arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $G$ be a graph and $S \subseteq V(G)$. In the cycle convexity, we say that $S$ is \textit{cycle convex} if for any $u\in V(G)\setminus S$, the induced subgraph of $S\cup\{u\}$ contains no cycle that includes $u$. The \textit{cycle convex hull} of $S$ is the smallest convex set containing $S$. The \textit{cycle hull number} of $G$, denoted by $hn_{cc}(G)$, is the cardinality of the smallest set $S$ such that the convex hull of $S$ is $V(G)$. The \textit{convexity number} of $G$, denoted by $C_{cc}(G)$, is the maximum cardinality of a proper convex set of $V(G)$. This paper studies cycle convexity in graph products. We show that the cycle hull number is always two for strong and lexicographic products. For the Cartesian, we establish tight bounds for this product and provide a closed formula when the factors are trees, generalizing an existing result for grid graphs. In addition, given a graph $G$ and an integer $k$, we prove that $hn_{cc}(G) \leq k$ is NP-complete even if $G$ is a bipartite Cartesian product graph, addressing an open question in the literature. Furthermore, we present exact formulas for the cycle convexity number in those three graph products. That leads to the NP-completeness of, given a graph $G$ and an integer $k$, deciding whether $C_{cc}(G) \geq k$, when $G$ is a Cartesian, strong or lexicographic product graph.

We prove that any lower unitriangular and totally nonnegative matrix gives rise to a family of polynomials with only real zeros. This has consequences for problems in several areas of mathematics. We use it to develop a general theory for chain enumeration in posets and zeros of chain polynomials. The results obtained extend and unify results of the first author, Brenti, Welker and Athanasiadis. In the process we define a notion of $h$-vectors for a large class of posets which generalize the notions of $h$-vectors associated to simplicial and cubical complexes. A consequence of our methods is a characterization of the convex hull of all characteristic polynomials of hyperplane arrangements of fixed dimension and over a fixed finite field. This may be seen as a refinement of the Critical Problem of Crapo and Rota. We also use the methods developed to answer an open problem posed by Forgács and Tran on the real-rootedness of polynomials arising from certain bivariate rational functions.

A lattice $(d,k)$-polytope is the convex hull of a set of points in $\mathbb{R}^d$ whose coordinates are integers ranging between $0$ and $k$. We consider the smallest possible distance $\varepsilon(d,k)$ between two disjoint lattice $(d,k)$-polytopes. We propose an algebraic model for this distance and derive from it an explicit formula for $\varepsilon(2,k)$. Our model also allows for the computation of previously intractable values of $\varepsilon(d,k)$. In particular, we compute $\varepsilon(3,k)$ when $4\leq{k}\leq8$, $\varepsilon(4,k)$ when $2\leq{k}\leq3$, and $\varepsilon(6,1)$.

The length polyhedron of an interval order $P$ is the convex hull of integer vectors representing the interval lengths in possible interval representations of $P$ in which all intervals have integer endpoints. This polyhedron is an integral translation of a polyhedral cone, with its apex corresponding to the canonical interval representation of $P$ (also known as the minimal endpoint representation). In earlier work, we introduced an arc-weighted directed graph model, termed the key graph, inspired by this canonical representation. We showed that cycles in the key graph correspond, via Fourier-Motzkin elimination, to inequalities that describe supporting hyperplanes of the length polyhedron. These cycle inequalities derived from the key graph form a complete system of linear inequalities defining the length polyhedron. By applying a theorem due to Cook, we establish here that this system of inequalities is totally dual integral (TDI). Leveraging circulations, total dual integrality, and the special structure of the key graph, our main theorem demonstrates that a cycle inequality is a positive linear combination of other cycle inequalities if and only if it is a positive integral linear combination of smaller cycle inequalities (where `smaller' here refers a natural weak ordering among these cycle inequalities). This yields an efficient method to remove redundant cycle inequalities and ultimately construct the unique minimal TDI-system, also known as the Schrijver system, for the length polyhedron. Notably, if the key graph contains a polynomial number of cycles, this gives a polynomial-time algorithm to compute the Schrijver system for the length polyhedron. Lastly, we provide examples of interval orders where the Schrijver system has an exponential size.

This article introduces the theory of Veronese polytopes, a broad generalisation of cyclic polytopes. These arise as convex hulls of points on curves with one or more connected components, obtained as the image of the rational normal curve in affine charts. We describe their facial structure by extending Gale's evenness condition, and provide a further combinatorial characterisation of facets via $σ$-parity alternating sequences. Notably, we establish a bijective correspondence between combinatorial types of Veronese polytopes and partitions of finite sets equipped with a cyclic order, called circular compositions. We show that, although the only Veronese $3$-polytopes are the cyclic $3$-polytopes and the octahedron, in general dimension they form a rich and diverse class including all combinatorial types of simplicial $d$-polytopes with at most $d+3$ vertices, the cross-polytope and particular stacked polytopes. In addition, we characterise which curves defining Veronese polytopes are $d$-order curves, and provide a closed formula for the number of facets of any Veronese polytope.

Pick $n$ independent and uniform random points $U_1,\ldots,U_n$ in a compact convex set $K$ of $\mathbb{R}^d$ with volume 1, and let $P^{(d)}_K(n)$ be the probability that these points are in convex position. The Sylvester conjecture in $\mathbb{R}^d$ is that $\min_K P^{(d)}_K(d+2)$ is achieved by the $d$-dimensional simplices $K$ (only). In this paper, we focus on a companion model, already studied in the $2d$ case, which we define in any dimension $d$: we say that $K$ has $F$ as a flat floor, if $F$ is a subset of $K$, contained in a hyperplan $P$, such that $K$ lies in one of the half-spaces defined by $P$. We define $Q_K^F(n)$ as the probability that $U_1,\cdots,U_n$ together with $F$ are in convex position (i.e., the $U_i$ are on the boundary of the convex hull ${\sf CH}(\{U_1,\cdots,U_n\}\cup F\})$). We prove that, for all fixed $F$, $K\mapsto Q_K^F(2)$ reaches its minimum on the "mountains" with floor $F$ (mountains are convex hull of $F$ union an additional vertex), while the maximum is not reached, but $K\mapsto Q_K^F(2)$ has values arbitrary close to 1. If the optimisation is done on the set of $K$ contained in $F\times[0,d]$ (the "subprism case"), then the minimum is also reached by the mountains, and the maximum by the "prism" $F\times[0,1]$. Since again, $Q_K^F{(2)}$ relies on the expected volume (of ${\sf CH}(\{V_1,V_2\}\cup F\})$), this result can be seen as a proof of the Sylvester problem in the floor case. In $2d$, where $F$ can essentially be the segment $[0,1],$ we give a general decomposition formula for $Q_K^F(n)$ so to compute several formulas and bounds for different $K$. In 3D, we give some bounds for $Q_K^F(n)$ for various floors $F$ and special cases of $K$.

The length polyhedron $Q_P$ of an interval order $P$ is the convex hull of integral vectors representing the interval lengths in interval representations of $P$. This polyhedron has been studied by various authors, including Fishburn and Isaak. Notably, $Q_P$ forms a pointed affine cone, a property inherited from being a projection of the representation polyhedron, a structure explored also by Doignon and Pauwels. The apex of the length polyhedron corresponds to Greenough's minimal endpoint representation, which is, in fact, the length vector of the canonical interval representation -- an interval representation that minimizes the sum of the interval lengths. Building on a combinatorial perspective of canonical representations, we refine Isaak's graph-theoretical model by introducing a new and simpler directed graph. From directed cycles of this key digraph, we extract a linear system of inequalities that precisely characterizes the length polyhedron $Q_P$. This combinatorial approach also reveals the unique Hilbert basis of the polyhedron. We prove that the intersection graph of the sets corresponding to these binary rays are Berge graphs; therefore they are perfect graphs. As a result, for interval orders with bounded width, the length polyhedron has a polynomial-sized Hilbert basis, which can be computed in polynomial time. We also provide an example of interval orders with a Hilbert basis of exponential size. In a companion paper we determine the Schrijver system for the length polyhedron. We conclude with open problems.

Given a graph $G$, we study the $2$-edge-connected subgraph polytope $\mathrm{TECSP}(G)$, which is given by the convex hull of the incidence vectors of all $2$-edge-connected subgraphs of $G$. We describe the lattice points of this polytope by linear inequalities which provides an ILP-algorithm for finding a $2$-edge-connected subgraph of maximum weight. Furthermore, we characterize when these inequalities define facets of $\mathrm{TECSP}(G)$. We also consider further types of supporting hyperplanes of $\mathrm{TECSP}(G)$ and study when they are facet-defining. Finally, we investigate the efficiency of our considered inequalities practically on some classes of graphs.

We prove that the spanning trees of any outerplanar triangulation $G$ can be listed so that any two consecutive spanning trees differ in an exchange of two edges that share an end vertex. For outerplanar graphs $G$ with faces of arbitrary lengths (not necessarily 3) we establish a similar result, with the condition that the two exchanged edges share an end vertex or lie on a common face. These listings of spanning trees are obtained from a simple greedy algorithm that can be implemented efficiently, i.e., in time $\mathcal{O}(n \log n)$ per generated spanning tree, where $n$ is the number of vertices of $G$. Furthermore, the listings correspond to Hamilton paths on the 0/1-polytope that is obtained as the convex hull of the characteristic vectors of all spanning trees of $G$.

We study lattice polytopes which arise as the convex hull of chip vectors for \textit{self-reachable} chip configurations on a tree $T$. We show that these polytopes always have the integer decomposition property and characterize the vertex sets of these polytopes. Additionally, in the case of self-reachable configurations with the smallest possible number of chips, we show that these polytopes are unimodularly equivalent to a unit cube.

The simplest way to generate a lattice of convex sets is to consider an initial set of points and draw segments, triangles, and any convex hull from it, then intersect them to obtain new points, and so forth. The result is an infinite lattice for most sets, while only a few initial sets of points perform a finite lattice. By giving an adequate notion of the configuration of points, we identify which sets in the plane define a finite convex hull lattice: four regular families and one sporadic configuration. We explore configurations in the space and higher dimensions.

We study the natural extended-variable formulation for the disjunction of $n+1$ polytopes in $\mathbb{R}^d$. We demonstrate that the convex hull $D$ in the natural extended-variable space $\mathbb{R}^{d+n}$ is given by full optimal big-M lifting (i) when $d\leq 2$ (and that it is not generally true for $d\geq 3$), and also (ii) under some technical conditions, when the polytopes have a common facet-describing constraint matrix, for arbitrary $d\geq 1$ and $n\geq 1$. We give a broad family of examples with $d\geq 3$ and $n=1$, where the convex hull is not described after employing all full optimal big-M lifting inequalities, but it is described after one round of MIR inequalities. Additionally, we give some general results on the polyhedral structure of $D$, and we demonstrate that all facets of $D$ can be enumerated in polynomial time when $d$ is fixed.

The Brunn-Minkowski inequality, applicable to bounded measurable sets $A$ and $B$ in $\mathbb{R}^d$, states that $|A+B|^{1/d} \geq |A|^{1/d}+|B|^{1/d}$. Equality is achieved if and only if $A$ and $B$ are convex and homothetic sets in $\mathbb{R}^d$. The concept of stability in this context concerns how, when approaching equality, sets $A$ and $B$ are close to homothetic convex sets. In a recent breakthrough [FvHT23], the authors of this paper proved the following folklore conjectures on the sharp stability for the Brunn-Minkowski inequality: (1) A linear stability result concerning the distance from $A$ and $B$ to their respective convex hulls. (2) A quadratic stability result concerning the distance from $A$ and $B$ to their common convex hull. As announced in [FvHT23], in the present paper, we leverage (1) in conjunction with a novel optimal transportation approach to offer an alternative proof for (2).

The matching polytope of a graph $G$ is the convex hull of the indicator vectors of the matchings on $G$. We characterize the graphs whose associated matching polytopes are Gorenstein, and then prove that all Gorenstein matching polytopes possess the integer decomposition property. As a special case study, we examine the matching polytopes of wheel graphs and show that they are not Gorenstein, but do possess the integer decomposition property.

In decision making a weight vector is often obtained from a reciprocal matrix A that gives pairwise comparisons among n alternatives. The weight vector should be chosen from among efficient vectors for A. Since the reciprocal matrix is usually not consistent, there is no unique way of obtaining such a vector. It is known that all weighted geometric means of the columns of A are efficient for A. In particular, any column and the standard geometric mean of the columns are efficient, the latter being an often used weight vector. Here we focus on the study of the efficiency of the vectors in the (algebraic) convex hull of the columns of A. This set contains the (right) Perron eigenvector of A, a classical proposal for the weight vector, and the Perron eigenvector of AA^{T} (the right singular vector of A), recently proposed as an alternative. We consider reciprocal matrices A obtained from a consistent matrix C by modifying at most three pairs of reciprocal entries contained in a 4-by-4 principal submatrix of C. For such matrices, we give necessary and sufficient conditions for all vectors in the convex hull of the columns to be efficient. In particular, this generalizes the known sufficient conditions for the efficiency of the Perron vector. Numerical examples comparing the performance of efficient convex combinations of the columns and weighted geometric means of the columns are provided.

In this paper we study the class of polytopes which can be obtained by taking the convex hull of some subset of the points $\{e_i-e_j \ \vert \ i \neq j\} \cup \{\pm e_i\}$ in $\mathbb{R}^n$, where $e_1,\dots,e_n$ is the standard basis of $\mathbb{R}^n$. Such a polytope can be encoded by a quiver $Q$ with vertices $V \subseteq \{v_1,\dots,v_n\} \cup \{\star\}$, where each edge $v_j\to v_i$ or $\star \to v_i$ or $v_i\to \star$ gives rise to the point $e_i-e_j$ or $e_i$ or $-e_i$, respectively; we denote the corresponding polytope as $\operatorname{Root}(Q)$. These polytopes have been studied extensively under names such as edge polytope and root polytope. We show that if the quiver $Q$ is strongly-connected then the root polytope $\operatorname{Root}(Q)$ is reflexive and terminal; we moreover give a combinatorial description of the facets of $\operatorname{Root}(Q)$. We also show that if $Q$ is planar, then $\operatorname{Root}(Q)$ is (integrally equivalent to the) polar dual of the flow polytope of the dual quiver. Finally we consider the case that $Q$ comes from a ranked poset $P$, and show that $\operatorname{Root}(Q)$ is polar dual to (a translation of) a marked poset polytope. We then study the toric variety $Y(\mathcal{F}_Q)$ associated to the face fan $\mathcal{F}_Q$ of $\operatorname{Root}(Q)$. If $Q$ comes from a ranked poset $P$ we give a combinatorial description of the Picard group of $Y(\mathcal{F}_Q)$, and we show that $Y(\mathcal{F}_Q)$ is a small partial desingularisation of the Hibi toric variety $Y_{\mathcal{O}(P)}$ of the order polytope $\mathcal{O}(P)$. We show that $Y(\mathcal{F}_Q)$ has a small crepant toric resolution of singularities $Y(\widehat{\mathcal{F}}_Q)$, and as a consequence that the Hibi toric variety $Y_{\mathcal{O}(P)}$ has a small resolution of singularities for any ranked poset $P$. These results have applications to mirror symmetry.

Let $V$ be a finite nonempty set. A transit function is a map $R:V\times V\rightarrow 2^V$ such that $R(u,u)=\{u\}$, $R(u,v)=R(v,u)$ and $u\in R(u,v)$ hold for every $u,v\in V$. A set $K\subseteq V$ is $R$-convex if $R(u,v)\subset K$ for every $u,v\in K$ and all $R$-convex subsets of $V$ form a convexity $\mathcal{C}_R$. We consider Minkowski-Krein-Milman property that every $R$-convex set $K$ in a convexity $\mathcal{C}_R$ is the convex hull of the set of extreme points of $K$ from axiomatic point of view and present a characterization of it. Later we consider several well-known transit functions on graphs and present the use of the mentioned characterizations on them.

A triangulation of a point configuration is regular if it can be given by a height function, that is every point gets lifted to a certain height and projecting the lower convex hull gives the triangulation. Checking regularity of a triangulation usually is done by solving a linear program. However when checking many flip-connected triangulations for regularity, one can instead ask which flips preserve regularity. When traversing the flip graph for enumerating all regular triangulations, this allows for vast reduction of the linear programs needing to be solved. At the same time the remaining linear programs will be much smaller.

We consider a class of $0$-$1$ polynomial programming termed multiple choice polynomial programming (MCPP) where the constraint requires exact one component per subset of the partition to be $1$ after all the entries are partitioned. Compared to the unconstrained counterpart, there are few polyhedral studies of MCPP in general form. This paper serves as the first attempt to propose a polytope associated with a hypergraph to study MCPP, which is the convex hull of $0$-$1$ vectors satisfying multiple choice constraints and production constraints. With the help of the decomposability property, we obtain an explicit half-space representation of the MCPP polytope when the underlying hypergraph is $α$-acyclic by induction on the number of hyperedges, which is an analogy of the acyclicity results on the multilinear polytope by Del Pia and Khajavirad (SIAM J Optim 28 (2018) 1049) when the hypergraph is $γ$-acyclic. We also present a necessary and sufficient condition for the inequalities lifted from the facet-inducing ones for the multilinear polytope to be still facet-inducing for the MCPP polytope. This result covers the particular cases by Bärmann, Martin and Schneider (SIAM J Optim 33 (2023) 2909).

The Heilbronn triangle problem asks for the placement of $n$ points in a unit square that maximizes the smallest area of a triangle formed by any three of those points. In $1972$, Schmidt considered a natural generalization of this problem. He asked for the placement of $n$ points in a unit square that maximizes the smallest area of the convex hull formed by any four of those points. He showed a lower bound of $Ω(n^{-3/2})$, which was improved to $Ω(n^{-3/2}\log{n})$ by Leffman. A trivial upper bound of $3/n$ could be obtained, and Schmidt asked if this could be improved asymptotically. However, despite several efforts, no asymptotic improvement over the trivial upper bound was known for the last $50$ years, and the problem started to get the tag of being notoriously hard. Szemer{é}di posed the question of whether one can, at least, improve the constant in this trivial upper bound. In this work, we answer this question by proving an upper bound of $2/n+o(1/n)$. We also extend our results to any convex hulls formed by $k\geq 4$ points.