arXiv++ Combinatorics

It is well known that a graph with $m$ edges can be made triangle-free by removing (slightly less than) $m/2$ edges. On the other hand, there are many classes of graphs which are hard to make triangle-free in the sense that it is necessary to remove roughly $m/2$ edges in order to eliminate all triangles. It is proved that dense graphs that are hard to make triangle-free, have a large packing of pairwise edge-disjoint triangles. In particular, they have more than $m(1/4+cβ^2)$ pairwise edge-disjoint triangles where $β$ is the density of the graph and $c$ is an absolute constant. This improves upon a previous $m(1/4-o(1))$ bound which follows from the asymptotic validity of Tuza's conjecture for dense graphs. It is conjectured that such graphs have an asymptotically optimal triangle packing of size $m(1/3-o(1))$. The result is extended to larger cliques and odd cycles.

We prove that the sizes of the maximal dissociated subsets of a given finite subset of an abelian group differ by a logarithmic factor at most. On the other hand, we show that the set $\{0,1\}^n\seq\Z^n$ possesses a dissociated subset of size $\Ome(n\log n)$; since the standard basis of $\Z^n$ is a maximal dissociated subset of $\{0,1\}^n$ of size $n$, the result just mentioned is essentially sharp.

Let a_1,...,a_k satisfy a_1+...+a_k=1 and suppose a k-uniform hypergraph on n vertices satisfies the following property; in any partition of its vertices into k sets A_1,...,A_k of sizes a_1*n,...,a_k*n, the number of edges intersecting A_1,...,A_k is the number one would expect to find in a random k-uniform hypergraph. Can we then infer that H is quasi-random? We show that the answer is negative if and only if a_1=...=a_k=1/k. This resolves an open problem raised in 1991 by Chung and Graham [J. AMS '91]. While hypergraphs satisfying the property corresponding to a_1=...=a_k=1/k are not necessarily quasi-random, we manage to find a characterization of the hypergraphs satisfying this property. Somewhat surprisingly, it turns out that (essentially) there is a unique non quasi-random hypergraph satisfying this property. The proofs combine probabilistic and algebraic arguments with results from the theory of association schemes.

The theorem of Chung, Graham, and Wilson on quasi-random graphs asserts that of all graphs with edge density p, the random graph G(n,p) contains the smallest density of copies of K_{t,t}, the complete bipartite graph of size 2t. Since K_{t,t} is a t-blowup of an edge, the following intriguing open question arises: Is it true that of all graphs with triangle density p^3, the random graph G(n,p) contains the smallest density of K_{t,t,t}, which is the t-blowup of a triangle? Our main result gives an indication that the answer to the above question is positive by showing that for some blowup, the answer must be positive. More formally we prove that if G has triangle density p^3, then there is some 2 <= t <= T(p) for which the density of K_{t,t,t} in G is at least p^{(3+o(1))t^2}, which (up to the o(1) term) equals the density of K_{t,t,t} in G(n,p). We also consider the analogous question on skewed blowups, showing that somewhat surprisingly, the behavior there is different. We also raise several conjectures related to these problems and discuss some applications to other areas.

One of the main questions that arise when studying random and quasi-random structures is which properties P are such that any object that satisfies P "behaves" like a truly random one. In the context of graphs, Chung, Graham, and Wilson call a graph p-quasi-random} if it satisfies a long list of the properties that hold in G(n,p) with high probability, like edge distribution, spectral gap, cut size, and more. Our main result here is that the following holds for any fixed graph H: if the distribution of induced copies of H in a graph G is close (in a well defined way) to the distribution we would expect to have in G(n,p), then G is either p-quasi-random or p'-quasi-random, where p' is the unique non-trivial solution of a certain polynomial equation. We thus infer that having the correct distribution of induced copies of any single graph H is enough to guarantee that a graph has the properties of a random one. The proof techniques we develop here, which combine probabilistic, algebraic and combinatorial tools, may be of independent interest to the study of quasi-random structures.

The triangle removal lemma states that a simple graph with o(n^3) triangles can be made triangle-free by removing o(n^2) edges. It is natural to ask if this widely used result can be extended to multi-graphs (or equivalently, weighted graphs). In this short paper we rule out the possibility of such an extension by showing that there are multi-graphs with only n^{2+o(1)} triangles that are still far from being triangle-free. On the other hand, we show that for some g(n)=ω(1), if a multi-graph (or weighted graph) has only g(n)n^2 triangles then it must be close to being triangle-free. The proof relies on variants of the Ruzsa-Szemerédi theorem.

An edge-colored graph $G$ is {\em rainbow connected} if any two vertices are connected by a path whose edges have distinct colors. The {\em rainbow connection} of a connected graph $G$, denoted $rc(G)$, is the smallest number of colors that are needed in order to make $G$ rainbow connected. In the first result of this paper we prove that computing $rc(G)$ is NP-Hard solving an open problem from \cite{Ca-Yu}. In fact, we prove that it is already NP-Complete to decide if $rc(G)=2$, and also that it is NP-Complete to decide whether a given edge-colored (with an unbounded number of colors) graph is rainbow connected. On the positive side, we prove that for every $ε>0$, a connected graph with minimum degree at least $εn$ has {\em bounded} rainbow connection, where the bound depends only on $ε$, and a corresponding coloring can be constructed in polynomial time. Additional non-trivial upper bounds, as well as open problems and conjectures are also presented.

For every fixed graph $H$ and every fixed $0 < α< 1$, we show that if a graph $G$ has the property that all subsets of size $αn$ contain the ``correct'' number of copies of $H$ one would expect to find in the random graph $G(n,p)$ then $G$ behaves like the random graph $G(n,p)$; that is, it is $p$-quasi-random in the sense of Chung, Graham, and Wilson. This solves a conjecture raised by Shapira and solves in a strong sense an open problem of Simonovits and Sós.

Let $τ(\mathcal{H})$ be the cover number and $ν(\mathcal{H})$ be the matching number of a hypergraph $\mathcal{H}$. Ryser conjectured that every $r$-partite hypergraph $\mathcal{H}$ satisfies the inequality $τ(\mathcal{H}) \leq (r-1) ν(\mathcal{H})$. This conjecture is open for all $r \ge 4$. For intersecting hypergraphs, namely those with $ν(\mathcal{H})=1$, Ryser's conjecture reduces to $τ(\mathcal{H}) \leq r-1$. Even this conjecture is extremely difficult and is open for all $ r \ge 6$. For infinitely many $r$ there are examples of intersecting $r$-partite hypergraphs with $τ(\mathcal{H})=r-1$, demonstrating the tightness of the conjecture for such $r$. However, all previously known constructions are not optimal as they use far too many edges. How sparse can an intersecting $r$-partite hypergraph be, given that its cover number is as large as possible, namely $τ(\mathcal{H}) \ge r-1$? In this paper we solve this question for $r \le 5$, give an almost optimal construction for $r=6$, prove that any $r$-partite intersecting hypergraph with $τ(H) \ge r-1$ must have at least $(3-\frac{1}{\sqrt{18}})r(1-o(1)) \approx 2.764r(1-o(1))$ edges, and conjecture that there exist constructions with $Θ(r)$ edges.

A $ρ$-mean coloring of a graph is a coloring of the edges such that the average number of colors incident with each vertex is at most $ρ$. For a graph $H$ and for $ρ\geq 1$, the {\em mean Ramsey-Turán number} $RT(n,H,ρ-mean)$ is the maximum number of edges a $ρ$-mean colored graph with $n$ vertices can have under the condition it does not have a monochromatic copy of $H$. It is conjectured that $RT(n,K_m,2-mean)=RT(n,K_m,2)$ where $RT(n,H,k)$ is the maximum number of edges a $k$ edge-colored graph with $n$ vertices can have under the condition it does not have a monochromatic copy of $H$. We prove the conjecture holds for $K_3$. We also prove that $RT(n,H,ρ-mean) \leq RT(n,K_{χ(H)},ρ-mean)+o(n^2)$. This result is tight for graphs $H$ whose clique number equals their chromatic number. In particular we get that if $H$ is a 3-chromatic graph having a triangle then $RT(n,H,2-mean) = RT(n,K_3,2-mean)+o(n^2)=RT(n,K_3,2)+o(n^2)=0.4n^2(1+o(1))$.

Let $H$ be a fixed graph. A {\em fractional $H$-decomposition} of a graph $G$ is an assignment of nonnegative real weights to the copies of $H$ in $G$ such that for each $e \in E(G)$, the sum of the weights of copies of $H$ containing $e$ in precisely one. An {\em $H$-packing} of a graph $G$ is a set of edge disjoint copies of $H$ in $G$. The following results are proved. For every fixed $k > 2$, every graph with $n$ vertices and minimum degree at least $n(1-1/9k^{10})+o(n)$ has a fractional $K_k$-decomposition and has a $K_k$-packing which covers all but $o(n^2)$ edges.

We prove that every Eulerian orientation of $K_{m,n}$ contains $\frac{1}{4+\sqrt{8}}mn(1-o(1))$ arc-disjoint directed 4-cycles, improving earlier lower bounds. Combined with a probabilistic argument, this result is used to prove that every regular tournament with $n$ vertices contains $\frac{1}{8+\sqrt{32}}n^2(1-o(1))$ arc-disjoint directed 4-cycles. The result is also used to provide an upper bound for the distance between two antipodal vertices in interchange graphs.

Let ${\cal F}$ be a family of graphs. For a graph $G$, the {\em ${\cal F}$-packing number}, denoted $ν_{\cal F}(G)$, is the maximum number of pairwise edge-disjoint elements of ${\cal F}$ in $G$. A function $ψ$ from the set of elements of ${\cal F}$ in $G$ to $[0,1]$ is a {\em fractional ${\cal F}$-packing} of $G$ if $\sum_{e \in H \in {\cal F}} {ψ(H)} \leq 1$ for each $e \in E(G)$. The {\em fractional ${\cal F}$-packing number}, denoted $ν^*_{\cal F}(G)$, is defined to be the maximum value of $\sum_{H \in {{G} \choose {\cal F}}} ψ(H)$ over all fractional ${\cal F}$-packings $ψ$. Our main result is that $ν^*_{\cal F}(G)-ν_{\cal F}(G) = o(|V(G)|^2)$. Furthermore, a set of $ν_{\cal F}(G) -o(|V(G)|^2)$ edge-disjoint elements of ${\cal F}$ in $G$ can be found in randomized polynomial time. For the special case ${\cal F}=\{H_0\}$ we obtain a significantly simpler proof of a recent difficult result of Haxell and Rödl \cite{HaRo} that $ν^*_{H_0}(G)-ν_{H_0}(G) = o(|V(G)|^2)$.

We prove that a tournament with $n$ vertices has more than $0.13n^2(1+o(1))$ edge-disjoint transitive triples. We also prove some results on the existence of large packings of $k$-vertex transitive tournaments in an $n$-vertex tournament. Our proofs combine probabilistic arguments and some powerful packing results due to Wilson and to Frankl and Rödl.

Let $G$ be a graph. For a given positive integer $d$, let $f_G(d)$ denote the largest integer $t$ such that in every coloring of the edges of $G$ with two colors there is a monochromatic subgraph with minimum degree at least $d$ and order at least $t$. For $n > k > d$ let $f(n,k,d)$ denote the minimum of $f_G(d)$ where $G$ ranges over all graphs with $n$ vertices and minimum degree at least $k$. In this paper we establish $f(n,k,d)$ whenever $k$ or $n-k$ are fixed, and $n$ is sufficiently large. We also consider the case where more than two colors are allowed.

Let $TT_k$ denote the transitive tournament on $k$ vertices. Let $TT(h,k)$ denote the graph obtained from $TT_k$ by replacing each vertex with an independent set of size $h \geq 1$. The following result is proved: Let $c_2=1/2$, $c_3=5/6$ and $c_k=1-2^{-k-\log k}$ for $k \geq 4$. For every $ε> 0$ there exists $N=N(ε,h,k)$ such that for every undirected graph $G$ with $n > N$ vertices and with $δ(G) \geq c_kn$, every orientation of $G$ contains vertex disjoint copies of $TT(h,k)$ that cover all but at most $εn$ vertices. In the cases $k=2$ and $k=3$ the result is asymptotically tight. For $k \geq 4$, $c_k$ cannot be improved to less than $1-2^{-0.5k(1+o(1))}$.

Let $F=\{H_1,...,H_k\}$ be a family of graphs. A graph $G$ with $m$ edges is called {\em totally $F$-decomposable} if for {\em every} linear combination of the form $α_1 e(H_1) + ... + α_k e(H_k) = m$ where each $α_i$ is a nonnegative integer, there is a coloring of the edges of $G$ with $α_1+...+α_k$ colors such that exactly $α_i$ color classes induce each a copy of $H_i$, for $i=1,...,k$. We prove that if $F$ is any fixed family of trees then $\log n/n$ is a sharp threshold function for the property that the random graph $G(n,p)$ is totally $F$-decomposable. In particular, if $H$ is a tree, then $\log n/n$ is a sharp threshold function for the property that $G(n,p)$ contains $\lfloor e(G)/e(H) \rfloor$ edge-disjoint copies of $H$.

Let $H$ be a $k$-uniform hypergraph with $n$ vertices. A {\em strong $r$-coloring} is a partition of the vertices into $r$ parts, such that each edge of $H$ intersects each part. A strong $r$-coloring is called {\em equitable} if the size of each part is $\lceil n/r \rceil$ or $\lfloor n/r \rfloor$. We prove that for all $a \geq 1$, if the maximum degree of $H$ satisfies $Δ(H) \leq k^a$ then $H$ has an equitable coloring with $\frac{k}{a \ln k}(1-o_k(1))$ parts. In particular, every $k$-uniform hypergraph with maximum degree $O(k)$ has an equitable coloring with $\frac{k}{\ln k}(1-o_k(1))$ parts. The result is asymptotically tight. The proof uses a double application of the non-symmetric version of the Lovász Local Lemma.

Let $H$ be a hypergraph. For a $k$-edge coloring $c : E(H) \to \{1,...,k\}$ let $f(H,c)$ be the number of components in the subhypergraph induced by the color class with the least number of components. Let $f_k(H)$ be the maximum possible value of $f(H,c)$ ranging over all $k$-edge colorings of $H$. If $H$ is the complete graph $K_n$ then, trivially, $f_1(K_n)=f_2(K_n)=1$. In this paper we prove that for $n \geq 6$, $f_3(K_n)=\lfloor n/6 \rfloor+1$ and supply close upper and lower bounds for $f_k(K_n)$ in case $k \geq 4$. Several results concerning the value of $f_k(K_n^r)$, where $K_n^r$ is the complete $r$-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices, are also established.

The domatic number of a graph $G$, denoted $dom(G)$, is the maximum possible cardinality of a family of disjoint sets of vertices of $G$, each set being a dominating set of $G$. It is well known that every graph without isolated vertices has $dom(G) \geq 2$. For every $k$, it is known that there are graphs with minimum degree at least $k$ and with $dom(G)=2$. In this paper we prove that this is not the case if $G$ is $k$-regular or {\em almost} $k$-regular (by ``almost'' we mean that the minimum degree is $k$ and the maximum degree is at most $Ck$ for some fixed real number $C \geq 1$). In this case we prove that $dom(G) \geq (1+o_k(1))k/(2\ln k)$. We also prove that the order of magnitude $k/\ln k$ cannot be improved. One cannot replace the constant 2 with a constant smaller than 1. The proof uses the so called {\em semi-random method} which means that combinatorial objects are generated via repeated applications of the probabilistic method; in our case iterative applications of the Lovász Local Lemma.