arXiv++ Combinatorics

In a $(1:b)$ Maker-Breaker game, a primary question is to find the maximal value of $b$ that allows Maker to win the game (that is, the critical bias $b^*$). Erdős conjectured that the critical bias for many Maker-Breaker games played on the edge set of $K_n$ is the same as if both players claim edges randomly. Indeed, in many Maker-Breaker games, "Erdős Paradigm" turned out to be true. Therefore, the next natural question to ask is the (typical) value of the critical bias for Maker-Breaker games where only one player claims edges randomly. A random-player Maker-Breaker game is a two-player game, played the same as an ordinary (biased) Maker-Breaker game, except that one player plays according to his best strategy and claims one element in each round, while the other plays randomly and claims $b$ elements. In fact, for every (ordinary) Maker-Breaker game, there are two different random-player versions; the $(1:b)$ random-Breaker game and the $(m:1)$ random-Maker game. We analyze the random-player version of several classical Maker-Breaker games such as the Hamilton cycle game, the perfect-matching game and the $k$-vertex-connectivity game (played on the edge sets of $K_n$). For each of these games we find or estimate the asymptotic values of $b$ that allow each player to typically win the game. In fact, we provide the "smart" player with an explicit winning strategy for the corresponding value of $b$.

We give several results showing that different discrete structures typically gain certain spanning substructures (in particular, Hamilton cycles) after a modest random perturbation. First, we prove that adding linearly many random edges to a dense k-uniform hypergraph ensures the (asymptotically almost sure) existence of a perfect matching or a loose Hamilton cycle. The proof involves an interesting application of Szemerédi's Regularity Lemma, which might be independently useful. We next prove that digraphs with certain strong expansion properties are pancyclic, and use this to show that adding a linear number of random edges typically makes a dense digraph pancyclic. Finally, we prove that perturbing a certain (minimum-degree-dependent) number of random edges in a tournament typically ensures the existence of multiple edge-disjoint Hamilton cycles. All our results are tight.

A famous conjecture of Pósa from 1962 asserts that every graph on $n$ vertices and with minimum degree at least $2n/3$ contains the square of a Hamilton cycle. The conjecture was proven for large graphs in 1996 by Komlós, Sárközy and Szemerédi. In this paper we prove a degree sequence version of Pósa's conjecture: Given any $η>0$, every graph $G$ of sufficiently large order $n$ contains the square of a Hamilton cycle if its degree sequence $d_1\leq \dots \leq d_n$ satisfies $d_i \geq (1/3+η)n+i$ for all $i \leq n/3$. The degree sequence condition here is asymptotically best possible. Our approach uses a hybrid of the Regularity-Blow-up method and the Connecting-Absorbing method.

We consider a game played on an initially empty graph where two players alternate drawing an edge between vertices subject to the condition that no degree can exceed $k$. We show that for $k=3$, either player can avoid a Hamilton cycle, and for $k\geq4$, either player can force the resulting graph to be Hamiltonian.

A {\it weak (Berge) cycle} is an alternating sequence of vertices and (hyper)edges $C=(v_0, e_1, v_1, ..., v_{\ell-1}, e_\ell, v_{\ell}=v_0)$ such that the vertices $v_0, ..., v_{\ell-1}$ are distinct with $v_k, v_{k+1} \in e_{k}$ for each $k$, but the edges $e_1, ..., e_\ell$ are not necessarily distinct. We prove that the main barrier to the random $d$-uniform hypergraph $H_d(n,p),$ where each of the potential edges of cardinality $d$ is present with probability $p$, developing a weak Hamilton cycle is the presence of isolated vertices. In particular, for $d \geq 3$ fixed and $p=(d-1)! \frac{\ln n + c}{n^{d-1}}$, the probability that $H_d(n, p)$ has a weak Hamilton cycle tends to $e^{-e^{-c}}$, which is also the limiting probability that $H_d(n,p)$ has no isolated vertices. As a consequence, the probability that the random hypergraph $H_d(n, m=\frac{n(\ln n + c)}{d}),$ where $m$ potential edges are chosen uniformly at random to be present, is weak Hamiltonian also tends to $e^{-e^{-c}}$.

In his seminal paper from 1952 Dirac showed that the complete graph on $n\geq 3$ vertices remains Hamiltonian even if we allow an adversary to remove $\lfloor n/2\rfloor$ edges touching each vertex. In 1960 Ghouila-Houri obtained an analogue statement for digraphs by showing that every directed graph on $n\geq 3$ vertices with minimum in- and out-degree at least $n/2$ contains a directed Hamilton cycle. Both statements quantify the robustness of complete graphs (digraphs) with respect to the property of containing a Hamilton cycle. A natural way to generalize such results to arbitrary graphs (digraphs) is using the notion of \emph{local resilience}. The local resilience of a graph (digraph) $G$ with respect to a property $\mathcal{P}$ is the maximum number $r$ such that $G$ has the property $\mathcal{P}$ even if we allow an adversary to remove an $r$-fraction of (in- and out-going) edges touching each vertex. The theorems of Dirac and Ghouila-Houri state that the local resilience of the complete graph and digraph with respect to Hamiltonicity is $1/2$. Recently, this statements have been generalized to random settings. Lee and Sudakov (2012) proved that the local resilience of a random graph with edge probability $p=ω(\log n /n)$ with respect to Hamiltonicity is $1/2\pm o(1)$. For random directed graphs, Hefetz, Steger and Sudakov (2014+) proved an analogue statement, but only for edge probability $p=ω(\log n/\sqrt{n})$. In this paper we significantly improve their result to $p=ω(\log^8 n/ n)$, which is optimal up to the polylogarithmic factor.

Let $G$ be a graph on $n$ vertices and let $k$ be a fixed positive integer. We denote by $\mathcal G_{\text{$k$-out}}(G)$ the probability space consisting of subgraphs of $G$ where each vertex $v\in V(G)$ randomly picks $k$ neighbors from $G$, independently from all other vertices. We show that if $δ(G)=ω(\log n)$ and $k\geq 2$, then the following holds for every $p=ω(\log n/δ(G))$. Let $H$ be a random graph obtained by keeping each $e\in E(G)$ with probability $p$ independently at random and then coloring its edges independently and uniformly at random with elements from the set $[kn]$. Then, w.h.p. $H$ contains $t:=(1-o(1))δ(G)p/(2k)$ edge-disjoint graphs $H_1,...,H_t$ such that each of the $H_i$ is \emph{rainbow} (that is, all the edges are colored with distinct colors), and such that for every monotone increasing property of graphs $\mathcal P$ and for every $1\leq i\leq t$ we have $\Pr[\mathcal G_{\text{$k$-out}}(G)\models \mathcal P]\leq \Pr[H_i\models \mathcal P]+n^{-ω(1)}$. Note that since (in this case) a typical member of $\mathcal G_{\text{$k$-out}}(G)$ has average degree roughly $2k$, this result is asymptotically best possible. We present several applications of this; for example, we use this result to prove that for $p=ω(\log n/n)$ and $c=23n$, a graph $H\sim \mathcal G_{c}(K_n,p)$ w.h.p. contains $(1-o(1))np/46$ edge-disjoint rainbow Hamilton cycles. More generally, using a recent result of Frieze and Johansson, the same method allows us to prove that if $G$ has minimum degree $δ(G)\geq (1+\varepsilon)n/2$, then there exist functions $c=O(n)$ and $t=Θ(np)$ (depending on $\varepsilon$) such that the random subgraph $H\sim \mathcal G_{c}(G,p)$ w.h.p. contains $t$ edge-disjoint rainbow Hamilton cycles.

A graph is Hamiltonian if it contains a cycle passing through every vertex exactly once. A celebrated theorem of Dirac from 1952 asserts that every graph on $n\ge 3$ vertices with minimum degree at least $n/2$ is Hamiltonian. We refer to such graphs as Dirac graphs. In this paper we obtain the following strengthening of this result. Given a graph $G=(V,E)$, an {\em incompatibility system} $\mathcal{F}$ over $G$ is a family $\mathcal{F}=\{F_v\}_{v\in V}$ such that for every $v\in V$, the set $F_v$ is a set of unordered pairs $F_v \subseteq \{\{e,e'\}: e\ne e'\in E, e\cap e'=\{v\}\}$. An incompatibility system is {\em $Δ$-bounded} if for every vertex $v$ and an edge $e$ incident to $v$, there are at most $Δ$ pairs in $F_v$ containing $e$. We say that a cycle $C$ in $G$ is {\em compatible} with $\mathcal{F}$ if every pair of incident edges $e,e'$ of $C$ satisfies $\{e,e'\} \notin F_v$, where $v=e\cap e'$. This notion is partly motivated by a concept of transition systems defined by Kotzig in 1968, and can be viewed as a quantitative measure of robustness of graph properties. We prove that there is a constant $μ>0$ such that for every $μn$-bounded incompatibility system $\mathcal{F}$ over a Dirac graph $G$, there exists a Hamilton cycle compatible with $\mathcal{F}$. This settles in a very strong form, a conjecture of Häggkvist from 1988.

A graph is Hamiltonian if it contains a cycle passing through every vertex. One of the cornerstone results in the theory of random graphs asserts that for edge probability $p \gg \frac{\log n}{n}$, the random graph $G(n,p)$ is asymptotically almost surely Hamiltonian. We obtain the following strengthening of this result. Given a graph $G=(V,E)$, an {\em incompatibility system} $\mathcal{F}$ over $G$ is a family $\mathcal{F}=\{F_v\}_{v\in V}$ where for every $v\in V$, the set $F_v$ is a set of unordered pairs $F_v \subseteq \{\{e,e'\}: e\ne e'\in E, e\cap e'=\{v\}\}$. An incompatibility system is {\em $Δ$-bounded} if for every vertex $v$ and an edge $e$ incident to $v$, there are at most $Δ$ pairs in $F_v$ containing $e$. We say that a cycle $C$ in $G$ is {\em compatible} with $\mathcal{F}$ if every pair of incident edges $e,e'$ of $C$ satisfies $\{e,e'\} \notin F_v$. This notion is partly motivated by a concept of transition systems defined by Kotzig in 1968, and can be used as a quantitative measure of robustness of graph properties. We prove that there is a constant $μ>0$ such that the random graph $G=G(n,p)$ with $p(n) \gg \frac{\log n}{n}$ is asymptotically almost surely such that for any $μnp$-bounded incompatibility system $\mathcal{F}$ over $G$, there is a Hamilton cycle in $G$ compatible with $\mathcal{F}$. We also prove that for larger edge probabilities $p(n)\gg \frac{\log^8n}{n}$, the parameter $μ$ can be taken to be any constant smaller than $1-\frac{1}{\sqrt 2}$. These results imply in particular that typically in $G(n,p)$ for $p \gg \frac{\log n}{n}$, for any edge-coloring in which each color appears at most $μnp$ times at each vertex, there exists a properly colored Hamilton cycle.

A tree with at most $k$ leaves is called a $k$-ended tree. A spanning 2-ended tree is a Hamilton path. A Hamilton cycle can be considered as a spanning 1-ended tree. The earliest result concerning spanning trees with few leaves states that if $k$ is a positive integer and $G$ is a connected graph of order $n$ with $d(x)+d(y)\ge n-k+1$ for each pair of nonadjacent vertices $x,y$, then $G$ has a spanning $k$-ended tree. In this paper, we improve this result in two ways, and an analogous result is proved for dominating $k$-ended trees based on the generalized parameter $t_k$ - the order of a largest $k$-ended tree. In particular, $t_1$ is the circumference (the length of a longest cycle), and $t_2$ is the order of a longest path.

We consider random-turn positional games, introduced by Peres, Schramm, Sheffield and Wilson in 2007. A $p$-random-turn positional game is a two-player game, played the same as an ordinary positional game, except that instead of alternating turns, a coin is being tossed before each turn to decide the identity of the next player to move (the probability of Player I to move is $p$). We analyze the random-turn version of several classical Maker-Breaker games such as the game Box (introduced by Chvátal and Erd\H os in 1987), the Hamilton cycle game and the $k$-vertex-connectivity game (both played on the edge set of $K_n$). For each of these games we provide each of the players with a (randomized) efficient strategy which typically ensures his win in the asymptotic order of the minimum value of $p$ for which he typically wins the game, assuming optimal strategies of both players.

For a given graph $G$ of minimum degree at least $k$, let $G_p$ denote the random spanning subgraph of $G$ obtained by retaining each edge independently with probability $p=p(k)$. We prove that if $p \ge \frac{\log k + \log \log k + ω_k(1)}{k}$, where $ω_k(1)$ is any function tending to infinity with $k$, then $G_p$ asymptotically almost surely contains a cycle of length at least $k+1$. When we take $G$ to be the complete graph on $k+1$ vertices, our theorem coincides with the classic result on the threshold probability for the existence of a Hamilton cycle in the binomial random graph.

Let $n$ be sufficiently large and suppose that $G$ is a digraph on $n$ vertices where every vertex has in- and outdegree at least $n/2$. We show that $G$ contains every orientation of a Hamilton cycle except, possibly, the antidirected one. The antidirected case was settled by DeBiasio and Molla, where the threshold is $n/2+1$. Our result is best possible and improves on an approximate result by Häggkvist and Thomason.

This MSci thesis surveys results in extremal graph theory, in particular relating to Hamilton cycles. Szeméredi's Regularity Lemma plays a central role. We also investigate the robust outexpansion property for digraphs. Kelly showed that every sufficiently large oriented graph on $n$ vertices with minimum in- and outdegree at least $3n/8 +o(n)$ contains any orientation of a Hamilton cycle. We use Kelly's arguments to extend his result to any robustly expanding digraph of linear degree.

We consider problems about packing and counting Hamilton $\ell$-cycles in hypergraphs of large minimum degree. Given a hypergraph $\mathcal H$, for a $d$-subset $A\subseteq V(\mathcal H)$, we denote by $d_{\mathcal H}(A)$ the number of distinct \emph{edges} $f\in E(\mathcal H)$ for which $A\subseteq f$, and set $δ_d(\mathcal H)$ to be the minimum $d_{\mathcal H}(A)$ over all $A\subseteq V(\mathcal H)$ of size $d$. We show that if a $k$-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices $\mathcal H$ satisfies $δ_{k-1}(\mathcal H)\geq αn$ for some $α>1/2$, then for every $\ell<k/2$ $\mathcal H$ contains $(1-o(1))^n\cdot n!\cdot \left(\fracα{\ell!(k-2\ell)!}\right)^{\frac{n}{k-\ell}}$ Hamilton $\ell$-cycles. The exponent above is easily seen to be optimal. In addition, we show that if $δ_{k-1}(\mathcal H)\geq αn$ for $α>1/2$, then $\mathcal H$ contains $f(α)n$ edge-disjoint Hamilton $\ell$-cycles for an explicit function $f(α)>0$. For the case where every $(k-1)$-tuple $X\subset V({\mathcal H})$ satisfies $d_{\mathcal H}(X)\in (α\pm o(1))n$, we show that $\mathcal H$ contains edge-disjoint Haimlton $\ell$-cycles which cover all but $o\left(|E(\mathcal H)|\right)$ edges of $\mathcal H$. As a tool we prove the following result which might be of independent interest: For a bipartite graph $G$ with both parts of size $n$, with minimum degree at least $δn$, where $δ>1/2$, and for $p=ω(\log n/n)$ the following holds. If $G$ contains an $r$-factor for $r=Θ(n)$, then by retaining edges of $G$ with probability $p$ independently at random, w.h.p the resulting graph contains a $(1-o(1))rp$-factor.

For $1\le \ell<k/2$, we show that for sufficiently large $n$, every $k$-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices with minimum codegree at least $\frac n{2 (k-\ell)} $ contains a Hamilton $\ell$-cycle. This codegree condition is best possible and improves on work of Hàn and Schacht who proved an asymptotic result.

In 1992, Manoussakis conjectured that a strongly 2-connected digraph $D$ on $n$ vertices is hamiltonian if for every two distinct pairs of independent vertices $x,y$ and $w,z$ we have $d(x)+d(y)+d(w)+d(z)\geq 4n-3$. In this note we show that $D$ has a Hamilton path, which gives an affirmative evidence supporting this conjecture.

A classical theorem of Ghouila-Houri from 1960 asserts that every directed graph on $n$ vertices with minimum out-degree and in-degree at least $n/2$ contains a directed Hamilton cycle. In this paper we extend this theorem to a random directed graph ${\mathcal D}(n,p)$, that is, a directed graph in which every ordered pair $(u,v)$ becomes an arc with probability $p$ independently of all other pairs. Motivated by the study of resilience of properties of random graphs, we prove that if $p \gg \log n/\sqrt{n}$, then a.a.s. every subdigraph of ${\mathcal D}(n,p)$ with minimum out-degree and in-degree at least $(1/2 + o(1)) n p$ contains a directed Hamilton cycle. The constant $1/2$ is asymptotically best possible. Our result also strengthens classical results about the existence of directed Hamilton cycles in random directed graphs.

Define the middle layer graph as the graph whose vertex set consists of all bitstrings of length $2n+1$ that have exactly $n$ or $n+1$ entries equal to 1, with an edge between any two vertices for which the corresponding bitstrings differ in exactly one bit. The middle levels conjecture asserts that this graph has a Hamilton cycle for every $n\geq 1$. This conjecture originated probably with Havel, Buck and Wiedemann, but has also been attributed to Dejter, Erdős, Trotter and various others, and despite considerable efforts it remained open during the last 30 years. In this paper we prove the middle levels conjecture. In fact, we construct $2^{2^{Ω(n)}}$ different Hamilton cycles in the middle layer graph, which is best possible.

We first consider the following problem. We are given a fixed perfect matching $M$ of $[n]$ and we add random edges one at a time until there is a Hamilton cycle containing $M$. We show that w.h.p. the hitting time for this event is the same as that for the first time there are no isolated vertices in the graph induced by the random edges. We then use this result for the following problem. We generate random edges and randomly color them black or white. A path/cycle is said to \emph{zebraic} if the colors alternate along the path. We show that w.h.p. the hitting time for a zebraic Hamilton cycle coincides with every vertex meeting at least one edge of each color. We then consider some related problems and extend to multiple colors. We also briefly consider directed versions.