Papers by Nicolas Trotignon
77 paper(s) by this author
· All BibTeX
On Detecting $H$-Induced Minors for Small $H$
We consider the $H$-Induced Minor problem: for a fixed graph~$H$, decide whether a given graph $G$ contains $H$ as an induced minor. While the problem is known to be NP-complete for some trees~$H$ on more than $2^{300}$ vertices, the complexity for small trees remains unresolved. In particular, the case where $H$ is the $7$-vertex tree consisting of a path on five vertices with a pendant vertex attached to the second and fourth vertex was a long-standing open problem. We show that this case is polynomial-time solvable by developing algorithms that detect a sequence of carefully chosen substructures. Complementing this, we prove that detecting some of these substructures individually is NP-hard. We also give polynomial-time algorithms for three cases where $H$ is a graph on five vertices (that is not a tree). In this way, we completed the classification of $H$-Induced Minor for graphs $H$ on five vertices and answered an open problem of Dallard, Dumas, Hilaire and Perez (2025).
(Even hole, triangle)-free graphs revisited
We revisit a classical paper about (even hole, triangle)-free graphs [Conforti, Cornuéjols, Kapoor and Vu\v sković, Triangle-free graphs that are signable without even holes, Journal of Graph Theory, 34(3), 204--220, 2000]. In fact, the previous study describes a more general class, the so called triangle-free odd signable graphs, and we further generalise the class to the (theta, triangle, wac)-free graphs (not worth defining in an abstract).
We exhibit a stronger structure theorem, by precisely describing basic classes and separators. We prove that the separators preserve the treewidth and several properties. Some consequences are a recognition algorithm with running time $O(|V(G)|^4|E(G)|)$, a proof that the treewidth of graphs in the class is at most~4 (improving a previous bound of~5), and a simple criterion to decide if a graph in the class is planar.
On the structure of ($4K_1$, $C_4$, $P_6$)-free graphs
Determining the complexity of colouring ($4K_1, C_4$)-free graph is a long open problem. Recently Penev showed that there is a polynomial-time algorithm to colour a ($4K_1, C_4, C_6$)-free graph. In this paper, we will prove that if $G$ is a ($4K_1, C_4, P_6$)-free graph that contains a $C_6$, then $G$ has bounded clique-width. To this purpose, we use a new method to bound the clique-width, that is of independent interest. As a consequence, there is a polynomial-time algorithm to colour ($4K_1, C_4, P_6$)-free graphs.
Pathographs and some (un)decidability results
We introduce pathographs as a framework to study graph classes defined by forbidden structures, including forbidding induced subgraphs, minors, etc. Pathographs approximately generalize s-graphs of Lévêque--Lin--Maffray--Trotignon by the addition of two extra adjacency relations: one between subdivisible edges and vertices called spokes, and one between pairs of subdivisible edges called rungs. We consider the following decision problem: given a pathograph $\mathfrak{H}$ and a finite set of pathographs $\mathcal{F}$, is there an $\mathcal{F}$-free realization of $\mathfrak{H}$? This may be regarded as a generalization of the "graph class containment problem": given two graph classes $S$ and $S'$, is it the case that $S\subseteq S'$? We prove the pathograph realization problem is undecidable in general, but it is decidable in the case that $\mathfrak{H}$ has no rungs (but may have spokes), or if $\mathcal{F}$ is closed under adding edges, spokes, and rungs. We also discuss some potential applications to proving decomposition theorems.
Every Graph is Essential to Large Treewidth
We show that for every graph $H$, there is a hereditary weakly sparse graph class $\mathcal C_H$ of unbounded treewidth such that the $H$-free (i.e., excluding $H$ as an induced subgraph) graphs of $\mathcal C_H$ have bounded treewidth. This refutes several conjectures and critically thwarts the quest for the unavoidable induced subgraphs in classes of unbounded treewidth, a wished-for counterpart of the Grid Minor theorem. We actually show a stronger result: For every positive integer $t$, there is a hereditary graph class $\mathcal C_t$ of unbounded treewidth such that for any graph $H$ of treewidth at most $t$, the $H$-free graphs of $\mathcal C_t$ have bounded treewidth. Our construction is a variant of so-called layered wheels. We also introduce a framework of abstract layered wheels, based on their most salient properties. In particular, we streamline and extend key lemmas previously shown on individual layered wheels. We believe that this should greatly help develop this topic, which appears to be a very strong yet underexploited source of counterexamples.
Lollipops, dense cycles and chords
In 1980, Gupta, Kahn and Robertson proved that every graph $G$ with minimum degree at least $k\geq 2$ contains a cycle $C$ containing at least $k+1$ vertices each having at least $k$ neighbors in $C$ (so $C$ has at least $\frac{(k+1)(k-2)}{2}$ chords). In this work, we go further by showing that some of its edges can be contracted to obtain a graph with high minimum degree (we call such a minor of $C$ a \emph{cyclic minor}). We then investigate further cycles having cliques as cyclic minors, and show that minimum degree at least $O(k^2)$ guarantees a cyclic $K_k$-minor.
Induced Disjoint Paths Without an Induced Minor
We exhibit a new obstacle to the nascent algorithmic theory for classes excluding an induced minor. We indeed show that on the class of string graphs -- which avoids the 1-subdivision of, say, $K_5$ as an induced minor -- Induced 2-Disjoint Paths is NP-complete. So, while $k$-Disjoint Paths, for a fixed $k$, is polynomial-time solvable in general graphs, the absence of a graph as an induced minor does not make its induced variant tractable, even for $k=2$. This answers a question of Korhonen and Lokshtanov [SODA '24], and complements a polynomial-time algorithm for Induced $k$-Disjoint Paths in classes of bounded genus by Kobayashi and Kawarabayashi [SODA '09]. In addition to being string graphs, our produced hard instances are subgraphs of a constant power of bounded-degree planar graphs, hence have bounded twin-width and bounded maximum degree.
We also leverage our new result to show that there is a fixed subcubic graph $H$ such that deciding if an input graph contains $H$ as an induced subdivision is NP-complete. Until now, all the graphs $H$ for which such a statement was known had a vertex of degree at least 4. This answers a question by Chudnovsky, Seymour, and the fourth author [JCTB '13], and by Le [JGT '19]. Finally we resolve another question of Korhonen and Lokshtanov by exhibiting a subcubic graph $H$ without two adjacent degree-3 vertices and such that deciding if an input $n$-vertex graph contains $H$ as an induced minor is NP-complete, and unless the Exponential-Time Hypothesis fails, requires time $2^{Ω(\sqrt n)}$. This complements an algorithm running in subexponential time $2^{O(n^{2/3} \log n)}$ by these authors [SODA '24] under the same technical condition.
Treewidth versus clique number: induced minors
We prove that a hereditary class of graphs is $(\mathsf{tw}, ω)$-bounded if and only if the induced minors of the graphs from the class form a $(\mathsf{tw}, ω)$-bounded class.
A structural description of Zykov and Blanche Descartes graphs
In 1949, Zykov proposed the first explicit construction of triangle-free graphs with arbitrarily large chromatic number. We define a Zykov graph as any induced subgraph of a graph created using Zykov's construction. We give a structural characterization of Zykov graphs based on a specific type of stable set, that we call splitting stable set. It implies that recognizing this class is NP-complete, while being FPT in the treewidth of the input graph. We provide similar results for the Blanche Descartes construction.
Tree independence number III. Thetas, prisms and stars
We prove that for every $t\in \mathbb{N}$, there exists $τ=τ(t)\in \mathbb{N}$ such that every (theta, prism, $K_{1,t}$)-free graph has tree independence number at most $τ$ (where we allow "prisms" to have one path of length zero).
On treewidth and maximum cliques
Published in Innovations in Graph Theory, Volume 2 (2025), pp. 223-243
• View Publication
• BIB
We construct classes of graphs that are variants of the so-called layered wheel. One of their key properties is that while the treewidth is bounded by a function of the clique number, the construction can be adjusted to make the dependance grow arbitrarily. Some of these classes provide counter-examples to several conjectures. In particular, the construction includes hereditary classes of graphs whose treewidth is bounded by a function of the clique number while the tree-independence number is unbounded, thus disproving a conjecture of Dallard, Milanič and Štorgel [Treewidth versus clique number. II. Tree-independence number. Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series B, 164:404-442, 2024.]. The construction can be further adjusted to provide, for any fixed integer $c$, graphs of arbitrarily large treewidth that contain no $K_c$-free graphs of high treewidth, thus disproving a conjecture of Hajebi [Chordal graphs, even-hole-free graphs and sparse obstructions to bounded treewidth, arXiv:2401.01299, 2024].
Unavoidable induced subgraphs in graphs with complete bipartite induced minors
Published in SIAM Journal on Discrete Mathematics, 39(4):2049-2066, 2025
• View Publication
• BIB
We prove that if a graph contains the complete bipartite graph $K_{134, 12}$ as an induced minor, then it contains a cycle of length at most~12 or a theta as an induced subgraph. With a longer and more technical proof, we prove that if a graph contains $K_{3, 4}$ as an induced minor, then it contains a triangle or a theta as an induced subgraph. Here, a \emph{theta} is a graph made of three internally vertex-disjoint chordless paths $P_1 = a \dots b$, $P_2 = a \dots b$, $P_3 = a \dots b$, each of length at least two, such that no edges exist between the paths except the three edges incident to $a$ and the three edges incident to $b$.
A consequence is that excluding a grid and a complete bipartite graph as induced minors is not enough to guarantee a bounded tree-independence number, or even that the treewidth is bounded by a function of the size of the maximum clique, because the existence of graphs with large treewidth that contain no triangles or thetas as induced subgraphs is already known (the so-called layered wheels).
Induced Minor Models. I. Structural Properties and Algorithmic Consequences
A graph $H$ is said to be an induced minor of a graph $G$ if $H$ can be obtained from $G$ by a sequence of vertex deletions and edge contractions. Equivalently, $H$ is an induced minor of $G$ if there exists an induced minor model of $H$ in $G$, that is, a collection of pairwise disjoint subsets of vertices of $G$ labeled by the vertices of $H$, each inducing a connected subgraph in $G$, such that two vertices of $H$ are adjacent if and only if there is an edge in $G$ between the corresponding subsets.
In this paper, we investigate structural properties of induced minor models, including bounds on treewidth and chromatic number of the subgraphs induced by minimal induced minor models. It is known that for some graphs $H$, testing whether a given graph $G$ contains $H$ as an induced minor is an NP-complete problem. Nevertheless, as algorithmic applications of our structural results, we make use of recent developments regarding tree-independence number to show that if $H$ is the $4$-wheel, the $5$-vertex complete graph minus an edge, or a complete bipartite graph $K_{2,q}$, then there is a polynomial-time algorithm to find in a given graph $G$ an induced minor model of $H$ in $G$, if there is one. We also develop an alternative polynomial-time algorithm for recognizing graphs that do not contain $K_{2,3}$ as an induced minor, which revolves around the idea of detecting the induced subgraphs whose presence is forced when the input graph contains $K_{2,3}$ as an induced minor, using the so-called shortest path detector. It turns out that all these induced subgraphs are Truemper configurations.
Graphs without a 3-connected subgraph are 4-colorable
Published in Electronic Journal of Combinatorics, 32(1):#1.26, 2025
• View Publication
• BIB
In 1972, Mader showed that every graph without a 3-connected subgraph is 4-degenerate and thus 5-colorable}. We show that the number 5 of colors can be replaced by 4, which is best possible.
A tamed family of triangle-free graphs with unbounded chromatic number
We construct a hereditary class of triangle-free graphs with unbounded chromatic number, in which every non-trivial graph either contains a pair of non-adjacent twins or has an edgeless vertex cutset of size at most two. This answers in the negative a question of Chudnovsky, Penev, Scott, and Trotignon. The class is the hereditary closure of a family of (triangle-free) twincut graphs $G_1, G_2, \ldots$ such that $G_k$ has chromatic number $k$. We also show that every twincut graph is edge-critical.
When all holes have the same length
For every integer $\ell \geq 7$, we give a structural description of the class of graphs whose chordless cycles of length at least 4 all have length $\ell$.
Burling graphs revisited, part III: Applications to $χ$-boundedness
Published in European Journal of Combinatorics, Volume 116, 2024, 103850
• View Publication
• BIB
The Burling sequence is a sequence of triangle-free graphs of unbounded chromatic number. The class of Burling graphs consists of all the induced subgraphs of the graphs of this sequence. In the first and second parts of this work, we introduced derived graphs, a class of graphs, equal to the class of Burling graphs, and proved several geometric and structural results about them. In this third part, we use those results to find some Burling and non-Burling graphs, and we see some applications of this in the theory of $χ$-boundedness. In particular, we show that several graphs, like $K_5$, some series-parallel graphs that we call necklaces, and some other graphs are not weakly pervasive.
Graphs with all holes the same length
Published in Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series~B, 168:96-158, 2024
• View Publication
• BIB
A graph is "$\ell$-holed" if all its induced cycles of length at least four have length exactly $\ell$. We give a complete description of the $\ell$-holed graphs for each $\ell\ge 7$.
Burling graphs revisited, part II: Structure
Published in European Journal of Combinatorics, Volume 116, 2024, 103849
• View Publication
• BIB
The Burling sequence is a sequence of triangle-free graphs of increasing chromatic number. Any graph which is an induced subgraph of a graph in this sequence is called a Burling graph. These graphs have attracted some attention because they have geometric representations and because they provide counter-examples to several conjectures about bounding the chromatic number in classes of graphs. We recall an equivalent definition of Burling graphs from the first part of this work: the graphs derived from a tree. We then give several structural properties of derived graphs.
Burling graphs revisited, part I: New characterizations
Published in European Journal of Combinatorics, Volume 110,2023,103686
• View Publication
• BIB
The Burling sequence is a sequence of triangle-free graphs of increasing chromatic number. Each of them is isomorphic to the intersection graph of a set of axis-parallel boxes in $R^3$. These graphs were also proved to have other geometrical representations: intersection graphs of line segments in the plane, and intersection graphs of frames, where a frame is the boundary of an axis-aligned rectangle in the plane. We call Burling graph every graph that is an induced subgraph of some graph in the Burling sequence. We give five new equivalent ways to define Burling graphs. Three of them are geometrical, one is of a more graph-theoretical flavour and one is more axiomatic.