arXiv++ Combinatorics

For a graph $F$, a graph $G$ is \emph{$F$-free} if it does not contain an induced subgraph isomorphic to $F$. For two graphs $G$ and $H$, an \emph{$H$-coloring} of $G$ is a mapping $f:V(G)\rightarrow V(H)$ such that for every edge $uv\in E(G)$ it holds that $f(u)f(v)\in E(H)$. We are interested in the complexity of the problem $H$-{\sc Coloring}, which asks for the existence of an $H$-coloring of an input graph $G$. In particular, we consider $H$-{\sc Coloring} of $F$-free graphs, where $F$ is a fixed graph and $H$ is an odd cycle of length at least 5. This problem is closely related to the well known open problem of determining the complexity of 3-{\sc Coloring} of $P_t$-free graphs. We show that for every odd $k \geq 5$ the $C_k$-{\sc Coloring} problem, even in the list variant, can be solved in polynomial time in $P_9$-free graphs. The algorithm extends for the case of list version of $C_k$-{\sc Coloring}, where $k$ is an even number of length at least 10. On the other hand, we prove that if some component of $F$ is not a subgraph of a subdividecd claw, then the following problems are NP-complete in $F$-free graphs: a)extension version of $C_k$-{\sc Coloring} for every odd $k \geq 5$, b) list version of $C_k$-{\sc Coloring} for every even $k \geq 6$.

We extend the definition of the chromatic symmetric function $X_G$ to include graphs $G$ with a vertex-weight function $w : V(G) \rightarrow \mathbb{N}$. We show how this provides the chromatic symmetric function with a natural deletion-contraction relation analogous to that of the chromatic polynomial. Using this relation we derive new properties of the chromatic symmetric function, and we give alternate proofs of many fundamental properties of $X_G$.

This paper investigates entropic matroids, that is, matroids whose rank function is given as the Shannon entropy of random variables. In particular, we consider $p$-entropic matroids, for which the random variables each have support of cardinality $p$. We draw connections between such entropic matroids and secret-sharing matroids and show that entropic matroids are linear matroids when $p = 2,3$ but not when $p = 9$. Our results leave open the possibility for $p$-entropic matroids to be linear whenever $p$ is prime, with particular cases proved here. Applications of entropic matroids to coding theory and cryptography are also discussed.

A family of vectors $A \subset [k]^n$ is said to be intersecting if any two elements of $A$ agree on at least one coordinate. We prove, for fixed $k \ge 3$, that the size of a symmetric intersecting subfamily of $[k]^n$ is $o(k^n)$, which is in stark contrast to the case of the Boolean hypercube (where $k =2$). Our main contribution addresses limitations of existing technology: while there is now some spectral machinery, developed by Ellis and the third author, to tackle extremal problems in set theory involving symmetry, this machinery relies crucially on the interplay between up-sets and biased product measures on the Boolean hypercube, features that are notably absent in the problem at hand; here, we describe a method for circumventing these barriers.

We study the disproportionate version of the classical cake-cutting problem: how efficiently can we divide a cake, here $[0,1]$, among $n$ agents with different demands $α_1, α_2, \dots, α_n$ summing to $1$? When all the agents have equal demands of $α_1 = α_2 = \dots = α_n = 1/n$, it is well-known that there exists a fair division with $n-1$ cuts, and this is optimal. For arbitrary demands on the other hand, folklore arguments from algebraic topology show that $O(n\log n)$ cuts suffice, and this has been the state of the art for decades. Here, we improve the state of affairs in two ways: we prove that disproportionate division may always be achieved with $3n-4$ cuts, and give an effective combinatorial procedure to construct such a division. We also offer a topological conjecture that implies that $2n-2$ cuts suffice in general, which would be optimal.

A hole in a graph G is an induced cycle of length at least four; an antihole is a hole in the complement of G. In 2005, Chudnovsky, Cornuejols, Liu, Seymour and Vuskovic showed that it is possible to test in polynomial time whether a graph contains an odd hole or antihole (and thus whether G is perfect). However, the complexity of testing for odd holes has remained open. Indeed, it seemed quite likely that testing for an odd hole was NP-complete: for instance, Bienstock showed that testing if a graph has an odd hole containing a given vertex is NP-complete. In this paper we resolve the question, by giving a polynomial-time algorithm to test whether a graph contains an odd hole. This also gives a new and considerably simpler polynomial-time algorithm that tests for perfection.

Let $x,y\in(0,1]$ and let $A,B,C$ be disjoint nonempty subsets of a graph $G$, where every vertex in $A$ has at least $x|B|$ neighbours in $B$, and every vertex in $B$ has at least $y|C|$ neighbours in $C$. We denote by $φ(x,y)$ the maximum $z$ such that, in all such graphs $G$, there is a vertex $v$ in $C$ that is joined to at least $z|A|$ vertices in $A$ by two-edge paths. The function $φ$ is interesting, and we investigate some of its properties. For instance, we show that it is symmetric in $x$ and $y$, and that it has a discontinuity at $x=y=1/k$ for all integers $k>1$. We raise a number of questions and conjectures.

Let $T$ be a tree such that all its vertices of degree more than two lie on one path, that is, $T$ is a caterpillar subdivision. We prove that there exists $ε>0$ such that for every graph $G$ with $|V(G)|\ge 2$ not containing $T$ as an induced subgraph, either some vertex has at least $ε|V(G)|$ neighbours, or there are two disjoint sets of vertices $A,B$, both of cardinality at least $ε|V(G)|$, where there is no edge joining $A$ and $B$. A consequence is: for every caterpillar subdivision $T$, there exists $c>0$ such that for every graph $G$ containing neither of $T$ and its complement as an induced subgraph, $G$ has a clique or stable set with at least $|V(G)|^c$ vertices. This extends a theorem of Bousquet, Lagoutte and Thomassé [JCTB 2015], who proved the same when $T$ is a path, and a recent theorem of Choromanski, Falik, Liebenau, Patel and Pilipczuk [Electron. J. Combin. 2018], who proved it when $T$ is a "hook".

A graph is "$H$-free" if it has no induced subgraph isomorphic to $H$. A conjecture of Conlon, Fox and Sudakov states that for every graph $H$, there exists $s>0$ such that in every $H$-free graph with $n>1$ vertices, either some vertex has degree at least $sn$, or there are two disjoint sets of vertices, of sizes at least $sn^s$ and $sn$, anticomplete to each other. We prove this holds for a large class of graphs $H$, and we prove that something like it holds for all graphs $H$. Say $H$ is "almost-bipartite" if $H$ is triangle-free and $V(H)$ can be partitioned into a stable set and a set inducing a graph of maximum degree at most one. We prove that the conjecture above holds for when $H$ is almost-bipartite. We also prove a stronger version where instead of excluding $H$ we restrict the number of copies of $H$. We prove some variations on the conjecture, such as: for every graph $H$, there exists $s >0$ such that in every $H$-free graph with $n>1$ vertices, either some vertex has degree at least $sn$, or there are two disjoint sets $A, B$ of vertices with $|A||B| > s n^{1 + s}$, anticomplete to each other.

Let $G$ be a graph, and let $f_G$ be the sum of $(-1)^{|A|}$, over all stable sets $A$. If $G$ is a cycle with length divisible by three, then $f_G= \pm 2$. Motivated by topological considerations, G. Kalai and R. Meshulam made the conjecture that,if no induced cycle of a graph $G$ has length divisible by three, then $|f_G|\le 1$. We prove this conjecture.

The Caccetta-Häggkvist conjecture implies that for every integer $k\ge 1$, if $G$ is a bipartite digraph, with $n$ vertices in each part, and every vertex has out-degree more than $n/(k+1)$, then $G$ has a directed cycle of length at most $2k$. If true this is best possible, and we prove this for $k = 1,2,3,4,6$ and all $k\ge 224,539$. More generally, we conjecture that for every integer $k\ge 1$, and every pair of reals $α, β> 0$ with $kα+β>1$, if $G$ is a bipartite digraph with bipartition $(A,B)$, where every vertex in $A$ has out-degree at least $β|B|$, and every vertex in $B$ has out-degree at least $α|A|$, then $G$ has a directed cycle of length at most $2k$. This implies the Caccetta-Häggkvist conjecture (set $β>0$ and very small), and again is best possible for infinitely many pairs $(α,β)$. We prove this for $k = 1,2$, and prove a weaker statement (that $α+β>2/(k+1)$ suffices) for $k=3,4$.

The Erdos-Hajnal Conjecture asserts that for every graph H there is a constant c > 0 such that every graph G that does not contain H as an induced subgraph has a clique or stable set of cardinality at least |G|^c. In this paper, we prove a conjecture of Liebenau and Pilipczuk, that for every forest H there exists c > 0, such that every graph G contains either an induced copy of H, or a vertex of degree at least c|G|, or two disjoint sets of at least c|G| vertices with no edges between them. It follows that for every forest H there is c > 0 so that if G contains neither H nor its complement as an induced subgraph then there is a clique or stable set of cardinality at least |G|^c.

For an integer $r$, the graph $P_6+rP_3$ has $r+1$ components, one of which is a path on $6$ vertices, and each of the others is a path on $3$ vertices. In this paper we provide a polynomial-time algorithm to test if a graph with no induced subgraph isomorphic to $P_6+rP_3$ is three-colorable. We also solve the list version of this problem, where each vertex is assigned a list of possible colors, which is a subset of $\{1,2,3\}$.

We prove for every graph H there exists a>0 such that, for every graph G with at least two vertices, if no induced subgraph of G is a subdivision of H, then either some vertex of G has at least a|G| neighbours, or there are two disjoint sets A,B of at least a|G| vertices such that no edge joins A and B. It follows that for every graph H, there exists c>0 such that for every graph G, if no induced subgraph of G or its complement is a subdivision of H, then G has a clique or stable set of cardinality at least |G|^c. This is related to the Erdos-Hajnal conjecture.

A graph is called $P_t$-free if it does not contain the path on $t$ vertices as an induced subgraph. Let $H$ be a multigraph with the property that any two distinct vertices share at most one common neighbour. We show that the generating function for (list) graph homomorphisms from $G$ to $H$ can be calculated in subexponential time $2^{O\left(\sqrt{tn\log(n)}\right)}$ for $n=|V(G)|$ in the class of $P_t$-free graphs $G$. As a corollary, we show that the number of 3-colourings of a $P_t$-free graph $G$ can be found in subexponential time. On the other hand, no subexponential time algorithm exists for 4-colourability of $P_t$-free graphs assuming the Exponential Time Hypothesis. Along the way, we prove that $P_t$-free graphs have pathwidth that is linear in their maximum degree.

The Erdos-Hajnal conjecture says that for every graph $H$ there exists $c>0$ such that $\max(α(G),ω(G))\ge n^c$ for every $H$-free graph $G$ with $n$ vertices, and this is still open when $H=C_5$. Until now the best bound known on $\max(α(G),ω(G))$ for $C_5$-free graphs was the general bound of Erdos and Hajnal, that for all $H$, $\max(α(G),ω(G))\ge 2^{Ω(\sqrt{\log n })}$ if $G$ is $H$-free. We improve this when $H=C_5$ to $\max(α(G),ω(G))\ge 2^{Ω(\sqrt{\log n \log \log n})}.$

This is the first paper in a series whose goal is to give a polynomial time algorithm for the $4$-coloring problem and the $4$-precoloring extension problem restricted to the class of graphs with no induced six-vertex path, thus proving a conjecture of Huang. Combined with previously known results this completes the classification of the complexity of the $4$-coloring problem for graphs with a connected forbidden induced subgraph. In this paper we give a polynomial time algorithm that determines if a special kind of precoloring of a $P_6$-free graph has a precoloring extension, and constructs such an extension if one exists. Combined with the main result of the second paper of the series, this gives a complete solution to the problem.

This is the second paper in a series of two. The goal of the series is to give a polynomial time algorithm for the $4$-coloring problem and the $4$-precoloring extension problem restricted to the class of graphs with no induced six-vertex path, thus proving a conjecture of Huang. Combined with previously known results this completes the classification of the complexity of the $4$-coloring problem for graphs with a connected forbidden induced subgraph. In this paper we give a polynomial time algorithm that starts with a $4$-precoloring of a graph with no induced six-vertex path, and outputs a polynomial-size collection of so-called excellent precolorings. Excellent precolorings are easier to handle than general ones, and, in addition, in order to determine whether the initial precoloring can be extended to the whole graph, it is enough to answer the same question for each of the excellent precolorings in the collection. The first paper in the series deals with excellent precolorings, thus providing a complete solution to the problem.

A graph is perfect if the chromatic number of every induced subgraph equals the size of its largest clique, and an algorithm of Grötschel, Lovász, and Schrijver from 1988 finds an optimal colouring of a perfect graph in polynomial time. But this algorithm uses the ellipsoid method, and it is a well-known open question to construct a "combinatorial" polynomial-time algorithm that yields an optimal colouring of a perfect graph. A skew partition in $G$ is a partition $(A,B)$ of $V(G)$ such that $G[A]$ is not connected and $\bar{G}[B]$ is not connected, where $\bar{G}$ denotes the complement graph ; and it is balanced if an additional parity condition of paths in $G$ and $\bar{G}$ is satisfied. In this paper we first give a polynomial-time algorithm that, with input a perfect graph, outputs a balanced skew partition if there is one. Then we use this to obtain a combinatorial algorithm that finds an optimal colouring of a perfect graph with clique number $k$, in time that is polynomial for fixed $k$.

Let $\F$ be a finite family of axis-parallel boxes in $\R^d$ such that $\F$ contains no $k+1$ pairwise disjoint boxes. We prove that if $\F$ contains a subfamily $\M$ of $k$ pairwise disjoint boxes with the property that for every $F\in \F$ and $M\in \M$ with $F \cap M \neq \emptyset$, either $F$ contains a corner of $M$ or $M$ contains $2^{d-1}$ corners of $F$, then $\F$ can be pierced by $O(k)$ points. One consequence of this result is that if $d=2$ and the ratio between any of the side lengths of any box is bounded by a constant, then $\F$ can be pierced by $O(k)$ points. We further show that if for each two intersecting boxes in $\F$ a corner of one is contained in the other, then $\F$ can be pierced by at most $O(k\log\log(k))$ points, and in the special case where $\F$ contains only cubes this bound improves to $O(k)$.