\mathcal{P}$ in $\mathbb{F^d}$ whose unit-distance graph is $K_{s, s}$-free, showing that it is $Θ_{d,s}(n^{2-\frac{1}{\lceil d/2\rceil +1}})$. Finally, we obtain tight bounds on the maximum number of edges of a $K_{s, s}$-free algebraic graph defined over a finite field, thus resolving the Zarankiewicz problem for this class of graphs.

An $n$-vertex graph $G$ is a $C$-expander if $|N(X)|\geq C|X|$ for every $X\subseteq V(G)$ with $|X|< n/2C$ and there is an edge between every two disjoint sets of at least $n/2C$ vertices. We show that there is some constant $C>0$ for which every $C$-expander is Hamiltonian. In particular, this implies the well known conjecture of Krivelevich and Sudakov from 2003 on Hamilton cycles in $(n,d,λ)$-graphs. This completes a long line of research on the Hamiltonicity of sparse graphs, and has many applications, including to the Hamiltonicity of random Cayley graphs.

Given a $k$-uniform hypergraph $H$ on $n$ vertices, an even cover in $H$ is a collection of hyperedges that touch each vertex an even number of times. Even covers are a generalization of cycles in graphs and are equivalent to linearly dependent subsets of a system of linear equations modulo $2$. As a result, they arise naturally in the context of well-studied questions in coding theory and refuting unsatisfiable $k$-SAT formulas. Analogous to the irregular Moore bound of Alon, Hoory, and Linial (2002), in 2008, Feige conjectured an extremal trade-off between the number of hyperedges and the length of the smallest even cover in a $k$-uniform hypergraph. This conjecture was recently settled up to a multiplicative logarithmic factor in the number of hyperedges (Guruswami, Kothari, and Manohar 2022 and Hsieh, Kothari, and Mohanty 2023). These works introduce the new technique that relates hypergraph even covers to cycles in the associated Kikuchi graphs. Their analysis of these Kikuchi graphs, especially for odd $k$, is rather involved and relies on matrix concentration inequalities. In this work, we give a simple and purely combinatorial argument that recovers the best-known bound for Feige's conjecture for even $k$. We also introduce a novel variant of a Kikuchi graph which together with this argument improves the logarithmic factor in the best-known bounds for odd $k$. As an application of our ideas, we also give a purely combinatorial proof of the improved lower bounds (Alrabiah, Guruswami, Kothari and Manohar, 2023) on 3-query binary linear locally decodable codes.

The celebrated Kővári-Sós-Turán theorem states that any $n$-vertex graph containing no copy of the complete bipartite graph $K_{s,s}$ has at most $O_s(n^{2-1/s})$ edges. In the past two decades, motivated by the applications in discrete geometry and structural graph theory, a number of results demonstrated that this bound can be greatly improved if the graph satisfies certain structural restrictions. We propose the systematic study of this phenomenon, and state the conjecture that if $H$ is a bipartite graph, then an induced $H$-free and $K_{s,s}$-free graph cannot have much more edges than an $H$-free graph. We provide evidence for this conjecture by considering trees, cycles, the cube graph, and bipartite graphs with degrees bounded by $k$ on one side, obtaining in all the cases similar bounds as in the non-induced setting. Our results also have applications to the Erdős-Hajnal conjecture, the problem of finding induced $C_4$-free subgraphs with large degree and bounding the average degree of $K_{s, s}$-free graphs which do not contain induced subdivisions of a fixed graph.

The study of counting point-hyperplane incidences in the $d$-dimensional space was initiated in the 1990's by Chazelle and became one of the central problems in discrete geometry. It has interesting connections to many other topics, such as additive combinatorics and theoretical computer science. Assuming a standard non-degeneracy condition, i.e., that no $s$ points are contained in the intersection of $s$ hyperplanes, the currently best known upper bound on the number of incidences of $m$ points and $n$ hyperplanes in $\mathbb{R}^d$ is $$O_{d, s}((mn)^{1-1/(d+1)}+m+n).$$ This bound by Apfelbaum and Sharir is based on geometrical space partitioning techniques, which apply only over the real numbers. In this paper, we propose a novel combinatorial approach to study such incidence problems over arbitrary fields. Perhaps surprisingly, this approach matches the best known bounds for point-hyperplane incidences in $\mathbb{R}^d$ for many interesting values of $m, n, d$, e.g. when $m=n$ and $d$ is odd. Moreover, in finite fields our bounds are sharp as a function of $m$ and $n$ in every dimension. We also study the size of the largest complete bipartite graph in point-hyperplane incidence graphs with a given number of edges and obtain optimal bounds as well. Additionally, we study point-variety incidences and unit-distance problem in finite fields, and give tight bounds for both problems under a similar non-degeneracy assumption. We also resolve Zarankiewicz type problems for algebraic graphs. Our proofs use tools such as induced Turán problems, VC-dimension theory, evasive sets and Hilbert polynomials. Also, we extend the celebrated result of Rónyai, Babai and Ganapathy on the number of zero-patterns of polynomials to the context of varieties, which might be of independent interest.

The $q$-color Ramsey number of a $k$-uniform hypergraph $G,$ denoted $r(G;q)$, is the minimum integer $N$ such that any coloring of the edges of the complete $k$-uniform hypergraph on $N$ vertices contains a monochromatic copy of $G$. The study of these numbers is one of the most central topics in combinatorics. One natural question, which for triangles goes back to the work of Schur in 1916, is to determine the behaviour of $r(G;q)$ for fixed $G$ and $q$ tending to infinity. In this paper we study this problem for $3$-uniform hypergraphs and determine the tower height of $r(G;q)$ as a function of $q$. More precisely, given a hypergraph $G$, we determine when $r(G; q)$ behaves polynomially, exponentially or double-exponentially in $q$. This answers a question of Axenovich, Gyárfás, Liu and Mubayi.

Many well-studied problems in extremal combinatorics deal with the maximum possible size of a family of objects in which every pair of objects satisfies a given restriction. One problem of this type was recently raised by Alon, Gujgiczer, Körner, Milojević and Simonyi. They asked to determine the maximum size of a family $\mathcal{G}$ of graphs on $[n]$, such that for every two $G_1,G_2 \in \mathcal{G}$, the graphs $G_1 \setminus G_2$ and $G_2 \setminus G_1$ are isomorphic. We completely resolve this problem by showing that this maximum is exactly $2^{\frac{1}{2}\big(\binom{n}{2} - \lfloor \frac{n}{2}\rfloor\big)}$ and characterizing all the extremal constructions. We also prove an analogous result for $r$-uniform hypergraphs.

Given an $m\times n$ binary matrix $M$ with $|M|=p\cdot mn$ (where $|M|$ denotes the number of 1 entries), define the discrepancy of $M$ as $\mbox{disc}(M)=\displaystyle\max_{X\subset [m], Y\subset [n]}\big||M[X\times Y]|-p|X|\cdot |Y|\big|$. Using semidefinite programming and spectral techniques, we prove that if $\mbox{rank}(M)\leq r$ and $p\leq 1/2$, then $$\mbox{disc}(M)\geq Ω(mn)\cdot \min\left\{p,\frac{p^{1/2}}{\sqrt{r}}\right\}.$$ We use this result to obtain a modest improvement of Lovett's best known upper bound on the log-rank conjecture. We prove that any $m\times n$ binary matrix $M$ of rank at most $r$ contains an $(m\cdot 2^{-O(\sqrt{r})})\times (n\cdot 2^{-O(\sqrt{r})})$ sized all-1 or all-0 submatrix, which implies that the deterministic communication complexity of any Boolean function of rank $r$ is at most $O(\sqrt{r})$.

Let $f(n, v, e)$ denote the maximum number of edges in a 3-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices which does not contain $v$ vertices spanning at least $e$ edges. A central problem in extremal combinatorics, famously posed by Brown, Erdős and Sós in 1973, asks whether $f(n, e+3, e)=o(n^2)$ for every $e \ge 3$. A classical result of Sárközy and Selkow states that $f(n, e+\lfloor \log_2 e\rfloor+2, e)=o(n^{2})$ for every $e \ge 3$. This bound was recently improved by Conlon, Gishboliner, Levanzov and Shapira. Motivated by applications to other problems, Gowers and Long made the striking conjecture that $f(n, e+4, e)=O(n^{2-\varepsilon})$ for some $\varepsilon=\varepsilon(e)>0$. Conlon, Gishboliner, Levanzov and Shapira, and later, Shapira and Tyomkyn reiterated the following approximate version of this problem. What is the smallest $d(e)$ for which $f(n, e+d(e), e)=O(n^{2-\varepsilon})$ for some $\varepsilon=\varepsilon(e)>0$? In this paper, we prove that for each $e\geq 3$ we have $f(n, e+\lfloor \log_2 e\rfloor +38, e)=O(n^{2-\varepsilon})$ for some $\varepsilon>0$. This shows that one can already obtain power saving near the Sárközy-Selkow bound at the cost of a small additive constant.