arXiv++ Combinatorics

A square matrix is called Hessenberg whenever each entry below the subdiagonal is zero and each entry on the subdiagonal is nonzero. A Hessenberg pair is an ordered pair of diagonalizable linear maps on a nonzero finite-dimensional vector space, that each act on an eigenbasis of the other one in a Hessenberg fashion. A Hessenberg system $Φ$ an `oriented' version of a Hessenberg pair. It is known that $Φ$ is determined up to isomorphism by its parameter array; this consists of the eigenvalue sequence of $Φ$, the dual eigenvalue sequence of $Φ$, and a sequence of nonzero scalars $\{φ_i\}_{i=1}^d$ called the split sequence of $Φ$. We are interested in some types of Hessenberg matrices, said to be circular, quasi-circular, tridiagonal, and irreducible tridiagonal. We are interested in the families of Hessenberg systems for which the associated Hessenberg matrices have one of the above types. A Hessenberg system of irreducible tridiagonal type is often called a Leonard system. In this case the associated Hessenberg pair satisfies two relations, called the tridiagonal relations. We are interested in the family of Hessenberg systems for which the associated Hessenberg pair satisfies the tridiagonal relations. We are also interested in the family of Hessenberg systems for which the eigenvalue sequence and dual eigenvalue sequence satisfy a linear three-term recurrence. In the present paper we have two main goals. First, we show how the above families of Hessenberg systems are related to each other. Second, we describe each family in terms of the parameter array.

A square matrix is said to be Hessenberg whenever each entry below the subdiagonal is zero, and each entry on the subdiagonal is nonzero. A Hessenberg matrix is called circular whenever the top-right corner entry is nonzero, and every other entry above the superdiagonal is zero. A circular Hessenberg pair consists of two diagonalizable linear maps on a nonzero finite-dimensional vector space, that each act on an eigenbasis of the other one in a circular Hessenberg fashion. In 2022, Jae-ho Lee conjectured that a circular Hessenberg pair satisfies two relations called the tridiagonal relations. In the present paper, we prove Lee's conjecture. Our proof is not elementary.

We consider a Leonard pair $A, A^*$ of linear maps on a vector space $V$ that has finite positive dimension. This Leonard pair $A,A^*$ is said to have spin whenever there exist invertible linear maps $W : V \to V$ and $W^* : V \to V$ such that $W A = A W$ and $W^* A^* = A^* W^*$ and $W A^* W^{-1} = (W^*)^{-1} A W^*$. Let $\{θ^*_i\}_{i=0}^d$ denote a standard ordering of the eigenvalues of $A^*$. There is a related sequence of scalars $\{a_i\}_{i=0}^d$ called intersection numbers. The Leonard pair $A,A^*$ is called self-dual whenever $\{θ^*_i\}_{i=0}^d$ is a standard ordering of the eigenvalues of $A$. We obtain the following results under the assumption that the ground field is algebraically closed and $d \geq 3$. We show that a Leonard pair $A,A^*$ on $V$ has spin if and only if both (i) $A,A^*$ is self-dual; (ii) there exist scalars $f_0,f_1,f_2, f_3$ (not all zero) such that $f_0 + f_1 θ^*_i + f_2 a_i + f_3 a_i θ^*_i = 0$ for $0 \leq i \leq d$. We also classify the Leonard pairs $A,A^*$ on $V$ that satisfy (ii) without assuming (i). To do this we bring in the following maps. For $0 \leq i \leq d$ let $E^*_i : V \to V$ denote the projection onto the $θ^*_i$-eigenspace of $A^*$. Let ${\mathcal Z}(A,A^*)$ denote the set of elements $X$ in $\text{Span}\{I, A^*, A, A A^*\}$ such that $E^*_i X E^*_i= 0$ for $0 \leq i \leq d$. We call ${\mathcal Z}(A,A^*)$ the zero diagonal space of $A,A^*$. As we will see, ${\mathcal Z}(A,A^*) \neq 0$ if and only if the above condition (ii) holds. As we investigate the case ${\mathcal Z}(A,A^*) \neq 0$ in detail, we break the problem into 13 cases called types; these are the $q$-Racah type and its relatives. For each type we give a necessary and sufficient condition for ${\mathcal Z}(A,A^*) \not=0$. For each type we give an explicit basis for ${\mathcal Z}(A,A^*)$.

Let $Γ$ denote a $Q$-polynomial distance-regular graph, with vertex set $X$ and diameter $D\geq 3$. The standard module $V$ has a basis $\lbrace {\hat x} \vert x \in X\rbrace$, where ${\hat x}$ denotes column $x$ of the identity matrix $I \in {\rm Mat}_X(\mathbb C)$. Let $E$ denote a $Q$-polynomial primitive idempotent of $Γ$. The eigenspace $EV$ is spanned by the vectors $\lbrace E {\hat x} \vert x \in X\rbrace$. It was previously known that these vectors satisfy a condition called the balanced set condition. In this paper, we introduce a variation on the balanced set condition called the Norton-balanced condition. The Norton-balanced condition involves the Norton algebra product on $EV$. We define $Γ$ to be Norton-balanced whenever $Γ$ has a $Q$-polynomial primitive idempotent $E$ such that the set $\lbrace E {\hat x} \vert x \in X\rbrace$ is Norton-balanced. We show that $Γ$ is Norton-balanced in the following cases: (i) $Γ$ is bipartite; (ii) $Γ$ is almost bipartite; (iii) $Γ$ is dual-bipartite; (iv) $Γ$ is almost dual-bipartite; (v) $Γ$ is tight; (vi) $Γ$ is a Hamming graph; (vii) $Γ$ is a Johnson graph; (viii) $Γ$ is the Grassmann graph $J_q(2D,D)$; (ix) $Γ$ is a halved bipartite dual-polar graph; (x) $Γ$ is a halved Hemmeter graph; (xi) $Γ$ is a halved hypercube; (xii) $Γ$ is a folded-half hypercube; (xiii) $Γ$ has $q$-Racah type and affords a spin model. Some theoretical results about the Norton-balanced condition are obtained, and some open problems are given.

Let $Γ$ denote a distance-regular graph, with vertex set $X$ and diameter $D\geq 3$. We assume that $Γ$ is formally self-dual and $q$-Racah type. We also assume that for each $x \in X$ the subconstituent algebra $T=T(x)$ contains a certain central element $Z=Z(x)$. We use $Z$ to construct a spin model $\sf W$ afforded by $Γ$. We investigate the combinatorial implications of $Z$. We reverse the logical direction and recover $Z$ from $\sf W$. We finish with some open problems.

There is a concept in linear algebra called a tridiagonal pair. The concept was motivated by the theory of $Q$-polynomial distance-regular graphs. We give a tutorial introduction to tridiagonal pairs, working with a special case as a concrete example. The special case is called totally bipartite, or TB. Starting from first principles, we give an elementary but comprehensive account of TB tridiagonal pairs. The following topics are discussed: (i) the notion of a TB tridiagonal system; (ii) the eigenvalue array; (iii) the standard basis and matrix representations; (iv) the intersection numbers; (v) the Askey-Wilson relations; (vi) a recurrence involving the eigenvalue array; (vii) the classification of TB tridiagonal systems; (viii) self-dual TB tridiagonal pairs and systems; (ix) the $\mathbb{Z}_3$-symmetric Askey-Wilson relations; (x) some automorphisms and antiautomorphisms associated with a TB tridiagonal pair; (xi) an action of the modular group ${\rm PSL}_2(\mathbb{Z})$ associated with a TB tridiagonal pair.

A Leonard pair is a pair of diagonalizable linear transformations of a finite-dimensional vector space, each of which acts in an irreducible tridiagonal fashion on an eigenbasis for the other one. In the present paper we give an elementary but comprehensive account of how the following are related: (i) Krawtchouk polynomials; (ii) finite-dimensional irreducible modules for the Lie algebra ${\mathfrak{sl}_2}$; (iii) a class of Leonard pairs said to have Krawtchouk type. Along the way we obtain elementary proofs of some well-known facts about Krawtchouk polynomials, such as the three-term recurrence, the orthogonality, the difference equation, and the generating function. The paper is a tutorial meant for a graduate student or a researcher unfamiliar with the above topics.

In this paper we characterize the nonnegative irreducible tridiagonal matrices and their permutations, using certain entries in their primitive idempotents. Our main result is summarized as follows. Let $d$ denote a nonnegative integer. Let $A$ denote a matrix in $\matR$ and let $\{þ_i\}_{i=0}^d$ denote the roots of the characteristic polynomial of $A$. We say $A$ is multiplicity-free whenever these roots are mutually distinct and contained in $\R$. In this case $E_i$ will denote the primitive idempotent of $A$ associated with $þ_i$ $(0 \leq i \leq d)$. We say $A$ is symmetrizable whenever there exists an invertible diagonal matrix $Δ\in \matR$ such that $ΔA Δ^{-1}$ is symmetric. Let $Γ(A)$ denote the directed graph with vertex set $\{0,1,...,d\}$, where $i \rightarrow j$ whenever $i \neq j$ and $A_{ij} \neq 0$. Theorem: Assume that each entry of $A$ is nonnegative. Then the following are equivalent for $0 \leq s,t \leq d$: (i) The graph $Γ(A)$ is a bidirected path with endpoints $s$, $t$: (ii) The matrix $A$ is symmetrizable and multiplicity-free. Moreover the $(s,t)$-entry of $E_i$ times $(þ_i-þ_0)...(þ_i-þ_{i-1})(þ_i-þ_{i+1})...(þ_i-þ_d)$ is independent of $i$ for $0 \leq i \leq d$, and this common value is nonzero. Recently Kurihara and Nozaki obtained a theorem that characterizes the $Q$-polynomial property for symmetric association schemes. We view the above result as a linear algebraic generalization of their theorem.

Let $F$ denote a field and let $V$ denote a vector space over $F$ with finite positive dimension. We consider a pair of linear transformations $A:V \to V$ and $A^*:V \to V$ that satisfy the following conditions: (i) each of $A,A^*$ is diagonalizable; (ii) there exists an ordering $\lbrace V_i\rbrace_{i=0}^d$ of the eigenspaces of $A$ such that $A^* V_i \subseteq V_{i-1} + V_{i} + V_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq d$, where $V_{-1}=0$ and $V_{d+1}=0$; (iii) there exists an ordering $\lbrace V^*_i\rbrace_{i=0}^δ$ of the eigenspaces of $A^*$ such that $A V^*_i \subseteq V^*_{i-1} + V^*_{i} + V^*_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq δ$, where $V^*_{-1}=0$ and $V^*_{δ+1}=0$; (iv) there is no subspace $W$ of $V$ such that $AW \subseteq W$, $A^* W \subseteq W$, $W \neq 0$, $W \neq V$. We call such a pair a {\it tridiagonal pair} on $V$. It is known that $d=δ$ and for $ 0 \leq i \leq d$ the dimensions of $V_i,V_{d-i},V^*_i, V^*_{d-i}$ coincide. The pair $A,A^*$ is called {\it sharp} whenever ${\rm dim} V_0=1$. It is known that if $F$ is algebraically closed then $A,A^*$ is sharp. In this paper we classify up to isomorphism the sharp tridiagonal pairs. As a corollary, we classify up to isomorphism the tridiagonal pairs over an algebraically closed field. We obtain these classifications by proving the $μ$-conjecture.

Let $\K$ denote a field and let $V$ denote a vector space over $\K$ with finite positive dimension. We consider a pair of linear transformations $A:V \to V$ and $A^*:V \to V$ that satisfy the following conditions: (i) each of $A,A^*$ is diagonalizable; (ii) there exists an ordering $\lbrace V_i\rbrace_{i=0}^d$ of the eigenspaces of $A$ such that $A^* V_i \subseteq V_{i-1} + V_{i} + V_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq d$, where $V_{-1}=0$ and $V_{d+1}=0$; (iii) there exists an ordering $\lbrace V^*_i\rbrace_{i=0}^δ$ of the eigenspaces of $A^*$ such that $A V^*_i \subseteq V^*_{i-1} + V^*_{i} + V^*_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq δ$, where $V^*_{-1}=0$ and $V^*_{δ+1}=0$; (iv) there is no subspace $W$ of $V$ such that $AW \subseteq W$, $A^* W \subseteq W$, $W \neq 0$, $W \neq V$. We call such a pair a {\it tridiagonal pair} on $V$. It is known that $d=δ$ and for $0 \leq i \leq d$ the dimensions of $V_i$, $V_{d-i}$, $V^*_i$, $V^*_{d-i}$ coincide. We say the pair $A,A^*$ is {\it sharp} whenever $\dim V_0=1$. It is known that if $\K$ is algebraically closed then $A,A^*$ is sharp. A conjectured classification of the sharp tridiagonal pairs was recently introduced by T. Ito and the second author. Shortly afterwards we introduced a conjecture, called the {\em $μ$-conjecture}, which implies the classification conjecture. In this paper we show that the $μ$-conjecture holds in a special case called $q$-Racah.

Let $F$ denote a field and let $V$ denote a vector space over $F$ with finite positive dimension. We consider a pair of linear transformations $A:V \to V$ and $A^*:V \to V$ that satisfy the following conditions: (i) each of $A,A^*$ is diagonalizable; (ii) there exists an ordering $\{V_i\}_{i=0}^d$ of the eigenspaces of $A$ such that $A^* V_i \subseteq V_{i-1} + V_{i} + V_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq d$, where $V_{-1}=0$ and $V_{d+1}=0$; (iii) there exists an ordering $\{V^*_i\}_{i=0}^δ$ of the eigenspaces of $A^*$ such that $A V^*_i \subseteq V^*_{i-1} + V^*_{i} + V^*_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq δ$, where $V^*_{-1}=0$ and $V^*_{δ+1}=0$; (iv) there is no subspace $W$ of $V$ such that $AW \subseteq W$, $A^* W \subseteq W$, $W \neq 0$, $W \neq V$. We call such a pair a {\it tridiagonal pair} on $V$. It is known that $d=δ$ and for $0 \leq i \leq d$ the dimensions of $V_i$, $V_{d-i}$, $V^*_i$, $V^*_{d-i}$ coincide. We say the pair $A,A^*$ is {\it sharp} whenever $\dim V_0=1$. It is known that if $F$ is algebraically closed then $A,A^*$ is sharp. A conjectured classification of the sharp tridiagonal pairs was recently introduced by T. Ito and the second author. We present a result which supports the conjecture. Given scalars $\{þ_i\}_{i=0}^d$, $\{þ^*_i\}_{i=0}^d$ in $F$ that satisfy the known constraints on the eigenvalues of a tridiagonal pair, we define an $F$-algebra $T$ by generators and relations. We consider the algebra $e^*_0Te^*_0$ for a certain idempotent $e^*_0 \in T$. Let $R$ denote the polynomial algebra over $F$ involving $d$ variables.We display a surjective algebra homomorphism $μ: R \to e^*_0Te^*_0$. We conjecture that $μ$ is an isomorphism. We show that this $μ$-conjecture implies the classification conjecture, and that the $μ$-conjecture holds for $d\leq 5$.

Let $K$ denote a field and let $V$ denote a vector space over $K$ with finite positive dimension. We consider a pair of linear transformations $A:V \to V$ and $A^*:V \to V$ that satisfy the following conditions: (i) each of $A,A^*$ is diagonalizable; (ii) there exists an ordering $\lbrace V_i\rbrace_{i=0}^d$ of the eigenspaces of $A$ such that $A^* V_i \subseteq V_{i-1} + V_{i} + V_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq d$, where $V_{-1}=0$ and $V_{d+1}=0$; (iii) there exists an ordering $\lbrace V^*_i\rbrace_{i=0}^δ$ of the eigenspaces of $A^*$ such that $A V^*_i \subseteq V^*_{i-1} + V^*_{i} + V^*_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq δ$, where $V^*_{-1}=0$ and $V^*_{δ+1}=0$; (iv) there is no subspace $W$ of $V$ such that $AW \subseteq W$, $A^* W \subseteq W$, $W \neq 0$, $W \neq V$. We call such a pair a {\it tridiagonal pair} on $V$. It is known that $d=δ$ and for $0 \leq i \leq d$ the dimensions of $V_i$, $V^*_i$, $V_{d-i}$, $V^*_{d-i}$ coincide; we denote this common dimension by $ρ_i$. In this paper we prove that $ρ_i \leq ρ_0 \binom{d}{i}$ for $0 \leq i \leq d$. It is already known that $ρ_0=1$ if $\K$ is algebraically closed.

Let $K$ denote a field and let $V$ denote a vector space over $K$ with finite positive dimension. We consider a pair of linear transformations $A:V \to V$ and $A^*:V \to V$ that satisfy the following conditions: (i) each of $A,A^*$ is diagonalizable; (ii) there exists an ordering $\{V_i\}_{i=0}^d$ of the eigenspaces of $A$ such that $A^* V_i \subseteq V_{i-1} + V_i + V_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq d$, where $V_{-1}=0$ and $V_{d+1}=0$; (iii) there exists an ordering $\{V^*_i\}_{i=0}^δ$ of the eigenspaces of $A^*$ such that $A V^*_i \subseteq V^*_{i-1} + V^*_i + V^*_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq δ$, where $V^*_{-1}=0$ and $V^*_{δ+1}=0$; (iv)there is no subspace $W$ of $V$ such that $AW \subseteq W$, $A^* W \subseteq W$, $W \neq 0$, $W \neq V$. We call such a pair a tridiagonal pair on $V$. It is known that $d=δ$ and for $0 \leq i \leq d$ the dimensions of $V_i, V_{d-i}, V^*_i, V^*_{d-i}$ coincide. In this paper we show that the following (i)--(iv) hold provided that $K$ is algebraically closed: (i) Each of $V_0$, $V^*_0$, $V_d$, $V^*_d$ has dimension 1. (ii) There exists a nondegenerate symmetric bilinear form $(,)$ on $V$ such that $(Au,v)=(u,Av)$ and $(A^*u,v)=(u,A^*v)$ for all $u,v \in V$. (iii) There exists a unique anti-automorphism of $End(V)$ that fixes each of $A,A^*$. (iv) The pair $A,A^*$ is determined up to isomorphism by the data $(\{þ_i\}_{i=0}^d; \{þ^*_i\}_{i=0}^d; \{ζ_i\}_{i=0}^d)$, where $þ_i$ (resp. $þ^*_i$) is the eigenvalue of $A$ (resp. $A^*$) on $V_i$ (resp. $V^*_i$), and $\{ζ_i\}_{i=0}^d$ is the split sequence of $A,A^*$ corresponding to $\{þ_i\}_{i=0}^d$ and $\{þ^*_i\}_{i=0}^d$.

Let $K$ denote a field and let $V$ denote a vector space over $K$ with finite positive dimension. Let $End(V)$ denote the $K$-algebra consisting of all $K$-linear transformations from $V$ to $V$. We consider a pair $A,A^* \in End(V)$ that satisfy (i)--(iv) below: (i) Each of $A,A^*$ is diagonalizable. (ii) There exists an ordering $\{V_i\}_{i=0}^d$ of the eigenspaces of $A$ such that $A^* V_i \subseteq V_{i-1} + V_{i} + V_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq d$, where $V_{-1}=0$ and $V_{d+1}=0$. (iii) There exists an ordering $\{V^*_i\}_{i=0}^δ$ of the eigenspaces of $A^*$ such that $A V^*_i \subseteq V^*_{i-1} + V^*_{i} + V^*_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq δ$, where $V^*_{-1}=0$ and $V^*_{δ+1}=0$. (iv) There is no subspace $W$ of $V$ such that $AW \subseteq W$, $A^* W \subseteq W$, $W \neq 0$, $W \neq V$. We call such a pair a {\em tridiagonal pair} on $V$. Let $E^*_0$ denote the element of $End(V)$ such that $(E^*_0-I)V^*_0=0$ and $E^*_0V^*_i=0$ for $1 \leq i \leq d$. Let $D$ (resp. $D^*$) denote the $K$-subalgebra of $End(V)$ generated by $A$ (resp. $A^*$). In this paper we prove that the span of $E^*_0 D D^*DE^*_0$ equals the span of $E^*_0D E^*_0DE^*_0$, and that the elements of $E^*_0 D E^*_0$ mutually commute. We relate these results to some conjectures of Tatsuro Ito and the second author that are expected to play a role in the classification of tridiagonal pairs.

Let $K$ denote a field and let $V$ denote a vector space over $K$ with finite positive dimension. We consider a pair of $K$-linear transformations $A:V \to V$ and $A^*:V \to V$ that satisfies the following conditions: (i) each of $A,A^*$ is diagonalizable; (ii) there exists an ordering ${V_i}_{i=0}^d$ of the eigenspaces of $A$ such that $A^* V_i \subseteq V_{i-1} + V_{i} + V_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq d$, where $V_{-1}=0$ and $V_{d+1}=0$; (iii) there exists an ordering ${V^*_i}_{i=0}^δ$ of the eigenspaces of $A^*$ such that $A V^*_i \subseteq V^*_{i-1} + V^*_{i} + V^*_{i+1}$ for $0 \leq i \leq δ$, where $V^*_{-1}=0$ and $V^*_{δ+1}=0$; (iv) there is no subspace $W$ of $V$ such that $AW \subseteq W$, $A^* W \subseteq W$, $W \neq 0$, $W \neq V$. We call such a pair a {\em tridiagonal pair} on $V$. It is known that $d=δ$ and for $0 \leq i \leq d$ the dimensions of $V_i$, $V_{d-i}$, $V^*_i$, $V^*_{d-i}$ coincide. We say the pair $A,A^*$ is {\em sharp} whenever $\dim V_0=1$. A conjecture of Tatsuro Ito and the second author states that if $K$ is algebraically closed then $A,A^*$ is sharp. In order to better understand and eventually prove the conjecture, in this paper we begin a systematic study of the sharp tridiagonal pairs.

Let $V$ denote a vector space with finite positive dimension. We consider a pair of linear transformations $A : V \to V$ and $A^* : V \to V$ that satisfy (i) and (ii) below: (i) There exists a basis for $V$ with respect to which the matrix representing $A$ is irreducible tridiagonal and the matrix representing $A^*$ is diagonal. (ii) There exists a basis for $V$ with respect to which the matrix representing $A^*$ is irreducible tridiagonal and the matrix representing $A$ is diagonal. We call such a pair a Leonard pair on $V$. In an earlier paper we described 24 special bases for $V$. One feature of these bases is that with respect to each of them the matrices that represent $A$ and $A^*$ are (i) diagonal and irreducible tridiagonal or (ii) irreducible tridiagonal and diagonal or (iii) lower bidiagonal and upper bidiagonal or (iv) upper bidiagonal and lower bidiagonal. For each ordered pair of bases among the 24, there exists a unique linear transformation from $V$ to $V$ that sends the first basis to the second basis; we call this the transition map. In this paper we find each transition map explicitly as a polynomial in $A,A^*$.

Let $K$ denote a field and let $V$ denote a vector space over $K$ with finite positive dimension. We consider an ordered pair of linear transformations $A : V \to V$ and $A^* : V \to V$ that satisfy (i) and (ii) below: (i) There exists a basis for $V$ with respect to which the matrix representing $A$ is irreducible tridiagonal and the matrix representing $A^*$ is diagonal. (ii) There exists a basis for $V$ with respect to which the matrix representing $A^*$ is irreducible tridiagonal and the matrix representing $A$ is diagonal. We call such a pair a Leonard pair on $V$. Let $x$, $c$, $x^*$, $c^*$ denote scalars in $K$ with $x$, $x^*$ nonzero, and note that $xA+cI$, $x^*A^* + c^*I$ is a Leonard pair on $V$. We give necessary and sufficient conditions for this Leonard pair to be isomorphic to the Leonard pair $A$, $A^*$. We also give necessary and sufficient conditions for this Leonard pair to be isomorphic to the Leonard pair $A^*$, $A$.

Let $V$ denote a vector space with finite positive dimension. We consider a pair of linear transformations $A : V \to V$ and $A^* : V \to V$ that satisfy (i) and (ii) below: (i) There exists a basis for $V$ with respect to which the matrix representing $A$ is irreducible tridiagonal and the matrix representing $A^*$ is diagonal. (ii) There exists a basis for $V$ with respect to which the matrix representing $A^*$ is irreducible tridiagonal and the matrix representing $A$ is diagonal. We call such a pair a {\em Leonard pair} on $V$. Let $v_0,v_1,...,v_d$ (resp. $w_0,w_1,...,w_d$) denote a basis for $V$ referred to in (i) (resp. (ii)). We show that there exists a unique linear transformation $S: V \to V$ that sends $v_0$ to a scalar multiple of $v_d$, fixes $w_0$, and sends $w_i$ to a scalar multiple of $w_i$ for $1 \leq i \leq d$. We call $S$ the {\it switching element}. We describe $S$ from many points of view.

Let $K$ denote a field and let $V$ denote a vector space over $K$ with finite positive dimension. We consider a pair of linear transformations $A : V \to V$ and $A^* : V \to V$ that satisfy (i) and (ii) below: (i) There exists a basis for $V$ with respect to which the matrix representing $A$ is irreducible tridiagonal and the matrix representing $A^*$ is diagonal. (ii) There exists a basis for $V$ with respect to which the matrix representing $A^*$ is irreducible tridiagonal and the matrix representing $A$ is diagonal. We call such a pair a {\it Leonard pair} on $V$. Let $\cal X$ denote the set of linear transformations $X:V \to V$ such that the matrix representing $X$ with respect to the basis (i) is tridiagonal and the matrix representing $X$ with respect to the basis (ii) is tridiagonal. We show that $\cal X$ is spanned by $I$, $A$, $A^*$, $AA^*$, $A^*A$, and these elements form a basis for $\cal X$ provided the dimension of $V$ is at least 3.

Let $K$ denote a field, and let $V$ denote a vector space over $K$ with finite positive dimension. We consider a pair of linear transformations $A:V \to V$ and $A^*: V \to V$ that satisfy (i), (ii) below: (i) There exists a basis for $V$ with respect to which the matrix representing $A$ is irreducible tridiagonal and the matrix representing $A^*$ is diagonal. (ii) There exists a basis for $V$ with respect to which the matrix representing $A^*$ is irreducible tridiagonal and the matrix representing $A$ is diagonal. We call such a pair a {\em Leonard pair} on $V$. In this paper we investigate the commutator $AA^*-A^*A$. Our results are as follows. First assume the dimension of $V$ is even. We show $AA^*-A^*A$ is invertible and display several attractive formulae for the determinant. Next assume the dimension of $V$ is odd. We show that the null space of $AA^*-A^*A$ has dimension 1. We display a nonzero vector in this null space. We express this vector as a sum of eigenvectors for $A$ and as a sum of eigenvectors for $A^*$.