arXiv++ Combinatorics

Mahaney's Theorem states that, assuming $\mathsf{P} \neq \mathsf{NP}$, no NP-hard set can have a polynomially bounded number of yes-instances at each input length. We give an exposition of a very simple unpublished proof of Manindra Agrawal whose ideas appear in Agrawal-Arvind ("Geometric sets of low information content," Theoret. Comp. Sci., 1996). This proof is so simple that it can easily be taught to undergraduates or a general graduate CS audience - not just theorists! - in about 10 minutes, which the author has done successfully several times. We also include applications of Mahaney's Theorem to fundamental questions that bright undergraduates would ask which could be used to fill the remaining hour of a lecture, as well as an application (due to Ikenmeyer, Mulmuley, and Walter, arXiv:1507.02955) to the representation theory of the symmetric group and the Geometric Complexity Theory Program. To this author, the fact that sparsity results on NP-complete sets have an application to classical questions in representation theory says that they are not only a gem of classical theoretical computer science, but indeed a gem of mathematics.

In this paper, we present a new network flow linear programming (LP) model of the standard Assignment Problem (AP) polytope. The model is not meant to be competitive with the existing standard, two-dimensional abstraction of the AP with respect to solution procedures, as it is very-large-scale, with a variable space of dimension m^9, where m is the number of assignments. However, it allows for hard combinatorial optimization problems (COPs) to be solved as "strict" linear programs. Because the size complexity of the model is O(m^9), it affirms "P=NP." Conditions which can be used to assess the validity (or guide the formulations) of other models are developed. Illustrative applications to hard COPs are provided for the Quadratic Assignment (QAP) and Traveling Salesman (TSP) problems. Issues pertaining to the extended formulations "barriers" for the LP modeling of hard COPs are not discussed because the developments in the paper are focused on the AP polytope only, and also because the applicability/non-applicability of those "barriers" in the context of the modeling framework used is thoroughly addressed in a separate paper*. Specific reasons why applications of the proposed modeling approach in variable spaces of dimension less than m^9 may not yield integral LP models are discussed (in an appendix), along with an illustrative numerical example. *: Diaby, M., M. Karwan, and L. Sun [2024]. On modeling NP-Complete problems as polynomial-sized linear programs: Escaping/Side-stepping the "barriers." Available at: arXiv:2304.07716 [cc.CC].

In social networks the {\sc Strong Triadic Closure} is an assignment of the edges with strong or weak labels such that any two vertices that have a common neighbor with a strong edge are adjacent. The problem of maximizing the number of strong edges that satisfy the strong triadic closure was recently shown to be NP-complete for general graphs. Here we initiate the study of graph classes for which the problem is solvable. We show that the problem admits a polynomial-time algorithm for two unrelated classes of graphs: proper interval graphs and trivially-perfect graphs. To complement our result, we show that the problem remains NP-complete on split graphs, and consequently also on chordal graphs. Thus we contribute to define the first border between graph classes on which the problem is polynomially solvable and on which it remains NP-complete.

In this paper, we prove that the numerical-semigroup-gap counting problem is #NP-complete as a main theorem. A numerical semigroup is an additive semigroup over the set of all nonnegative integers. A gap of a numerical semigroup is defined as a positive integer that does not belong to the numerical semigroup. The computation of gaps of numerical semigroups has been actively studied from the 19th century. However, little has been known on the computational complexity. In 2005, Ramirez-Alfonsin proposed a question whether or not the numerical-semigroup-gap counting problem is #P-complete. This work is an answer for his question. For proving the main theorem, we show the #NP-completenesses of other two variants of the numerical-semigroup-gap counting problem.

Given two $k$-graphs $H$ and $F$, a perfect $F$-packing in $H$ is a collection of vertex-disjoint copies of $F$ in $H$ which together cover all the vertices in $H$. In the case when $F$ is a single edge, a perfect $F$-packing is simply a perfect matching. For a given fixed $F$, it is often the case that the decision problem whether an $n$-vertex $k$-graph $H$ contains a perfect $F$-packing is NP-complete. Indeed, if $k \geq 3$, the corresponding problem for perfect matchings is NP-complete whilst if $k=2$ the problem is NP-complete in the case when $F$ has a component consisting of at least $3$ vertices. In this paper we give a general tool which can be used to determine classes of (hyper)graphs for which the corresponding decision problem for perfect $F$-packings is polynomial time solvable. We then give three applications of this tool: (i) Given $1\leq \ell \leq k-1$, we give a minimum $\ell$-degree condition for which it is polynomial time solvable to determine whether a $k$-graph satisfying this condition has a perfect matching; (ii) Given any graph $F$ we give a minimum degree condition for which it is polynomial time solvable to determine whether a graph satisfying this condition has a perfect $F$-packing; (iii) We also prove a similar result for perfect $K$-packings in $k$-graphs where $K$ is a $k$-partite $k$-graph. For a range of values of $\ell,k$ (i) resolves a conjecture of Keevash, Knox and Mycroft whilst (ii) answers a question of Yuster in the negative. In many cases our results are best possible in the sense that lowering the minimum degree condition means that the corresponding decision problem becomes NP-complete.

A graph $G$ covers a graph $H$ if there exists a locally bijective homomorphism from $G$ to $H$. We deal with regular covers where this homomorphism is prescribed by the action of a semiregular subgroup of $\textrm{Aut}(G)$. We study computational aspects of regular covers that have not been addressed before. The decision problem RegularCover asks for given graphs $G$ and $H$ whether $G$ regularly covers $H$. When $|H|=1$, this problem becomes Cayley graph recognition for which the complexity is still unresolved. Another special case arises for $|G| = |H|$ when it becomes the graph isomorphism problem. Our main result is an involved FPT algorithm solving RegularCover for planar inputs $G$ in time $O^*(2^{e(H)/2})$ where $e(H)$ denotes the number of edges of $H$. The algorithm is based on dynamic programming and employs theoretical results proved in a related structural paper. Further, when $G$ is 3-connected, $H$ is 2-connected or the ratio $|G|/|H|$ is an odd integer, we can solve the problem RegularCover in polynomial time. In comparison, Bílka et al. (2011) proved that testing general graph covers is NP-complete for planar inputs $G$ when $H$ is a small fixed graph such as $K_4$ or $K_5$.

A sequence of vertices in a graph $G$ with no isolated vertices is called a total dominating sequence if every vertex in the sequence totally dominates at least one vertex that was not totally dominated by preceding vertices in the sequence, and, at the end all vertices of $G$ are totally dominated (by definition a vertex totally dominates its neighbors). The maximum length of a total dominating sequence is called the Grundy total domination number, $γ_{\rm gr}^t(G)$, of $G$, as introduced in [B. Brešar, M.A. Henning, and D. F. Rall, Total dominating sequences in graphs, Discrete Math. 339 (2016), 1165--1676]. In this paper we continue the investigation of this concept, mainly from the algorithmic point of view. While it was known that the decision version of the problem is NP-complete in bipartite graphs, we show that this is also true if we restrict to split graphs. A linear time algorithm for determining the Grundy total domination number of an arbitrary tree $T$ is presented, based on the formula $γ_{\rm gr}^t(T)=2τ(T)$, where $τ(T)$ is the vertex cover number of $T$. A similar efficient algorithm is presented for bipartite distance-hereditary graphs. Using the modular decomposition of a graph, we present a frame for obtaining polynomial algorithms for this problem in classes of graphs having relatively simple modular subgraphs. In particular, a linear algorithm for determining the Grundy total domination number of $P_4$-tidy graphs is presented. In addition, we prove a realization result by exhibiting a family of graphs $G_k$ such that $γ_{\rm gr}^t(G_k)=k$, for any $k\in{\mathbb{Z}^+}\setminus\{1,3\}$, and showing that there are no graphs $G$ with $γ_{\rm gr}^t(G)\in \{1,3\}$. We also present such a family, which has minimum possible order and size among all graphs with Grundy total domination number equal to $k$.

A graph H is a square root of a graph G if G can be obtained from H by adding an edge between any two vertices in H that are of distance 2. The Square Root problem is that of deciding whether a given graph admits a square root. This problem is only known to be NP-complete for chordal graphs and polynomial-time solvable for non-trivial minor-closed graph classes and a very limited number of other graph classes. We prove that Square Root is O(n)-time solvable for graphs of maximum degree 5 and O(n^4)-time solvable for graphs of maximum degree at most 6.

The main result of the paper is motivated by the following two, apparently unrelated graph optimization problems: (A) as an extension of Edmonds' disjoint branchings theorem, characterize digraphs comprising $k$ disjoint branchings $B_i$ each having a specified number $μ_i$ of arcs, (B) as an extension of Ryser's maximum term rank formula, determine the largest possible matching number of simple bipartite graphs complying with degree-constraints. The solutions to these problems and to their generalizations will be obtained from a new min-max theorem on covering a supermodular function by a simple degree-constrained bipartite graph. A specific feature of the result is that its minimum cost extension is already NP-complete. Therefore classic polyhedral tools themselves definitely cannot be sufficient for solving the problem, even though they make some good service in our approach.

Let $G$ be a graph with degree sequence $d_1\geq \ldots \geq d_n$. Slater proposed $s\ell(G)=\min\{ s: (d_1+1)+\cdots+(d_s+1)\geq n\}$ as a lower bound on the domination number $γ(G)$ of $G$. We show that deciding the equality of $γ(G)$ and $s\ell(G)$ for a given graph $G$ is NP-complete but that one can decide efficiently whether $γ(G)>s\ell(G)$ or $γ(G)\leq \left(\left\lceil\ln \left(\frac{n(G)}{s\ell(G)}\right)\right\rceil+1\right)s\ell(G)$. For real numbers $α$ and $β$ with $α\geq \max\{ 0,β\}$, let ${\cal G}(α,β)$ be the class of non-null graphs $G$ such that every non-null subgraph $H$ of $G$ has at most $αn(H)-β$ many edges. Generalizing a result of Desormeaux, Haynes, and Henning, we show that $γ(G)\leq (2α+1)s\ell(G)-2β$ for every graph $G$ in ${\cal G}(α,β)$ with $α\leq \frac{3}{2}$. Furthermore, we show that $γ(G)/s\ell(G)$ is bounded for graphs $G$ in ${\cal G}(α,β)$ if and only if $α<2$. For an outerplanar graph $G$ with $s\ell(G)\geq 2$, we show $γ(G)\leq 6s\ell(G)-6$. In analogy to $s\ell(G)$, we propose $s\ell_t(G)=\min\{ s: d_1+\cdots+d_s\geq n\}$ as a lower bound on the total domination number. Strengthening results due to Raczek as well as Chellali and Haynes, we show that $s\ell_t(T)\geq \frac{n+2-n_1}{2}$ for every tree $T$ of order $n$ at least $2$ with $n_1$ endvertices.

In this paper we study the class of bi-arc digraphs, important from two seemingly unrelated perspectives. On the one hand, they are precisely the digraphs that admit certain polymorphisms of interest in the study of constraint satisfaction problems; on the other hand, they are a very broad generalization of interval graphs. Bi-arc digraphs is the class of digraphs that admit conservative semilattice polymorphisms. There is much interest in understanding structures that admit particular types of polymorphisms, and especially in their recognition algorithms. (Such problems are referred to as metaproblems.) Surprisingly, the class of bi-arc digraphs also describes the class of digraphs that admit certain other kinds of conservative polymorphisms. Thus solving the recognition problem for bi-arc digraphs solves the metaproblem for digraphs for several types of conservative polymorphisms. The complexity of the recognition problem for digraphs with conservative semilattice polymorphisms was an open problem, while it was known to be NP-complete for certain more complex relational structures. We complement our result by providing a complete dichotomy classification of which general relational structures have polynomial or NP-complete recognition problems for the existence of conservative semilattice polymorphisms. Bi-arc digraphs also generalizes the class of interval graphs; in fact it reduces to the class of interval graphs for symmetric and reflexive digraphs. It is much broader than interval graphs and includes other generalizations of interval graphs such as co-threshold tolerance graphs and adjusted interval digraphs. Yet, it is still a reasonable extension of interval graphs, in the sense that it keeps much of the appeal of interval graphs. Our main result is a forbidden obstruction characterization of, and a polynomial recognition for, the class of bi-arc digraphs.

Biró et al. (1992) introduced $H$-graphs, intersection graphs of connected subgraphs of a subdivision of a graph $H$. They are related to many classes of geometric intersection graphs, e.g., interval graphs, circular-arc graphs, split graphs, and chordal graphs. We negatively answer the 25-year-old question of Biró et al. which asks if $H$-graphs can be recognized in polynomial time, for a fixed graph $H$. We prove that it is NP-complete if $H$ contains the diamond graph as a minor. We provide a polynomial-time algorithm recognizing $T$-graphs, for each fixed tree $T$. When $T$ is a star $S_d$ of degree $d$, we have an $O(n^{3.5})$-time algorithm. We give FPT- and XP-time algorithms solving the minimum dominating set problem on $S_d$-graphs and $H$-graphs parametrized by $d$ and the size of $H$, respectively. The algorithm for $H$-graphs adapts to an XP-time algorithm for the independent set and the independent dominating set problems on $H$-graphs. If $H$ contains the double-triangle as a minor, we prove that $H$-graphs are GI-complete and that the clique problem is APX-hard. The clique problem can be solved in polynomial time if $H$ is a cactus graph. When a graph $G$ has a Helly $H$-representation, the clique problem can be solved in polynomial time. We show that both the $k$-clique and the list $k$-coloring problems are solvable in FPT-time on $H$-graphs (parameterized by $k$ and the treewidth of $H$). In fact, these results apply to classes of graphs with treewidth bounded by a function of the clique number. We observe that $H$-graphs have at most $n^{O(\|H\|)}$ minimal separators which allows us to apply the meta-algorithmic framework of Fomin et al. (2015) to show that for each fixed $t$, finding a maximum induced subgraph of treewidth $t$ can be done in polynomial time. When $H$ is a cactus, we improve the bound to $O(\|H\|n^2)$.

In this paper we study three substructures in hypergraphs that generalize the notion of an Euler tour in a graph. A flag-traversing tour of a hypergraph corresponds to an Euler tour of its incidence graph, hence complete characterization of hypergraphs with an Euler tour follows from Euler's Theorem. An Euler tour is a closed walk that traverses each edge of the hypergraph exactly once; and an Euler family is a family of closed walks that cannot be concatenated and that jointly traverse each edge of the hypergraph exactly once. Lonc and Naroski have shown that the problem of existence of an Euler tour is NP-complete even on a very restricted subclass of 3-uniform hypergraphs, while we show that the problem of existence of an Euler family is polynomial on the class of all hypergraphs. Furthermore, we examine the necessary conditions for a hypergraph to admit an Euler family (Euler tour, respectively); we show that while these necessary conditions are sufficient for connected graphs, they are not sufficient for general hypergraphs. On the other hand, we exhibit a new class of hypergraphs for which these necessary conditions are also sufficient, extending a result by Lonc and Naroski. We give a partial characterization of hypergraphs with an Euler family (Euler tour, respectively) in terms of the intersection graph of the hypergraph, and a complete (but not easy to verify) characterization in terms of the incidence graph. For hypergraphs with an Euler family, we give a complete verifiable characterization using a theorem of Lovász, and then show that every 3-uniform hypergraph without cut edges admits an Euler family. Finally, we show that a hypergraph admits an Euler family if and only if it can be decomposed into cycles, and exhibit a relationship between 2-factors in a hypergraph and eulerian properties of its dual.

Permutation Pattern Matching (or PPM) is a decision problem whose input is a pair of permutations $π$ and $τ$, represented as sequences of integers, and the task is to determine whether $τ$ contains a subsequence order-isomorphic to $π$. Bose, Buss and Lubiw proved that PPM is NP-complete on general inputs. We show that PPM is NP-complete even when $π$ has no decreasing subsequence of length 3 and $τ$ has no decreasing subsequence of length 4. This provides the first known example of PPM being hard when one or both of $π$ and $σ$ are restricted to a proper hereditary class of permutations. This hardness result is tight in the sense that PPM is known to be polynomial when both $π$ and $τ$ avoid a decreasing subsequence of length 3, as well as when $π$ avoids a decreasing subsequence of length 2. The result is also tight in another sense: we will show that for any hereditary proper subclass C of the class of permutations avoiding a decreasing sequence of length 3, there is a polynomial algorithm solving PPM instances where $π$ is from C and $τ$ is arbitrary. We also obtain analogous hardness and tractability results for the class of so-called skew-merged patterns. From these results, we deduce a complexity dichotomy for the PPM problem restricted to $π$ belonging to $Av(ρ)$, where $Av(ρ)$ denotes the class of permutations avoiding a permutation $ρ$. Specifically, we show that the problem is polynomial when $ρ$ is in the set {1, 12, 21, 132, 213, 231, 312}, and it is NP-complete for any other $ρ$.

The complexity of graph isomorphism (GraphIso) is a famous unresolved problem in theoretical computer science. For graphs $G$ and $H$, it asks whether they are the same up to a relabeling of vertices. In 1981, Lubiw proved that list restricted graph isomorphism (ListIso) is NP-complete: for each $u \in V(G)$, we are given a list ${\mathfrak L}(u) \subseteq V(H)$ of possible images of $u$. After 35 years, we revive the study of this problem and consider which results for GraphIso translate to ListIso. We prove the following: 1) When GraphIso is GI-complete for a class of graphs, it translates into NP-completeness of ListIso. 2) Combinatorial algorithms for GraphIso translate into algorithms for ListIso: for trees, planar graphs, interval graphs, circle graphs, permutation graphs, bounded genus graphs, and bounded treewidth graphs. 3) Algorithms based on group theory do not translate: ListIso remains NP-complete for cubic colored graphs with sizes of color classes bounded by 8. Also, ListIso allows to classify results for the graph isomorphism problem. Some algorithms are robust and translate to ListIso. A fundamental problem is to construct a combinatorial polynomial-time algorithm for cubic graph isomorphism, avoiding group theory. By the 3rd result, ListIso is NP-hard for them, so no robust algorithm for cubic graph isomorphism exists, unless P = NP.

We study the computational complexity of the Buttons \& Scissors game and obtain sharp thresholds with respect to several parameters. Specifically we show that the game is NP-complete for $C = 2$ colors but polytime solvable for $C = 1$. Similarly the game is NP-complete if every color is used by at most $F = 4$ buttons but polytime solvable for $F \leq 3$. We also consider restrictions on the board size, cut directions, and cut sizes. Finally, we introduce several natural two-player versions of the game and show that they are PSPACE-complete.

The goal of this paper is to prove that several variants of deciding whether a poset can be (weakly) embedded into a small Boolean lattice, or to a few consecutive levels of a Boolean lattice, are NP-complete, answering a question of Griggs and of Patkos. As an equivalent reformulation of one of these problems, we also derive that it is NP-complete to decide whether a given graph can be embedded to the two middle levels of some hypercube.

We investigate new graph classes of bounded mim-width, strictly extending interval graphs and permutation graphs. The graphs $K_t \boxminus K_t$ and $K_t \boxminus S_t$ are graphs obtained from the disjoint union of two cliques of size $t$, and one clique of size $t$ and one independent set of size $t$ respectively, by adding a perfect matching. We prove that : (1) interval graphs are $(K_3\boxminus S_3)$-free chordal graphs; and $(K_t\boxminus S_t)$-free chordal graphs have mim-width at most $t-1$, (2) permutation graphs are $(K_3\boxminus K_3)$-free co-comparability graphs; and $(K_t\boxminus K_t)$-free co-comparability graphs have mim-width at most $t-1$, (3) chordal graphs and co-comparability graphs have unbounded mim-width in general. We obtain several algorithmic consequences; for instance, while Minimum Dominating Set is NP-complete on chordal graphs, it can be solved in time $n^{\mathcal{O}(t)}$ on $(K_t\boxminus S_t)$-free chordal graphs. The third statement strengthens a result of Belmonte and Vatshelle stating that either those classes do not have constant mim-width or a decomposition with constant mim-width cannot be computed in polynomial time unless $P=NP$. We generalize these ideas to bigger graph classes. We introduce a new width parameter sim-width, of stronger modelling power than mim-width, by making a small change in the definition of mim-width. We prove that chordal graphs and co-comparability graphs have sim-width at most 1. We investigate a way to bound mim-width for graphs of bounded sim-width by excluding $K_t\boxminus K_t$ and $K_t\boxminus S_t$ as induced minors or induced subgraphs, and give algorithmic consequences. Lastly, we show that circle graphs have unbounded sim-width, and thus also unbounded mim-width.

Given a graph $G$ possibly with multiple edges but no loops, denote by $Δ$ the {\it maximum degree}, $μ$ the {\it multiplicity}, $χ'$ the {\it chromatic index} and $χ_f'$ the {\it fractional chromatic index} of $G$, respectively. It is known that $Δ\le χ_f' \le χ' \le Δ+ μ$, where the upper bound is a classic result of Vizing. While deciding the exact value of $χ'$ is a classic NP-complete problem, the computing of $χ_f'$ is in polynomial time. In fact, it is shown that if $χ_f' > Δ$ then $χ_f'= \max \frac{|E(H)|}{\lfloor |V(H)|/2\rfloor}$, where the maximality is over all induced subgraphs $H$ of $G$. Gupta\,(1967), Goldberg\,(1973), Andersen\,(1977), and Seymour\,(1979) conjectured that $χ'=\lceilχ_f'\rceil$ if $χ'\ge Δ+2$, which is commonly referred as Goldberg's conjecture. In this paper, we show that if $χ' >Δ+\sqrt[3]{Δ/2}$ then $χ'=\lceilχ_f'\rceil$. The previous best known result is for graphs with $χ'> Δ+\sqrt{Δ/2}$ obtained by Scheide, and by Chen, Yu and Zang, independently. It has been shown that Goldberg's conjecture is equivalent to the following conjecture of Jakobsen: {\it For any positive integer $m$ with $m\ge 3$, every graph $G$ with $χ'>\frac{m}{m-1}Δ+\frac{m-3}{m-1}$ satisfies $χ'=\lceilχ_f'\rceil$.} Jakobsen's conjecture has been verified for $m$ up to 15 by various researchers in the last four decades. We show that it is true for $m\le 23$. Moreover, we show that Goldberg's conjecture holds for graphs $G$ with $Δ\leq 23$ or $|V(G)|\leq 23$.

A $k$-coloring of a graph $G=(V,E)$ is called semi-equitable if there exists a partition of its vertex set into independent subsets $V_1,\ldots,V_k$ in such a way that $|V_1| \notin \{\lceil |V|/k\rceil, \lfloor |V|/k \rfloor\}$ and $||V_i|-|V_j|| \leq 1$ for each $i,j=2,\ldots,k$. The color class $V_1$ is called non-equitable. In this note we consider the complexity of semi-equitable $k$-coloring, $k\geq 4$, of the vertices of a cubic or subcubic graph $G$. In particular, we show that, given a $n$-vertex subcubic graph $G$ and constants $ε> 0$, $k \geq 4$, it is NP-complete to obtain a semi-equitable $k$-coloring of $G$ whose non-equitable color class is of size $s$ if $s \geq n/3+εn$, and it is polynomially solvable if $s \leq n/3$.