arXiv++ Combinatorics

In 1979, Albertson and Berman conjectured that every planar graph $G$ contains an induced forest of order at least $|V(G)|/2$. This long-standing conjecture was recently disproved by several explicit counterexamples, which naturally led to several extremal and structural questions that we answer. We combine mathematical arguments and exhaustive computations to show that the minimum order of a counterexample is $29$. We also construct infinitely many $4$-connected $5$-edge-connected counterexamples (and show that the unique such counterexample of minimum order has order $41$), whereas previously all known counterexamples had vertex-connectivity at most $3$. Furthermore, we construct an infinite family of planar graphs on $n$ vertices whose maximum induced forests have order at most $\frac{25}{52}n$, thereby improving the previous best upper bound. This family also yields infinitely many counterexamples (for every integer $d \geq 7$) to a conjecture of Chappell and Pelsmajer concerning induced forests of maximum degree at most $d$.

We investigate the minimum non-zero number of perfect matchings in planar graphs. We prove that this is a constant for 2-connected planar graphs of minimum degree 3 and 3-connected planar graphs. In the former case, the constant is 4 and this is best possible. In the 3-connected case, we give several infinite families, including nearly 3-regular graphs and triangulations with a constant number of perfect matchings. In contrast, it was known that in the 4-connected case the minimum non-zero number of perfect matchings is at least linear. For 5-connected triangulations, it follows from a result of Alahmadi, Aldred, and Thomassen that there must be exponentially many perfect matchings. The families of planar graphs we investigate here are classified by connectivity. We conclude the article with an infinite family of counterexamples to a conjecture published by Zaks; these are not planar, but very much concern connectivity constraints.

For graphs $G$ and $F$, we say that $G$ is $F$-free if $F$ does not occur as an induced subgraph of $G$. This paper is concerned with the following question: Given an $F$-free graph $G$ having two vertices between which there exists at least one Hamiltonian path, how many Hamiltonian paths between these endpoints must exist (in terms of the order of $G$)? Our main result shows that there exists a sharp dichotomy. More precisely, we show that if $F$ is not an induced subgraph of $P_3+sP_1$ for any integer $s \geq 0$, then there exists an infinite family of $F$-free graphs having two vertices between which there exists a unique Hamiltonian path. On the other hand, we prove that if $F$ is an induced subgraph of $P_3+sP_1$ for some integer $s \geq 0$, then any $F$-free graph having two vertices between which there exists a Hamiltonian path contains exponentially many such paths between these two vertices. Our proofs use Ramsey-theoretic methods, a result on the existence of two vertices with low degree in graphs containing a unique Hamiltonian cycle, a path variant of Thomassen's red-independent weakly green-dominating sets, and a structural analysis of Hamiltonian paths in $P_3+sP_1$-free graphs. As an algorithmic consequence we obtain that for every fixed $s \geq 1$, given a Hamiltonian $sP_1$-free graph together with a Hamiltonian cycle, one can decide in linear time whether a second Hamiltonian cycle exists and construct one if it does.

For graphs $G, F_1$ and $F_2$, we say that $G$ is $(F_1,F_2)$-free if neither $F_1$ nor $F_2$ is an induced subgraph of $G$. We say that $G$ is $k$-vertex-critical if the chromatic number of $G$ is $k$, but every proper induced subgraph of $G$ has chromatic number at most $k-1$. The $\textit{chair}$ graph is a $5$-vertex graph obtained by adding a pendant vertex to one of the two central vertices of a path on $4$ vertices. The $\textit{cricket}$ graph is a $5$-vertex graph obtained by adding two pendant vertices to a common vertex of a triangle. The path on $5$ vertices is denoted by $P_5$. We prove that for every $k \geq 1$, there are only finitely many $(P_5,\text{chair})$-free $k$-vertex-critical graphs. We also prove that the same conclusion holds if $\text{chair}$ is replaced by $\text{cricket}$. We further characterize all $5$-vertex-critical $(P_5,\text{chair})$-free graphs, all $5$-vertex-critical $(P_5,\text{cricket})$-free graphs and all $6$-vertex-critical $(P_5,\text{cricket})$-free graphs. Our proofs rely on bounding the size of antichains and developing Ramsey-theoretic ideas. For any fixed integer $k \geq 1$, our results imply the existence of a polynomial time algorithm to decide whether a $(P_5,\text{chair})$-free (or $(P_5,\text{cricket})$-free) graph is $(k-1)$-colourable such that this algorithm can also present a negative constant-size certificate in case the graph is not $(k-1)$-colourable.

A $k$-regular graph of girth $g$ is called vertex-girth-regular if every vertex is contained in the same number of cycles of length $g$. For integers $n, k, g$ and $λ$, we denote such a graph on $n$ vertices in which every vertex lies on exactly $λ$ cycles of length $g$ by a $\text{vgr}(n,k,g,λ)$-graph. It is well-known that any vertex-girth-regular graph satisfies $λ\le \frac{k(k-1)^{\left\lfloor \frac{g}{2} \right\rfloor}}{2}$. Graphs for which $λ$ is close to this bound are of particular interest in connection with the cage problem, since requiring many girth cycles through every vertex is a natural way to isolate highly structured candidates for small regular graphs of prescribed girth. In this paper, we prove that for every $k\ge 3$ and every integer $0< \varepsilon \leq \frac{k-1}{2}$, there does not exist a $\text{vgr}(n,k,5,\frac{k(k-1)^2}{2}-\varepsilon)$-graph. Previous non-existence results had already settled all odd girths at least $7$ and very recently also girth $3$, leaving girth $5$ as the only girth for which no non-trivial non-existence result was known. Thus, our result resolves the final remaining case and completes the picture for odd girths.

A graph $G$ is $k$-vertex-critical if $χ(G)=k$, but $χ(G')<k$ for every proper induced subgraph $G'$ of $G$. For a family of graphs $\mathcal{F}$, $G$ is $\mathcal{F}$-free if no graph $F \in \mathcal{F}$ is an induced subgraph of $G$. We show that there are exactly three 4-vertex-critical $\{P_7,C_3\}$-free graphs containing an induced $C_7$, thereby settling the first of the two cases of a conjecture by Goedgebeur and Schaudt [J.~Graph Theory, 87:188--207, 2018]. Moreover, we show that all $\{P_5+P_1,C_3\}$-free graphs are $3$-colorable and by combining our result with known results from the literature, we completely characterize the maximum chromatic number of $\{F,C_3\}$-free graphs if $F$ is a six-vertex induced subgraph of $P_7$. Finally, we construct an infinite family of $4$-vertex-critical $\{4K_2,C_3\}$-free graphs. These graphs are also $\{P_{11},C_3\}$-free and this is the first value of $t$ for which an infinite family of $4$-vertex-critical $\{P_{t},C_3\}$-free graphs is known.

We consider Colouring on graphs that are $H$-subgraph-free for some fixed graph $H$, i.e., graphs that do not contain $H$ as a subgraph. It is known that even $3$-Colouring is NP-complete for $H$-subgraph-free graphs whenever $H$ has a cycle; or a vertex of degree at least $5$; or a component with two vertices of degree $4$, while Colouring is polynomial-time solvable for $H$-subgraph-free graphs if $H$ is a forest of maximum degree at most $3$, in which each component has at most one vertex of degree $3$. For connected graphs $H$, this means that it remains to consider when $H$ is tree of maximum degree $4$ with exactly one vertex of degree $4$, or a tree of maximum degree $3$ with at least two vertices of degree $3$. We let $H$ be a so-called subdivided "H"-graph, which is either a subdivided $\mathbb{H}_0$: a tree of maximum degree $4$ with exactly one vertex of degree $4$ and no vertices of degree $3$, or a subdivided $\mathbb{H}_1$: a tree of maximum degree $3$ with exactly two vertices of degree $3$. In the literature, only a limited number of polynomial-time and NP-completeness results for these cases are known. We develop new polynomial-time techniques that allow us to determine the complexity of Colouring on $H$-subgraph-free graphs for all the remaining subdivided "H"-graphs, so we fully classify both cases. As a consequence, the complexity of Colouring on $H$-subgraph-free graphs has now been settled for all connected graphs $H$ except when $H$ is a tree of maximum degree $4$ with exactly one vertex of degree $4$ and at least one vertex of degree $3$; or a tree of maximum degree $3$ with at least three vertices of degree $3$. We also employ our new techniques to obtain the same new polynomial-time results for another classic graph problem, namely Stable Cut.

For integers $k,g,d$, a $(k;g,d)$-cage (or simply girth-diameter cage) is a smallest $k$-regular graph of girth $g$ and diameter $d$ (if it exists). The order of a $(k;g,d)$-cage is denoted by $n(k;g,d)$. We determine asymptotic lower and upper bounds for the ratio between the order and the diameter of girth-diameter cages as the diameter goes to infinity. We also prove that this ratio can be computed in constant time for fixed $k$ and $g$. We theoretically determine the exact values $n(3;g,d)$, and count the number of corresponding girth-diameter cages, for $g \in \{4,5\}$. Moreover, we design and implement an exhaustive graph generation algorithm and use it to determine the exact order of several open cases and obtain -- often exhaustive -- sets of the corresponding girth-diameter cages. The largest case we generated and settled with our algorithm is a $(3;7,35)$-cage of order 136.

The cage problem concerns finding $(k,g)$-graphs, which are $k$-regular graphs with girth $g$, of the smallest possible number of vertices. The central goal is to determine $n(k,g)$, the minimum order of such a graph, and to identify corresponding extremal graphs. In this paper, we study the cage problem and several of its variants from a computational perspective. Four complementary graph generation algorithms are developed based on exhaustive generation of lifts, a tabu search heuristic, a hill climbing heuristic and excision techniques. Using these methods, we establish new upper bounds for eleven cases of the classical cage problem: $n(3,16) \leq 936$, $n(3,17) \leq 2048$, $n(4,9) \leq 270$, $n(4,10) \leq 320$, $n(4,11) \leq 713$, $n(5,9) \leq 1116$, $n(6,11) \leq 7783$, $n(8,7) \leq 774$, $n(10,7) \leq 1608$, $n(12,7) \leq 2890$ and $n(14,7) \leq 4716$. Notably, our results improve upon several of the best-known bounds, some of which have stood unchanged for 22 years. Moreover, the improvement for $n(4,10)$, from the longstanding upper bound of 384 down to 320, is surprising and constitutes a substantial improvement. While the main focus is on the cage problem, we also adapted our algorithms for variants of the cage problem that received attention in the literature. For these variants, additional improvements are obtained, further narrowing the gaps between known lower and upper bounds.

It has been conjectured that the minimum and maximum of the mean subtree order among connected graphs of order $n$ are attained by the path $P_n$ and clique $K_n$, respectively. Extending ideas due to Haslegrave and Vince, we confirm that the minimum is indeed attained by $P_n$. On the other hand, we discuss different approaches (both promising and flawed) that could lead to a proof of the extremality of $K_n$.

Computers and algorithms play an ever-increasing role in obtaining new results in graph theory. In this survey, we present a broad range of techniques used in computer-assisted graph theory, including the exhaustive generation of all pairwise non-isomorphic graphs within a given class, the use of searchable databases containing graphs and invariants as well as other established and emerging algorithmic paradigms. We cover approaches based on mixed integer linear programming, semidefinite programming, dynamic programming, SAT solving, metaheuristics and machine learning. The techniques are illustrated with numerous detailed results covering several important subareas of graph theory such as extremal graph theory, graph coloring, structural graph theory, spectral graph theory, regular graphs, topological graph theory, special sets in graphs, algebraic graph theory and chemical graph theory. We also present some smaller new results that demonstrate how readily a computer-assisted graph theory approach can be applied once the appropriate tools have been developed.

We present a new algorithm for improving lower bounds on $ex(n;\{C_3,C_4\})$, the maximum size (number of edges) of an $n$-vertex graph of girth at least 5. The core of our algorithm is a variant of a hill-climbing heuristic introduced by Exoo, McKay, Myrvold and Nadon (2011) to find small cages. Our algorithm considers a range of values of $n$ in multiple passes. In each pass, the hill-climbing heuristic for a specific value of $n$ is initialized with a few graphs obtained by modifying near-extremal graphs previously found for neighboring values of $n$, allowing to `propagate' good patterns that were found. Focusing on the range $n\in \{74,75, \dots, 198\}$, which is currently beyond the scope of exact methods, our approach yields improvements on existing lower bounds for $ex(n;\{C_3,C_4\})$ for all $n$ in the range, except for two values of $n$ ($n=96,97$).

A theorem due to Seyffarth states that every planar $4$-connected $n$-vertex graph has a cycle double cover (CDC) containing at most $n-1$ cycles (a "small" CDC). We extend this theorem by proving that, in fact, such a graph must contain linearly many small CDCs (in terms of $n$), and provide stronger results in the case of planar $4$-connected triangulations. We complement this result with constructions of planar $4$-connected graphs which contain at most polynomially many small CDCs. Thereafter we treat cubic graphs, strengthening a lemma of Hušek and Šámal on the enumeration of CDCs, and, motivated by a conjecture of Bondy, give an alternative proof of the result that every planar 2-connected cubic graph on $n > 4$ vertices has a CDC of size at most $n/2$. Our proof is much shorter and obtained by combining a decomposition based argument, which might be of independent interest, with further combinatorial insights. Some of our results are accompanied by a version thereof for CDCs containing no cycle twice.

In 1976 Faudree and Schelp conjectured that in a hamiltonian-connected graph on $n$ vertices, any two distinct vertices are connected by a path of length $k$ for every $k \ge n/2$. In 1978 Thomassen constructed a (non-cubic and non-planar) family of counterexamples, showing that there exist hamiltonian-connected $n$-vertex graphs containing two vertices with no path of length $n-2$ between them. We complement this result by describing cubic planar counterexamples on $6p+16$ vertices, each containing vertices between which there is no path of any odd length greater than $1$ and at most $4p+9$. Motivated by a remark of Thomassen about a gap in the cycle spectrum of hamiltonian-connected graphs, we also describe an infinite family of hamiltonian-connected graphs with many gaps in the first half of their cycle spectra.

In this paper, we are interested in $4$-colouring algorithms for graphs that do not contain an induced path on $6$ vertices nor an induced bull, i.e., the graph with vertex set $\{v_1,v_2,v_3,v_4,v_5\}$ and edge set $\{v_1v_2,v_2v_3,v_3v_4,v_2v_5,v_3v_5\}$. Such graphs are referred to as $(P_6,\text{bull})$-free graphs. A graph $G$ is \emph{$k$-vertex-critical} if $χ(G)=k$, and every proper induced subgraph $H$ of $G$ has $χ(H)<k$. In the current paper, we investigate the structure of $5$-vertex-critical $(P_6,\text{bull})$-free graphs and show that there are only finitely many such graphs, thereby answering a question of Maffray and Pastor. A direct corollary of this is that there exists a polynomial-time algorithm to decide if a $(P_6,\text{bull})$-free graph is $4$-colourable such that this algorithm can also provide a certificate that can be verified in polynomial time and serves as a proof of 4-colourability or non-4-colourability.

A graph is pseudo 2-factor isomorphic if all of its 2-factors have the same parity of number of cycles. Abreu et al. [J. Comb. Theory, Ser. B. 98 (2008) 432--442] conjectured that $K_{3,3}$, the Heawood graph and the Pappus graph are the only essentially 4-edge-connected pseudo 2-factor isomorphic cubic bipartite graphs. This conjecture was disproved by Goedgebeur [Discr. Appl. Math. 193 (2015) 57--60] who constructed a counterexample $\mathcal{G}$ (of girth 6) on 30 vertices. Using a computer search, he also showed that this is the only counterexample up to at least 40 vertices and that there are no counterexamples of girth greater than 6 up to at least 48 vertices. In this manuscript, we show that the Gray graph -- which has 54 vertices and girth 8 -- is also a counterexample to the pseudo 2-factor isomorphic graph conjecture. Next to the graph $\mathcal{G}$, this is the only other known counterexample. Using a computer search, we show that there are no smaller counterexamples of girth 8 and show that there are no other counterexamples up to at least 42 vertices of any girth. Moreover, we also verified that there are no further counterexamples among the known censuses of symmetrical graphs. Recall that a graph is 2-factor Hamiltonian if all of its 2-factors are Hamiltonian cycles. As a by-product of the computer searches performed for this paper, we have verified that the $2$-factor Hamiltonian conjecture of Funk et al. [J. Comb. Theory, Ser. B. 87(1) (2003) 138--144], which is still open, holds for cubic bipartite graphs of girth at least 8 up to 52 vertices, and up to 42 vertices for any girth.

We consider the Erdős, Pach, Pollack and Tuza problem, asking for the maximum diameter of a graph with given order $n$, minimum degree $δ$ and clique number at most $ω$. We solve their problem asymptotically for the first hard case, $ω\leq 3$, for the smallest values of $δ$ by determining the smallest rational number $f(δ)$ such that $diam(G) \leq f(δ)n+O(1)$ for all graphs $G$ with order $n$, minimum degree $δ$ and clique number $ω\leq 3$. We also consider the weaker version where the clique number $ω\leq 3$ is replaced by having chromatic number $χ\leq 3$ and solve this version for small $δ$, thereby yielding a counterexample to a conjecture of Erdős et al. in a regime where this conjecture was still open. When restricting the conjecture to graphs with chromatic number $χ\leq 3$, we show that this counterexample appears for the smallest possible $δ$, namely $δ=16.$

A graph $G$ is $k$-vertex-critical if $χ(G) = k$ but $χ(G-v)<k$ for all $v \in V(G)$. A graph is $(H_1,H_2)$-free if it contains no induced subgraph isomorphic to $H_1$ nor $H_2$. A $W_4$ is the graph consisting of a $C_4$ plus an additional vertex adjacent to all the vertices of the $C_4$. We show that there are finitely many $k$-vertex-critical $(P_5,W_4)$-free graphs for all $k \ge 1$ and we characterize all $5$-vertex-critical $(P_5,W_4)$-free graphs. Our results imply the existence of a polynomial-time certifying algorithm to decide the $k$-colorability of $(P_5,W_4)$-free graphs for each $k \ge 1$ where the certificate is either a $k$-coloring or a $(k+1)$-vertex-critical induced subgraph.

A $(k,g,\underline{g+1})$-graph is a $k$-regular graph of girth $g$ which does not contain cycles of length $g+1$. Such graphs are known to exist for all parameter pairs $k \geq 3, g \geq 3 $, and we focus on determining the orders $n(k,g,\underline{g+1})$ of the smallest $(k,g,\underline{g+1})$-graphs. This problem can be viewed as a special case of the previously studied Girth Pair Problem, the problem of finding the order of a smallest $k$-regular graph in which the length of a smallest even length cycle and the length of a smallest odd length cycle are prescribed. When considering the case of an odd girth $g$, this problem also yields results towards the Cage Problem, the problem of finding the order of a smallest $k$-regular graph of girth $g$. We establish the monotonicity of the function $n(k,g,\underline{g+1})$ with respect to increasing $g$, and present universal lower bounds for the values $n(k,g,\underline{g+1})$. We propose an algorithm for generating all $(k,g,\underline{g+1})$-graphs on $n$ vertices, use this algorithm to determine several of the smaller values $n(k,g,\underline{g+1})$, and discuss various approaches to finding smallest $(k,g,\underline{g+1})$-graphs within several classes of highly symmetrical graphs.

An $(\{r,m\};g)$-graph is a (simple, undirected) graph of girth $g\geq3$ with vertices of degrees $r$ and $m$ where $2 \leq r < m$ . Given $r,m,g$, we seek the $(\{r,m\};g)$-graphs of minimum order, called $(\{r,m\};g)$-cages or bi-regular cages, whose order is denoted by $n(\{r,m\};g)$. In this paper, we use computational methods for finding $(\{r,m\};g)$-graphs of small order. Firstly, we present an exhaustive generation algorithm, which leads to $\unicode{x2013}$ previously unknown $\unicode{x2013}$ exhaustive lists of $(\{r,m\};g)$-cages for 24 different triples $(r,m,g)$. This also leads to the improvement of the lower bound of $n(\{4,5\};7)$ from 66 to 69. Secondly, we improve 49 upper bounds of $n(\{r,m\};g)$ based on constructions that start from $r$-regular graphs. Lastly, we generalize a theorem by Aguilar, Araujo-Pardo and Berman [arXiv:2305.03290, 2023], leading to 73 additional improved upper bounds.