arXiv++ Combinatorics

The strong chromatic index $χ'_s(G)$ is the smallest number of colours needed to colour the edges of a graph $G$ so that any two edges at distance at most $2$ receive different colours. Using the \emph{local flag algebra} framework introduced in a companion paper, we prove $χ'_s(G) \leq 1.73\,Δ(G)^2$ for every graph $G$ of maximum degree $Δ(G)$, $χ'_s(G) \leq 1.6255\,Δ(G)^2$ for every bipartite $G$, and $χ'_s(G) \leq 1.6633\,Δ_A(G)\,Δ_B(G)$ for every bipartite $G$ of side maximum degrees $Δ_A(G), Δ_B(G)$ with rational $Δ_B(G)/Δ_A(G) \in (0, 1]$, provided $Δ(G)$, $Δ_A(G)$, $Δ_B(G)$ are sufficiently large. These three bounds make progress towards three established conjectures: those of Erdős-Nešetřil (1985) for general graphs, Faudree-Gyárfás-Schelp-Tuza (1989) for bipartite graphs, and Brualdi-Quinn Massey (1993) in the asymmetric bipartite setting. Additionally, for the random bipartite graph $G \sim G(n_A, n_B, p)$ at constant $p \in (0,1)$ and bounded aspect ratio $\max(n_A, n_B) = O(\min(n_A, n_B))$, we prove the Brualdi-Quinn Massey bound $χ'_s(G) \leq Δ_A(G)\,Δ_B(G)$ asymptotically almost surely.

We introduce local flag algebras, a variant of Razborov's flag algebra framework in which densities are normalised by the maximum degree $Δ(G)$ rather than the order $|G|$. The framework supports the same semidefinite-method machinery as the classical version, but is tailored to extremal problems that scale with the maximum degree. As an illustrative first application we bound the number of pentagons in a triangle-free graph $G$ as a function of $|G|$ and $Δ(G)$.

Let $G$ be a graph on an even number $n$ of vertices and let ${\cal M}_G$ be the collection of perfect matchings in $G$. Dirac's theorem says that if the minimum degree $δ(G)$ of $G$ is at least $n/2$, then ${\cal M}_G$ is guaranteed to be non-empty, while this is not necessarily the case if $δ(G) \le n/2-1$. Given an integer $k\ge 2$, let $\mathcal H_k(G)$ be the reconfiguration graph formed on ${\cal M}_G$ by connecting two distinct $M_1,M_2\in {\cal M}_G$ by an edge in $\mathcal H_k(G)$ if $M_1$ can be obtained from $M_2$ by switching at most $k$ edges. Besides non-emptiness, as per Dirac's theorem, what other natural properties of $\mathcal H_k(G)$ are guaranteed based on the minimum degree $δ(G)$ of $G$? We show that if $δ(G) \ge \lfloor2n/3\rfloor+1$, then $\mathcal H_2(G)$ must be connected and an expander, while for each $δ\le \lfloor(2n-2)/3\rfloor$ there are $n$-vertex graphs $G$ with minimum degree $δ$ such that $\mathcal H_2(G)$ is disconnected. We also show that, if $δ(G) \ge n/2+2$, then $\mathcal H_3(G)$ must be connected and an expander, while for each $δ\le n/2-C_k$ there are $n$-vertex graphs $G$ with minimum degree $δ$ such that $\mathcal H_k(G)$ is disconnected, for some $C_k$ depending on $k\ge 3$. Furthermore, for every $\varepsilon >0$, there exists a $c>1$ such that for every $k\ge 2$ and every large enough $n$, there are $n$-vertex graphs $G$ with $δ(G) \ge \frac{n}2-\varepsilon kn$ such that $\mathcal H_k(G)$ has at least $c^n$ components. With respect to guaranteeing that $\mathcal H_k(G)$ has positive minimum degree (or, equivalently, no isolated vertices) we show that if $δ(G) \ge n/2+1$, then $\mathcal H_2(G)$ must have positive minimum degree. For $k\ge 3$, we show how this threshold for $δ(G)$ is related to the notorious Caccetta-Häggkvist conjecture.

We investigate `almost counterexamples' to Seymour's second neighbourhood conjecture. In what we call Seymour-tight orientations, the size of the first neighbourhood of each vertex equals the size of its second neighbourhood. We give several examples and constructions. Specifically, we prove that the class of Seymour-tight orientations is closed under taking (generalized) lexicographic products. Moreover, the lexicographic product of a putative counterexample to Seymour's second neighbourhood conjecture and a Seymour-tight orientation is again a counterexample. Using lexicographic products, we show that if the conjecture is false, then there exist counterexamples that are close to regular tournaments, and moreover that any digraph occurs as an induced subgraph of a counterexample. We then use this same machinery to construct special putative counterexamples to Sullivan's conjecture. The inherent symmetry of these orientations give access to an algebraic perspective. Seymour-tight orientations that are also Cayley digraphs correspond to special pairs of critical sets in groups, which connects potentially to additive combinatorics. We use Kemperman's theorem to characterize those Seymour-tight orientations that are the Cayley digraph of an abelian group.

Borodin and Kostochka in 1977 conjectured that if a graph $G$ has maximum degree $Δ(G)\ge 9$ and its clique number satisfies $ω(G)\le Δ(G)-1$, then its chromatic number satisfies $χ(G) \le Δ(G)-1$. We prove this statement with respect to a stronger graph coloring parameter, the correspondence chromatic number $χ_{DP}$, provided the maximum degree is sufficiently large. More precisely, we prove that for every integer $Δ\ge 3\cdot 10^9$, a graph $G$ of maximum degree at most $Δ$ satisfies $χ_{DP}(G) \le \max(ω(G),Δ-1)$. This strengthens earlier results of Reed (1999) for usual chromatic number and of Choi, Kierstead and Rabern (2023) for list chromatic number.

Given a graph $G$, let $Δ_2(G)$ denote the maximum number of neighbors any two distinct vertices of $G$ have in common. Vu (2002) proposed that, provided $Δ_2(G)$ is not too small as a proportion of the maximum degree $Δ(G)$ of $G$, the chromatic number of $G$ should never be too much larger than $Δ_2(G)$. We make a first approach towards Vu's conjecture from a structural graph theoretic point of view. We prove that, in the case where $G$ is claw-free, indeed the chromatic number of $G$ is at most $Δ_2(G)+3$. This is tight, as our bound is met with equality for the line graph of the Petersen graph. Moreover, we can prove this in terms of the more specific parameter that bounds the maximum number of neighbors any two endpoints of some edge of $G$ have in common. Our result may be viewed as a generalization of the classic bound of Vizing (1964) for edge-coloring.

Given a proper (list) colouring of a graph $G$, a recolouring step changes the colour at a single vertex to another colour (in its list) that is currently unused on its neighbours, hence maintaining a proper colouring. Suppose that each vertex $v$ has its own private list $L(v)$ of allowed colours such that $|L(v)|\ge \mbox{deg}(v)+1$. We prove that if $G$ is connected and its maximum degree $Δ$ is at least $3$, then for any two proper $L$-colourings in which at least one vertex can be recoloured, one can be transformed to the other by a sequence of $O(|V(G)|^2)$ recolouring steps. We also show that reducing the list-size of a single vertex $w$ to $\mbox{deg}(w)$ can lead to situations where the space of proper $L$-colourings is `shattered'. Our results can be interpreted as showing a sharp phase transition in the Glauber dynamics of proper $L$-colourings of graphs. This constitutes a `local' strengthening and generalisation of a result of Feghali, Johnson, and Paulusma, which considered the situation where the lists are all identical to $\{1,\ldots,Δ+1\}$.

Given $d>0$ and a positive integer $n$, let $G$ be a triangle-free graph on $n$ vertices with average degree $d$. With an elegant induction, Shearer (1983) tightened a seminal result of Ajtai, Komlós and Szemerédi (1980/1981) by proving that $G$ contains an independent set of size at least $(1+o(1))\frac{\log d}{d}n$ as $d\to\infty$. By a generalisation of Shearer's method, we prove that the number of independent sets in $G$ must be at least $\exp\left((1+o(1))\frac{(\log d)^2}{2d}n\right)$ as $d\to\infty$. This improves upon results of Cooper and Mubayi (2014) and Davies, Jenssen, Perkins, and Roberts (2018). Our method also provides good lower bounds on the independence polynomial of $G$, one of which implies Shearer's result itself. As certified by a classic probabilistic construction, our bound on the number of independent sets is sharp to several leading terms as $d\to\infty$.

An independent set may not contain both a vertex and one of its neighbours. This basic fact makes the uniform distribution over independent sets rather special. We consider the hard-core model, an essential generalization of the uniform distribution over independent sets. We show how its local analysis yields remarkable insights into the global structure of independent sets in the host graph, in connection with, for instance, Ramsey numbers, graph colourings, and sphere packings.

For a subfamily ${F}\subseteq 2^{[n]}$ of the Boolean lattice, consider the graph $G_{F}$ on ${F}$ based on the pairwise inclusion relations among its members. Given a positive integer $t$, how large can ${F}$ be before $G_{F}$ must contain some component of order greater than $t$? For $t=1$, this question was answered exactly almost a century ago by Sperner: the size of a middle layer of the Boolean lattice. For $t=2^n$, this question is trivial. We are interested in what happens between these two extremes. For $t=2^{g}$ with $g=g(n)$ being any integer function that satisfies $g(n)=o(n/\log n)$ as $n\to\infty$, we give an asymptotically sharp answer to the above question: not much larger than the size of a middle layer. This constitutes a nontrivial generalisation of Sperner's theorem. We do so by a reduction to a Turán-type problem for rainbow cycles in properly edge-coloured graphs. Among other results, we also give a sharp answer to the question, how large can ${F}$ be before $G_{F}$ must be connected?

In this paper, we explore algebraic approaches to $d$-improper and $t$-clustered colourings, where the colouring constraints are relaxed to allow some monochromatic edges. Bilu [J. Comb. Theory Ser. B, 96(4):608-613, 2006] proved a generalization of the Hoffman bound for $d$-improper colourings. We strengthen this theorem by characterizing the equality case. In particular, if the Hoffman bound is tight for a graph $G$, then the $d$-improper Hoffman bound is tight for the strong product $G \boxtimes K_{d+1}$. Moreover, we prove d-improper analogous for the inertia bound by Cvetkovíc and the multi-eigenvalue lower bounds of Elphick and Wocjan. We conjecture an equality between the chromatic number of a graph $G$ and the $d$-improper chromatic number of its strong product with a complete graph, $G \boxtimes K_{d+1}$, and prove the conjecture in special graph classes, including perfect graphs and graphs with chromatic number at most 4. Other supporting evidence for the conjecture includes a fractional analogue, a clustered analogue, and various spectral relaxations of the equality.

Given integers $Δ\ge 2$ and $t\ge 2Δ$, suppose there is a graph of maximum degree $Δ$ and a partition of its vertices into blocks of size at least $t$. By a seminal result of Haxell, there must be some independent set of the graph that is transversal to the blocks, a so-called independent transversal. We show that, if moreover $t\ge2Δ+1$, then every independent transversal can be transformed within the space of independent transversals to any other through a sequence of one-vertex modifications, showing connectivity of the so-called reconfigurability graph of independent transversals. This is sharp in that for $t=2Δ$ (and $Δ\ge 2$) the connectivity conclusion can fail. In this case we show furthermore that in an essential sense it can only fail for the disjoint union of copies of the complete bipartite graph $K_{Δ,Δ}$. This constitutes a qualitative strengthening of Haxell's theorem.

We prove that $χ(G) \le \lceil (Δ+1)/2\rceil+1$ for any triangle-free graph $G$ of maximum degree $Δ$ provided $Δ\ge 524$. This gives tangible progress towards an old problem of Vizing, in a form cast by Reed. We use a method of Hurley and Pirot, which in turn relies on a new counting argument of the second author.

Given a positive integer $d$, the class $d$-DIR is defined as all those intersection graphs formed from a finite collection of line segments in ${\mathbb R}^2$ having at most $d$ slopes. Since each slope induces an interval graph, it easily follows for every $G$ in $d$-DIR with clique number at most $ω$ that the chromatic number $χ(G)$ of $G$ is at most $dω$. We show for every even value of $ω$ how to construct a graph in $d$-DIR that meets this bound exactly. This partially confirms a conjecture of Bhattacharya, Dvořák and Noorizadeh. Furthermore, we show that the $χ$-binding function of $d$-DIR is $ω\mapsto dω$ for $ω$ even and $ω\mapsto d(ω-1)+1$ for $ω$ odd. This extends an earlier result by Kostochka and Nešetřil, which treated the special case $d=2$.

Given a bipartite graph $H=(V=V_A\cup V_B,E)$ in which any vertex in $V_A$ (resp.~$V_B$) has degree at most $D_A$ (resp.~$D_B$), suppose there is a partition of $V$ that is a refinement of the bipartition $V_A\cup V_B$ such that the parts in $V_A$ (resp.~$V_B$) have size at least $k_A$ (resp.~$k_B$). We prove that the condition $D_A/k_B+D_B/k_A\le 1$ is sufficient for the existence of an independent set of vertices of $H$ that is simultaneously transversal to the partition, and show moreover that this condition is sharp. This result is a bipartite refinement of two well-known results on independent transversals, one due to the second author and the other due to Szabó and Tardos.

We investigate the list packing number of a graph, the least $k$ such that there are always $k$ disjoint proper list-colourings whenever we have lists all of size $k$ associated to the vertices. We are curious how the behaviour of the list packing number contrasts with that of the list chromatic number, particularly in the context of bounded degree graphs. The main question we pursue is whether every graph with maximum degree $Δ$ has list packing number at most $Δ+1$. Our results highlight the subtleties of list packing and the barriers to, for example, pursuing a Brooks'-type theorem for the list packing number.

How large must the chromatic number of a graph be, in terms of the graph's maximum degree, to ensure that the most efficient way to reduce the chromatic number by removing vertices is to remove an independent set? By a reduction to a powerful, known stability form of Brooks' theorem, we answer this question precisely, determining the threshold to within two values (and indeed sometimes a unique value) for graphs of sufficiently large maximum degree.

List colouring is an influential and classic topic in graph theory. We initiate the study of a natural strengthening of this problem, where instead of one list-colouring, we seek many in parallel. Our explorations have uncovered a potentially rich seam of interesting problems spanning chromatic graph theory. Given a $k$-list-assignment $L$ of a graph $G$, which is the assignment of a list $L(v)$ of $k$ colours to each vertex $v\in V(G)$, we study the existence of $k$ pairwise-disjoint proper colourings of $G$ using colours from these lists. We may refer to this as a \emph{list-packing}. Using a mix of combinatorial and probabilistic methods, we set out some basic upper bounds on the smallest $k$ for which such a list-packing is always guaranteed, in terms of the number of vertices, the degeneracy, the maximum degree, or the (list) chromatic number of $G$. (The reader might already find it interesting that such a minimal $k$ is well defined.) We also pursue a more focused study of the case when $G$ is a bipartite graph. Our results do not yet rule out the tantalising prospect that the minimal $k$ above is not too much larger than the list chromatic number. Our study has taken inspiration from study of the strong chromatic number, and we also explore generalisations of the problem above in the same spirit.

We wish to bring attention to a natural but slightly hidden problem, posed by Erdős and Nešetřil in the late 1980s, an edge version of the degree--diameter problem. Our main result is that, for any graph of maximum degree $Δ$ with more than $1.5 Δ^t$ edges, its line graph must have diameter larger than $t$. In the case where the graph contains no cycle of length $2t+1$, we can improve the bound on the number of edges to one that is exact for $t\in\{1,2,3,4,6\}$. In the case $Δ=3$ and $t=3$, we obtain an exact bound. Our results also have implications for the related problem of bounding the distance-$t$ chromatic index, $t>2$; in particular, for this we obtain an upper bound of $1.941Δ^t$ for graphs of large enough maximum degree $Δ$, markedly improving upon earlier bounds for this parameter.

Suppose $G$ and $H$ are bipartite graphs and $L: V(G)\to 2^{V(H)}$ induces a partition of $V(H)$ such that the subgraph of $H$ induced between $L(v)$ and $L(v')$ is a matching whenever $vv'\in E(G)$. We show for each $\varepsilon>0$ that, if $H$ has maximum degree $D$ and $|L(v)| \ge (1+\varepsilon)D/\log D$ for all $v\in V(G)$, then $H$ admits an independent transversal with respect to $L$, provided $D$ is sufficiently large. This bound on the part sizes is asymptotically sharp up to a factor $2$. We also show some asymmetric variants of this result.