arXiv++ Combinatorics

We present a structural classification of constraint satisfaction problems (CSP) described by reflexive complete $2$-edge-coloured graphs. In particular, this classification extends the structural dichotomy for graph homomorphism problems known as the Hell--Nešetřil theorem (1990). Our classification is also efficient: we can check in polynomial time whether the CSP of a reflexive complete $2$-edge-coloured graph is in P or NP-complete, whereas for arbitrary $2$-edge-coloured graphs, this task is NP-complete. We then apply our main result in the context of matrix partition problems and sandwich problems. Firstly, we obtain one of the few algorithmic solutions to general classes of matrix partition problems. And secondly, we present a P vs. NP-complete classification of sandwich problems for matrix partitions.

In this paper, we characterize graphs with circular chromatic number less than 3 in terms of certain balancing labellings studied in the context of signed graphs. In fact, we construct a signed graph which is universal for all such labellings of graphs with circular chromatic number less than $3$, and is closely related to the generic circular triangle-free graph studied by Bodirsky and Guzmán-Pro. Moreover, our universal structure gives rise to a representation of the relation algebra $56_{65}$. We then use this representation to show that the network satisfaction problem described by this relation algebra belongs to NP. This concludes the full classification of the existence of a universal square representation, as well as the complexity of the corresponding network satisfaction problem, for relation algebras with at most four atoms.

The \emph{Sandwich Problem} (SP) for a graph class $\calC$ is the following computational problem. The input is a pair of graphs $(V,E_1)$ and $(V,E_2)$ where $E_1\subseteq E_2$, and the task is to decide whether there is an edge set $E$ where $E_1\subseteq E \subseteq E_2$ such that the graph $(V,E)$ belongs to $\calC$. In this paper we show that many SPs correspond to the constraint satisfaction problem (CSP) of an infinite $2$-edge-coloured graph $H$. We then notice that several known complexity results for SPs also follow from general complexity classifications of infinite-domain CSPs, suggesting a fruitful application of the theory of CSPs to complexity classifications of SPs. We strengthen this evidence by using basic tools from constraint satisfaction theory to propose new complexity results of the SP for several graph classes including line graphs of multigraphs, line graphs of bipartite multigraphs, $K_k$-free perfect graphs, and classes described by forbidding finitely many induced subgraphs, such as $\{I_4,P_4\}$-free graphs, settling an open problem of Alvarado, Dantas, and Rautenbach (2019). We also construct a graph sandwich problem which is in coNP, but neither in P nor coNP-complete (unless P = coNP).

Given a finite set of $2$-edge-coloured graphs $\mathcal F$ and a hereditary property of graphs $\mathcal{P}$, we say that $\mathcal F$ expresses $\mathcal{P}$ if a graph $G$ has the property $\mathcal{P}$ if and only if it admits a $2$-edge-colouring not having any graph in $\mathcal F$ as an induced $2$-edge-coloured subgraph. We show that certain classic hereditary classes are expressible by some set of $2$-edge-coloured graphs on three vertices. We then initiate a systematic study of the following problem. Given a finite set of $2$-edge-coloured graphs $\mathcal F$, structurally characterize the hereditary property expressed by $\mathcal F$. In our main results we describe all hereditary properties expressed by $\mathcal F$ when $\mathcal F$ consists of 2-edge-coloured graphs on three vertices and (1) patterns have at most two edges, or (2) $\mathcal F$ consists of both monochromatic paths and a set of coloured triangles. On the algorithmic side, we consider the $\mathcal F$-free colouring problem, i.e., deciding if an input graph admits an $\mathcal F$-free $2$-edge-colouring. It follows from our structural characterizations, that for all sets considered in (1) and (2) the $\mathcal F$-free colouring problem is solvable in polynomial time. We complement these tractability results with a uniform reduction to boolean constraint satisfaction problems which yield polynomial-time algorithms that recognize most graph classes expressible by a set $\mathcal F$ of $2$-edge-coloured graphs on at most three vertices. Finally, we exhibit some sets $\mathcal F$ such that the $\mathcal F$-free colouring problem is NP-complete.

In recent years, much attention has been placed on the complexity of graph homomorphism problems when the input is restricted to ${\mathbb P}_k$-free and ${\mathbb P}_k$-subgraph-free graphs. We consider the directed version of this research line, by addressing the questions, is it true that digraph homomorphism problems CSP$({\mathbb H})$ have a P versus NP-complete dichotomy when the input is restricted to $\vec{\mathbb P}_k$-free (resp.\ $\vec{\mathbb P}_k$-subgraph-free) digraphs? Our main contribution in this direction shows that if CSP$({\mathbb H})$ is NP-complete, then there is a positive integer $N$ such that CSP$({\mathbb H})$ remains NP-hard even for $\vec{\mathbb P}_N$-subgraph-free digraphs. Moreover, it remains NP-hard for acyclic $\vec{\mathbb P}_N$-subgraph-free digraphs, and becomes polynomial-time solvable for $\vec{\mathbb P}_{N-1}$-subgraph-free acyclic digraphs. We then verify the questions above for digraphs on three vertices and a family of smooth tournaments. We prove these results by establishing a connection between $\mathbb F$-(subgraph)-free algorithmics and constraint satisfaction theory. On the way, we introduce restricted CSPs, i.e., problems of the form CSP$({\mathbb H})$ restricted to yes-instances of CSP$({\mathbb H}')$ -- these were called restricted homomorphism problems by Hell and Nešetřil. Another main result of this paper presents a P versus NP-complete dichotomy for these problems. Moreover, this complexity dichotomy is accompanied by an algebraic dichotomy in the spirit of the finite domain CSP dichotomy.

Given an (infinite) relational structure $\mathbb S$, we say that a finite structure $\mathbb C$ is a minimal finite factor of $\mathbb S$ if for every finite structure $\mathbb A$ there is a homomorphism $\mathbb S\to \mathbb A$ if and only if there is a homomorphism $\mathbb{C} \to \mathbb{A}$. In this brief note we prove that if CSP($\mathbb S$) is in GMSNP, then $\mathbb S$ has a minimal finite factor $\mathbb C$, and moreover, CSP($\mathbb C$) reduces in polynomial time to CSP($\mathbb S$). We discuss two nice applications of this result. First, we see that if a finite promise constraint satisfaction problem PCSP($\mathbb A,\mathbb B$) has a tractable GMSNP sandwich, then it has a tractable finite sandwich. We also show that if $\mathbb G$ is a non-bipartite (possibly infinite) graph with finite chromatic number, and CSP($\mathbb G$) is in GMSNP, then CSP($\mathbb G$) in NP-complete, partially answering a question recently asked by Bodirsky and Guzmán-Pro.

In this paper, we introduce the generic circular triangle-free graph $\mathbb C_3$ and propose a finite axiomatization of its first order theory. In particular, our main results show that a countable graph $G$ embeds into $\mathbb C_3$ if and only if it is a $\{K_3, K_1 + 2K_2, K_1+C_5, C_6\}$-free graph. As a byproduct of this result, we obtain a geometric characterization of finite $\{K_3, K_1 + 2K_2, K_1+C_5, C_6\}$-free graphs, and the (finite) list of minimal obstructions of unit Helly circular-arc graphs with independence number strictly less than three. The circular chromatic number $χ_c(G)$ is a refinement of the classical chromatic number $χ(G)$. We construct $\mathbb C_3$ so that a graph $G$ has circular chromatic number strictly less than three if and only if $G$ maps homomorphically to $\mathbb C_3$. We build on our main results to show that $χ_c(G) < 3$ if and only if $G$ can be extended to a $\{K_3, K_1 + 2K_2, K_1+C_5, C_6\}$-free graph, and in turn, we use this result to reprove an old characterization of $χ_c(G) < 3$ due to Brandt (1999). Finally, we answer a question recently asked by Guzmán-Pro, Hell, and Hernández-Cruz by showing that the problem of deciding for a given finite graph $G$ whether $χ_c(G) < 3$ is NP-complete.

A well-established research line in structural and algorithmic graph theory is characterizing graph classes by listing their minimal obstructions. When this list is finite for some class $\mathcal C$ we obtain a polynomial-time algorithm for recognizing graphs in $\mathcal C$, and from a logic point of view, having finitely many obstructions corresponds to being definable by a universal sentence. However, in many cases we study classes with infinite sets of minimal obstructions, and this might have neither algorithmic nor logic implications for such a class. Some decades ago, Skrien (1982) and Damaschke (1990) introduced finite expressions of graph classes by means of forbidden orientations and forbidden linear orderings, and recently, similar research lines appeared in the literature, such as expressions by forbidden circular orders, by forbidden tree-layouts, and by forbidden edge-coloured graphs. In this paper, we introduce local expressions of graph classes; a general framework for characterizing graph classes by forbidden equipped graphs. In particular, it encompasses all research lines mentioned above, and we provide some new examples of such characterizations. Moreover, we see that every local expression of a class $\mathcal C$ yields a polynomial-time certification algorithm for graphs in $\mathcal C$. Finally, from a logic point of view, we show that being locally expressible corresponds to being definable in the logic SNP introduced by Feder and Vardi (1999).

For a fixed finite set of finite tournaments ${\mathcal F}$, the ${\mathcal F}$-free orientation problem asks whether a given finite undirected graph $G$ has an $\mathcal F$-free orientation, i.e., whether the edges of $G$ can be oriented so that the resulting digraph does not embed any of the tournaments from ${\mathcal F}$. We prove that for every ${\mathcal F}$, this problem is in P or NP-complete. Our proof reduces the classification task to a complete complexity classification of the orientation completion problem for ${\mathcal F}$, which is the variant of the problem above where the input is a directed graph instead of an undirected graph, introduced by Bang-Jensen, Huang, and Zhu (2017). Our proof uses results from the theory of constraint satisfaction, and a result of Agarwal and Kompatscher (2018) about infinite permutation groups and transformation monoids.

A full-homomorphism between a pair of graphs is a vertex mapping that preserves adjacencies and non-adjacencies. For a fixed graph $H$, a full $H$-colouring is a full-homomorphism of $G$ to $H$. A minimal $H$-obstruction is a graph that does not admit a full $H$-colouring, such that every proper induced subgraph of $G$ admits a full $H$-colouring. Feder and Hell proved that for every graph $H$ there is a finite number of minimal $H$-obstructions. We begin this work by describing all minimal obstructions of paths. Then, we study minimal obstructions of regular graphs to propose a description of minimal obstructions of cycles. As a consequence of these results, we observe that for each path $P$ and each cycle $C$, the number of minimal $P$-obstructions and $C$-obstructions is $\mathcal{O}(|V(P)|^2)$ and $\mathcal{O}(|V(C)|^2)$, respectively. Finally, we propose some problems regarding the largest minimal $H$-obstructions, and the number of minimal $H$-obstructions.

Lattice path matroids and bicircular matroids are two well-known classes of transversal matroids. In the seminal work of Bonin and de Mier about structural properties of lattice path matroids, the authors claimed that lattice path matroids significantly differ from bicircular matroids. Recently, it was proved that all cosimple lattice path matroids have positive double circuits, while it was shown that there is a large class of cosimple bicircular matroids with no positive double circuits. These observations support Bonin and de Miers' claim. Finally, Sivaraman and Slilaty suggested studying the intersection of lattice path matroids and bicircular matroids as a possibly interesting research topic. In this work, we exhibit the excluded bicircular matroids for the class of lattice path matroids, and we propose a characterization of the graph family whose bicircular matroids are lattice path matroids. As an application of this characterization, we propose a geometric description of $2$-connected lattice path bicircular matroids.

Colourings and flows are well-known dual notions in Graph Theory. In turn, the definition of flows in graphs naturally extends to flows in oriented matroids. So, the colour-flow duality gives a generalization of Hadwiger's conjecture about graph colourings, to a conjecture about coflows of oriented matroids. The first non-trivial case of Hadwiger's conjecture for oriented matroids reads as follows. If $\mathcal{O}$ is an $M(K_4)$-minor free oriented matroid, then $\mathcal{O}$ has a now-where $3$-coflow, i.e., it is $3$-colourable in the sense of Hochstättler-Nešetřil. The class of generalized series parallel ($GSP$) oriented matroids is a class of $3$-colourable oriented matroids with no $M(K_4)$-minor. So far, the only technique towards proving that all orientations of a class $\mathcal{C}$ of $M(K_4)$-minor free matroids are $GSP$ (and thus $3$-colourable), has been to show that every matroid in $\mathcal{C}$ has a positive coline. Towards proving Hadwiger's conjecture for the class of gammoids, Goddyn, Hochstättler, and Neudauer conjectured that every gammoid has a positive coline. In this work we disprove this conjecture by exhibiting an infinite class of strict gammoids that do not have positive colines. We conclude by proposing a simpler technique for showing that certain oriented matroids are $GSP$. In particular, we recover that oriented lattice path matroids are $GSP$, and we show that oriented cobicircular matroids are $GSP$.

Each hereditary property can be characterized by its set of minimal obstructions; these sets are often unknown, or known but infinite. By allowing extra structure it is sometimes possible to describe such properties by a finite set of forbidden objects. This has been studied most intensely when the extra structure is a linear ordering of the vertex set. For instance, it is known that a graph G is $k$-colourable if and only if $V(G)$ admits a linear ordering $\le$ with no vertices $v_1 \le \cdots \le v_{k+1}$ such that $v_i v_{i+1} \in E(G)$ for every $i \in \{ 1, \dots, k \}$. In this paper, we study such characterizations when the extra structure is a circular ordering of the vertex set. We show that the classes that can be described by finitely many forbidden circularly ordered graphs include forests, circular-arc graphs, and graphs with circular chromatic number less than $k$. In fact, every description by finitely many forbidden circularly ordered graphs can be translated to a description by finitely many forbidden linearly ordered graphs. Nevertheless, our observations underscore the fact that in many cases the circular order descriptions are nicer and more natural.

Several graph properties are characterized as the class of graphs that admit an orientation avoiding finitely many oriented structures. For instance, if $F_k$ is the set of homomorphic images of the directed path on $k+1$ vertices, then a graph is $k$-colourable if and only if it admits an orientation with no induced oriented graph in $F_k$. There is a fundamental question underlying this kind of characterizations: given a graph property, $\mathcal{P}$, is there a finite set of oriented graphs, $F$, such that a graph belongs to $\mathcal{P}$ if and only if it admits an orientation with no induced oriented graph in $F$? We address this question by exhibiting necessary conditions upon certain graph classes to admit such a characterization. Consequently, we exhibit an uncountable family of hereditary classes, for which no such finite set exists. In particular, the class of graphs with no holes of prime length belongs to this family.

In the homomorphism order of digraphs, a duality pair is an ordered pair of digraphs $(G,H)$ such that for any digraph, $D$, $G\to D$ if and only if $D\not\to H$. The directed path on $k+1$ vertices together with the transitive tournament on $k$ vertices is a classic example of a duality pair. This relation between paths and tournaments implies that a graph is $k$-colourable if and only if it admits an orientation with no directed path on more than $k$-vertices. In this work, for every undirected cycle $C$ we find an orientation $C_D$ and an oriented path $P_C$, such that $(P_C,C_D)$ is a duality pair. As a consequence we obtain that there is a finite set, $F_C$, such that an undirected graph is homomorphic to $C$, if and only if it admits an $F_C$-free orientation. As a byproduct of the proposed duality pairs, we show that if $T$ is a tree of height at most $3$, one can choose a dual of $T$ of linear size with respect to the size of $T$.

Given a set $F$ of oriented graphs, a graph $G$ is an $F$-graph if it admits an $F$-free orientation. Building on previous work by Bang-Jensen and Urrutia, we propose a master algorithm that determines if a graph admits an $F$-free orientation when $F$ is a subset of the orientations of $P_3$ and the transitive triangle. We extend previous results of Skrien by studying the class of $F$-graphs, when $F$ is any set of oriented graphs of order three. Structural characterizations for all such sets are provided, except for the so-called perfectly-orientable graphs and one of its subclasses, which remain as open problems.