arXiv++ Combinatorics

The sandpile group of a connected graph is a group whose cardinality is the number of spanning trees. The group is known to have a canonical simply transitive action on spanning trees if the graph is embedded into the plane. However, no canonical action on the spanning trees is known for the nonplanar case. We show that for any embedded Eulerian digraph, one can define a canonical simply transitive action of the sandpile group on compatible Eulerian tours (a set whose cardinality equals to the number of spanning arborescences). This enables us to give a new proof that the rotor-routing action of a ribbon graph is independent of the root if and only if the embedding is into the plane (originally proved by Chan, Church and Grochow). Recently, Merino, Moffatt and Noble defined a sandpile group variant (called Jacobian) for embedded graphs, whose cardinality is the number of quasi-trees. Baker, Ding and Kim showed that this group acts canonically on the quasitrees. We show that the Jacobian of an embedded graph is canonically isomorphic to the usual sandpile group of the medial digraph, and the action by Baker at al. agrees with the action of the sandpile group of the medial digraph on Eulerian tours (which fact is made possible by the existence of a canonical bijection between Eulerian tours of the medial digraph and quasi-trees due to Bouchet).

We study the extended root polytope associated to a directed graph. We show that under the operations of deletion and contraction of an edge of the graph, none of the coefficients of the $h^*$-polynomial of the associated extended root polytope increase. We examine cases when the $h^*$-polynomial does not change, for instance when contracting the edges of a minimal directed join in a digraph whose lattice polytope has the Gorenstein property.

In this paper we study the following extremal graph theoretic problem: Given an undirected Eulerian graph $G$, which Eulerian orientation minimizes or maximizes the number of arborescences? We solve the minimization for the complete graph $K_n$, the complete bipartite graph $K_{n,m}$, and for the so-called double graphs, where there are even number of edges between any pair of vertices. In fact, for $K_n$ we prove the following stronger statement. If $T$ is a tournament on $n$ vertices with out-degree sequence $d_1^+,\dots ,d^+_n$, then $$\mathrm{allarb}(T)\geq \frac{1}{n}\left(\prod_{k=1}^n(d^+_k+1)+\prod_{k=1}^nd^+_k\right),$$ where $\mathrm{allarb}(T)$ is the total number of arborescences. Equality holds if and only if $T$ is a locally transitive tournament. We also give an upper bound for the number of arborescences of an Eulerian orientation for an arbitrary graph $G$. This upper bound can be achieved on $K_n$ for infinitely many $n$.

Every regular matroid is associated with a sandpile group, which acts simply transitively on the set of bases in various ways. Ganguly and the second author introduced the notion of consistency to describe classes of actions that respect deletion-contraction in a precise sense, and proved the consistency of rotor-routing torsors (and uniqueness thereof) for plane graphs. In this work, we prove that the class of actions introduced by Backman, Baker, and the fourth author, is consistent for regular matroids. More precisely, we prove the consistency of its generalization given by Backman, Santos and the fourth author, and independently by the first author. This extends the above existence assertion, as well as makes progress on the goal of classifying all consistent actions.

We prove that the two-variable Tutte polynomial of hypergraphs can be defined via embedding activities. We also prove that embedding activities of hypergraphs yield a Crapo-style decomposition of $\mathbb{Z}^E$, thus generalizing Bernardi's results from graphs to hypergraphs. We also show that hypergraph embedding activities do not fit into the $Δ$-activity framework of Courtiel. Based on this observation, we construct a graph with an activity notion that yields a Crapo decomposition, but cannot be obtained as a $Δ$-activity.

The interior polynomial of a directed graph is defined as the $h^*$-polynomial of the graph's (extended) root polytope, and it displays several attractive properties. Here we express its degree in terms of the minimum cardinality of a directed join, and give a formula for the leading coefficient. We present natural generalizations of these results to oriented regular matroids; in the process we also give a facet description for the extended root polytope of an oriented regular matroid. By duality, our expression for the degree of the interior polynomial implies a formula for the degree of the parking function enumerator of an Eulerian directed graph (which is equivalent to the greedoid polynomial of the corresponding branching greedoid). We extend that result to obtain the degree of the parking function enumerator of an arbitrary rooted directed graph in terms of the minimum cardinality of a certain type of feedback arc set.

Baker and Norine initiated the study of graph divisors as a graph-theoretic analogue of the Riemann-Roch theory for Riemann surfaces. One of the key concepts of graph divisor theory is the {\it rank} of a divisor on a graph. The importance of the rank is well illustrated by Baker's {\it Specialization lemma}, stating that the dimension of a linear system can only go up under specialization from curves to graphs, leading to a fruitful interaction between divisors on graphs and curves. Due to its decisive role, determining the rank is a central problem in graph divisor theory. Kiss and Tóthméresz reformulated the problem using chip-firing games, and showed that computing the rank of a divisor on a graph is NP-hard via reduction from the Minimum Feedback Arc Set problem. In this paper, we strengthen their result by establishing a connection between chip-firing games and the Minimum Target Set Selection problem. As a corollary, we show that the rank is difficult to approximate to within a factor of $O(2^{\log^{1-\varepsilon}n})$ for any $\varepsilon > 0$ unless $P=NP$. Furthermore, assuming the Planted Dense Subgraph Conjecture, the rank is difficult to approximate to within a factor of $O(n^{1/4-\varepsilon})$ for any $\varepsilon>0$.

We define the root polytope of a regular oriented matroid, and show that the greedoid polynomial of an Eulerian branching greedoid rooted at vertex $v_0$ is equivalent to the $h^*$-polynomial of the root polytope of the dual of the graphic matroid. As the definition of the root polytope is independent of the vertex $v_0$, this gives a geometric proof for the root-independence of the greedoid polynomial for Eulerian branching greedoids, a fact which was first proved by Swee Hong Chan, Kévin Perrot and Trung Van Pham using sandpile models. We also obtain that the greedoid polynomial does not change if we reverse every edge of an Eulerian digraph.

Symmetric edge polytopes of graphs and root polytopes of semi-balanced digraphs are two classes of lattice polytopes whose $h^*$-polynomials have interesting properties and generalize important graph polynomials. For both classes of polytopes there are large, natural classes of dissections into unimodular simplices. These are such that the simplices correspond to certain spanning trees. We show that for any ``spanning tree dissection'' of the symmetric edge polytope of a graph, or the root polytope of a semi-balanced digraph, the $h^*$-polynomial of the polytope can be computed as a generating function of certain activities of the corresponding spanning trees. Apart from giving simple and flexible algorithms for computing these polynomials, our results also reveal that all dissections in question are surprisingly similar to each other: It turns out that the distributions of many statistics of spanning tree dissections are in fact independent of the actual dissection.

Using a ribbon structure of the graph, we construct a dissection of the symmetric edge polytope of a graph into unimodular simplices. Our dissection is shellable, and one can interpret the elements of the resulting $h$-vector via graph theory. This gives an elementary method for computing the $h^*$-vector of the symmetric edge polytope.

We associate root polytopes to directed graphs and study them by using ribbon structures. Most attention is paid to what we call the semi-balanced case, i.e., when each cycle has the same number of edges pointing in the two directions. Given a ribbon structure, we identify a natural class of spanning trees and show that, in the semi-balanced case, they induce a shellable dissection of the root polytope into maximal simplices. This allows for a computation of the $h^*$-vector of the polytope and for showing some properties of this new graph invariant, such as a product formula and that in the planar case, the $h^*$-vector is equivalent to the greedoid polynomial of the dual graph. We obtain a general recursion relation as well. We also work out the case of layer-complete directed graphs, where our method recovers a previously known triangulation. Indeed our dissection is often but not always a triangulation; we address this with a series of examples.

Chip-firing and rotor-routing are two well-studied examples of abelian networks. We study the complexity of their respective reachability problems. We show that the rotor-routing reachability problem is decidable in polynomial time, and we give a simple characterization of when a chip-and-rotor configuration is reachable from another one. For chip-firing, it has been known that the reachability problem is in P if we have a class of graphs whose period length is polynomial (for example, Eulerian digraphs). Here we show that in the general case, chip-firing reachability is hard in the sense that if the chip-firing reachability problem were in P for general digraphs, then the polynomial hierarchy would collapse to NP. We encode graphs by their adjacency matrix, and we encode ribbon structures "succinctly", only remembering the number of consecutive parallel edges.

We study the behavior of the activity of the parallel chip-firing upon increasing the number of chips on an Erdős--Rényi random graph. We show that in various situations the resulting activity diagrams converge to a devil's staircase as we increase the number of vertices. Our method is to generalize the parallel chip-firing to graphons, and to prove a continuity result for the activity. We also show that the activity of a chip configuration on a graphon does not necessarily exist, but it does exist for every chip configuration on a large class of graphons.

Baker and Wang define the so-called Bernardi action of the sandpile group of a ribbon graph on the set of its spanning trees. This potentially depends on a fixed vertex of the graph but it is independent of the base vertex if and only if the ribbon structure is planar, moreover, in this case the Bernardi action is compatible with planar duality. Earlier, Chan, Church and Grochow and Chan, Glass, Macauley, Perkinson, Werner and Yang proved analogous results about the rotor-routing action. Baker and Wang moreover showed that the Bernardi and rotor-routing actions coincide for plane graphs. We clarify this still confounding picture by giving a canonical definition for the planar Bernardi/rotor-routing action, and also a canonical isomorphism between sandpile groups of planar dual graphs. Our canonical definition implies the compatibility with planar duality via an extremely short argument. We also show hidden symmetries of the problem by proving our results in the slightly more general setting of balanced plane digraphs. Any balanced plane digraph gives rise to a trinity, i.e., a triangulation of the sphere with a three-coloring of the $0$-simplices. Our most important tool is a group associated to trinities, introduced by Cavenagh and Wanless, and a result of a subset of the authors characterizing the Bernardi bijection in terms of a dissection of a root polytope.

Recently O. Bernardi gave a formula for the Tutte polynomial $T(x,y)$ of a graph, based on spanning trees and activities just like the original definition, but using a fixed ribbon structure to order the set of edges in a different way for each tree. The interior polynomial $I$ is a generalization of $T(x,1)$ to hypergraphs. We supply a Bernardi-type description of $I$ using a ribbon structure on the underlying bipartite graph $G$. Our formula works because it is determined by the Ehrhart polynomial of the root polytope of $G$ in the same way as $I$ is. To prove this we interpret the Bernardi process as a way of dissecting the root polytope into simplices, along with a shelling order. We also show that our generalized Bernardi process gives a common extension of bijections (and their inverses) constructed by Baker and Wang between spanning trees and break divisors.

We introduce the notion of semibreak divisors on metric graphs (tropical curves) and prove that every effective divisor class (of degree at most the genus) has a semibreak divisor representative. This appropriately generalizes the notion of break divisors (in degree equal to genus). Our method of proof is new, even for the special case of break divisors. We provide an algorithm to efficiently compute such semibreak representatives. Semibreak divisors provide the tool to establish some basic properties of effective loci inside Picard groups of metric graphs. We prove that effective loci are pure-dimensional polyhedral sets. We also prove that a `generic' divisor class (in degree at most the genus) has rank zero, and that the Abel-Jacobi map is `birational' onto its image. These are analogues of classical results for Riemann surfaces.

A famous conjecture (usually called Ryser's conjecture) that appeared in the Ph.D thesis of his student, J.~R.~Henderson [15], states that for an $r$-uniform $r$-partite hypergraph $\mathcal{H}$, the inequality $τ(\mathcal{H})\le(r-1)\cdot ν(\mathcal{H})$ always holds. This conjecture is widely open, except in the case of $r=2$, when it is equivalent to K\H onig's theorem [18], and in the case of $r=3$, which was proved by Aharoni in 2001 [3]. Here we study some special cases of Ryser's conjecture. First of all the most studied special case is when $\mathcal{H}$ is intersecting. Even for this special case, not too much is known: this conjecture is proved only for $r\le 5$ in [10,21]. For $r>5$ it is also widely open. Generalizing the conjecture for intersecting hypergraphs, we conjecture the following. If an $r$-uniform $r$-partite hypergraph $\mathcal{H}$ is $t$-intersecting (i.e., every two hyperedges meet in at least $t<r$ vertices), then $τ(\mathcal{H})\le r-t$. We prove this conjecture for the case $t> r/4$. Gyárfás [10] showed that Ryser's conjecture for intersecting hypergraphs is equivalent to saying that the vertices of an $r$-edge-colored complete graph can be covered by $r-1$ monochromatic components. Motivated by this formulation, we examine what fraction of the vertices can be covered by $r-1$ monochromatic components of \emph{different} colors in an $r$-edge-colored complete graph. We prove a sharp bound for this problem. Finally we prove Ryser's conjecture for the very special case when the maximum degree of the hypergraph is two.

Baker and Norine proved a Riemann--Roch theorem for divisors on undirected graphs. The notions of graph divisor theory are in duality with the notions of the chip-firing game of Björner, Lovász and Shor. We use this connection to prove Riemann--Roch-type results on directed graphs. We give a simple proof for a Riemann--Roch inequality on Eulerian directed graphs, improving a result of Amini and Manjunath. We also study possibilities and impossibilities of Riemann--Roch-type equalities in strongly connected digraphs and give examples. We intend to make the connections of this theory to graph theoretic notions more explicit via using the chip-firing framework.

We define the analogue of linear equivalence of graph divisors for the rotor-router model, and use it to prove polynomial time computability of some problems related to rotor-routing. Using the connection between linear equivalence for chip-firing and for rotor-routing, we give a simple proof for the fact that the number of rotor-router unicycle-orbits equals the order of the Picard group. We also show that the rotor-router action of the Picard group on the set of spanning in-arborescences can be interpreted in terms of the linear equivalence.

In this paper, we study the complexity of the chip-firing reachability problem. We show that for Eulerian digraphs, the reachability problem can be decided in strongly polynomial time, even if the digraph has multiple edges. We also show a special case when the reachability problem can be decided in polynomial time for general digraphs: if the target distribution is recurrent restricted to each strongly connected component. As a further positive result, we show that the chip-firing reachability problem is in co-NP for general digraphs. We also show that the chip-firing halting problem is in co-NP for Eulerian digraphs.