arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study the mixing properties of permutations obtained as a product of two uniformly random permutations of fixed cycle types. For instance, we give an exact formula for the probability that elements $1,2,...,k$ are in distinct cycles of the random permutation of $\{1,2,...,n\}$ obtained as product of two uniformly random $n$-cycles.

We study the factorizations of the permutation $(1,2,...,n)$ into $k$ factors of given cycle types. Using representation theory, Jackson obtained for each $k$ an elegant formula for counting these factorizations according to the number of cycles of each factor. In the cases $k=2,3$ Schaeffer and Vassilieva gave a combinatorial proof of Jackson's formula, and Morales and Vassilieva obtained more refined formulas exhibiting a surprising symmetry property. These counting results are indicative of a rich combinatorial theory which has remained elusive to this point, and it is the goal of this article to establish a series of bijections which unveil some of the combinatorial properties of the factorizations of $(1,2,...,n)$ into $k$ factors for all $k$. We thereby obtain refinements of Jackson's formulas which extend the cases $k=2,3$ treated by Morales and Vassilieva. Our bijections are described in terms of "constellations", which are graphs embedded in surfaces encoding the transitive factorizations of permutations.

This article presents unified bijective constructions for planar maps, with control on the face degrees and on the girth. Recall that the girth is the length of the smallest cycle, so that maps of girth at least $d=1,2,3$ are respectively the general, loopless, and simple maps. For each positive integer $d$, we obtain a bijection for the class of plane maps (maps with one distinguished root-face) of girth $d$ having a root-face of degree $d$. We then obtain more general bijective constructions for annular maps (maps with two distinguished root-faces) of girth at least $d$. Our bijections associate to each map a decorated plane tree, and non-root faces of degree $k$ of the map correspond to vertices of degree $k$ of the tree. As special cases we recover several known bijections for bipartite maps, loopless triangulations, simple triangulations, simple quadrangulations, etc. Our work unifies and greatly extends these bijective constructions. In terms of counting, we obtain for each integer $d$ an expression for the generating function $F_d(x_d,x_{d+1},x_{d+2},...)$ of plane maps of girth $d$ with root-face of degree $d$, where the variable $x_k$ counts the non-root faces of degree $k$. The expression for $F_1$ was already obtained bijectively by Bouttier, Di Francesco and Guitter, but for $d\geq 2$ the expression of $F_d$ is new. We also obtain an expression for the generating function $\G_{p,q}^{(d,e)}(x_d,x_{d+1},...)$ of annular maps with root-faces of degrees $p$ and $q$, such that cycles separating the two root-faces have length at least $e$ while other cycles have length at least $d$. Our strategy is to obtain all the bijections as specializations of a single "master bijection" introduced by the authors in a previous article. In order to use this approach, we exhibit certain "canonical orientations" characterizing maps with prescribed girth constraints.

A unicellular map is the embedding of a connected graph in a surface in such a way that the complement of the graph is simply connected. In a famous article, Harer and Zagier established a formula for the generating function of unicellular maps counted according to the number of vertices and edges. The keystone of their approach is a counting formula for unicellular maps on orientable surfaces with $n$ edges, and with vertices colored using every color in $[q]$ (adjacent vertices are authorized to have the same color). We give an analogue of this formula for general (locally orientable) surfaces. Our approach is bijective and is inspired by Lass's proof of the Harer-Zagier formula. We first revisit Lass's proof and twist it into a bijection between unicellular maps on orientable surfaces with vertices colored using every color in $[q]$, and maps with vertex set $[q]$ on orientable surfaces \emph{with a marked spanning tree}. The bijection immediately implies Harer-Zagier's formula and a formula by Jackson concerning bipartite unicellular maps. It also shed a new light on constructions by Goulden and Nica, Schaeffer and Vassilieva, and Morales and Vassilieva. We then extend the bijection to general surfaces and obtain a correspondence between unicellular maps on general surfaces with vertices colored using every color in $[q]$, and maps on orientable surfaces with vertex set $[q]$ \emph{with a marked planar submap}. This correspondence gives an analogue of the Harer-Zagier formula for general surfaces. We also show that this formula implies a recursion formula due to Ledoux for the numbers of unicellular maps with given numbers of vertices and edges.

Consider a walk in the plane made of $n$ unit steps, with directions chosen independently and uniformly at random at each step. Rayleigh's theorem asserts that the probability for such a walk to end at a distance less than 1 from its starting point is $1/(n+1)$. We give an elementary proof of this result. We also prove the following generalization valid for any probability distribution $μ$ on the positive real numbers: if two walkers start at the same point and make respectively $m$ and $n$ independent steps with uniformly random directions and with lengths chosen according to $μ$, then the probability that the first walker ends farther than the second is $m/(m+n)$.

Schnyder woods are decompositions of simple triangulations into three edge-disjoint spanning trees crossing each other in a specific way. In this article, we define a generalization of Schnyder woods to $d$-angulations (plane graphs with faces of degree $d$) for all $d\geq 3$. A \emph{Schnyder decomposition} is a set of $d$ spanning forests crossing each other in a specific way, and such that each internal edge is part of exactly $d-2$ of the spanning forests. We show that a Schnyder decomposition exists if and only if the girth of the $d$-angulation is $d$. As in the case of Schnyder woods ($d=3$), there are alternative formulations in terms of orientations ("fractional" orientations when $d\geq 5$) and in terms of corner-labellings. Moreover, the set of Schnyder decompositions on a fixed $d$-angulation of girth $d$ is a distributive lattice. We also show that the structures dual to Schnyder decompositions (on $d$-regular plane graphs of mincut $d$ rooted at a vertex $v^*$) are decompositions into $d$ spanning trees rooted at $v^*$ such that each edge not incident to $v^*$ is used in opposite directions by two trees. Additionally, for even values of $d$, we show that a subclass of Schnyder decompositions, which are called even, enjoy additional properties that yield a reduced formulation; in the case d=4, these correspond to well-studied structures on simple quadrangulations (2-orientations and partitions into 2 spanning trees). In the case d=4, the dual of even Schnyder decompositions yields (planar) orthogonal and straight-line drawing algorithms. For a 4-regular plane graph $G$ of mincut 4 with $n$ vertices plus a marked vertex $v$, the vertices of $G\backslash v$ are placed on a $(n-1) \times (n-1)$ grid according to a permutation pattern, and in the orthogonal drawing each of the $2n-2$ edges of $G\backslash v$ has exactly one bend. Embedding also the marked vertex $v$ is doable at the cost of two additional rows and columns and 8 additional bends for the 4 edges incident to $v$. We propose a further compaction step for the drawing algorithm and show that the obtained grid-size is strongly concentrated around $25n/32\times 25n/32$ for a uniformly random instance with $n$ vertices.

A $d$-angulation is a planar map with faces of degree $d$. We present for each integer $d\geq 3$ a bijection between the class of $d$-angulations of girth $d$ (i.e., with no cycle of length less than $d$) and a class of decorated plane trees. Each of the bijections is obtained by specializing a "master bijection" which extends an earlier construction of the first author. Our construction unifies known bijections by Fusy, Poulalhon and Schaeffer for triangulations ($d=3$) and by Schaeffer for quadrangulations ($d=4$). For $d\geq 5$, both the bijections and the enumerative results are new. We also extend our bijections so as to enumerate \emph{$p$-gonal $d$-angulations} ($d$-angulations with a simple boundary of length $p$) of girth $d$. We thereby recover bijectively the results of Brown for simple $p$-gonal triangulations and simple $2p$-gonal quadrangulations and establish new results for $d\geq 5$. A key ingredient in our proofs is a class of orientations characterizing $d$-angulations of girth $d$. Earlier results by Schnyder and by De Fraysseix and Ossona de Mendez showed that simple triangulations and simple quadrangulations are characterized by the existence of orientations having respectively indegree 3 and 2 at each inner vertex. We extend this characterization by showing that a $d$-angulation has girth $d$ if and only if the graph obtained by duplicating each edge $d-2$ times admits an orientation having indegree $d$ at each inner vertex.

A unicellular map is the embedding of a connected graph in a surface in such a way that the complement of the graph is a topological disk. In this paper we present a bijective link between unicellular maps on a non-orientable surface and unicellular maps of a lower topological type, with distinguished vertices. From that we obtain a recurrence equation that leads to (new) explicit counting formulas for non-orientable unicellular maps of fixed topology. In particular, we give exact formulas for the precubic case (all vertices of degree 1 or 3), and asymptotic formulas for the general case, when the number of edges goes to infinity. Our strategy is inspired by recent results obtained by the second author for the orientable case, but significant novelties are introduced: in particular we construct an involution which, in some sense, "averages" the effects of non-orientability.

We consider maps on orientable surfaces. A map is called \emph{unicellular} if it has a single face. A \emph{covered map} is a map (of genus $g$) with a marked unicellular spanning submap (which can have any genus in $\{0,1,...,g\}$). Our main result is a bijection between covered maps with $n$ edges and genus $g$ and pairs made of a plane tree with $n$ edges and a unicellular bipartite map of genus $g$ with $n+1$ edges. In the planar case, covered maps are maps with a marked spanning tree and our bijection specializes into a construction obtained by the first author in \cite{OB:boisees}. Covered maps can also be seen as \emph{shuffles} of two unicellular maps (one representing the unicellular submap, the other representing the dual unicellular submap). Thus, our bijection gives a correspondence between shuffles of unicellular maps, and pairs made of a plane tree and a unicellular bipartite map. In terms of counting, this establishes the equivalence between a formula due to Harer and Zagier for general unicellular maps, and a formula due to Jackson for bipartite unicellular maps. We also show that the bijection of Bouttier, Di Francesco and Guitter \cite{BDFG:mobiles} (which generalizes a previous bijection by Schaeffer \cite{Schaeffer:these}) between bipartite maps and so-called well-labelled mobiles can be obtained as a special case of our bijection.

We address the enumeration of properly q-colored planar maps, or more precisely, the enumeration of rooted planar maps M weighted by their chromatic polynomial χ_M(q) and counted by the number of vertices and faces. We prove that the associated generating function is algebraic when q\not=0,4 is of the form 2+2 cos (jπ/m), for integers j and m. This includes the two integer values q=2 and q=3. We extend this to planar maps weighted by their Potts polynomial P_M(q,ν), which counts all q-colorings (proper or not) by the number of monochromatic edges. We then prove similar results for planar triangulations, thus generalizing some results of Tutte which dealt with their proper q-colorings. In statistical physics terms, the problem we study consists in solving the Potts model on random planar lattices. From a technical viewpoint, this means solving non-linear equations with two "catalytic" variables. To our knowledge, this is the first time such equations are being solved since Tutte's remarkable solution of properly q-colored triangulations.

A well-labelled positive path of size n is a pair (p,σ) made of a word p=p_1p_2...p_{n-1} on the alphabet {-1, 0,+1} such that the sum of the letters of any prefix is non-negative, together with a permutation σof {1,2,...,n} such that p_i=-1 implies σ(i)<σ(i+1), while p_i=1 implies σ(i)>σ(i+1). We establish a bijection between well-labelled positive paths of size $n$ and matchings (i.e. fixed-point free involutions) on {1,2,...,2n}. This proves that the number of well-labelled positive paths is (2n-1)!!. By specialising our bijection, we also prove that the number of permutations of size n such that each prefix has no more ascents than descents is [(n-1)!!]^2 if n is even and n!!(n-2)!! otherwise. Our result also prove combinatorially that the n-dimensional polytope consisting of all points (x_1,...,x_n) in [-1,1]^n such that the sum of the first j coordinates is non-negative for all j=1,2,...,n has volume (2n-1)!!/n!.

It is well-known that the triangulations of the disc with $n+2$ vertices on its boundary are counted by the $n$th Catalan number $C(n)=\frac{1}{n+1}{2n \choose n}$. This paper deals with the generalisation of this problem to any arbitrary compact surface $S$ with boundaries. We obtain the asymptotic number of simplicial decompositions of the surface $S$ with $n$ vertices on its boundary. More generally, we determine the asymptotic number of dissections of $S$ when the faces are $δ$-gons with $δ$ belonging to a set of admissible degrees $Δ\subseteq \{3,4,5,...\}$. We also give the limit laws of certain parameters of such dissections.

Mayer's theory of cluster integrals allows one to write the partition function of a gas model as a generating function of weighted graphs. Recently, Labelle, Leroux and Ducharme have studied the graph weights arising from the one-dimensional hard-core gas model and noticed that the sum of the weights over all connected graphs with $n$ vertices is $(-n)^{n-1}$. This is, up to sign, the number of rooted Cayley trees on $n$ vertices and the authors asked for a combinatorial explanation. The main goal of this article is to provide such an explanation.

A minor-closed class of graphs is a set of labelled graphs which is closed under isomorphism and under taking minors. For a minor-closed class $C$, we let $c_n$ be the number of graphs in $C$ which have $n$ vertices. A recent result of Norine et al. shows that for all minor-closed class $C$, there is a constant $r$ such that $c_n < r^n n!$. Our main results show that the growth rate of $c_n$ is far from arbitrary. For example, no minor-closed class $C$ has $c_n= r^{n+o(n)} n!$ with $0 < r < 1$ or $1 < r < ξ\approx 1.76$.

The Stanley lattice, Tamari lattice and Kreweras lattice are three remarkable orders defined on the set of Catalan objects of a given size. These lattices are ordered by inclusion: the Stanley lattice is an extension of the Tamari lattice which is an extension of the Kreweras lattice. The Stanley order can be defined on the set of Dyck paths of size $n$ as the relation of \emph{being above}. Hence, intervals in the Stanley lattice are pairs of non-crossing Dyck paths. In a former article, the second author defined a bijection $Φ$ between pairs of non-crossing Dyck paths and the realizers of triangulations (or Schnyder woods). We give a simpler description of the bijection $Φ$. Then, we study the restriction of $Φ$ to Tamari's and Kreweras' intervals. We prove that $Φ$ induces a bijection between Tamari intervals and minimal realizers. This gives a bijection between Tamari intervals and triangulations. We also prove that $Φ$ induces a bijection between Kreweras intervals and the (unique) realizers of stack triangulations. Thus, $Φ$ induces a bijection between Kreweras intervals and stack triangulations which are known to be in bijection with ternary trees.

For any graph G with n edges, the spanning subgraphs and the orientations of G are both counted by the evaluation T_G(2,2)=2^n of its Tutte polynomial. We define a bijection $Φ$ between spanning subgraphs and orientations and explore its enumerative consequences regarding the Tutte polynomial. The bijection $Φ$ is closely related to a recent characterization of the Tutte polynomial relying on a combinatorial embedding of the graph G, that is, on a choice of cyclic order of the edges around each vertex. Among other results, we obtain a combinatorial interpretation for each of the evaluations T_G(i,j), 0\leq i,j \leq 2 of the Tutte polynomial in terms of orientations. The strength of our approach is to derive all these interpretations by specializing the bijection $Φ$ in various ways. For instance, we obtain a bijection between the connected subgraphs of G (counted by T_G(1,2)) and the root-connected orientations. We also obtain a bijection between the forests (counted by T_G(2,1)) and outdegree sequences which specializes into a bijection between spanning trees (counted by T_G(1,1)) and root-connected outdegree sequences. We also define a bijection between spanning trees and recurrent configurations of the sandpile model. Combining our results we obtain a bijection between recurrent configurations and root-connected outdegree sequences which leaves the configurations at level 0 unchanged.

We give a new characterization of the Tutte polynomial of graphs. Our characterization is formally close (but inequivalent) to the original definition given by Tutte as the generating function of spanning trees counted according to activities. Tutte's notion of activity requires to choose a \emph{linear order} on the edge set (though the generating function of the activities is, in fact, independent of this order). We define a new notion of activity, the embedding-activity, which requires to choose a \emph{combinatorial embedding} of the graph, that is, a cyclic order of the edges around each vertex. We prove that the Tutte polynomial equals the generating function of spanning trees counted according to embedding-activities (this generating function being, in fact, independent of the embedding).

We consider lattice walks in the plane starting at the origin, remaining in the first quadrant and made of West, South and North-East steps. In 1965, Germain Kreweras discovered a remarkably simple formula giving the number of these walks (with prescribed length and endpoint). Kreweras' proof was very involved and several alternative derivations have been proposed since then. But the elegant simplicity of the counting formula remained unexplained. We give the first purely combinatorial explanation of this formula. Our approach is based on a bijection between Kreweras walks and triangulations with a distinguished spanning tree. We obtain simultaneously a bijective way of counting loopless triangulations.

We solve three enumerative problems concerning families of planar maps. More precisely, we establish algebraic equations for the generating function of non-separable triangulations in which all vertices have degree at least d, for a certain value d chosen in {3, 4, 5}. The originality of the problem lies in the fact that degree restrictions are placed both on vertices and faces. Our proofs first follow Tutte's classical approach: we decompose maps by deleting the root and translate the decomposition into an equation satisfied by the generating function of the maps under consideration. Then we proceed to solve the equation obtained using a recent technique that extends the so-called quadratic method.

The number of tree-rooted maps, that is, rooted planar maps with a distinguished spanning tree, of size $n$ is C(n)C(n+1) where C(n)=binomial(2n,n)/(n+1) is the nth Catalan number. We present a (long awaited) simple bijection which explains this result. We prove that our bijection is isomorphic to a former recursive construction on shuffles of parenthesis systems due to Cori, Dulucq and Viennot.