arXiv++ Combinatorics

In a remarkable paper, Tatsuyuki Hikita settled a longstanding e-positivity conjecture of Stanley and Stembridge. Among many other things, he wrote down a certain formula ${\varphi}_k$, and proved that the ${\varphi}_k$ sum to one, thereby defining a probability distribution. Though Hikita's proof was simple, it remains surprising that the ${\varphi}_k$ sum to one. In this note, we give a combinatorial interpretation of Hikita's probability distribution. The main tool is a certain permutation statistic that we call the watershed. After seeing an early version of our work, Darij Grinberg noticed that the permutation statistic was implicit in a so-called "bulldozer problem" that was on the short list for the 2015 International Mathematics Olympiad. However, our description of the statistic, which makes use of Foata's fundamental bijection, appears to be new.

It is well known that in games with imperfect information, such as poker, bluffing with some probability can be a component of the optimal strategy. However, as far as we know, nobody has ever exhibited a Scrabble position in which the optimal strategy involves bluffing, or even a Scrabble position in which the optimal strategy is a mixed (i.e., randomized) strategy. We present a carefully constructed Scrabble position, that could actually arise in a tournament game with no invalid words played, in which the optimal strategy (assuming that a tied score leads to the point being split equally, with no recourse to so-called "spread points" as a tie-breaking mechanism) is to make Move A with probability 1/3 and to make Move B with probability 2/3. Move B can reasonably be called a bluff, in the sense that it sets up a threat which the player cannot in fact execute, but which the opponent may not be able to rule out.

A Latin tableau of shape $λ$ and type $μ$ is a Young diagram of shape $λ$ in which each box contains a single positive integer, with no repeated integers in any row or column, and the $i$th most common integer appearing $μ_i$ times. Over twenty years ago, Chow et al., in their study of a generalization of Rota's basis conjecture that they called the wide partition conjecture, conjectured a necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of a Latin tableau of shape $λ$ and type $μ$. We report some computational evidence for this conjecture, and prove that the conjecture correctly characterizes, for any given $λ$, at least the first four parts of $μ$.

We revive an old lateral-thinking puzzle by Michael Rabin, involving poisons with strange properties. We show that the puzzle admits several unintended solutions that are just as interesting as the intended solution. Analyzing these alternative solutions using game theory yields surprisingly subtle results and several unanswered questions.

Suppose that $χ_λ$ and $χ_μ$ are distinct irreducible characters of the symmetric group $S_n$. We give an algorithm that, in time polynomial in $n$, constructs $π\in S_n$ such that $χ_λ(π)$ is provably different from $χ_μ(π)$. In fact, we show a little more. Suppose $f=χ_λ$ for some irreducible character $χ_λ$ of $S_n$, but we do not know $λ$, and we are given only oracle access to $f$. We give an algorithm that determines $λ$, using a number of queries to $f$ that is polynomial in $n$. Each query can be computed in time polynomial in $n$ by someone who knows $λ$.

Motivated by a 1993 conjecture of Stanley and Stembridge, Shareshian and Wachs conjectured that the characteristic map takes the dot action of the symmetric group on the cohomology of a regular semisimple Hessenberg variety to $ωX_G(t)$, where $X_G(t)$ is the chromatic quasisymmetric function of the incomparability graph $G$ of the corresponding natural unit interval order, and $ω$ is the usual involution on symmetric functions. We prove the Shareshian--Wachs conjecture. Our proof uses the local invariant cycle theorem of Beilinson-Bernstein-Deligne to obtain a surjection from the cohomology of a regular Hessenberg variety of Jordan type $λ$ to a space of local invariant cycles; as $λ$ ranges over all partitions, these spaces collectively contain all the information about the dot action on a regular semisimple Hessenberg variety. Using a palindromicity argument, we show that in our case the surjections are actually isomorphisms, thus reducing the Shareshian-Wachs conjecture to computing the cohomology of a regular Hessenberg variety. But this cohomology has already been described combinatorially by Tymoczko; we give a bijective proof (using a generalization of a combinatorial reciprocity theorem of Chow) that Tymoczko's combinatorial description coincides with the combinatorics of the chromatic quasisymmetric function.

There is a strikingly simple classical formula for the number of lattice paths avoiding the line x = ky when k is a positive integer. We show that the natural generalization of this simple formula continues to hold when the line x = ky is replaced by certain periodic staircase boundaries--but only under special conditions. The simple formula fails in general, and it remains an open question to what extent our results can be further generalized.

Rota's basis conjecture, open since 1989, states that if B_1, B_2, ..., B_n are n bases of a vector space of rank n, then there is an nxn grid of vectors such that the vectors in the ith row are precisely the elements of B_i and such that every column is also a basis. It is shown that Rota's basis conjecture follows from a similar conjecture that involves only three bases instead of n bases: If M is a matroid of rank n that is a disjoint union of 3 bases, and I_1, ..., I_n are disjoint independent sets with |I_i| <= 3, then there exists an nx3 grid G that contains each element of M exactly once, with the elements of I_i appearing in row i, such that the three columns of G are bases of M.

Say that mu is a ``subpartition'' of an integer partition lambda if the multiset of parts of mu is a submultiset of the parts of lambda, and define an integer partition lambda to be ``wide'' if for every subpartition mu of lambda, mu >= mu' in dominance order (where mu' denotes the conjugate or transpose of mu). Then Brian Taylor and the first author have conjectured that an integer partition lambda is wide if and only if there exists a tableau of shape lambda such that (1) for all i, the entries in the ith row of the tableau are precisely the integers from 1 to lambda_i inclusive, and (2) for all j, the entries in the jth column of the tableau are pairwise distinct. This conjecture was originally motivated by Rota's basis conjecture and, if true, yields a new class of integer multiflow problems that satisfy max-flow min-cut and integrality. Wide partitions also yield a class of graphs that satisfy ``delta-conjugacy'' (in the sense of Greene and Kleitman), and the above conjecture implies that these graphs furthermore have a completely saturated stable set partition. We present several partial results, but the conjecture remains very much open.

In Chapter 2 we study the path-cycle symmetric function of a digraph, a symmetric function generalization of Chung and Graham's cover polynomial. Most of this material appears in either Advances in Math. 118 (1996), 71-98 or J. Algebraic Combin. 10 (1999), 227-240. Chapter 3 contains miscellaneous results about Stanley's symmetric function generalization X_G of the chromatic polynomial, e.g., we establish a connection with some of Tutte's work on the chromatic polynomial and use this to prove that X_G is reconstructible. Most of Chapter 3 does not appear elsewhere.

The problem of minimizing the number of bidirectional SONET rings required to support a given traffic demand has been studied by several researchers. Here we study the related ``ring grooming problem'' of minimizing the number of add/drop locations instead of the number of rings; in a number of situations this is a better approximation to the true equipment cost. Our main result is a new lower bound for the case of uniform traffic. This allows us to prove that a certain simple algorithm for uniform traffic is in fact a constant-factor approximation algorithm, and it also demonstrates that known lower bounds for the general problem--in particular, the linear programming relaxation--are not within a constant factor of the optimum. We also show that our results for uniform traffic extend readily to the more practically important case of quasi-uniform traffic. Finally, we show that if the number of nodes on the ring is fixed, then ring grooming is solvable in polynomial time; however, whether ring grooming is fixed-parameter tractable is still an open question.

If a student asks for an antiderivative of exp(x^2), there is a standard reply: the answer is not an elementary function. But if a student asks for a closed-form expression for the real root of x = cos(x), there is no standard reply. We propose a definition of a closed-form expression for a number (as opposed to a *function*) that we hope will become standard. With our definition, the question of whether the root of x = cos(x) has a closed form is, perhaps surprisingly, still open. We show that Schanuel's conjecture in transcendental number theory resolves questions like this, and we also sketch some connections with Tarski's problem of the decidability of the first-order theory of the reals with exponentiation. Many (hopefully accessible) open problems are described.

One of the simplest axiomatizations of a matroid is in terms of independent sets. Curiously, no such independent set axiomatization is known for Gelfand and Serganova's WP-matroids (which are ``Coxeter group analogues'' of matroids). Here we state and prove such an axiomatization in the special case of symplectic matroids. No prior knowledge of WP-matroids is assumed; we believe the paper should be accessible and interesting to anyone with some interest in matroids.

We give a new proof of Chung and Graham's ``G-descent expansion'' of the classical chromatic polynomial, as well as a special case of the quasi-symmetric function expansion of the path-cycle symmetric function Xi_D. Both proofs rely on Stanley's quasi-symmetric function expansion of the chromatic symmetric function X_G. We also show that Stanley's expansion suggests that a Robinson-Schensted algorithm for (3+1)-free posets---something that has been sought for unsuccessfully for some time---ought to ``respect descents'' in a certain precise sense.

Stanley has studied a symmetric function generalization X_G of the chromatic polynomial of a graph G. The innocent-looking Stanley-Stembridge Poset Chain Conjecture states that the expansion of X_G in terms of elementary symmetric functions has nonnegative coefficients if G is a clawfree incomparability graph. Here we give a combinatorial interpretation of these coefficients by combining Gasharov's work on the conjecture with Egecioglu and Remmel's combinatorial interpretation of the inverse Kostka matrix. This gives a new proof of a partial nonnegativity result of Stanley. As an interesting byproduct we derive a previously unnoticed result relating acyclic orientations to P-tableaux.