arXiv++ Combinatorics

When a variety $V_\varphi$ equals the image of a polynomial map $\varphi$ whose coordinate functions are combinatorial generating polynomials (i.e.~polynomials enumerating combinatorial objects), the geometry of $V_\varphi$ reflects identities satisfied by the generating polynomials. The resulting interplay between combinatorics and algebraic geometry can be used to answer questions about $V_\varphi$. A recent technique proposes to do so using a partially ordered set (poset) $P_\varphi$ defined via the coefficient vectors of the polynomials defining $\varphi$. This paper characterizes the poset $P_\varphi$ when the generating polynomials defining $\varphi$ enumerate subgraphs of a directed tree known as treks. The characterization is used to compute the linear span of $V_\varphi$, prove it is toric and deduce a basis for its vanishing ideal. It is also shown that this poset of trek polynomials for a directed tree is a so-called $π$-system if and only if the tree satisfies a property characterized via Stanley's P-partitions. As an additional consequence, it is shown that the varieties for two distinct directed trees intersect in a strictly lower-dimensional variety. This solves an instance of the structural identifiability problem in the graphical models program from statistics.

We use partially ordered sets (posets) to provide a canonical parameterization for the Zariski closure of the image of a semialgebraic set under a rational map whose coordinate functions are polynomials with nonnegative integral coefficients. The resulting poset parametrization of such a unirational variety allows us to translate several well-studied problems into combinatorics; e.g. reducing the problems to describing the poset associated to the variety. These problems include, the implicitization problem from algebraic geometry, the toric reparameterization problem, the computation of the linear span of the variety, and the problem of distinguishing two semialgebraic subsets of the same ambient space. The technique applies to instances of these problems in several fields, including algebraic geometry, algebraic combinatorics, statistics and applied algebra. We demonstrate the technique on examples from each field, including degenerate subvarieties of secant varieties, matroid flat varieties -- which generalize toric varieties of edge polytopes, as well as varieties arising in multivariate data analysis and evolutionary biology.

The cosmological polytope of a graph $G$ was recently introduced to give a geometric approach to the computation of wavefunctions for cosmological models with associated Feynman diagram $G$. Basic results in the theory of positive geometries dictate that this wavefunction may be computed as a sum of rational functions associated to the facets in a triangulation of the cosmological polytope. The normalized volume of the polytope then provides a complexity estimate for these computations. In this paper, we examine the (Ehrhart) $h^\ast$-polynomial of cosmological polytopes. We derive recursive formulas for computing the $h^\ast$-polynomial of disjoint unions and $1$-sums of graphs. The degree of the $h^\ast$-polynomial for any $G$ is computed and a characterization of palindromicity is given. Using these observations, a tight lower bound on the $h^\ast$-polynomial for any $G$ is identified and explicit formulas for the $h^\ast$-polynomials of multitrees and multicycles are derived. The results generalize the existing results on normalized volumes of cosmological polytopes. A tight upper bound and a combinatorial formula for the $h^\ast$-polynomial of any cosmological polytope are conjectured.

Colored multiset Eulerian polynomials are a common generalization of MacMahon's multiset Eulerian polynomials and the colored Eulerian polynomials, both of which are known to satisfy well-studied distributional properties including real-rootedness, log-concavity and unimodality. The symmetric colored multiset Eulerian polynomials are characterized and used to prove sufficient conditions for a colored multiset Eulerian polynomial to be self-interlacing. The latter property implies the aforementioned distributional properties as well as others, including the alternatingly increasing property and bi-$γ$-positivity. To derive these results, multivariate generalizations of an identity due to MacMahon are deduced. The results are applied to a pair of questions, both previously studied in several special cases, that are seen to admit more general answers when framed in the context of colored multiset Eulerian polynomials. The first question pertains to $s$-Eulerian polynomials, and the second to interpretations of $γ$-coefficients.

Characteristic imsets are 0/1-vectors representing directed acyclic graphs whose edges represent direct cause-effect relations between jointly distributed random variables. A characteristic imset (CIM) polytope is the convex hull of a collection of characteristic imsets. CIM polytopes arise as feasible regions of a linear programming approach to the problem of causal disovery, which aims to infer a cause-effect structure from data. Linear optimization methods typically require a hyperplane representation of the feasible region, which has proven difficult to compute for CIM polytopes despite continued efforts. We solve this problem for CIM polytopes that are the convex hull of imsets associated to DAGs whose underlying graph of adjacencies is a tree. Our methods use the theory of toric fiber products as well as the novel notion of interventional CIM polytopes. Our solution is obtained as a corollary of a more general result for interventional CIM polytopes. The identified hyperplanes are applied to yield a linear optimization-based causal discovery algorithm for learning polytree causal networks from a combination of observational and interventional data.

Several approaches to graphically representing context-specific relations among jointly distributed categorical variables have been proposed, along with structure learning algorithms. While existing optimization-based methods have limited scalability due to the large number of context-specific models, the constraint-based methods are more prone to error than even constraint-based directed acyclic graph learning algorithms since more relations must be tested. We present an algorithm for learning context-specific models that scales to hundreds of variables. Scalable learning is achieved through a combination of an order-based Markov chain Monte-Carlo search and a novel, context-specific sparsity assumption that is analogous to those typically invoked for directed acyclic graphical models. Unlike previous Markov chain Monte-Carlo search methods, our Markov chain is guaranteed to have the true posterior of the variable orderings as the stationary distribution. To implement the method, we solve a first case of an open problem recently posed by Alon and Balogh. Future work solving increasingly general instances of this problem would allow our methods to learn increasingly dense models. The method is shown to perform well on synthetic data and real world examples, in terms of both accuracy and scalability.

A cosmological polytope is defined for a given Feynman diagram, and its canonical form may be used to compute the contribution of the Feynman diagram to the wavefunction of certain cosmological models. Given a subdivision of a polytope, its canonical form is obtained as a sum of the canonical forms of the facets of the subdivision. In this paper, we identify such formulas for the canonical form via algebraic techniques. It is shown that the toric ideal of every cosmological polytope admits a Gröbner basis with a squarefree initial ideal, yielding a regular unimodular triangulation of the polytope. In specific instances, including trees and cycles, we recover graphical characterizations of the facets of such triangulations that may be used to compute the desired canonical form. For paths and cycles, these characterizations admit simple enumeration. Hence, we obtain formulas for the normalized volume of these polytopes, extending previous observations of Kühne and Monin.

We consider the problem of estimating the marginal independence structure of a Bayesian network from observational data, learning an undirected graph we call the unconditional dependence graph. We show that unconditional dependence graphs of Bayesian networks correspond to the graphs having equal independence and intersection numbers. Using this observation, a Gröbner basis for a toric ideal associated to unconditional dependence graphs of Bayesian networks is given and then extended by additional binomial relations to connect the space of all such graphs. An MCMC method, called GrUES (Gröbner-based Unconditional Equivalence Search), is implemented based on the resulting moves and applied to synthetic Gaussian data. GrUES recovers the true marginal independence structure via a penalized maximum likelihood or MAP estimate at a higher rate than simple independence tests while also yielding an estimate of the posterior, for which the $20\%$ HPD credible sets include the true structure at a high rate for data-generating graphs with density at least $0.5$.

The edges of the characteristic imset polytope, $\operatorname{CIM}_p$, were recently shown to have strong connections to causal discovery as many algorithms could be interpreted as greedy restricted edge-walks, even though only a strict subset of the edges are known. To better understand the general edge structure of the polytope we describe the edge structure of faces with a clear combinatorial interpretation: for any undirected graph $G$ we have the face $\operatorname{CIM}_G$, the convex hull of the characteristic imsets of DAGs with skeleton $G$. We give a full edge-description of $\operatorname{CIM}_G$ when $G$ is a tree, leading to interesting connections to other polytopes. In particular the well-studied stable set polytope can be recovered as a face of $\operatorname{CIM}_G$ when $G$ is a tree. Building on this connection we are also able to give a description of all edges of $\operatorname{CIM}_G$ when $G$ is a cycle, suggesting possible inroads for generalization. We then introduce an algorithm for learning directed trees from data, utilizing our newly discovered edges, that outperforms classical methods on simulated Gaussian data.

Characteristic imsets are 0-1 vectors which correspond to Markov equivalence classes of directed acyclic graphs. The study of their convex hull, named the characteristic imset polytope, has led to new and interesting geometric perspectives on the important problem of causal discovery. In this paper we begin the study of the associated toric ideal. We develop a new generalization of the toric fiber product, which we call a quasi-independence gluing, and show that under certain combinatorial homogeneity conditions, one can iteratively compute a Gröbner basis via lifting. For faces of the characteristic imset polytope associated to trees, we apply this technique to compute a Gröbner basis for the associated toric ideal. We end with a study of the characteristic ideal of the cycle and propose directions for future work.

We consider the problem of characterizing Bayesian networks up to unconditional equivalence, i.e., when directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) have the same set of unconditional $d$-separation statements. Each unconditional equivalence class (UEC) is uniquely represented with an undirected graph whose clique structure encodes the members of the class. Via this structure, we provide a transformational characterization of unconditional equivalence; i.e., we show that two DAGs are in the same UEC if and only if one can be transformed into the other via a finite sequence of specified moves. We also extend this characterization to the essential graphs representing the Markov equivalence classes (MECs) in the UEC. UECs partition the space of MECs and are easily estimable from marginal independence tests. Thus, a characterization of unconditional equivalence has applications in methods that involve searching the space of MECs of Bayesian networks.

Decomposable graphical models, also known as perfect DAG models, play a fundamental role in standard approaches to probabilistic inference via graph representations in modern machine learning and statistics. However, such models are limited by the assumption that the data-generating distribution does not entail strictly context-specific conditional independence relations. The family of staged tree models generalizes DAG models so as to accommodate context-specific knowledge. We provide a new characterization of perfect discrete DAG models in terms of their staged tree representations. This characterization identifies the family of balanced staged trees as the natural generalization of discrete decomposable models to the context-specific setting.

Reflexive lattice polytopes play a key role in combinatorics, algebraic geometry, physics, and other areas. One important class of lattice polytopes are lattice simplices defining weighted projective spaces. We investigate the question of when a reflexive weighted projective space simplex has the integer decomposition property. We provide a complete classification of reflexive weighted projective space simplices having the integer decomposition property for the case when there are at most three distinct non-unit weights, and conjecture a general classification for an arbitrary number of distinct non-unit weights. Further, for any weighted projective space simplex and $m\geq 1$, we define the $m$-th reflexive stabilization, a reflexive weighted projective space simplex. We prove that when $m$ is $2$ or greater, reflexive stabilizations do not have the integer decomposition property. We also prove that the Ehrhart $h^\ast$-polynomial of any sufficiently large reflexive stabilization is not unimodal and has only $1$ and $2$ as coefficients. We use this construction to generate interesting examples of reflexive weighted projective space simplices that are near the boundary of both $h^*$-unimodality and the integer decomposition property.

Finding a directed acyclic graph (DAG) that best encodes the conditional independence statements observable from data is a central question within causality. Algorithms that greedily transform one candidate DAG into another given a fixed set of moves have been particularly successful, for example the GES, GIES, and MMHC algorithms. In 2010, Studený, Hemmecke and Lindner introduced the characteristic imset polytope, $\operatorname{CIM}_p$, whose vertices correspond to Markov equivalence classes, as a way of transforming causal discovery into a linear optimization problem. We show that the moves of the aforementioned algorithms are included within classes of edges of $\operatorname{CIM}_p$ and that restrictions placed on the skeleton of the candidate DAGs correspond to faces of $\operatorname{CIM}_p$. Thus, we observe that GES, GIES, and MMHC all have geometric realizations as greedy edge-walks along $\operatorname{CIM}_p$. Furthermore, the identified edges of $\operatorname{CIM}_p$ strictly generalize the moves of these algorithms. Exploiting this generalization, we introduce a greedy simplex-type algorithm called \emph{greedy CIM}, and a hybrid variant, \emph{skeletal greedy CIM}, that outperforms current competitors among hybrid and constraint-based algorithms.

We address the problem of representing context-specific causal models based on both observational and experimental data collected under general (e.g. hard or soft) interventions by introducing a new family of context-specific conditional independence models called CStrees. This family is defined via a novel factorization criterion that allows for a generalization of the factorization property defining general interventional DAG models. We derive a graphical characterization of model equivalence for observational CStrees that extends the Verma and Pearl criterion for DAGs. This characterization is then extended to CStree models under general, context-specific interventions. To obtain these results, we formalize a notion of context-specific intervention that can be incorporated into concise graphical representations of CStree models. We relate CStrees to other context-specific models, showing that the families of DAGs, CStrees, labeled DAGs and staged trees form a strict chain of inclusions. We end with an application of interventional CStree models to a real data set, revealing the context-specific nature of the data dependence structure and the soft, interventional perturbations.

We investigate the algebra and geometry of general interventions in discrete DAG models. To this end, we introduce a theory for modeling soft interventions in the more general family of staged tree models and develop the formalism to study these models as parametrized subvarieties of a product of probability simplices. We then consider the problem of finding their defining equations, and we derive a combinatorial criterion for identifying interventional staged tree models for which the defining ideal is toric. We apply these results to the class of discrete interventional DAG models and establish a criteria to determine when these models are toric varieties.

In geometric, algebraic, and topological combinatorics, the unimodality of combinatorial generating polynomials is frequently studied. Unimodality follows when the polynomial is (real) stable, a property often deduced via the theory of interlacing polynomials. Many of the open questions on stability and unimodality of polynomials pertain to the enumeration of faces of cell complexes. In this paper, we relate the theory of interlacing polynomials to the shellability of cell complexes. We first derive a sufficient condition for stability of the $h$-polynomial of a subdivision of a shellable complex. To apply it, we generalize the notion of reciprocal domains for convex embeddings of polytopes to abstract polytopes and use this generalization to define the family of stable shellings of a polytopal complex. We characterize the stable shellings of cubical and simplicial complexes, and apply this theory to answer a question of Brenti and Welker on barycentric subdivisions for the well-known cubical polytopes. We also give a positive solution to a problem of Mohammadi and Welker on edgewise subdivisions of cell complexes. We end by relating the family of stable line shellings to the combinatorics of hyperplane arrangements. We pose related questions, answers to which would resolve some long-standing problems while strengthening ties between the theory of interlacing polynomials and the combinatorics of hyperplane arrangements.

In this note, we investigate some of the fundamental algebraic and geometric properties of $s$-lecture hall simplices and their generalizations. We show that all $s$-lecture hall order polytopes, which simultaneously generalize $s$-lecture hall simplices and order polytopes, satisfy a property which implies the integer decomposition property. This answers one conjecture of Hibi, Olsen and Tsuchiya. By relating $s$-lecture hall polytopes to alcoved polytopes, we then use this property to show that families of $s$-lecture hall simplices admit a quadratic Gröbner basis with a square-free initial ideal. Consequently, we find that all $s$-lecture hall simplices for which the first order difference sequence of $s$ is a $0,1$-sequence have a regular and unimodular triangulation. This answers a second conjecture of Hibi, Olsen and Tsuchiya, and it gives a partial answer to a conjecture of Beck, Braun, Köppe, Savage and Zafeirakopoulos.

The invariance properties of interventional distributions relative to the observational distribution, and how these properties allow us to refine Markov equivalence classes (MECs) of DAGs, is central to causal DAG discovery algorithms that use both interventional and observational data. Here, we show how the invariance properties of interventional DAG models, and the corresponding refinement of MECs into interventional MECs, can be generalized to mixed graphical models that allow for latent cofounders and selection variables. We first generalize interventional Markov equivalence to all formal independence models associated to loopless mixed graphs. For ancestral graphs, we prove the resulting interventional MECs admit a graphical characterization generalizing that of DAGs. We then define interventional distributions for acyclic directed mixed graph models, and prove that this generalization aligns with the graphical generalization of interventional Markov equivalence given for the formal independence models. This provides a framework for causal model discovery via observational and interventional data in the presence of latent confounders that applies even when the interventions are uncontrolled.

In algebraic, topological, and geometric combinatorics inequalities among the coefficients of combinatorial polynomials are frequently studied. Recently a notion called the alternatingly increasing property, which is stronger than unimodality, was introduced. In this paper, we relate the alternatingly increasing property to real-rootedness of the symmetric decomposition of a polynomial to develop a systematic approach for proving the alternatingly increasing property for several classes of polynomials. We apply our results to strengthen and generalize real-rootedness, unimodality, and alternatingly increasing results pertaining to colored Eulerian and derangement polynomials, Ehrhart $h^\ast$-polynomials for lattice zonotopes, $h$-polynomials of barycentric subdivisions of doubly Cohen-Macaulay level simplicial complexes, and certain local $h$-polynomials for subdivisions of simplices. In particular, we prove two conjectures of Athanasiadis.