arXiv++ Combinatorics

The well known bunkbed conjecture about percolation on finite graphs is now resolved; Gladkov, Pak and Zimin, building upon work of Hollom, have constructed a counterexample. We revisit this conjecture and study it in the broader context of the class of random cluster measures. We show that the major partial (positive) results on the bunkbed conjecture can also be proved for all random cluster measures, including the results for complete graphs, complete bipartite graphs, and the case when $p \uparrow 1$. The arboreal gas measure for forests is another limit of the random cluster measure for which we conjecture the inequality to be true and provide proofs in special cases. We identify a setting where the conjecture does hold, that of ``almost spanning tree measures''. A further analysis leads to intriguing correlation inequalities that complement Rayleigh's inequalities for spanning tree measures.

We give a method for computing asymptotic formulas and approximations for the volumes of spectrahedra, based on the maximum-entropy principle from statistical physics. The method gives an approximate volume formula based on a single convex optimization problem of minimizing $-\log \det P$ over the spectrahedron. Spectrahedra can be described as affine slices of the convex cone of positive semi-definite (PSD) matrices, and the method yields efficient deterministic approximation algorithms and asymptotic formulas whenever the number of affine constraints is sufficiently dominated by the dimension of the PSD cone. Our approach is inspired by the work of Barvinok and Hartigan who used an analogous framework for approximately computing volumes of polytopes. Spectrahedra, however, possess a remarkable feature not shared by polytopes, a new fact that we also prove: central sections of the set of density matrices (the quantum version of the simplex) all have asymptotically the same volume. This allows for very general approximation algorithms, which apply to large classes of naturally occurring spectrahedra. We give two main applications of this method. First, we apply this method to what we call the "multi-way Birkhoff spectrahedron" and obtain an explicit asymptotic formula for its volume. This spectrahedron is the set of quantum states with maximal entanglement (i.e., the quantum states having univariant quantum marginals equal to the identity matrix) and is the quantum analog of the multi-way Birkhoff polytope. Second, we apply this method to explicitly compute the asymptotic volume of central sections of the set of density matrices.

We introduce a class of polytopes that we call chainlink polytopes and which allow us to construct infinite families of pairs of non isomorphic rational polytopes with the same Ehrhart quasi-polynomial. Our construction is based on circular fence posets, which admit a non-obvious and non-trivial symmetry in their rank sequences that turns out to be reflected in the polytope level. We introduce the related class of chainlink posets and show that they exhibit the same symmetry properties. We further prove an outstanding conjecture on the unimodality of circular rank polynomials.

We prove a conjecture of Morier-Genoud and Ovsienko that says that rank polynomials of the distributive lattices of lower ideals of fence posets are unimodal. We do this by introducing a related class of circular fence posets and proving a stronger version of the conjecture due to McConville, Sagan and Smyth. We show that the rank polynomials of circular fence posets are symmetric and conjecture that unimodality holds except in some particular cases. We also apply the recent work of Elizalde, Plante, Roby and Sagan on rowmotion on fences and show many of their homomesy results hold for the circular case as well.

We characterize all signed Minkowski sums that define generalized permutahedra, extending results of Ardila-Benedetti-Doker (2010). We use this characterization to give a complete classification of all positive, translation-invariant, symmetric Minkowski linear functionals on generalized permutahedra. We show that they form a simplicial cone and explicitly describe their generators. We apply our results to prove that the linear coefficients of Ehrhart polynomials of generalized permutahedra, which include matroid polytopes, are non-negative, verifying conjectures of De Loera-Haws-Koeppe (2009) and Castillo-Liu (2018) in this case. We also apply this technique to give an example of a solid-angle polynomial of a generalized permutahedron that has negative linear term and obtain inequalities for beta invariants of contractions of matroids.

Anderson's paving conjecture, now known to hold due to the resolution of the Kadison-Singer problem asserts that every zero diagonal Hermitian matrix admits non-trivial pavings with dimension independent bounds. In this paper, we develop a technique extending the arguments of Marcus, Spielman and Srivastava in their solution of the Kadison-Singer problem to show the existence of non-trivial pavings for collections of matrices. We show that given zero diagonal Hermitian contractions $A^{(1)}, \cdots, A^{(k)} \in M_n(\mathbb{C})$ and $ε> 0$, one may find a paving $X_1 \amalg \cdots \amalg X_r = [n]$ where $r \leq 18kε^{-2}$ such that, \[λ_{max} (P_{X_i} A^{(j)} P_{X_i}) < ε, \quad i \in [r], \, j \in [k].\] As a consequence, we get the correct asymptotic estimates for paving general zero diagonal matrices; zero diagonal contractions can be $(O(ε^{-2}),ε)$ paved. As an application, we give a simplified proof wth slightly better estimates of a theorem of Johnson, Ozawa and Schechtman concerning commutator representations of zero trace matrices.

A polynomial $p \in \mathbb{R}[z_1, \cdots, z_n]$ is called real stable if it is non-vanishing whenever all the variables take values in the upper half plane. A well known result of Elliott Lieb and Alan Sokal states that if $p$ and $q$ are $n$ variate real stable polynomials, then the polynomial $q(\partial)p := q(\partial_1, \cdots, \partial_n)p$, is real stable as well. In this paper, we prove analytical estimates on the locations on the zeroes of the real stable polynomial $q(\partial)p$ in the case when both $p$ and $q$ are multiaffine, an important special case, owing to connections to negative dependance in discrete probability. As an application, we prove a general estimate on the expected characteristic polynomials upon sampling from Strongly Rayleigh distributions. We then use this to deduce results concerning two classes of polynomials, mixed characteristic polynomials and mixed determinantal polynomials, that are related to the Kadison-Singer problem.

We apply the techniques developed by Marcus, Spielman and Srivastava, working with principal submatrices in place of rank $1$ decompositions to give an alternate proof of their results on restricted invertibility. We show that one can find well conditioned column submatrices all the way upto the so called modified stable rank. All constructions are algorithmic. A byproduct of these results is an interesting quantitative version of the classical Gauss-Lucas theorem on the critical points of complex polynomials. We show that for any degree $n$ polynomial $p$ and any $c \geq \frac{1}{2}$, the area of the convex hull of the roots of $p^{(cn)}$ is at most $4(c-c^2)$ that of the area of the convex hull of the roots of $p$.

We adapt the arguments of Marcus, Spielman and Srivastava in their proof of the Kadison-Singer problem to prove improved paving estimates. Working with Anderson's paving formulation of Kadison-Singer instead of Weaver's vector balancing version, we show that the machinery of interlacing polyomials due to Marcus, Spielman and Srivastava works in this setting as well. The relevant expected characteristic polynomials turn out to be related to the so called "mixed determinants" that have been carefully studied by Borcea and Branden. This technique allows us to show that any projection with diagonal entries strictly less than $\frac{1}{4}$ can be two paved, matching recent results of Bownik, Casazza, Marcus and Speegle, though our estimates are asymptotically weaker. We also show that any projection with diagonal entries at most $\frac{1}{2}$ can be four paved, yielding improvements over currently known estimates. We also relate the problem of finding optimal paving estimates to bounding the root intervals of a natural one parameter deformation of the characteristic polynomial of a matrix that turns out to have some remarkable combinatorial properties.