arXiv++ Combinatorics

A critical set in a Latin square of order $n$ is a set of entries in an $n\times n$ array which can be embedded in precisely one Latin square of order $n$, with the property that if any entry of the critical set is deleted, the remaining set can be embedded in more than one Latin square of order $n$. The cardinality of the largest critical set in any Latin square of order $n$ is denoted by $lcs(n)$. In 1978 Curran and van Rees proved that $lcs(n)\leq n^2-n$. In Chapter 4, it is shown that $lcs(n)\leq n^2-3n+3$. Chapter 5 provides new bounds on the maximum number of intercalates in Latin squares of orders $2^αm$ and $2^αm+1$, and a new lower bound on $lcs(4m)$. In Chapter 6 a construction is given which verifies the existence of a critical set of size $\displaystyle{\frac{n^2}{4}} + 1$ when $n$ is even and $n\geq 6$. In Chapter 7 the representation of Steiner trades of volume less than or equal to nine is examined. Computational results are used to identify those trades for which the associated partial Latin square can be decomposed into six disjoint Latin interchanges. Chapter 8 focusses on critical sets in Latin squares of order at most six and extensive computational routines are used to identify all the critical sets of different sizes in these Latin squares.

We derive explicit upper bounds for the number of nondegenerate critical points of a $k$-component Gaussian mixture density in $\mathbb{R}^d$, and the number of modes when the modal set is finite, together with lower bounds. By normalizing the critical-point equations by a reference component, for $k\ge2$ we get the direct Pfaffian bound \[ U_{\mathrm{het}}(d,k)=2^{\,d+\binom{k-1}{2}}\left(d+2\min(d,k-1)+1\right)^{k-1}. \] For the same parameter range, an exact elimination augmented by an algebraic reciprocal variable gives the alternative bound \[ U_{\mathrm{aug}}(d,k)= 2^{\binom{k-1}{2}}(d+1)\left((2k-1)d+2k-1\right)^{k-1}. \] Thus, for $k\ge2$, the best critical-point bound is their minimum. A Morse-theoretic argument improves the corresponding finite-mode upper bound to \[ \left\lfloor \frac{\min\{U_{\mathrm{het}}(d,k),U_{\mathrm{aug}}(d,k)\}+1}{2}\right\rfloor. \] In the homoscedastic case, for $k\ge2$, the direct bound improves to \[ U_{\mathrm{hom}}(d,k)=2^{\,d+\binom{k-1}{2}}\left(d+\min(d,k-1)+1\right)^{k-1}, \] an affine-rank reduction replaces $d$ by the affine rank of the component means, and an augmented homoscedastic reduction gives the dimension-free bound \[ U_{\mathrm{aug,hom}}(k)=2^{\binom{k-1}{2}+1}(2k)^{k-1}. \] On the lower-bound side, for $d,k\ge 2$ we obtain \[ L_{\mathrm{bin}}(d,k)=k+\max_{2\le r\le \min(d,k)}\binom{k}{r}, \] together with a padding-product family that in particular implies the linear lower bound $d+k-1$, and a seed-closure principle that packages product and padding constructions. We further give explicit bounds for the number of connected components of the critical set.

We investigate `almost counterexamples' to Seymour's second neighbourhood conjecture. In what we call Seymour-tight orientations, the size of the first neighbourhood of each vertex equals the size of its second neighbourhood. We give several examples and constructions. Specifically, we prove that the class of Seymour-tight orientations is closed under taking (generalized) lexicographic products. Moreover, the lexicographic product of a putative counterexample to Seymour's second neighbourhood conjecture and a Seymour-tight orientation is again a counterexample. Using lexicographic products, we show that if the conjecture is false, then there exist counterexamples that are close to regular tournaments, and moreover that any digraph occurs as an induced subgraph of a counterexample. We then use this same machinery to construct special putative counterexamples to Sullivan's conjecture. The inherent symmetry of these orientations give access to an algebraic perspective. Seymour-tight orientations that are also Cayley digraphs correspond to special pairs of critical sets in groups, which connects potentially to additive combinatorics. We use Kemperman's theorem to characterize those Seymour-tight orientations that are the Cayley digraph of an abelian group.

Let $α(G)$ denote the cardinality of a maximum independent set. An independent set $I$ of $G$ is critical if $\left|I\right|-\left|N(I)\right|\ge\left|J\right|-\left|N(J)\right|$ for every independent set $J$ of $G$. Let $\text{core}(G)$ and $\text{corona}(G)$ be the intersection/union of all maximum independent sets of $G$. Let $\text{ker}(G)$ and $\text{diadem}(G)$ be the intersection/union of all critical independent sets of $G$. In this paper we prove that \[ \left|\text{corona}(G)\right|+\left|\text{core}(G)\right|\le2α(G)+k, \] \noindent where $k$ is the number of vertex-distinct odd cycles in $G$, thus confirming a recent conjecture in the area. Moreover, we prove that \[ \left|\text{nucleus}(G)\right|+\left|\text{diadem}(G)\right|\le2α(G), \] \noindent thereby confirming another conjecture (Levit--Mandrescu 2014). As an application of these facts, we obtain a chain of inequalities \[ \left|\text{nucleus}(G)\right|+\left|\text{diadem}(G)\right|\le2α(G)\le\left|\text{corona}(G)\right|+\left|\text{core}(G)\right|\le2α(G)+k. \] \noindent The paper concludes with a collection of related open problems.

We describe in this paper additively left stable sets, i.e. sets satisfying $\left((A+A)-\inf(A)\right)\cap[\inf(A),\sup(A)]=A$ (meaning that $A-\inf(A)$ is stable by addition with itself on its convex hull), when $A$ is a finite subset of integers and when $A$ is a bounded subset of real numbers. More precisely we give a sharp upper bound for the density of $A$ in $[\inf(A),x]$ for $x\le\sup(A)$, and construct sets reaching this density for any given $x$ in this range. This gives some information on sets involved in the structural description of some critical sets in Freiman's $3k-4$ theorem in both cases.

The Borsuk conjecture and the Vázsonyi problem are two attractive and famous questions in discrete and combinatorial geometry, both based on the notion of diameter of a bounded sets. In this paper, we present an equivalence between the critical sets with Borsuk number 4 in $\mathbb{R}^3$ and the minimal structures for the Vázsonyi problem by using the well-known Reuleaux polyhedra. The latter lead to a full characterization of all finite sets in $\mathbb{R}^3$ with Borsuk number 4. The proof of such equivalence needs various ingredients, in particular, we proved a conjecture dealing with strongly critical configuration for the Vázsonyi problem and showed that the diameter graph arising from involutive polyhedra is vertex (and edge) 4-critical.

The Sudoku number has been defined under various names, indicating it is a natural concept. There are four variants of this parameter, that can be related to the maximum and minimum size of a critical set in a graph colouring problem. For each of these four related parameters, we present some simple characterizations of the graphs attaining the maximum possible values. As a main result, we answer a question by Cooper and Kirkpatrick, showing that there is monotone behaviour in the number of colours for only two of the four parameters. We investigate the monotone behaviour for the subgraph-order as well. For Latin squares and the Sudoku, we solve some variants for hypergraph colouring.

If $A$ and $B$ are two bounded sets of reals, Ruzsa proved a precise lower bound of the measure of the sumset $A+B$ involving the ratio $λ(A)/λ(B)$. De Roton established a structural result about the critical sets of this lower bound. Here, we prove a generalization of de Roton's work by establishing a result in a neighborhood of the case of equality.

We study the Hadamard product of the linear forms defining a hyperplane arrangement with those of its dual, which we view as generating an ideal in a certain polynomial ring. We use this ideal, which we call the ideal of pairs, to study logarithmic derivations and critical set varieties of arrangements in a way which is symmetric with respect to matroid duality. Our main result exhibits the variety of the ideal of pairs as a subspace arrangement whose components correspond to cyclic flats of the arrangement. As a corollary, we are able to give geometric explanations of some freeness and projective dimension results due to Ziegler and Kung--Schenck.

The optimization problem of the minimum set of leaders for the controllability of undirected graphs are addressed. It is difficult to find not only its optimal solution but also its approximate algorithm. We propose a new concept, namely minimal perfect critical set (MPCS), to obtain an optimal solution. Some properties are presented, and on the basis of these theorems, the problem of the minimum set of leaders of two typical self-similar bipartite networks, namely deterministic scale-free networks (DSFN) and Cayley trees, is solved completely.

A set $S\subseteq V(G)$ is independent (or stable) if no two vertices from $S$ are adjacent, and by $\mathrm{Ind}(G)$ we mean the set of all independent sets of $G$. A set $A\in\mathrm{Ind}(G)$ is critical (and we write $A\in CritIndep(G)$) if $\left\vert A\right\vert -\left\vert N(A)\right\vert =\max\{\left\vert I\right\vert -\left\vert N(I)\right\vert :I\in \mathrm{Ind}(G)\}$, where $N(I)$ denotes the neighborhood of $I$. If $S\in\mathrm{Ind}(G)$ and there is a matching from $N(S)$ into $S$, then $S$ is a crown, and we write $S\in Crown(G)$. Let $Ψ(G)$ be the family of all local maximum independent sets of graph $G$, i.e., $S\inΨ(G)$ if $S$ is a maximum independent set in the subgraph induced by $S\cup N(S)$. In this paper we show that $CritIndep(G)\subseteq Crown(G)$ $\subseteqΨ(G)$ are true for every graph. In addition, we present some classes of graphs where these families coincide and form greedoids or even more general set systems that we call augmentoids.

Let $D$ be a simple digraph (directed graph) with vertex set $V(D)$ and arc set $A(D)$ where $n=|V(D)|$, and each arc is an ordered pair of distinct vertices. If $(v,u) \in A(D)$, then $u$ is considered an \emph{out-neighbor} of $v$ in $D$. Initially, we designate each vertex to be either filled or empty. Then, the following color change rule (CCR) is applied: if a filled vertex $v$ has exactly one empty out-neighbor $u$, then $u$ will be filled. The process continues until the CCR does not allow any empty vertex to become filled. If all vertices in $V(D)$ are eventually filled, then the initial set is called a \emph{zero forcing set} (ZFS); if not, it is a \emph{failed zero forcing set} (FZFS). We introduce the \emph{failed zero forcing number} $F(D)$ on a digraph, which is the maximum cardinality of any FZFS. The \emph{zero forcing number}, $Z(D)$, is the minimum cardinality of any ZFS. We characterize digraphs that have $F(D)<Z(D)$ and determine $F(D)$ for several classes of digraphs including directed acyclic graphs, weak paths and cycles, and weakly connected line digraphs such as de Bruijn and Kautz digraphs. We also characterize digraphs with $F(D)=n-1$, $F(D)=n-2$, and $F(D)=0$, which leads to a characterization of digraphs in which any vertex is a ZFS. Finally, we show that for any integer $n \geq 3$ and any non-negative integer $k$ with $k <n$, there exists a weak cycle $D$ with $F(D)=k$.

Consider a matrix $M$ chosen uniformly at random from a class of $m \times n$ matrices of zeros and ones with prescribed row and column sums. A partially filled matrix $D$ is a $\mathit{defining}$ $\mathit{set}$ for $M$ if $M$ is the unique member of its class that contains the entries in $D$. The $\mathit{size}$ of a defining set is the number of filled entries. A $\mathit{critical}$ $\mathit{set}$ is a defining set for which the removal of any entry stops it being a defining set. For some small fixed $ε>0$, we assume that $n\le m=o(n^{1+ε})$, and that $λ\le1/2$, where $λ$ is the proportion of entries of $M$ that equal $1$. We also assume that the row sums of $M$ do not vary by more than $\mathcal{O}(n^{1/2+ε})$, and that the column sums do not vary by more than $\mathcal{O}(m^{1/2+ε})$. Under these assumptions we show that $M$ almost surely has no defining set of size less than $λmn-\mathcal{O}(m^{7/4+ε})$. It follows that $M$ almost surely has no critical set of size more than $(1-λ)mn+\mathcal{O}(m^{7/4+ε})$. Our results generalise a theorem of Cavenagh and Ramadurai, who examined the case when $λ=1/2$ and $n=m=2^k$ for an integer $k$.

If $D$ is a partially filled-in $(0,1)$-matrix with a unique completion to a $(0,1)$-matrix $M$ (with prescribed row and column sums), we say that $D$ is a {\em defining set} for $M$. A {\em critical set} is a minimal defining set (the deletion of any entry results in more than one completion). We give a new classification of critical sets in $(0,1)$-matrices and apply this theory to $Λ_{2m}^m$, the set of $(0,1)$-matrices of dimensions $2m\times 2m$ with uniform row and column sum $m$. The smallest possible size for a defining set of a matrix in $Λ_{2m}^m$ is $m^2$ \cite{Cav}, and the infimum (the largest smallest defining set size for members of $Λ_{2m}^m$) is known asymptotically \cite{CR}. We show that no critical set of size larger than $3m^2-2m$ exists in an element of $Λ_{2m}^m$ and that there exists a critical set of size $k$ in an element of $Λ_{2m}^m$ for each $k$ such that $m^2\leq k\leq 3m^2-4m+2$. We also bound the supremum (the smallest largest critical set size for members of $Λ_{2m}^m$) between $\lceil (3m^2-2m+1)/2\rceil$ and $2m^2-m$.

A non-negative integer invariant, estimating from below the number of geometrically different critical points of a smooth function $f$ defined in the 2-disk, $f:\mathbb{B}^{2}\rightarrow\mathbb{R}$, is considered. (We denote it by "$γ$".) It depends on combined $C^{0}+C^{1}$ type conditions on the boundary $\partial(\mathbb{B}^{2})=\mathbb{S}^{1}$, that we call "ribbons" here. It turns out to be an alternative to the degree of the gradient map and almost independent from it. Note that the computation of the degree does not guarantee multiple critical points, unlike the ribbon invariant $γ$. In fact, this invariant is counting the number of essential components of the critical set, rather than simply the number of critical points. Various estimates of $γ$ are established. Some other "ribbon type" invariants of geometrical nature are defined and investigated. All these invariants turn out to be more combinatorial, rather than algebraic, in nature. Algorithms for the calculation of the ribbon invariants are presented. Interconnections with some different areas, such as the theory of immersed curves in the plane or independent domination in graphs, as well as various geometric applications, are commented. The latter topics will be investigated in detail in Part II of the present article. At the end, different questions about $γ$ are asked.

Let $G$ be a finite simple graph. For $X \subset V(G)$, the difference of $X$, $d(X) := |X| - |N (X)|$ where $N(X)$ is the neighborhood of $X$ and $\max \, \{d(X):X\subset V(G)\}$ is called the critical difference of $G$. $X$ is called a critical set if $d(X)$ equals the critical difference and ker$(G)$ is the intersection of all critical sets. It is known that ker$(G)$ is an independent (vertex) set of $G$. diadem$(G)$ is the union of all critical independent sets. An independent set $S$ is an inclusion minimal set with $d(S) > 0$ if no proper subset of $S$ has positive difference. A graph $G$ is called König-Egerváry if the sum of its independence number ($α(G)$) and matching number ($μ(G)$) equals $|V(G)|$. It is known that bipartite graphs are König-Egerváry. In this paper, we study independent sets with positive difference for which every proper subset has a smaller difference and prove a result conjectured by Levit and Mandrescu in 2013. The conjecture states that for any graph, the number of inclusion minimal sets $S$ with $d(S) > 0$ is at least the critical difference of the graph. We also give a short proof of the inequality $|$ker$(G)| + |$diadem$(G)| \le 2α(G)$ (proved by Short in 2016). A characterization of unicyclic non-König-Egerváry graphs is also presented and a conjecture which states that for such a graph $G$, the critical difference equals $α(G) - μ(G)$, is proved. We also make an observation about ker$G)$ using Edmonds-Gallai Structure Theorem as a concluding remark.

A critical set in an $n \times n$ Latin square is a minimal set of entries that uniquely identifies it among all Latin squares of the same size. It is conjectured by Nelder in 1979, and later independently by Mahmoodian, and Bate and van Rees that the size of the smallest critical set is $\lfloor n^2/4\rfloor$. We prove a lower-bound of $n^2/10^4$ for sufficiently large $n$, and thus confirm the quadratic order predicted by the conjecture. We prove a lower-bound of $n^2/10^4$ for sufficiently large $n$, and thus confirm the quadratic order predicted by the conjecture. This improves a recent lower-bound of $Ω(n^{3/2})$ due to Cavenagh and Ramadurai. From the point of view of computational learning theory, the size of the smallest critical set corresponds to the minimum teaching dimension of the set of Latin squares. We study two related notions of dimension from learning theory. We prove a lower-bound of $n^2-(e+o(1))n^{5/3}$ for both of the VC-dimension and the recursive teaching dimension.

We consider a weighted family of $n$ parallelly transported hyperplanes in a $k$-dimensioinal affine space and describe the characteristic variety of the Gauss-Manin differential equations for associated hypergeometric integrals. The characteristic variety is given as the zero set of Laurent polynomials, whose coefficients are determined by weights and the associated point in the Grassmannian Gr$(k,n)$. The Laurent polynomials are in involution. An intermediate object between the differential equations and the characteristic variety is the algebra of functions on the critical set of the associated master function. We construct a linear isomorphism between the vector space of the Gauss-Manin differential equations and the algebra of functions. The isomorphism allows us to describe the characteristic variety. It also allowed us to define an integral structure on the vector space of the algebra and the associated (combinatorial) connection on the family of such algebras.

We discuss the problem of finding critical sets in graphs, a concept which has appeared in a number of guises in the combinatorics and graph theory literature. The case of the Sudoku graph receives particular attention, because critical sets correspond to minimal fair puzzles. We define four parameters associated with the sizes of extremal critical sets and (a) prove several general results about these parameters' properties, including their computational intractability, (b) compute their values exactly for some classes of graphs, (c) obtain bounds for generalized Sudoku graphs, and (d) offer a number of open questions regarding critical sets and the aforementioned parameters.

We consider a family of generic weighted arrangements of $n$ hyperplanes in $\C^k$ and show that the Gauss-Manin connection for the associated hypergeometric integrals, the contravariant form on the space of singular vectors, and the algebra of functions on the critical set of the master function define a Frobenius like structure on the base of the family. As a result of this construction we show that the matrix elements of the linear operators of the Gauss-Manin connection are given by the 2k+1-st derivatives of a single function on the base of the family, the function called the potential of second kind, see formula (6.46).