arXiv++ Combinatorics

In 1979, Albertson and Berman conjectured that every planar graph $G$ contains an induced forest of order at least $|V(G)|/2$. This long-standing conjecture was recently disproved by several explicit counterexamples, which naturally led to several extremal and structural questions that we answer. We combine mathematical arguments and exhaustive computations to show that the minimum order of a counterexample is $29$. We also construct infinitely many $4$-connected $5$-edge-connected counterexamples (and show that the unique such counterexample of minimum order has order $41$), whereas previously all known counterexamples had vertex-connectivity at most $3$. Furthermore, we construct an infinite family of planar graphs on $n$ vertices whose maximum induced forests have order at most $\frac{25}{52}n$, thereby improving the previous best upper bound. This family also yields infinitely many counterexamples (for every integer $d \geq 7$) to a conjecture of Chappell and Pelsmajer concerning induced forests of maximum degree at most $d$.

For positive integers $d$ and $k$, let $n_k(d)$ be the maximum order of a graph of maximum degree at most $d$ and diameter at most $k$. We prove that $$ \lim_{d\to\infty}\frac{n_k(d)}{d^k}=1$$ for every fixed $k$, thereby resolving the asymptotic degree-diameter problem for fixed diameter and proving a conjecture of Bollobás. The lower bound comes from regular graphs $H_{k,q}$, indexed by prime powers $q$, whose vertices are partial flags in $\mathbb{F}_q^{\,2k+1}$. These graphs have diameter $k$ and order $|V(H_{k,q})| =(1+o(1))Δ(H_{k,q})^k$. We also construct, for every fixed $\ell \ge 2$, graphs of maximum degree at most $d$ and line-graph diameter at most $\ell$ with $(1+o(1))d^{\ell}$ edges.

The domination number $γ(G)$ of a graph $G$ is the smallest possible size of a vertex set that intersects every radius-$1$ ball of $G$, and the packing number $ρ(G)$ is the maximum number of pairwise vertex-disjoint radius-$1$ balls. We prove that $\frac{γ(G)}{ρ(G)}\le 5$ for every planar graph and $\frac{γ(G)}{ρ(G)} \le \frac{18\sqrt3}π\approx 9.924$ for every unit disk graph, thus yielding Erdős-Pósa-type bounds for the hypergraph of radius-$1$ balls in the two graph classes. This improves upon results of Gutiérrez and Paul, and Dúcz and Gujgiczer, who in turn lowered bounds of Bonamy, Csikós, Gujgiczer and Yuditsky, and Böhme and Mohar. For both graph classes, the best known lower bound on the optimal constant remains $3$.

Thomassen famously proved that every planar graph is 5-choosable. We explore variants of this result, focusing on finding disjoint correspondence colorings, in the more general class of $K_5$-minor-free graphs. Correspondence colorings generalize list colorings as follows. Given a graph $G$ and a positive integer $t$, a correspondence $t$-cover $\textbf{M}$ assigns to each $v\in V(G)$ a set of allowable colors $\{1_v,\ldots,t_v\}$ and to each edge $vw\in E(G)$ a matching between $\{1_v,\ldots,t_v\}$ and $\{1_w,\ldots,t_w\}$. An $\textbf{M}$-coloring $\varphi$ picks for each vertex $v$ a color $\varphi(v)$ (from the set $\{1_v,\ldots,t_v\}$) such that for each edge $vw\in E(G)$ the colors $\varphi(v),\varphi(w)$ are not matched to each other. Two $\textbf{M}$-colorings $\varphi_1,\varphi_2$ of $G$ are called disjoint if $\varphi_1(v)\ne\varphi_2(v)$ for all $v\in V(G)$. For every $K_5$-minor-free graph $G$ and every correspondence 6-cover $\textbf{M}$ of $G$, we construct 3 pairwise disjoint $\textbf{M}$-colorings $\varphi_1,\varphi_2,\varphi_3$. In contrast, we provide examples of $K_5$-minor-free graphs and correspondence 5-covers $\textbf{M}$ that do not admit 3 disjoint $\textbf{M}$-colorings.

The chromatic number of the finite projective space $\mathrm{PG}(n-1,q)$, denoted $χ_q(n)$, is the minimum number of colors needed to color its points so that no line is monochromatic. We establish a recursive upper bound $χ_q(n) \leq χ_q(d) + χ_q(n - d)$ for all $1 \leq d < n$ and use it to prove new upper bounds on $χ_q(n)$ for all $q$. For $q = 2$, we further refine this recursion and prove that \[ χ_2(n) \le \lfloor 2n/3 \rfloor + 1 \] for all $n \ge 2$, and that this bound is tight for all $n \le 7$. In particular, this recovers all previously known cases for $n \le 6$ and resolves the first open case $n = 7$. On the lower-bound side, using a connection with multicolor Ramsey numbers for triangles, we note that \[ χ_2(n) \ge (1 - o(1))\,\frac{n}{\log n}. \] We also consider $χ_q(t;n)$, the minimum number of colors needed to color the points of $\mathrm{PG}(n-1,q)$ with no monochromatic $(t - 1)$-dimensional subspace, and establish an equivalence between $χ_q(t;n)$ and the multicolor vector-space Ramsey numbers $R_q(t;k)$. Using this equivalence together with our upper bounds on $χ_q(t;n)$, we improve, for every fixed $t$, the best known lower bounds on $R_q(t;k)$ from $Ω_q(\log k)$ to $Ω(k)$.

We show that the $k$-colour Ramsey number of an odd cycle of length $2 \ell + 1$ is at most $(4 \ell)^k \cdot k^{k/\ell}$. This proves a conjecture of Fox and is the first improvement in the exponent that goes beyond an absolute constant factor since the work of Bondy and Erdős from 1973.

Given a proper (list) colouring of a graph $G$, a recolouring step changes the colour at a single vertex to another colour (in its list) that is currently unused on its neighbours, hence maintaining a proper colouring. Suppose that each vertex $v$ has its own private list $L(v)$ of allowed colours such that $|L(v)|\ge \mbox{deg}(v)+1$. We prove that if $G$ is connected and its maximum degree $Δ$ is at least $3$, then for any two proper $L$-colourings in which at least one vertex can be recoloured, one can be transformed to the other by a sequence of $O(|V(G)|^2)$ recolouring steps. We also show that reducing the list-size of a single vertex $w$ to $\mbox{deg}(w)$ can lead to situations where the space of proper $L$-colourings is `shattered'. Our results can be interpreted as showing a sharp phase transition in the Glauber dynamics of proper $L$-colourings of graphs. This constitutes a `local' strengthening and generalisation of a result of Feghali, Johnson, and Paulusma, which considered the situation where the lists are all identical to $\{1,\ldots,Δ+1\}$.

A graph class $\mathcal{C}$ has polynomial expansion if there is a polynomial function $f$ such that for every graph $G\in \mathcal{C}$, each of the depth-$r$ minors of $G$ has average degree at most $f(r)$. In this note, we study bounded-radius variants of some classical graph parameters such as bramble number, linkedness and well-linkedness, and we show that they are pairwise polynomially related. Furthermore, in a monotone graph class with polynomial expansion they are all uniformly bounded by a polynomial in $r$.

A recolouring sequence, between $k$-colourings $α$ and $β$ of a graph $G$, transforms $α$ into $β$ by recolouring one vertex at a time, such that after each recolouring step we again have a proper $k$-colouring of $G$. The diameter of the $k$-recolouring graph, $\textrm{diam}~\mathcal{C}_k(G)$, is the maximum over all pairs $α$ and $β$ of the minimum length of a recolouring sequence from $α$ to $β$. Much previous work has focused on determining the asymptotics of $\textrm{diam}~\mathcal{C}_k(G)$: Is it $Θ(|G|)$? Is it $Θ(|G|^2)$? Or even larger? Here we focus on graphs for which $\textrm{diam}~\mathcal{C}_k(G)=Θ(|G|)$, and seek to determine more precisely the multiplicative constant implicit in the $Θ()$. In particular, for each $k\ge 3$, for all positive integers $p$ and $q$ we exactly determine $\textrm{diam}~\mathcal{C}_k(K_{p,q})$, up to a small additive constant. We also sharpen a recolouring lemma that has been used in multiple papers, proving an optimal version. This improves the multiplicative constant in various prior results. Finally, we investigate plausible relationships between similar reconfiguration graphs.

The fractional list packing number $χ_{\ell}^{\bullet}(G)$ of a graph $G$ is a graph invariant that has recently arisen from the study of disjoint list-colourings. It measures how large the lists of a list-assignment $L:V(G)\rightarrow 2^{\mathbb{N}}$ need to be to ensure the existence of a `perfectly balanced' probability distribution on proper $L$-colourings, i.e., such that at every vertex $v$, every colour appears with equal probability $1/|L(v)|$. In this work we give various bounds on $χ_{\ell}^{\bullet}(G)$, which admit strengthenings for correspondence and local-degree versions. As a corollary, we improve theorems on the related notion of flexible list colouring. In particular we study Cartesian products and $d$-degenerate graphs, and we prove that $χ_{\ell}^{\bullet}(G)$ is bounded from above by the pathwidth of $G$ plus one. The correspondence analogue of the latter is false for treewidth instead of pathwidth.

One of Thomassen's classical results is that every planar graph of girth at least $5$ is 3-choosable. One can wonder if for a planar graph $G$ of girth sufficiently large and a $3$-list-assignment $L$, one can do even better. Can one find $3$ disjoint $L$-colorings (a packing), or $2$ disjoint $L$-colorings, or a collection of $L$-colorings that to every vertex assigns every color on average in one third of the cases (a fractional packing)? We prove that the packing is impossible, but two disjoint $L$-colorings are guaranteed if the girth is at least $8$, and a fractional packing exists when the girth is at least $6.$ For a graph $G$, the least $k$ such that there are always $k$ disjoint proper list-colorings whenever we have lists all of size $k$ associated to the vertices is called the list packing number of $G$. We lower the two-times-degeneracy upper bound for the list packing number of planar graphs of girth $3,4$ or $5$. As immediate corollaries, we improve bounds for $ε$-flexibility of classes of planar graphs with a given girth. For instance, where previously Dvořák et al. proved that planar graphs of girth $6$ are (weighted) $ε$-flexibly $3$-choosable for an extremely small value of $ε$, we obtain the optimal value $ε=\frac{1}{3}$. Finally, we completely determine and show interesting behavior on the packing numbers for $H$-minor-free graphs for some small graphs $H.$

We investigate the list packing number of a graph, the least $k$ such that there are always $k$ disjoint proper list-colourings whenever we have lists all of size $k$ associated to the vertices. We are curious how the behaviour of the list packing number contrasts with that of the list chromatic number, particularly in the context of bounded degree graphs. The main question we pursue is whether every graph with maximum degree $Δ$ has list packing number at most $Δ+1$. Our results highlight the subtleties of list packing and the barriers to, for example, pursuing a Brooks'-type theorem for the list packing number.

The reconfiguration graph $\mathcal{C}_k(G)$ for the $k$-colourings of a graph $G$ has a vertex for each proper $k$-colouring of $G$, and two vertices of $\mathcal{C}_k(G)$ are adjacent precisely when those $k$-colourings differ on a single vertex of $G$. Much work has focused on bounding the maximum value of ${\rm{diam}}~\mathcal{C}_k(G)$ over all $n$-vertex graphs $G$. We consider the analogous problems for list colourings and for correspondence colourings. We conjecture that if $L$ is a list-assignment for a graph $G$ with $|L(v)|\ge d(v)+2$ for all $v\in V(G)$, then ${\rm{diam}}~\mathcal{C}_L(G)\le n(G)+μ(G)$. We also conjecture that if $(L,H)$ is a correspondence cover for a graph $G$ with $|L(v)|\ge d(v)+2$ for all $v\in V(G)$, then ${\rm{diam}}~\mathcal{C}_{(L,H)}(G)\le n(G)+τ(G)$. (Here $μ(G)$ and $τ(G)$ denote the matching number and vertex cover number of $G$.) For every graph $G$, we give constructions showing that both conjectures are best possible. Our first main result proves the upper bounds (for the list and correspondence versions, respectively) ${\rm{diam}}~\mathcal{C}_L(G)\le n(G)+2μ(G)$ and ${\rm{diam}}~\mathcal{C}_{(L,H)}(G)\le n(G)+2τ(G)$. Our second main result proves that both conjectured bounds hold, whenever all $v$ satisfy $|L(v)|\ge 2d(v)+1$. We conclude by proving one or both conjectures for various classes of graphs such as complete bipartite graphs, subcubic graphs, cactuses, and graphs with bounded maximum average degree.

List colouring is an influential and classic topic in graph theory. We initiate the study of a natural strengthening of this problem, where instead of one list-colouring, we seek many in parallel. Our explorations have uncovered a potentially rich seam of interesting problems spanning chromatic graph theory. Given a $k$-list-assignment $L$ of a graph $G$, which is the assignment of a list $L(v)$ of $k$ colours to each vertex $v\in V(G)$, we study the existence of $k$ pairwise-disjoint proper colourings of $G$ using colours from these lists. We may refer to this as a \emph{list-packing}. Using a mix of combinatorial and probabilistic methods, we set out some basic upper bounds on the smallest $k$ for which such a list-packing is always guaranteed, in terms of the number of vertices, the degeneracy, the maximum degree, or the (list) chromatic number of $G$. (The reader might already find it interesting that such a minimal $k$ is well defined.) We also pursue a more focused study of the case when $G$ is a bipartite graph. Our results do not yet rule out the tantalising prospect that the minimal $k$ above is not too much larger than the list chromatic number. Our study has taken inspiration from study of the strong chromatic number, and we also explore generalisations of the problem above in the same spirit.

We wish to bring attention to a natural but slightly hidden problem, posed by Erdős and Nešetřil in the late 1980s, an edge version of the degree--diameter problem. Our main result is that, for any graph of maximum degree $Δ$ with more than $1.5 Δ^t$ edges, its line graph must have diameter larger than $t$. In the case where the graph contains no cycle of length $2t+1$, we can improve the bound on the number of edges to one that is exact for $t\in\{1,2,3,4,6\}$. In the case $Δ=3$ and $t=3$, we obtain an exact bound. Our results also have implications for the related problem of bounding the distance-$t$ chromatic index, $t>2$; in particular, for this we obtain an upper bound of $1.941Δ^t$ for graphs of large enough maximum degree $Δ$, markedly improving upon earlier bounds for this parameter.

We prove that every connected cubic graph with $n$ vertices has a maximal matching of size at most $\frac{5}{12} n+ \frac{1}{2}$. This confirms the cubic case of a conjecture of Baste, Fürst, Henning, Mohr and Rautenbach (2019) on regular graphs. More generally, we prove that every graph with $n$ vertices and $m$ edges and maximum degree at most $3$ has a maximal matching of size at most $\frac{4n-m}{6}+ \frac{1}{2}$. These bounds are attained by the graph $K_{3,3}$, but asymptotically there may still be some room for improvement. Moreover, the claimed maximal matchings can be found efficiently. As a corollary, we have a $\left(\frac{25}{18} + O \left( \frac{1}{n}\right)\right) $-approximation algorithm for minimum maximal matching in connected cubic graphs.

We prove that for every integer $t\ge 1$ there exists a constant $c_t$ such that for every $K_t$-minor-free graph $G$, and every set $S$ of balls in $G$, the minimum size of a set of vertices of $G$ intersecting all the balls of $S$ is at most $c_t$ times the maximum number of vertex-disjoint balls in $S$. This was conjectured by Chepoi, Estellon, and Vaxès in 2007 in the special case of planar graphs and of balls having the same radius.

Motivated by a recent conjecture of the first author, we prove that every properly coloured triangle-free graph of chromatic number $χ$ contains a rainbow independent set of size $\lceil\frac12χ\rceil$. This is sharp up to a factor $2$. This result and its short proof have implications for the related notion of chromatic discrepancy. Drawing inspiration from both structural and extremal graph theory, we conjecture that every triangle-free graph of chromatic number $χ$ contains an induced cycle of length $Ω(χ\logχ)$ as $χ\to\infty$. Even if one only demands an induced path of length $Ω(χ\logχ)$, the conclusion would be sharp up to a constant multiple. We prove it for regular girth $5$ graphs and for girth $21$ graphs. As a common strengthening of the induced paths form of this conjecture and of Johansson's theorem (1996), we posit the existence of some $c >0$ such that for every forest $H$ on $D$ vertices, every triangle-free and induced $H$-free graph has chromatic number at most $c D/\log D$. We prove this assertion with `triangle-free' replaced by `regular girth $5$'.

A classic theorem of Erdős and Pósa (1965) states that every graph has either $k$ vertex-disjoint cycles or a set of $O(k \log k)$ vertices meeting all its cycles. While the standard proof revolves around finding a large `frame' in the graph (a subdivision of a large cubic graph), an alternative way of proving this theorem is to use a ball packing argument of Kühn and Osthus (2003) and Diestel and Rempel (2005). In this paper, we argue that the latter approach is particularly well suited for studying edge variants of the Erdős-Pósa theorem. As an illustration, we give a short proof of a theorem of Bruhn, Heinlein, and Joos (2019), that cycles of length at least $\ell$ have the so-called edge-Erdős-Pósa property. More precisely, we show that every graph $G$ either contains $k$ edge-disjoint cycles of length at least $\ell$ or an edge set $F$ of size $O(k\ell \cdot \log (k\ell))$ such that $G-F$ has no cycle of length at least $\ell$. For fixed $\ell$, this improves on the previously best known bound of $O(k^2 \log k +k\ell)$.

Every $n$-vertex planar triangle-free graph with maximum degree at most $3$ has an independent set of size at least $\frac{3}{8}n$. This was first conjectured by Albertson, Bollobás and Tucker, and was later proved by Heckman and Thomas. Fraughnaugh and Locke conjectured that the planarity requirement could be relaxed into just forbidding a few specific nonplanar subgraphs: They described a family $\mathcal{F}$ of six nonplanar graphs (each of order at most $22$) and conjectured that every $n$-vertex triangle-free graph with maximum degree at most $3$ having no subgraph isomorphic to a member of $\mathcal{F}$ has an independent set of size at least $\frac{3}{8}n$. In this paper, we prove this conjecture. As a corollary, we obtain that every $2$-connected $n$-vertex triangle-free graph with maximum degree at most $3$ has an independent set of size at least $\frac{3}{8}n$, with the exception of the six graphs in $\mathcal{F}$. This confirms a conjecture made independently by Bajnok and Brinkmann, and by Fraughnaugh and Locke.