arXiv++ Combinatorics

The combinatorial discrepancy of arithmetic progressions inside $[N] := \{1, \ldots, N\}$ is the smallest integer $D$ for which $[N]$ can be colored with two colors so that any arithmetic progression in $[N]$ contains at most $D$ more elements from one color class than the other. Bounding the discrepancy of such set systems is a classical problem in discrepancy theory. More recently, this problem was generalized to arithmetic progressions in grids like $[N]^d$ (Valk{ó}) and $[N_1]\times \ldots \times [N_d]$ (Fox, Xu, and Zhou). In the latter setting, Fox, Xu, and Zhou gave upper and lower bounds on the discrepancy that match within a $\frac{\log |Ω|}{\log \log |Ω|}$ factor, where $Ω:= [N_1]\times \ldots \times [N_d]$ is the ground set. In this work, we use the connection between factorization norms and discrepancy to improve their upper bound to be within a $\sqrt{\log|Ω|}$ factor from the lower bound. We also generalize Fox, Xu, and Zhou's lower bound, and our upper bounds to arithmetic progressions in arbitrary convex bodies.

The determinant lower bound of Lovasz, Spencer, and Vesztergombi [European Journal of Combinatorics, 1986] is a powerful general way to prove lower bounds on the hereditary discrepancy of a set system. In their paper, Lovasz, Spencer, and Vesztergombi asked if hereditary discrepancy can also be bounded from above by a function of the hereditary discrepancy. This was answered in the negative by Hoffman, and the largest known multiplicative gap between the two quantities for a set system of $m$ substes of a universe of size $n$ is on the order of $\max\{\log n, \sqrt{\log m}\}$. On the other hand, building on work of Matoušek [Proceedings of the AMS, 2013], recently Jiang and Reis [SOSA, 2022] showed that this gap is always bounded up to constants by $\sqrt{\log(m)\log(n)}$. This is tight when $m$ is polynomial in $n$, but leaves open what happens for large $m$. We show that the bound of Jiang and Reis is tight for nearly the entire range of $m$. Our proof relies on a technique of amplifying discrepancy via taking Kronecker products, and on discrepancy lower bounds for a set system derived from the discrete Haar basis.

Given vectors $v_1,\dots,v_n\in\mathbb{R}^d$ and a matroid $M=([n],I)$, we study the problem of finding a basis $S$ of $M$ such that $\det(\sum_{i \in S}v_i v_i^\top)$ is maximized. This problem appears in a diverse set of areas such as experimental design, fair allocation of goods, network design, and machine learning. The current best results include an $e^{2k}$-estimation for any matroid of rank $k$ and a $(1+ε)^d$-approximation for a uniform matroid of rank $k\ge d+\frac dε$, where the rank $k\ge d$ denotes the desired size of the optimal set. Our main result is a new approximation algorithm with an approximation guarantee that depends only on the dimension $d$ of the vectors and not on the size $k$ of the output set. In particular, we show an $(O(d))^{d}$-estimation and an $(O(d))^{d^3}$-approximation for any matroid, giving a significant improvement over prior work when $k\gg d$. Our result relies on the existence of an optimal solution to a convex programming relaxation for the problem which has sparse support; in particular, no more than $O(d^2)$ variables of the solution have fractional values. The sparsity results rely on the interplay between the first-order optimality conditions for the convex program and matroid theory. We believe that the techniques introduced to show sparsity of optimal solutions to convex programs will be of independent interest. We also give a randomized algorithm that rounds a sparse fractional solution to a feasible integral solution to the original problem. To show the approximation guarantee, we utilize recent works on strongly log-concave polynomials and show new relationships between different convex programs studied for the problem. Finally, we use the estimation algorithm and sparsity results to give an efficient deterministic approximation algorithm with an approximation guarantee that depends solely on the dimension $d$.

It is well-known that for every $N \geq 1$ and $d \geq 1$ there exist point sets $x_1, \dots, x_N \in [0,1]^d$ whose discrepancy with respect to the Lebesgue measure is of order at most $(\log N)^{d-1} N^{-1}$. In a more general setting, the first author proved together with Josef Dick that for any normalized measure $μ$ on $[0,1]^d$ there exist points $x_1, \dots, x_N$ whose discrepancy with respect to $μ$ is of order at most $(\log N)^{(3d+1)/2} N^{-1}$. The proof used methods from combinatorial mathematics, and in particular a result of Banaszczyk on balancings of vectors. In the present note we use a version of the so-called transference principle together with recent results on the discrepancy of red-blue colorings to show that for any $μ$ there even exist points having discrepancy of order at most $(\log N)^{d-\frac12} N^{-1}$, which is almost as good as the discrepancy bound in the case of the Lebesgue measure.

Combinatorial discrepancy is a complexity measure of a collection of sets which quantifies how well the sets in the collection can be simultaneously balanced. More precisely, we are given an n-point set $P$, and a collection $\mathcal{F} = \{F_1, ..., F_m\}$ of subsets of $P$, and our goal is color $P$ with two colors, red and blue, so that the maximum over the $F_i$ of the absolute difference between the number of red elements and the number of blue elements (the discrepancy) is minimized. Combinatorial discrepancy has many applications in mathematics and computer science, including constructions of uniformly distributed point sets, and lower bounds for data structures and private data analysis algorithms. We investigate the combinatorial discrepancy of geometrically defined systems, in which $P$ is an n-point set in $d$-dimensional space ,and $\mathcal{F}$ is the collection of subsets of $P$ induced by dilations and translations of a fixed convex polytope $B$. Such set systems include systems of sets induced by axis-aligned boxes, whose discrepancy is the subject of the well known Tusnady problem. We prove new discrepancy upper and lower bounds for such set systems by extending the approach based on factorization norms previously used by the author and Matousek. We improve the best known upper bound for the Tusnady problem by a logarithmic factor, using a result of Banaszczyk on signed series of vectors. We extend this improvement to any arbitrary convex polytope $B$ by using a decomposition due to Matousek. Using Fourier analytic techniques, we also prove a nearly matching discrepancy lower bound for sets induced by any fixed bounded polytope $B$ satisfying a certain technical condition. We also outline applications of our results to geometric discrepancy, data structure lower bounds, and differential privacy.

The $γ_2$ norm of a real $m\times n$ matrix $A$ is the minimum number $t$ such that the column vectors of $A$ are contained in a $0$-centered ellipsoid $E\subseteq\mathbb{R}^m$ which in turn is contained in the hypercube $[-t, t]^m$. We prove that this classical quantity approximates the \emph{hereditary discrepancy} $\mathrm{herdisc}\ A$ as follows: $γ_2(A) = {O(\log m)}\cdot \mathrm{herdisc}\ A$ and $\mathrm{herdisc}\ A = O(\sqrt{\log m}\,)\cdotγ_2(A) $. Since $γ_2$ is polynomial-time computable, this gives a polynomial-time approximation algorithm for hereditary discrepancy. Both inequalities are shown to be asymptotically tight. We then demonstrate on several examples the power of the $γ_2$ norm as a tool for proving lower and upper bounds in discrepancy theory. Most notably, we prove a new lower bound of $Ω(\log^{d-1} n)$ for the \emph{$d$-dimensional Tusnády problem}, asking for the combinatorial discrepancy of an $n$-point set in $\mathbb{R}^d$ with respect to axis-parallel boxes. For $d>2$, this improves the previous best lower bound, which was of order approximately $\log^{(d-1)/2}n$, and it comes close to the best known upper bound of $O(\log^{d+1/2}n)$, for which we also obtain a new, very simple proof.

We show that the hereditary discrepancy of homogeneous arithmetic progressions is lower bounded by $n^{1/O(\log \log n)}$. This bound is tight up to the constant in the exponent. Our lower bound goes via proving an exponential lower bound on the discrepancy of set systems of subcubes of the boolean cube $\{0, 1\}^d$.

The Komlos conjecture in discrepancy theory states that for some constant K and for any m by n matrix A whose columns lie in the unit ball there exists a +/- 1 vector x such that the infinity norm of Ax is bounded above by K. This conjecture also implies the Beck-Fiala conjecture on the discrepancy of bounded degree hypergraphs. Here we prove a natural relaxation of the Komlos conjecture: if the columns of A are assigned unit real vectors rather than +/- 1 then the Komlos conjecture holds with K=1. Our result rules out the possibility of a counterexample to the conjecture based on semidefinite programming. It also opens the way to proving tighter efficient (polynomial-time computable) upper bounds for the conjecture using semidefinite programming techniques.