arXiv++ Combinatorics

We extend the notion of parking function polytopes and study their geometric and combinatorial structure, including normal fans, face posets, and $h$-polynomials, as well as their connections to other classes of polytopes. To capture their combinatorial features, we introduce generalizations of ordered set partitions, called binary partitions and skewed binary partitions. Using properties of preorder cones, we characterize the skewed binary partitions that are in bijection with the cones of the normal fan of a parking function polytope. This description of the normal fan yields an explicit formula for the $h$-polynomials of simple parking function polytopes in terms of generalized Eulerian polynomials. Finally, we relate parking function polytopes to several well-known polytopes, leading to additional results, including formulas for their volumes and Ehrhart polynomials.

We show that the linear coefficient of the Ehrhart polynomial of a matroid base polytope evaluated at $t-1$ is equal to, up to normalization, the $β$-invariant of the matroid. This yields a lattice-point counting formula for the $β$-invariant and establishes a new and unexpected positivity property of Ehrhart polynomials of matroid polytopes.

Motivated by the authors' work on permuto-associahedra, which can be considered as a symmetrization of the associahedron using the symmetric group, we introduce and study the $\mathfrak{G}$-symmetrization of an arbitrary polytope $P$ for any reflection group $\mathfrak{G}$. We show that the combinatorics, and moreover, the normal fan of such a symmetrization can be recovered from its refined fundamental fan, a decorated poset describing how the normal fan of $P$ subdivides the fundamental chamber associated to the reflection group $\mathfrak{G}$. One important application of our results is providing a way to approach the realization problem of a $\mathfrak{G}$-symmetric poset F, that is, the problem of constructing a polytope whose face poset is F. Instead of working with the original poset F, we look at its dual poset T (which is $\mathfrak{G}$-symmetric as well) and focus on a generating subposet Z of T, and reduce the problem to realizing Z as a refined fundamental fan.

For $\boldsymbol{a} \in \R_{\geq 0}^{n}$, the Tesler polytope $\tes_{n}(\boldsymbol{a})$ is the set of upper triangular matrices with non-negative entries whose hook sum vector is $\ba$. We first give a different proof of the known fact that for every fixed $\boldsymbol{a}_{0} \in \mathbb{R}_{>0}^{n}$, all the Tesler polytopes $\tes_{n}(\boldsymbol{a})$ are deformations of $\tes_{n}(\boldsymbol{a}_{0})$. We then calculate the deformation cone of $\tes_{n}(\boldsymbol{a}_{0})$. In the process, we also show that any deformation of $\tes_{n}(\boldsymbol{a}_{0})$ is a translation of a Tesler polytope. Lastly, we consider a larger family of polytopes called flow polytopes which contains the family of Tesler polytopes and give a characterization on which flow polytopes are deformations of $\tes_{n}(\boldsymbol{a}_{0})$.

A classic problem connecting algebraic and geometric combinatorics is the realization problem: given a poset, determine whether there exists a polytope whose face lattice is the poset. In 1990s, Kapranov defined a poset as a hybrid between the face poset of a permutohedron and that of an associahedron, and he asked whether this poset is realizable. Shortly after his question was posed, Reiner and Ziegler provided a realization. Based on our previous work on the nested braid fan, we provide in this paper a different realization of Kapranov's poset by constructing the vertex set and the normal fan of a permuto-associahedron simultaneously.

For $\ba \in \R_{\geq 0}^{n}$, the Tesler polytope $\tes_{n}(\ba)$ is the set of upper triangular matrices with non-negative entries whose hook sum vector is $\ba$. Motivated by a conjecture of Morales', we study the questions of whether the coefficients of the Ehrhart polynomial of $\tes_n(1,1,\dots,1)$ are positive. We attack this problem by studying a certain function constructed by Berline-Vergne and its values on faces of a unimodularly equivalent copy of $\tes_n(1,1,\dots,1).$ We develop a method of obtaining the dot products appeared in formulas for computing Berline-Vergne's function directly from facet normal vectors. Using this method together with known formulas, we are able to show Berline-Vergne's function has positive values on codimension $2$ and $3$ faces of the polytopes we consider. As a consequence, we prove that the $3$rd and $4$th coefficients of the Ehrhart polynomial of $\tes_{n}(1,\dots,1)$ are positive. Using the Reduction Theorem by Castillo and the second author, we generalize the above result to all deformations of $\tes_{n}(1,\dots,1)$ including all the integral Tesler polytopes.

In the special case of braid fans, we give a combinatorial formula for the Berline-Vergne's construction for an Euler-Maclaurin type formula that computes number of lattice points in polytopes. Our formula is obtained by computing a symmetric expression for the Todd class of the permutohedral variety. By showing that this formula does not always have positive values, we prove that the Todd class of the permutohedral variety $X_d$ is not effective for $d\geq 24$. Additionally, we prove that the linear coefficient in the Ehrhart polynomial of any lattice generalized permutohedron is positive.

For an $n$-dimensional lattice simplex $Δ_{(1,\mathbf{q})}$ with vertices given by the standard basis vectors and $-\mathbf{q}$ where $\mathbf{q}$ has positive entries, we investigate when the Ehrhart $h^*$-polynomial for $Δ_{(1,\mathbf{q})}$ factors as a product of geometric series in powers of $z$. Our motivation is a theorem of Rodriguez-Villegas implying that when the $h^*$-polynomial of a lattice polytope $P$ has all roots on the unit circle, then the Ehrhart polynomial of $P$ has positive coefficients. We focus on those $Δ_{(1,\mathbf{q})}$ for which $\mathbf{q}$ has only two or three distinct entries, providing both theoretical results and conjectures/questions motivated by experimental evidence.

We say a polytope is Ehrhart positive if all the coefficients in its Ehrhart polynomial are positive. Answering an Ehrhart positivity question posed on Mathoverflow, Stanley provided an example of a non-Ehrhart-positive order polytope of dimension $21$. Stanley's example comes from a certain family of order polytopes. In this paper, we study the Ehrhart positivity question on this family of polytopes. By giving explicit formulas for the coefficients of the Ehrhart polynomials of these polytopes in terms of Bernolli numbers, we determine the sign of each Ehrhart coefficient of each polytope in the family. As a consequence of our result, we conclude that for any positive integer $d \ge 21,$ there exists an order polytope of dimension $d$ that is not Ehrhart positive, and for any positive integer $\ell$, there exists an order polytope whose Ehrhart polynomial has precisely $\ell$ negative coefficients, which answers a question posed by Hibi. We finish this article by discussing the existence of lower-dimensional order polytopes whose Ehrhart polynomials have a negative coefficient.

For a given lattice polytope, two fundamental problems within the field of Ehrhart theory are to (1) determine if its (Ehrhart) $h^\ast$-polynomial is unimodal and (2) to determine if its Ehrhart polynomial has only positive coefficients. The former property of a lattice polytope is known as Ehrhart unimodality and the latter property is known as Ehrhart positivity. These two properties are often simultaneously conjectured to hold for interesting families of lattice polytopes, yet they are typically studied in parallel. As to answer a question posed at the 2017 Introductory Workshop to the MSRI Semester on Geometric and Topological Combinatorics, the purpose of this note is to show that there is no general implication between these two properties in any dimension greater than two. To do so, we investigate these two properties for families of well-studied lattice polytopes, assessing one property where previously only the other had been considered. Consequently, new examples of each phenomena are developed, some of which provide an answer to an open problem in the literature. The well-studied families of lattice polytopes considered include zonotopes, matroid polytopes, simplices of weighted projective spaces, empty lattice simplices, smooth polytopes, and $s$-lecture hall simplices.

Ehrhart discovered that the function that counts the number of lattice points in dilations of an integral polytope is a polynomial. We call the coefficients of this polynomial Ehrhart coefficients, and say a polytope is Ehrhart positive if all Ehrhart coefficients are positive (which is not true for all integral polytopes). The main purpose of this article is to survey interesting families of polytopes that are known to be Ehrhart positive and discuss the reasons from which their Ehrhart positivity follows. We also include examples of polytopes that have negative Ehrhart coefficients and polytopes that are conjectured to be Ehrhart positive, as well as pose a few relevant questions.

Generalized permutohedra are deformations of regular permutohedra, and arise in many different fields of mathematics. One important characterization of generalized permutohedra is the Submodular Theorem, which is related to the deformation cone of the Braid fan. We lay out general techniques for determining deformation cones of a fixed polytope and apply it to the Braid fan to obtain a natural combinatorial proof for the Submodular Theorem. We also consider a refinement of the Braid fan, called the nested Braid fan, and construct usual (respectively, generalized) nested permutohedra which have the nested Braid fan as (respectively, refining) their normal fan. We extend many results on generalized permutohedra to this new family of polytopes, including a one-to-one correspondence between faces of nested permutohedra and chains in ordered partition posets, and a theorem analogous to the Submodular Theorem. Finally, we show that the nested Braid fan is the barycentric subdivision of the Braid fan, which gives another way to construct this new combinatorial object.

We present examples of smooth lattice polytopes in dimensions 3 and higher where each coefficient of their Ehrhart polynomials that can potentially be negative is indeed negative. This answers a question by Bruns. We also discuss Berline-Vergne valuations as a useful tool in proving Ehrhart positivity results.

Generalizing a conjecture by De Loera et al., we conjecture that integral generalized permutohedra all have positive Ehrhart coefficients. Berline and Vergne construct a valuation that assigns values to faces of polytopes, which provides a way to write Ehrhart coefficients of a polytope as positive sums of these values. Based on available results, we pose a stronger conjecture: Berline-Vergne's valuation is always positive on permutohedra, which implies our first conjecture. This article proves that our strong conjecture on Berline-Vergne's valuation is true for dimension up to 6, and is true if we restrict to faces of codimension up to 3. In addition to investigating the positivity conjectures, we study the Berline-Vergne's valuation, and show that it is the unique construction for McMullen's formula used to describe number of lattice points in permutohedra under certain symmetry constraints. We also give an equivalent statement to the strong conjecture in terms of mixed valuations.

Ardila and Block used tropical results of Brugalle and Mikhalkin to count nodal curves on a certain family of toric surfaces. Building on a linearity result of the first author, we revisit their work in the context of the Goettsche-Yau-Zaslow formula for counting nodal curves on arbitrary smooth surfaces, addressing several questions they raised by proving stronger versions of their main theorems. In the process, we give new combinatorial formulas for the coefficients arising in the Goettsche-Yau-Zaslow formulas, and give correction terms arising from rational double points in the relevant family of toric surfaces.

Let $\mathcal{T}$ be a collection of 3-element subsets $S$ of $\{1, \ldots,n\}$ with the property that if $i<j<k$ and $a<b<c$ are two 3-element subsets in $S$, then there exists an integer sequence $x_1 < x_2 < \cdots < x_n$ such that $x_i, x_j, x_k$ and $x_a, x_b, x_c$ are arithmetic progressions. We determine the number of such collections $\mathcal{T}$ and the number of them of maximum size. These results confirm two conjectures of Noam Elkies.

Based on results by Brugallé and Mikhalkin, Fomin and Mikhalkin give formulas for computing classical Severi degrees $N^{d, δ}$ using long-edge graphs. In 2012, Block, Colley and Kennedy considered the logarithmic version of a special function associated to long-edge graphs appeared in Fomin-Mikhalkin's formula, and conjectured it to be linear. They have since proved their conjecture. At the same time, motivated by their conjecture, we consider a special multivariate function associated to long-edge graphs that generalizes their function. The main result of this paper is that the multivariate function we define is always linear. A special case of our result gives an independent proof of Block-Colley-Kennedy's conjecture. The first application of our linearity result is that by applying it to classical Severi degrees, we recover quadraticity of $Q^{d, δ}$ and a bound $δ$ for the threshold of polynomiality of $N^{d, δ}.$ Next, in joint work with Osserman, we apply the linearity result to a special family of toric surfaces and obtain universal polynomial results having connections to the Göttsche-Yau-Zaslow formula. As a result, we provide combinatorial formulas for the two unidentified power series $B_1(q)$ and $B_2(q)$ appearing in the Göttsche-Yau-Zaslow formula. The proof of our linearity result is completely combinatorial. We define $τ$-graphs which generalize long-edge graphs, and a closely related family of combinatorial objects we call $(τ, n)$-words. By introducing height functions and a concept of irreducibility, we describe ways to decompose certain families of $(τ, n)$-words into irreducible words, which leads to the desired results.

The s-lecture hall polytopes P_s are a class of integer polytopes defined by Savage and Schuster which are closely related to the lecture hall partitions of Eriksson and Bousquet-Mélou. We define a half-open parallelopiped Par_s associated with P_s and give a simple description of its integer points. We use this description to recover earlier results of Savage et al. on the δ-vector (or h^*-vector) and to obtain the connections to s-ascents and s-descents, as well as some generalizations of these results.

We describe a perturbation method that can be used to reduce the problem of finding the multivariate generating function (MGF) of a non-simple polytope to computing the MGF of simple polytopes. We then construct a perturbation that works for any transportation polytope. We apply this perturbation to the family of central transportation polytopes of order kn x n, and obtain formulas for the MGFs of the feasible cone of each vertex of the polytope and the MGF of the polytope. The formulas we obtain are enumerated by combinatorial objects. A special case of the formulas recovers the results on Birkhoff polytopes given by the author and De Loera and Yoshida. We also recover the formula for the number of maximum vertices of transportation polytopes of order kn x n.

In this paper, we study factorizations of cycles. The main result is that under certain condition, the number of ways to factor a $d$-cycle into a product of cycles of prescribed lengths is $d^{r-2}.$ To prove our result, we first define a new class of combinatorial objects, multi-noded rooted trees, which generalize rooted trees. We find the cardinality of this new class which with proper parameters is exactly $d^{r-2}.$ The main part of this paper is the proof that there is a bijection from factorizations of a $d$-cycle to multi-noded rooted trees via factorization graphs. This implies the desired formula. The factorization problem we consider has its origin in geometry, and is related to the study of a special family of Hurwitz numbers: pure-cycle Hurwitz numbers. Via the standard translation of Hurwitz numbers into group theory, our main result is equivalent to the following: when the genus is $0$ and one of the ramification indices is $d,$ the degree of the covers, the pure-cycle Hurwitz number is $d^{r-3},$ where $r$ is the number of branch points.