arXiv++ Combinatorics

In this survey we describe a recently-developed technique for bounding the number (and controlling the typical structure) of finite objects with forbidden substructures. This technique exploits a subtle clustering phenomenon exhibited by the independent sets of uniform hypergraphs whose edges are sufficiently evenly distributed; more precisely, it provides a relatively small family of 'containers' for the independent sets, each of which contains few edges. We attempt to convey to the reader a general high-level overview of the method, focusing on a small number of illustrative applications in areas such as extremal graph theory, Ramsey theory, additive combinatorics, and discrete geometry, and avoiding technical details as much as possible.

We present a short, self-contained, and purely combinatorial proof of Linnik's theorem: for any $\varepsilon > 0$ there exists a constant $C_\varepsilon$ such that for any $N$, there are at most $C_\varepsilon$ primes $p \leqslant N$ such that the least positive quadratic non-residue modulo $p$ exceeds $N^\varepsilon$.

We study survival among two competing types in two settings: a planar growth model related to two-neighbour bootstrap percolation, and a system of urns with graph-based interactions. In the planar growth model, uncoloured sites are given a colour at rate $0$, $1$ or $\infty$, depending on whether they have zero, one, or at least two neighbours of that colour. In the urn scheme, each vertex of a graph $G$ has an associated urn containing some number of either blue or red balls (but not both). At each time step, a ball is chosen uniformly at random from all those currently present in the system, a ball of the same colour is added to each neighbouring urn, and balls in the same urn but of different colours annihilate on a one-for-one basis. We show that, for every connected graph $G$ and every initial configuration, only one colour survives almost surely. As a corollary, we deduce that in the two-type growth model on $\mathbb{Z}^2$, one of the colours only infects a finite number of sites with probability one. We also discuss generalisations to higher dimensions and multi-type processes, and list a number of open problems and conjectures.

Consider a random sequence of $N$ integers, each chosen uniformly and independently from the set $\{1,\dots,x\}$. Motivated by applications to factorisation algorithms such as Dixon's algorithm, the quadratic sieve, and the number field sieve, Pomerance in 1994 posed the following problem: how large should $N$ be so that, with high probability, this sequence contains a subsequence, the product of whose elements is a perfect square? Pomerance determined asymptotically the logarithm of the threshold for this event, and conjectured that it in fact exhibits a sharp threshold in $N$. More recently, Croot, Granville, Pemantle and Tetali determined the threshold up to a factor of $4/π+ o(1)$ as $x \to \infty$, and made a conjecture regarding the location of the sharp threshold. In this paper we prove both of these conjectures, by determining the sharp threshold for making squares. Our proof combines techniques from combinatorics, probability and analytic number theory; in particular, we use the so-called method of self-correcting martingales in order to control the size of the 2-core of the random hypergraph that encodes the prime factors of our random numbers. Our method also gives a new (and completely different) proof of the upper bound in the main theorem of Croot, Granville, Pemantle and Tetali.

The class of critical bootstrap percolation models in two dimensions was recently introduced by Bollobás, Smith and Uzzell, and the critical threshold for percolation was determined up to a constant factor for all such models by the authors of this paper. Here we develop and refine the techniques introduced in that paper in order to determine a sharp threshold for the Duarte model. This resolves a question of Mountford from 1995, and is the first result of its type for a model with drift.

We consider a dynamical process on a graph $G$, in which vertices are infected (randomly) at a rate which depends on the number of their neighbours that are already infected. This model includes bootstrap percolation and first-passage percolation as its extreme points. We give a precise description of the evolution of this process on the graph $\mathbb{Z}^2$, significantly sharpening results of Dehghanpour and Schonmann. In particular, we determine the typical infection time up to a constant factor for almost all natural values of the parameters, and in a large range we obtain a stronger, sharp threshold.

The chromatic threshold $δ_χ(H,p)$ of a graph $H$ with respect to the random graph $G(n,p)$ is the infimum over $d > 0$ such that the following holds with high probability: the family of $H$-free graphs $G \subset G(n,p)$ with minimum degree $δ(G) \ge dpn$ has bounded chromatic number. The study of the parameter $δ_χ(H) := δ_χ(H,1)$ was initiated in 1973 by Erdős and Simonovits, and was recently determined for all graphs $H$. In this paper we show that $δ_χ(H,p) = δ_χ(H)$ for all fixed $p \in (0,1)$, but that typically $δ_χ(H,p) \ne δ_χ(H)$ if $p = o(1)$. We also make significant progress towards determining $δ_χ(H,p)$ for all graphs $H$ in the range $p = n^{-o(1)}$. In sparser random graphs the problem is somewhat more complicated, and is studied in a separate paper.

The chromatic threshold $δ_χ(H,p)$ of a graph $H$ with respect to the random graph $G(n,p)$ is the infimum over $d > 0$ such that the following holds with high probability: the family of $H$-free graphs $G \subset G(n,p)$ with minimum degree $δ(G) \ge dpn$ has bounded chromatic number. The study of $δ_χ(H) :=δ_χ(H,1)$ was initiated in 1973 by Erdős and Simonovits. Recently $δ_χ(H)$ was determined for all graphs $H$. It is known that $δ_χ(H,p) =δ_χ(H)$ for all fixed $p \in (0,1)$, but that typically $δ_χ(H,p) \ne δ_χ(H)$ if $p = o(1)$. Here we study the problem for sparse random graphs. We determine $δ_χ(H,p)$ for most functions $p = p(n)$ when $H\in\{K_3,C_5\}$, and also for all graphs $H$ with $χ(H) \not\in \{3,4\}$.

We prove that the probability of crossing a large square in quenched Voronoi percolation converges to 1/2 at criticality, confirming a conjecture of Benjamini, Kalai and Schramm from 1999. The main new tools are a quenched version of the box-crossing property for Voronoi percolation at criticality, and an Efron-Stein type bound on the variance of the probability of the crossing event in terms of the sum of the squares of the influences. As a corollary of the proof, we moreover obtain that the quenched crossing event at criticality is almost surely noise sensitive.

In 1987, Kolaitis, Prömel and Rothschild proved that, for every fixed $r \in \mathbb{N}$, almost every $n$-vertex $K_{r+1}$-free graph is $r$-partite. In this paper we extend this result to all functions $r = r(n)$ with $r \leqslant (\log n)^{1/4}$. The proof combines a new (close to sharp) supersaturation version of the Erdős-Simonovits stability theorem, the hypergraph container method, and a counting technique developed by Balogh, Bollobás and Simonovits.

We study the class of monotone, two-state, deterministic cellular automata, in which sites are activated (or 'infected') by certain configurations of nearby infected sites. These models have close connections to statistical physics, and several specific examples have been extensively studied in recent years by both mathematicians and physicists. This general setting was first studied only recently, however, by Bollobás, Smith and Uzzell, who showed that the family of all such 'bootstrap percolation' models on $\mathbb{Z}^2$ can be naturally partitioned into three classes, which they termed subcritical, critical and supercritical. In this paper we determine the order of the threshold for percolation (complete occupation) for every critical bootstrap percolation model in two dimensions. This 'universality' theorem includes as special cases results of Aizenman and Lebowitz, Gravner and Griffeath, Mountford, and van Enter and Hulshof, significantly strengthens bounds of Bollobás, Smith and Uzzell, and complements recent work of Balister, Bollobás, Przykucki and Smith on subcritical models.

We show that, for $pn \to \infty$, the largest set in a $p$-random sub-family of the power set of $\{1, \ldots, n\}$ containing no $k$-chain has size $( k - 1 + o(1) ) p \binom{n}{n/2}$ with high probability. This confirms a conjecture of Osthus, and has been proved independently by Balogh, Mycroft and Treglown.

We study sum-free sets in sparse random subsets of even order abelian groups. In particular, we determine the sharp threshold for the following property: the largest such set is contained in some maximum-size sum-free subset of the group. This theorem extends recent work of Balogh, Morris and Samotij, who resolved the case G = Z_{2n}, and who obtained a weaker threshold (up to a constant factor) in general.

One of the most basic questions one can ask about a graph $H$ is: how many $H$-free graphs on $n$ vertices are there? For non-bipartite $H$, the answer to this question has been well-understood since 1986, when Erdős, Frankl and Rödl proved that there are $2^{(1 + o(1)) ex(n,H)}$ such graphs. For bipartite graphs, however, much less is known: even the weaker bound $2^{O(ex(n,H))}$ has been proven in only a few special cases: for cycles of length four and six, and for some complete bipartite graphs. For even cycles, Bondy and Simonovits proved in the 1970s that ex$(n,C_{2l}) = O( n^{1 + 1/l} )$, and this bound is conjectured to be sharp up to the implicit constant. In this paper we prove that the number of $C_{2l}$-free graphs on $n$ vertices is at most $2^{O(n^{1 + 1/l})}$, confirming a conjecture of Erdős. Our proof uses the hypergraph container method, which was developed recently (and independently) by Balogh, Morris and Samotij, and by Saxton and Thomason, together with a new 'balanced supersaturation theorem' for even cycles. We moreover show that there are at least $2^{(1 + c)ex(n,C_6)}$ $C_6$-free graphs on $n$ vertices for some $c > 0$ and infinitely many values of $n$, disproving a well-known and natural conjecture. As a further application of our method, we essentially resolve the so-called Turán problem on the Erdős-Rényi random graph $G(n,p)$ for both even cycles and complete bipartite graphs.

Two central topics of study in combinatorics are the so-called evolution of random graphs, introduced by the seminal work of Erdős and Rényi, and the family of $H$-free graphs, that is, graphs which do not contain a subgraph isomorphic to a given (usually small) graph $H$. A widely studied problem that lies at the interface of these two areas is that of determining how the structure of a typical $H$-free graph with $n$ vertices and $m$ edges changes as $m$ grows from $0$ to $\text{ex}(n,H)$. In this paper, we resolve this problem in the case when $H$ is a clique, extending a classical result of Kolaitis, Prömel, and Rothschild. In particular, we prove that for every $r \ge 2$, there is an explicit constant $θ_r$ such that, letting $m_r = θ_r n^{2-\frac{2}{r+2}} (\log n)^{1/\left[\binom{r+1}{2}-1\right]}$, the following holds for every positive constant $\varepsilon$. If $m \ge (1+\varepsilon) m_r$, then almost all $K_{r+1}$-free $n$-vertex graphs with $m$ edges are $r$-partite, whereas if $n \ll m \le (1-\varepsilon)m_r$, then almost all of them are not $r$-partite.

The Ramsey number r(K_s,Q_n) is the smallest positive integer N such that every red-blue colouring of the edges of the complete graph K_N on N vertices contains either a red n-dimensional hypercube, or a blue clique on s vertices. Answering a question of Burr and Erdős from 1983, and improving on recent results of Conlon, Fox, Lee and Sudakov, and of the current authors, we show that r(K_s,Q_n) = (s-1) (2^n - 1) + 1 for every s \in \N and every sufficiently large n \in \N.

We study the number of $k$-element sets $A \subset \{1,\ldots,N\}$ with $|A + A| \leq K|A|$ for some (fixed) $K > 0$. Improving results of the first author and of Alon, Balogh, Samotij and the second author, we determine this number up to a factor of $2^{o(k)} N^{o(1)}$ for most $N$ and $k$. As a consequence of this and a further new result concerning the number of sets $A \subset \mathbf{Z}/N\mathbf{Z}$ with $|A +A| \leq c |A|^2$, we deduce that the random Cayley graph on $\mathbf{Z}/N\mathbf{Z}$ with edge density~$\frac{1}{2}$ has no clique or independent set of size greater than $\big( 2 + o(1) \big) \log_2 N$, asymptotically the same as for the Erdős-Rényi random graph. This improves a result of the first author from 2003 in which a bound of $160 \log_2 N$ was obtained. As a second application, we show that if the elements of $A \subset \mathbf{N}$ are chosen at random, each with probability $1/2$, then the probability that $A+A$ misses exactly $k$ elements of $\mathbf{N}$ is equal to $\big( 2 + o(1) \big)^{-k/2}$ as $k \to \infty$.

The areas of Ramsey theory and random graphs have been closely linked ever since Erdős' famous proof in 1947 that the 'diagonal' Ramsey numbers $R(k)$ grow exponentially in $k$. In the early 1990s, the triangle-free process was introduced as a model which might potentially provide good lower bounds for the 'off-diagonal' Ramsey numbers $R(3,k)$. In this model, edges of $K_n$ are introduced one-by-one at random and added to the graph if they do not create a triangle; the resulting final (random) graph is denoted $G_{n,\triangle}$. In 2009, Bohman succeeded in following this process for a positive fraction of its duration, and thus obtained a second proof of Kim's celebrated result that $R(3,k) = Θ\big( k^2 / \log k \big)$. In this paper we improve the results of both Bohman and Kim, and follow the triangle-free process all the way to its asymptotic end. In particular, we shall prove that $$e\big( G_{n,\triangle} \big) \,=\, \left( \frac{1}{2\sqrt{2}} + o(1) \right) n^{3/2} \sqrt{\log n },$$ with high probability as $n \to \infty$. We also obtain several pseudorandom properties of $G_{n,\triangle}$, and use them to bound its independence number, which gives as an immediate corollary $$R(3,k) \, \ge \, \left( \frac{1}{4} - o(1) \right) \frac{k^2}{\log k}.$$ This significantly improves Kim's lower bound, and is within a factor of $4 + o(1)$ of the best known upper bound, proved by Shearer over 25 years ago.

The Ramsey number r(K_3,Q_n) is the smallest integer N such that every red-blue colouring of the edges of the complete graph K_N contains either a red n-dimensional hypercube, or a blue triangle. Almost thirty years ago, Burr and Erdős conjectured that r(K_3,Q_n) = 2^{n+1} - 1 for every n \in \N, but the first non-trivial upper bound was obtained only recently, by Conlon, Fox, Lee and Sudakov, who proved that r(K_3,Q_n) \le 7000 \cdot 2^n. Here we show that r(K_3,Q_n) = (1 + o(1)) 2^{n+1} as n \to \infty.

Many important theorems in combinatorics, such as Szemerédi's theorem on arithmetic progressions and the Erdős-Stone Theorem in extremal graph theory, can be phrased as statements about independent sets in uniform hypergraphs. In recent years, an important trend in the area has been to extend such classical results to the so-called sparse random setting. This line of research culminated recently in the breakthroughs of Conlon and Gowers and of Schacht, who developed general tools for solving problems of this type. In this paper, we provide a third, completely different approach to proving extremal and structural results in sparse random sets. We give a structural characterization of the independent sets in a large class of uniform hypergraphs by showing that every independent set is almost contained in one of a small number of relatively sparse sets. We then derive many interesting results as fairly straightforward consequences of this abstract theorem. In particular, we prove the well-known conjecture of Kohayakawa, Łuczak and Rödl, a probabilistic embedding lemma for sparse graphs. We also give alternative proofs of many of the results of Conlon and Gowers and Schacht, and obtain their natural counting versions, which in some cases are considerably stronger. We moreover prove a sparse version of the Erdős-Frankl-Rödl Theorem on the number of H-free graphs and extend a result of Rödl and Ruciński on Ramsey properties in sparse random graphs to the general, non-symmetric setting. We remark that similar results have been discovered independently by Saxton and Thomason, and that, in parallel to this work, Conlon, Gowers, Samotij and Schacht have proved a sparse analogue of the counting lemma for subgraphs of the random graph G(n,p), which may be viewed as a version of the KŁR conjecture that is stronger in some ways and weaker in others.