arXiv++ Combinatorics

We use the Strong Splitter Theorem to decompose the excluded minor class of binary matroids with no $E_4$-minor. Using this theorem we can get the 3-decomposers and the extremal internally 4-connected matroids as well as any other important matroids in the class. The matroid $E_4$ is a self-dual 10-element binary 3-connected matroid that plays a useful role in structural results. It is a single-element coextension of $P_9$, which is a single-element extension of the 4-wheel. We show that the extremal matroids in this class are the binary rank-$r$ spikes $Z_r$, the rank 3 and 4 projective geometries $F_7$ and $PG(3,2)$, respectively, the 17-element internally 4-connected matroid $R_{17}$, and one 12-element rank-6 matroid. All the other 3-connected members have $P_9$ or $P_9^*$ as 3-decomposers. As immediate corollaries we get decomposition results for $EX[P_9^*]$ and $EX[P_9]$ as well as the internally 4-connected members of these classes.

We establish the following splitter theorem for graphs and its generalization for matroids: Let $G$ and $H$ be $3$-connected simple graphs such that $G$ has an $H$-minor and $k:=|V(G)|-|V(H)|\ge 2$. Let $n:=\left\lceil k/2\right\rceil+1$. Then there are pairwise disjoint sets $X_1,\dots,X_n\subseteq E(G)$ such that each $G/X_i$ is a $3$-connected graph with an $H$-minor, each $X_i$ is a singleton set or the edge set of a triangle of $G$ with $3$ degree-$3$ vertices and $X_1\cup\cdots\cup X_n$ contains no edge sets of circuits of $G$ other than the $X_i$'s. This result extends previous ones of Whittle (for $k=1,2$) and Costalonga (for $k=3$).

Let $EX[M_1\dots, M_k]$ denote the class of binary matroids with no minors isomorphic to $M_1, \dots, M_k$. In this paper we give a decomposition theorem for $EX[S_{10}, S_{10}^*]$, where $S_{10}$ is a certain 10-element rank-4 matroid. As corollaries we obtain decomposition theorems for the classes obtained by excluding the Kuratowski graphs $EX[M(K_{3,3}), M^*(K_{3,3}), M(K_5), M^*(K_5)]$ and $EX[M(K_{3,3}), M^*(K_{3,3})]$. These decomposition theorems imply results on internally $4$-connected matroids by Zhou [\ref{Zhou2004}], Qin and Zhou [\ref{Qin2004}], and Mayhew, Royle and Whitte [\ref{Mayhewsubmitted}].

Let $\mathcal M$ be a class of matroids closed under minors and isomorphism. Let $N$ be a matroid in $\mathcal M$ with an exact $k$-separation $(A, B)$. We say $N$ is a $k$-decomposer for $\mathcal M$ having $(A, B)$ as an inducer, if every matroid $M\in \mathcal M$ having $N$ as a minor has a $k$-separation $(X, Y)$ such that, $A\subseteq X$ and $B\subseteq Y$. Seymour [3, 9.1] proved that a matroid $N$ is a $k$-decomposer for an excluded-minor class, if certain conditions are met for all 3-connected matroids $M$ in the class, where $|E(M)-E(N)|\le 2$. We reinterpret Seymour's Theorem in terms of the connectivity function and give a check-list that is easier to implement because case-checking is reduced.

A matroid is $\text{GF}(q)$-regular if it is representable over all proper superfields of the field $\text{GF}(q)$. We show that, for highly connected matroids having a large projective geometry over $\text{GF}(q)$ as a minor, the property of $\text{GF}(q)$-regularity is equivalent to representability over both $\text{GF}(q^2)$ and $\text{GF}(q^t)$ for some odd integer $t \geq 3$. We do this by means of an exact structural description of all such matroids.

For any minor-closed class of matroids over a fixed finite field, we state an exact structural characterization for the sufficiently connected matroids in the class. We also state a number of conjectures that might be approachable using the structural characterization.

A result of Seymour implies that any 3-connected matroid with a modular 3-point line is binary. We prove a similar characterization for 3-connected matroids with modular 4-point lines. We show that such a matroid is either representable over GF(3) or GF(4) or has an $F_7$-minor and either an $(F_7^-)$- or $(F_7^-)^*$-minor.

We prove that if M is a vertically 4-connected matroid with a modular flat X of rank at least three, then every representation of M | X over a finite field F extends to a unique F-representation of M. A corollary is that when F has order q, any vertically 4-connected matroid with a PG(2, F)-restriction is either F-representable or has a U_{2, q^2+1}-minor. We also show that no excluded minor for the class of F-representable matroids has a PG(2, F)-restriction.

In this paper we establish a variation of the Splitter Theorem. Let $M$ and $N$ be simple 3-connected matroids. We say that $x\in E(M)$ is vertically $N$-contractible if $si(M/x)$ is a 3-connected matroid with an $N$-minor. Whittle (for $k=1,2$) and Costalonga(for $k=3$) proved that, if $r(M)- r(N)\ge k$, then $M$ has a $k$-independent set $I$ of vertically $N$-contractible elements. Costalonga also characterized an obstruction for the existence of such a 4-independent set $I$ in the binary case, provided $r(M)-r(N)\ge 5$, and improved this result when $r(M)-r(N)\ge 6$, and in the graphic case. In this paper we generalize the results of Costalonga to the non-binary case. Moreover, we apply our results to the study of properties similar to 3-roundedness in classes of matroids.

The prism graph is the dual of the complete graph on five vertices with an edge deleted, $K_5\backslash e$. In this paper we determine the class of binary matroids with no prism minor. The motivation for this problem is the 1963 result by Dirac where he identified the simple 3-connected graphs with no minor isomorphic to the prism graph. We prove that besides Dirac's infinite families of graphs and four infinite families of non-regular matroids determined by Oxley, there are only three possibilities for a matroid in this class: it is isomorphic to the dual of the generalized parallel connection of $F_7$ with itself across a triangle with an element of the triangle deleted; it's rank is bounded by 5; or it admits a non-minimal exact 3-separation induced by the 3-separation in $P_9$. Since the prism graph has rank 5, the class has to contain the binary projective geometries of rank 3 and 4, $F_7$ and $PG(3, 2)$, respectively. We show that there is just one rank 5 extremal matroid in the class. It has 17 elements and is an extension of $R_{10}$, the unique splitter for regular matroids. As a corollary, we obtain Dillon, Mayhew, and Royle's result identifying the binary internally 4-connected matroids with no prism minor [5].

The weak-map order on the matroid base polytopes is the partial order defined by inclusion. Lucas proved that the base polytope of no binary matroid includes the base polytope of a connected matroid. A matroid base polytope is said to be decomposable when it has a polytopal decomposition which consists of at least two matroid base polytopes. We shed light on the relation between the decomposability and the weak-map order of matroid base polytopes. We classify matroids into five types with respect to the weak-map order and decomposability. We give an example of a matroid in each class. Moreover, we give a counterexample to a conjecture proposed by Lucas, which says that, when one matroid base polytope covers another matroid base polytope with respect to inclusion, the latter matroid base polytope should be a facet of the former matroid base polytope.

The Splitter Theorem states that, if $N$ is a 3-connected proper minor of a 3-connected matroid $M$ such that, if $N$ is a wheel or whirl then $M$ has no larger wheel or whirl, respectively, then there is a sequence $M_0,..., M_n$ of 3-connected matroids with $M_0\cong N$, $M_n=M$ and for $i\in \{1,..., n\}$, $M_i$ is a single-element extension or coextension of $M_{i-1}$. Observe that there is no condition on how many extensions may occur before a coextension must occur. In this paper, we give a strengthening of the Splitter Theorem, as a result of which we can obtain, up to isomorphism, $M$ starting with $N$ and at each step doing a 3-connected single-element extension or coextension, such that at most two consecutive single-element extensions occur in the sequence (unless the rank of the matroids involved are $r(M)$). Moreover, if two consecutive single-element extensions by elements $\{e, f\}$ are followed by a coextension by element $g$, then $\{e, f, g\}$ form a triad in the resulting matroid. Using the Strong Splitter Theorem, we make progress toward the problem of determining the almost-regular matroids [6, 15.9.8]. {\it Find all 3-connected non-regular matroids such that, for all $e$, either $M\backslash e$ or $M/e$ is regular.} In [4] we determined the binary almost-regular matroids with at least one regular element (an element such that both $M\backslash e$ and $M/e$ is regular) by characterizing the class of binary almost-regular matroids with no minor isomorphic to one particular matroid that we called $E_5$. As a consequence of the Strong Splitter Theorem we can determine the class of binary matroids with an $E_5$-minor, but no $E_4$-minor.

Generalizing a well known theorem for finite matroids, we prove that for every (infinite) connected matroid M there is a unique tree T such that the nodes of T correspond to minors of M that are either 3-connected or circuits or cocircuits, and the edges of T correspond to certain nested 2-separations of M. These decompositions are invariant under duality.

If EE is a set of matroids, then ex(EE) denotes the set of matroids that have no minor isomorphic to a member of EE. If EE' is a subset of EE, we say that EE' is /superfluous/ if ex(EE - EE') - ex(EE) contains only finitely many 3-connected matroids. We characterize the superfluous subsets of six well-known collections of excluded minors.

We prove that, for each nonnegative integer k and each matroid N, if M is a 3-connected matroid containing N as a minor, and the the branch width of M is sufficiently large, then there is a k-element subset X of E(M) such that one of M\X and M/X is 3-connected and contains N as a minor.

For a matroid $M$, an element $e$ such that both $M\backslash e$ and $M/e$ are regular is called a regular element of $M$. We determine completely the structure of non-regular matroids with at least two regular elements. Besides four small size matroids, all 3-connected matroids in the class can be pieced together from $F_7$ or $S_8$ and a regular matroid using 3-sums. This result takes a step toward solving a problem posed by Paul Seymour: Find all 3-connected non-regular matroids with at least one regular element [5, 14.8.8].

It is proved that for each prime field $GF(p)$, there is an integer $f(p)$ such that a 4-connected matroid has at most $f(p)$ inequivalent representations over $GF(p)$. We also prove a stronger theorem that obtains the same conclusion for matroids satisfying a connectivity condition, intermediate between 3-connectivity and 4-connectivity that we term "$k$-coherence". We obtain a variety of other results on inequivalent representations including the following curious one. For a prime power $q$, let ${\mathcal R}(q)$ denote the set of matroids representable over all fields with at least $q$ elements. Then there are infinitely many Mersenne primes if and only if, for each prime power $q$, there is an integer $m_q$ such that a 3-connected member of ${\mathcal R}(q)$ has at most $m_q$ inequivalent GF(7)-representations. The theorems on inequivalent representations of matroids are consequences of structural results that do not rely on representability. The bulk of this paper is devoted to proving such results.

The multivariate Tutte polynomial $\hat Z_M$ of a matroid $M$ is a generalization of the standard two-variable version, obtained by assigning a separate variable $v_e$ to each element $e$ of the ground set $E$. It encodes the full structure of $M$. Let $\bv = \{v_e\}_{e\in E}$, let $K$ be an arbitrary field, and suppose $M$ is connected. We show that $\hat Z_M$ is irreducible over $K(\bv)$, and give three self-contained proofs that the Galois group of $\hat Z_M$ over $K(\bv)$ is the symmetric group of degree $n$, where $n$ is the rank of $M$. An immediate consequence of this result is that the Galois group of the multivariate Tutte polynomial of any matroid is a direct product of symmetric groups. Finally, we conjecture a similar result for the standard Tutte polynomial of a connected matroid.

Let M be a matroid representable over a (partial) field P and B a matrix representable over a sub-partial field P' of P. We say that B confines M to P' if, whenever a P-representation matrix A of M has a submatrix B, A is a scaled P'-matrix. We show that, under some conditions on the partial fields, on M, and on B, verifying whether B confines M to P' amounts to a finite check. A corollary of this result is Whittle's Stabilizer Theorem. A combination of the Confinement Theorem and the Lift Theorem from arXiv:0804.3263 leads to a short proof of Whittle's characterization of the matroids representable over GF(3) and other fields. We also use a combination of the Confinement Theorem and the Lift Theorem to prove a characterization, in terms of representability over partial fields, of the 3-connected matroids that have k inequivalent representations over GF(5), for k = 1, ..., 6. Additionally we give, for a fixed matroid M, an algebraic construction of a partial field P_M and a representation A over P_M such that every representation of M over a partial field P is equal to f(A) for some homomorphism f:P_M->P. Using the Confinement Theorem we prove an algebraic analog of the theory of free expansions by Geelen et al.

There exist several theorems which state that when a matroid is representable over distinct fields F_1,...,F_k, it is also representable over other fields. We prove a theorem, the Lift Theorem, that implies many of these results. First, parts of Whittle's characterization of representations of ternary matroids follow from our theorem. Second, we prove the following theorem by Vertigan: if a matroid is representable over both GF(4) and GF(5), then it is representable over the real numbers by a matrix such that the absolute value of the determinant of every nonsingular square submatrix is a power of the golden ratio. Third, we give a characterization of the 3-connected matroids having at least two inequivalent representations over GF(5). We show that these are representable over the complex numbers. Additionally we provide an algebraic construction that, for any set of fields F_1,...,F_k, gives the best possible result that can be proven using the Lift Theorem.