arXiv++ Combinatorics

A corollary of Hall's marriage theorem is that a sufficient condition for a list $(V_1, \ldots ,V_m)$ of sets to have a system of distinct representatives is that $|V_i|\ge deg_{\{V_1, \ldots ,V_m\}}(v)$ for every $i\in [m]$ and $v \in \bigcup_{i\in [m]}V_i$. This we dub a {\em global} condition. A folklore result is that a {\em local} condition - that the inequality holds for pairs $i,v$ for which $v \in V_i$ - suffices. These are special cases of a general type of results - large sets, whose elements are sparse in some sense, have a system of representatives that is independent in a related graph. We study two such scenarios, in both of which each $V_i$ is replaced by a $k$-uniform hypergraph $H_i$, the representatives are hyperedges, and distinctness is replaced by disjointness. In one setting the sparsity is measured by the degrees of vertices in the hypergraphs, in the other by the degrees of vertices in the line graph. The proofs use the topological version of Hall's theorem. In particular, we shall use a lower bound on the topological connectivity of the independence complex of a graph, defined by vector representations. We also provide short proofs of the local infinite version, known as the ``Milner-Shelah theorem''.

Given a hypergraph with edges of size at most 3, the 3-set cover problem asks to determine the minimum size of a family of edges which covers the vertex set. As the problem is NP-hard, it is natural to consider its fractional (linear programming) relaxation, which provides a lower bound on the value of the optimal solution. The ratio between the actual value and that of the fractional relaxation is called the integrality gap. A classic bound of Lovász implies that the integrality gap in this problem is at most 11/6. This has been improved to 5/3 by Fujito and Okumura. Here we prove that the integrality gap is at most 3/2, which is best possible. A corollary of this result is that the vertex set of any 3-uniform, regular hypergraph on n vertices can be covered by n/2 (or fewer) edges. This solves the k=3 case of a problem of de A. Moreira and Kohayakawa. As another application, we derive a certain variant of the Gale-Shapley stable marriage theorem for triples.

A digraph $G$ is weightable if its edges can be weighted with real numbers such that the total weight in each directed cycle equals 1. There are several equivalent conditions: that $G$ admits a 0/1-weighting with the same property, or that $G$ contains no subdivided "double-cycle" as a subdigraph, or that for every triple of vertices, all directed cycles containing all three pass through them in the same cyclic order. And there is quite a rich supply of such digraphs: for instance, any digraph drawn in the plane such that each of its directed cycles rotates clockwise around the origin is weightable (let us call such digraphs "circular"), and there are weightable planar digraphs with much more complicated structure than this. Until now the general structure of weightable digraphs was not known, and that is our objective in this paper. We will show that: - there is a construction that builds every planar weightable digraph from circular digraphs; and - there is a (different) construction that builds every weightable digraph from planar ones. We derive a poly-time algorithm to test if a digraph is weightable.

Let $\mathcal{M}$ and $\mathcal{N}$ be two matroids on the same ground set $V$. Let $A_1,\dots,A_{2n-1}$ be sets which are independent in both $\mathcal{M}$ and $\mathcal{N}$, satisfying $|A_i|\geq \textrm{min}(i,n)$ for all $i$. We show that there exists a partial rainbow set of size $n$, which is independent in both $\mathcal{M}$ and $\mathcal{N}$. This is a common generalization of rainbow matching results for bipartite graphs by Aharoni, Berger, Kotlar, and Ziv, and for the intersection of two matroid by Kotlar and Ziv.

A result [The intersection of a matroid and a simplicial complex, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 358] from 2006 of Aharoni and the first author of this paper states that for any two positive integers $p,q$, where $p$ divides $q$, if a matroid $\mathcal{M}$ is $p$-colorable and a matroid $\mathcal{N}$ is $q$-colorable then $\mathcal{M} \cap \mathcal{N}$ is $(p+q)$-colorable. In this paper we show that the assumption that $p$ divides $q$ is in fact redundant, and we also prove that $\mathcal{M} \cap \mathcal{N}$ is even $p+q$ list-colorable. The result uses topology and relies on a new parameter yielding a lower bound for the topological connectivity of the intersection of two matroids.

It is known that in matroids the difference between the chromatic number and the fractional chromatic number is smaller than 1, and that the list chromatic number is equal to the chromatic number. We investigate the gap within these pairs of parameters for hypergraphs that are the intersection of a given number k of matroids. We prove that in such hypergraphs the list chromatic number is at most k times the chromatic number and at most 2k-1 times the maximum chromatic number among the k matroids. We study the relationship between three polytopes associated with k-sets of matroids, and connect them to bounds on the fractional chromatic number of the intersection of the members of the k-set. This also connects to bounds on the matroidal matching and covering number of the intersection of the members of the k-set. The tools used are in part topological.

A Young diagram $Y$ is called wide if every sub-diagram $Z$ formed by a subset of the rows of $Y$ dominates $Z'$, the conjugate of $Z$. A Young diagram $Y$ is called Latin if its squares can be assigned numbers so that for each $i$, the $i$th row is filled injectively with the numbers $1, \ldots ,a_i$, where $a_i$ is the length of $i$th row of $Y$, and every column is also filled injectively. A conjecture of Chow and Taylor, publicized by Chow, Fan, Goemans, and Vondrak is that a wide Young diagram is Latin. We prove a dual version of the conjecture.

Sivaraman conjectured that if $G$ is a graph with no induced even cycle then there exist sets $X_1, X_2 \subseteq V(G)$ satisfying $V(G) = X_1 \cup X_2$ such that the induced graphs $G[X_1]$ and $G[X_2]$ are both chordal. We prove this conjecture in the special case where $G$ contains no sector wheel, namely, a pair $(H, w)$ where $H$ is an induced cycle of $G$ and $w$ is a vertex in $V(G) \setminus V(H)$ such that $N(w) \cap H$ is either $V(H)$ or a path with at least three vertices.

A pair $(A,B)$ of hypergraphs is called orthogonal if $|a \cap b|=1$ for every pair of edges $a \in A$ and $b \in B$. An orthogonal pair of hypergraphs is called a loom if each of its two members is the set of minimum covers of the other. Looms appear naturally in the context of a conjecture of Gyárfás and Lehel on the covering number of cross-intersecting hypergraphs. We study their properties and ways of construction, and prove special cases of a conjecture that if true would imply the Gyárfás--Lehel conjecture.

When does a graph admit a tree-decomposition in which every bag has small diameter? For finite graphs, this is a property of interest in algorithmic graph theory, where it is called having bounded ``tree-length''. We will show that this is equivalent to being ``boundedly quasi-isometric to a tree'', which for infinite graphs is a much-studied property from metric geometry. One object of this paper is to tie these two areas together. We will prove that there is a tree-decomposition in which each bag has small diameter, if and only if there is a map $φ$ from $V(G)$ into the vertex set of a tree $T$, such that for all $u,v\in V(G)$, the distances $d_G(u,v), d_T(φ(u),φ(v))$ differ by at most a constant. A ``geodesic loaded cycle'' in $G$ is a pair $(C,F)$, where $C$ is a cycle of $G$ and $F\subseteq E(C)$, such that for every pair $u,v$ of vertices of $C$, one of the paths of $C$ between $u,v$ contains at most $d_G(u,v)$ $F$-edges, where $d_G(u,v)$ is the distance between $u,v$ in $G$. We will show that a graph $G$ admits a tree-decomposition in which every bag has small diameter, if and only if $|F|$ is small for every geodesic loaded cycle $(C,F)$. Our proof is an extension of an algorithm to approximate tree-length in finite graphs by Dourisboure and Gavoille. In metric geometry, there is a similar theorem that characterizes when a graph is quasi-isometric to a tree, ``Manning's bottleneck criterion''. The goal of this paper is to tie all these concepts together, and add a few more related ideas. For instance, we prove a conjecture of Rose McCarty, that $G$ admits a tree-decomposition in which every bag has small diameter, if and only if for all vertices $u,v,w$ of $G$, some ball of small radius meets every path joining two of $u,v,w$.

The Caccetta-Häggkvist conjecture (denoted below CHC) states that the directed girth (the smallest length of a directed cycle) $dgirth(D)$ of a directed graph $D$ on $n$ vertices is at most $\lceil \frac{n}{δ^+(D)}\rceil$, where $δ^+(D)$ is the minimum out-degree of~$D$. We consider a version involving all out-degrees, not merely the minimum one, and prove that if $D$ does not contain a sink, then $dgirth(D) \le 2 \sum_{v\in V(D)} \frac{1}{deg^+(v)+1}$. In the spirit of a generalization of the CHC to rainbow cycles in \cite{ADH2019}, this suggests the conjecture that given non-empty sets $F_1, \ldots,F_n$ of edges of $K_n$, there exists a rainbow cycle of length at most $2\sum_{1\le i \le n}\frac{1}{|F_i|+1}$. We prove a bit stronger result when $1\le |F_i|\le 2$, thereby strengthening a result of DeVos et. al \cite{DDFGGHMM2021}. We prove a logarithmic bound on the rainbow girth in the case that the sets $F_i$ are triangles.

A conjecture of the first two authors is that $n$ matchings of size $n$ in any graph have a rainbow matching of size $n-1$. We prove a lower bound of $\frac{2}{3}n-1$, improving on the trivial $\frac{1}{2}n$, and an analogous result for hypergraphs. For $\{C_3,C_5\}$-free graphs and for disjoint matchings we obtain a lower bound of $\frac{3n}{4}-O(1)$. We also discuss a conjecture on rainbow alternating paths, that if true would yield a lower bound of $n-\sqrt{2n}$. We prove the non-alternating (ordinary paths) version of this conjecture.

A d-partite hypergraph is called *fractionally balanced* if there exists a non-negative, not identically zero, function on its edge set that has constant degrees in each vertex side. Using a topological version of Hall's theorem we prove lower bounds on the matching number of such hypergraphs. These bounds yield rainbow versions of the KKM theorem for products of simplices, which in turn are used to obtain some results on multiple-cake division, and on rainbow matchings in families of d-intervals.

We give a polynomial-time algorithm that, with input a graph $G$ and two vertices $u,v$ of $G$, decides whether there is an induced $uv$-path that is longer than the shortest $uv$-path.

A conjecture of Alon, Pach and Solymosi, which is equivalent to the celebrated Erdős-Hajnal Conjecture, states that for every tournament $S$ there exists $ε(S)>0$ such that if $T$ is an $n$-vertex tournament that does not contains $S$ as a subtournament, then $T$ contains a transitive subtournament on at least $n^{ε(S)}$ vertices. Let $C_5$ be the unique five-vertex tournament where every vertex has two inneighbors and two outneighbors. The Alon-Pach-Solymosi conjecture is known to be true for the case when $S=C_5$. Here we prove a strengthening of this result, showing that in every tournament $T$ with no subtorunament isomorphic to $C_5$ there exist disjoint vertex subsets $A$ and $B$, each containing a linear proportion of the vertices of $T$, and such that every vertex of $A$ is adjacent to every vertex of $B$.

Given a system $(G_1, \ldots ,G_m)$ of graphs on the same vertex set $V$, a cooperative coloring is a choice of vertex sets $I_1, \ldots ,I_m$, such that $I_j$ is independent in $G_j$ and $\bigcup_{j=1}^{m}I_j = V$. For a class $\mathcal{G}$ of graphs, let $m_{\mathcal{G}}(d)$ be the minimal $m$ such that every $m$ graphs from $\mathcal{G}$ with maximum degree $d$ have a cooperative coloring. We prove that $Ω(\log\log d) \le m_\mathcal{T}(d) \le O(\log d)$ and $Ω(\log d)\le m_\mathcal{B}(d) \le O(d/\log d)$, where $\mathcal{T}$ is the class of trees and $\mathcal{B}$ is the class of bipartite graphs.

For a simplicial complex ${\mathcal C}$ denote by $β({\mathcal C})$ the minimal number of edges from ${\mathcal C}$ needed to cover the ground set. If ${\mathcal C}$ is a matroid then for every partition $A_1, \ldots, A_m$ of the ground set there exists a set $S \in {\mathcal C}$ meeting each $A_i$ in at least $\frac{|A_i|}{β({\mathcal C})}$ elements. We conjecture that a slightly weaker result is true for the intersections of two matroids: if ${\mathcal D}={\mathcal P} \cap {\mathcal Q}$, where ${\mathcal P},{\mathcal Q}$ are matroids on the same ground set $V$ and $β({\mathcal P}), β({\mathcal P}) \le k$, then for every partition $A_1, \ldots, A_m$ of the ground set there exists a set $S \in {\mathcal D}$ meeting each $A_i$ in at least $(\frac{1}{k}-\frac{1}{|V|})|A_i|-1$ elements. We prove this for a partition into two sets.

By a theorem of Drisko, any $2n-1$ matchings of size $n$ in a bipartite graph have a partial rainbow matching of size $n$. Inspired by discussion of Barát, Gyárfás and Sárközy, we conjecture that if $n$ is odd then the same is true also in general graphs, and that if $n$ is even then $2n$ matchings of size $n$ suffice. We prove that any $3n-2$ matchings of size $n$ have a partial rainbow matching of size $n$.

For a hypergraph $H$ let $β(H)$ denote the minimal number of edges from $H$ covering $V(H)$. An edge $S$ of $H$ is said to represent {\em fairly} (resp. {\em almost fairly}) a partition $(V_1,V_2, \ldots, V_m)$ of $V(H)$ if $|S\cap V_i|\ge \lfloor\frac{|V_i|}{β(H)}\rfloor$ (resp. $|S\cap V_i|\ge \lfloor\frac{|V_i|}{β(H)}\rfloor-1$) for all $i \le m$. In matroids any partition of $V(H)$ can be represented fairly by some independent set. We look for classes of hypergraphs $H$ in which any partition of $V(H)$ can be represented almost fairly by some edge. We show that this is true when $H$ is the set of independent sets in a path, and conjecture that it is true when $H$ is the set of matchings in $K_{n,n}$. We prove that partitions of $E(K_{n,n})$ into three sets can be represented almost fairly. The methods of proofs are topological.

We study conjectures relating degree conditions in $3$-partite hypergraphs to the matching number of the hypergraph, and use topological methods to prove special cases. In particular, we prove a strong version of a theorem of Drisko \cite{drisko} (as generalized by the first two authors \cite{ab}), that every family of $2n-1$ matchings of size $n$ in a bipartite graph has a partial rainbow matching of size $n$. We show that milder restrictions on the sizes of the matchings suffice. Another result that is strengthened is a theorem of Cameron and Wanless \cite{CamWan}, that every Latin square has a diagonal (permutation submatrix) in which no symbol appears more than twice. We show that the same is true under the weaker condition that the square is row-Latin.