arXiv++ Combinatorics

Given a tournament $T$, Aboulker, Aubian, Charbit, and Lopes (2023) defined its clique number $\vecω(T)$ as the minimum clique number of a backedge graph of $T$, and raised the question: Which classes of tournaments are polynomially $\vecχ$-bounded? Aboulker, Duron, Jacob, Kimbrough, Thomassé, and this work's authors (2026) showed that this holds for classes of tournaments whose arc sets may be written as the union of a bounded number of comparability digraphs. What about classes of tournaments that do not admit such a decomposition? The crossing tournaments of Nguyen, Scott, and Seymour (2025) are an example of such a class, as shown in the aforementioned 2026 work; we show that nonetheless crossing tournaments are polynomially $\vecχ$-bounded by adapting a method of Davies and McCarty (2021) and Davies (2022). We additionally show that we cannot extend this result for crossing tournaments to tournaments with chordal graphs as backedge graphs.

Aboulker, Aubian, Charbit, and Lopes (2023) defined the clique number of a tournament to be the minimum clique number of one of its backedge graphs. Here we show that if $T$ is a tournament of sufficiently large clique number, then $T$ contains a subtournament of large clique number from one of two simple families of tournaments. In particular, large clique number is always certified by a bounded-size set. This answers a question of Aboulker, Aubian, Charbit, and Lopes (2023), and gives new insight into a line of research initiated by Kim and Kim (2018) into unavoidable subtournaments in tournaments with large dichromatic number.

Lovász proved that two graphs $G$ and $H$ are isomorphic if $\hom(K,G) = \hom(K,H)$ for all graphs $K$, where $\hom(G_1,G_2)$ denotes the number of homomorphisms from $G_1$ to $G_2$. Dvořák showed that it suffices to count homomorphisms from all $2$-degenerate graphs $K$. On the other hand, for several interesting graph classes $\mathcal{M}$, it has been shown that there exist non-isomorphic graphs $G$ and $H$ such that $\hom(K,G)=\hom(K,H)$ for all $K\in \mathcal{M}$. Most such classes are minor-closed classes and Roberson conjectured that every proper minor-closed and union-closed graph class $\mathcal{M}$ has the property of there existing non-isomorphic graphs that are indistinguishable by homomorphism counts from $\mathcal{M}$. There has been an effort to prove Roberson's conjecture as it is believed that minor-closed classes play a special role in the context of homomorphism indistinguishability. We show that this special role, if so, must be shared, by proving an analogue of Roberson's conjecture holds for a rich family of non-minor-closed classes. Namely, we prove that for any proper immersion-closed and union-closed class $\mathcal{M}$, there exist non-isomorphic graphs $G$ and $H$ such that $\hom(K,G) = \hom(K,H)$ for all $K \in \mathcal{M}$. This extends a result of Roberson on homomorphism indistinguishability over bounded degree graphs, and gives an almost full picture since our result cannot be extended in the natural way, that is, by replacing immersions with topological minors, due to a result of Neuen and Seppelt.

We characterize all orientations of cycles $C$ for which for every fixed $\varepsilon > 0$ there exists a constant $c \geq 1$ such that every digraph $D$ without loops or parallel arcs with $χ(D) \geq c$ and minimum out-degree at least $\varepsilon |V(D)|$ contains $C$ as a subdigraph. This generalizes a result of Thomassen.

Lovász et al. proved that every $6$-edge-connected graph has a nowhere-zero $3$-flow. In fact, they proved a more technical statement which says that there exists a nowhere zero $3$-flow that extends the flow prescribed on the incident edges of a single vertex $z$ with bounded degree. We extend this theorem of Lovász et al. to allow $z$ to have arbitrary degree, but with the additional assumption that there is another vertex $x$ with large degree and no small cut separating $x$ and $z$. Using this theorem, we prove two results regarding the generation of minimal graphs with the property that prescribing the edges incident to a vertex with specific flow does not extend to a nowhere-zero $3$-flow. We use this to further strengthen the theorem of Lovász et al., as well as make progress on a conjecture of Li et al.

There is no known polynomial-time algorithm for graph isomorphism testing, but elementary combinatorial "refinement" algorithms seem to be very efficient in practice. Some philosophical justification is provided by a classical theorem of Babai, Erdős and Selkow: an extremely simple polynomial-time combinatorial algorithm (variously known as "naïve refinement", "naïve vertex classification", "colour refinement" or the "1-dimensional Weisfeiler-Leman algorithm") yields a so-called canonical labelling scheme for "almost all graphs". More precisely, for a typical outcome of a random graph $G(n,1/2)$, this simple combinatorial algorithm assigns labels to vertices in a way that easily permits isomorphism-testing against any other graph. We improve the Babai-Erdős-Selkow theorem in two directions. First, we consider randomly perturbed graphs, in accordance with the smoothed analysis philosophy of Spielman and Teng: for any graph $G$, naïve refinement becomes effective after a tiny random perturbation to $G$ (specifically, the addition and removal of $O(n\log n)$ random edges). Actually, with a twist on naïve refinement, we show that $O(n)$ random additions and removals suffice. These results significantly improve on previous work of Gaudio-Rácz-Sridhar, and are in certain senses best-possible. Second, we complete a long line of research on canonical labelling of random graphs: for any $p$ (possibly depending on $n$), we prove that a random graph $G(n,p)$ can typically be canonically labelled in polynomial time. This is most interesting in the extremely sparse regime where $p$ has order of magnitude $c/n$; denser regimes were previously handled by Bollobás, Czajka-Pandurangan, and Linial-Mosheiff. Our proof also provides a description of the automorphism group of a typical outcome of $G(n,p_n)$ (slightly correcting a prediction of Linial-Mosheiff).

We prove the Strong Nine Dragon Tree Conjecture is true if we replace the edge bound with $d + \big\lceil k \big\lfloor\frac{d-1}{k+1}\big\rfloor \big(\frac{d}{k+1} - \frac{1}{2} \big\lceil\frac{d}{k+1}\big\rceil \big)\big\rceil \leq d + \frac{k}{2} \cdot \big(\frac{d}{k+1}\big)^2$. More precisely: let $G$ be a graph, let $d$ and $k$ be positive integers and $γ(G) = \max_{H \subseteq G, v(H) \geq 2} \frac{e(H)}{v(H) - 1}$. If $γ(G) \leq k + \frac{d}{d + k + 1}$, then there is a partition of $E(G)$ into $k + 1$ forests, where in one forest every connected component has at most $d + \big\lceil k \big\lfloor\frac{d-1}{k+1}\big\rfloor \big(\frac{d}{k+1} - \frac{1}{2} \big\lceil\frac{d}{k+1}\big\rceil \big)\big\rceil$ edges.

The arboricity $Γ(G)$ of an undirected graph $G =(V,E)$ is the minimal number $k$ such that $E$ can be partitioned into $k$ forests on $V$. Nash-Williams' formula states that $k = \lceil γ(G) \rceil$, where $γ(G)$ is the maximum of $\frac{|E_{H}|}{|V_{H}|-1}$ over all subgraphs $(V_H , E_H )$ of $G$ with $|V_H | \geq 2$. The Strong Nine Dragon Tree Conjecture states that if $γ(G) \leq k + \frac{d}{d+k+1}$ for $k, d \in \mathbb{N}$, then there is a partition of the edge set of $G$ into $k + 1$ forests on $V$ such that one forest has at most $d$ edges in each connected component. Here we prove the Strong Nine Dragon Tree Conjecture when $d \leq 2(k +1)$, which is a new result for all $(k, d)$ such that $d > k + 1$. In fact, we prove a stronger theorem. We prove that a weaker sparsity notion, called $(k, d)$-sparseness, suffices to give the decomposition, under the assumption that the graph decomposes into $k+1$ forests. This is a new result for all $(k, d)$ where $d > 1$, and improves upon the recent resolution of the Overfull Nine Dragon Tree Theorem for all $(k, d)$ when $d \leq 2(k +1)$. As a corollary, we obtain that planar graphs of girth five decompose into a forest and a forest where every component has at most four edges, and by duality, we obtain that $5$-edge-connected planar graphs have a $\frac{4}{5}$-thin tree, improving a result of the authors that $5$-edge-connected planar graphs have a $\frac{5}{6}$-thin tree

We consider the 4-precoloring extension problem in \emph{planar near-Eulerian-triangulations}, i.e., plane graphs where all faces except possibly for the outer one have length three, all vertices not incident with the outer face have even degree, and exactly the vertices incident with the outer face are precolored. We give a necessary topological condition for the precoloring to extend, and give a complete characterization when the outer face has length at most five and when all vertices of the outer face have odd degree and are colored using only three colors.

The pseudoforest version of the Strong Nine Dragon Tree Conjecture states that if a graph $G$ has maximum average degree $\text{mad}(G) = 2 \max_{H \subseteq G} \frac{e(G)}{v(G)}$ at most $2(k + \frac{d}{k+d+1})$, then it has a decomposition into $k+1$ pseudoforests where in one pseudoforest $F$ the components of $F$ have at most $d$ edges. This was proven in 2020. We strengthen this theorem by showing that we can find such a decomposition where additionally $F$ is acyclic, the diameter of the components of $F$ is at most $2\ell + 2$, where $\ell = \lfloor\frac{d-1}{k+1} \rfloor$, and at most $2\ell + 1$ if $d \equiv 1 \bmod k+1$. Furthermore, for any component $K$ of $F$ and any $z \in \mathbb N$, we have $diam(K) \leq 2z$ if $e(K) \geq d - z(k-1) + 1$. We also show that both diameter bounds are best possible as an extension for both the Strong Nine Dragon Tree Conjecture for pseudoforests and its original conjecture for forests. In fact, they are still optimal even if we only enforce $F$ to have any constant maximum degree, instead of enforcing every component of $F$ to have at most $d$ edges.

We continue a line of research which studies which hereditary families of digraphs have bounded dichromatic number. For a class of digraphs $\mathcal{C}$, a hero in $\mathcal{C}$ is any digraph $H$ such that $H$-free digraphs in $\mathcal{C}$ have bounded dichromatic number. We show that if $F$ is an oriented star of degree at least five, the only heroes for the class of $F$-free digraphs are transitive tournaments. For oriented stars $F$ of degree exactly four, we show the only heroes in $F$-free digraphs are transitive tournaments, or possibly special joins of transitive tournaments. Aboulker et al. characterized the set of heroes of $\{H, K_{1} + \vec{P_{2}}\}$-free digraphs almost completely, and we show the same characterization for the class of $\{H, rK_{1} + \vec{P_{3}}\}$-free digraphs. Lastly, we show that if we forbid two "valid" orientations of brooms, then every transitive tournament is a hero for this class of digraphs.

A $k$-subcolouring of a graph $G$ is a function $f:V(G) \to \{0,\ldots,k-1\}$ such that the set of vertices coloured $i$ induce a disjoint union of cliques. The subchromatic number, $χ_{\textrm{sub}}(G)$, is the minimum $k$ such that $G$ admits a $k$-subcolouring. Nešetřil, Ossona de Mendez, Pilipczuk, and Zhu (2020), recently raised the problem of finding tight upper bounds for $χ_{\textrm{sub}}(G^2)$ when $G$ is planar. We show that $χ_{\textrm{sub}}(G^2)\le 43$ when $G$ is planar, improving their bound of 135. We give even better bounds when the planar graph $G$ has larger girth. Moreover, we show that $χ_{\textrm{sub}}(G^{3})\le 95$, improving the previous bound of 364. For these we adapt some recent techniques of Almulhim and Kierstead (2022), while also extending the decompositions of triangulated planar graphs of Van den Heuvel, Ossona de Mendez, Quiroz, Rabinovich and Siebertz (2017), to planar graphs of arbitrary girth. Note that these decompositions are the precursors of the graph product structure theorem of planar graphs. We give improved bounds for $χ_{\textrm{sub}}(G^p)$ for all $p$, whenever $G$ has bounded treewidth, bounded simple treewidth, bounded genus, or excludes a clique or biclique as a minor. For this we introduce a family of parameters which form a gradation between the strong and the weak colouring numbers. We give upper bounds for these parameters for graphs coming from such classes. Finally, we give a 2-approximation algorithm for the subchromatic number of graphs coming from any fixed class with bounded layered cliquewidth. In particular, this implies a 2-approximation algorithm for the subchromatic number of powers $G^p$ of graphs coming from any fixed class with bounded layered treewidth (such as the class of planar graphs). This algorithm works even if the power $p$ and the graph $G$ is unknown.

For some $k \in \mathbb{Z}_{\geq 0}\cup \infty$, we call a linear forest $k$-bounded if each of its components has at most $k$ edges. We will say a $(k,\ell)$-bounded linear forest decomposition of a graph $G$ is a partition of $E(G)$ into the edge sets of two linear forests $F_k,F_\ell$ where $F_k$ is $k$-bounded and $F_\ell$ is $\ell$-bounded. We show that the problem of deciding whether a given graph has such a decomposition is NP-complete if both $k$ and $\ell$ are at least $2$, NP-complete if $k\geq 9$ and $\ell =1$, and is in P for $(k,\ell)=(2,1)$. Before this, the only known NP-complete cases were the $(2,2)$ and $(3,3)$ cases. Our hardness result answers a question of Bermond et al. from 1984. We also show that planar graphs of girth at least nine decompose into a linear forest and a matching, which in particular is stronger than $3$-edge-colouring such graphs.

The arboricity $Γ(G)$ of an undirected graph $G = (V,E)$ is the minimal number such that $E$ can be partitioned into $Γ(G)$ forests. Nash-Williams' formula states that $k = \lceil γ(G) \rceil$, where $γ(G)$ is the maximum of ${|E_H|}/(|V_H| -1)$ over all subgraphs $(V_H, E_H)$ of $G$ with $|V_H| \geq 2$. The Strong Nine Dragon Tree Conjecture states that if $γ(G) \leq k + \frac{d}{d+k+1}$ for $k, d \in \mathbb N_0$, then there is a partition of the edge set of $G$ into $k+1$ forests such that one forest has at most $d$ edges in each connected component. We settle the conjecture for $d \leq k + 1$. For $d \leq 2(k+1)$, we cannot prove the conjecture, however we show that there exists a partition in which the connected components in one forest have at most $d + \lceil k \cdot \frac{d}{k+1} \rceil - k$ edges. As an application of this theorem, we show that every $5$-edge-connected planar graph $G$ has a $\frac{5}{6}$-thin spanning tree. This theorem is best possible, in the sense that we cannot replace $5$-edge-connected with $4$-edge-connected, even if we replace $\frac{5}{6}$ with any positive real number less than $1$. This strengthens a result of Merker and Postle which showed $6$-edge-connected planar graphs have a $\frac{18}{19}$-thin spanning tree.

We prove that it is NP-hard to decide whether a graph is the square of a 6-apex graph. This shows that the square root problem is not tractable for squares of sparse graphs (or even graphs from proper minor-closed classes).

For $t \ge 2$, let us call a digraph $D$ \emph{t-chordal} if all induced directed cycles in $D$ have length equal to $t$. In a previous paper, we asked for which $t$ it is true that $t$-chordal graphs with bounded clique number have bounded dichromatic number. Recently, Aboulker, Bousquet, and de Verclos answered this in the negative for $t=3$, that is, they gave a construction of $3$-chordal digraphs with clique number at most $3$ and arbitrarily large dichromatic number. In this paper, we extend their result, giving for each $t \ge 3$ a construction of digraphs with clique number at most $3$ and arbitrarily large dichromatic number, thus answering our question in the negative. On the other hand, we show that a more restricted class, digraphs with no induced directed cycle of length less than $t$, and no induced directed $t$-vertex path, have bounded dichromatic number if their clique number is bounded. We also show the following complexity result: for fixed $t \ge 2$, the problem of determining whether a digraph is $t$-chordal is coNP-complete.

We propose local versions of Hadwiger's Conjecture, where only balls of radius $Ω(\log(v(G)))$ around each vertex are required to be $K_{t}$-minor-free. We ask: if a graph is locally-$K_{t}$-minor-free, is it $t$-colourable? We show that the answer is yes when $t \leq 5$, even in the stronger setting of list-colouring, and we complement this result with a $O(\log v(G))$-round distributed colouring algorithm in the LOCAL model. Further, we show that for large enough values of $t$, we can list-colour locally-$K_{t}$-minor-free graphs with $13\cdot \max\left\{h(t),\left\lceil \frac{31}{2}(t-1) \right\rceil \right\})$colours, where $h(t)$ is any value such that all $K_{t}$-minor-free graphs are $h(t)$-list-colourable. We again complement this with a $O(\log v(G))$-round distributed algorithm.

We prove that for every $n$, there is a graph $G$ with $χ(G) \geq n$ and $ω(G) \leq 3$ such that every induced subgraph $H$ of $G$ with $ω(H) \leq 2$ satisfies $χ(H) \leq 4$. This disproves a well-known conjecture. Our construction is a digraph with bounded clique number, large dichromatic number, and no induced directed cycles of odd length at least 5.

For a positive integer $k$, the $k$-recolouring graph of a graph $G$ has as vertex set all proper $k$-colourings of $G$ with two $k$-colourings being adjacent if they differ by the colour of exactly one vertex. A result of Dyer et al. regarding graphs of bounded degeneracy implies that the $7$-recolouring graphs of planar graphs, the $5$-recolouring graphs of triangle-free planar graphs and the $4$-recolouring graphs planar graphs of girth at least six are connected. On the other hand, there are planar graphs whose $6$-recolouring graph is disconnected, triangle-free planar graphs whose $4$-recolouring graph is disconnected and planar graphs of any given girth whose $3$-recolouring graph is disconnected. The main result of this paper consists in showing, via a novel application of the discharging method, that the $4$-recolouring graph of every planar graph of girth five is connected. This completes the classification of the connectedness of the recolouring graph for planar graphs of given girth. We also prove some theorems regarding the diameter of the recolouring graph of planar graphs.

We prove that every triangle-free $4$-critical graph $G$ satisfies $e(G) \geq \frac{5v(G)+2}{3}$. This result gives a unified proof that triangle-free planar graphs are $3$-colourable, and that graphs of girth at least five which embed in either the projective plane, torus, or Klein Bottle are $3$-colourable, which are results of Grötzsch, Thomassen, and Thomas and Walls. Our result is nearly best possible, as Davies has constructed triangle-free $4$-critical graphs $G$ such that $e(G) = \frac{5v(G) + 4}{3}$. To prove this result, we prove a more general result characterizing sparse $4$-critical graphs with few vertex-disjoint triangles.