arXiv++ Combinatorics

An embedding of a graph in a book consists of a linear order of its vertices along the spine of the book and of an assignment of its edges to the pages of the book, so that no two edges on the same page cross. The book thickness of a graph is the minimum number of pages over all its book embeddings. Accordingly, the book thickness of a class of graphs is the maximum book thickness over all its members. In this paper, we address a long-standing open problem regarding the exact book thickness of the class of planar graphs, which previously was known to be either three or four. We settle this problem by demonstrating planar graphs that require four pages in any of their book embeddings, thus establishing that the book thickness of the class of planar graphs is four.

A Condorcet domain is a collection of linear orders which satisfy an acyclic majority relation. In this paper we describe domains as collections of directed Hamilton paths. We prove that while Black's single-peaked domains are defined by their extremal paths, Arrow's single-peaked domains are not. We also introduce domain contractions and domain extensions as well as self-paired domains, and describe some properties of these. We give a formula for the number of isomorphism classes of Arrow's single-peaked domains in terms of the number of self-paired domains, and give upper and lower bounds on this number. We also enumerate the distinct maximal Arrow's single-peaked domains for $|A|=5,6,7, 8$. Finally, we show that all of the observations in this paper can be translated to single-dipped domains, that is, Condorcet domains with complete "never-top" conditions.

As a step towards resolving a question of Ruškuc on the decidability of joint embedding for hereditary classes of permutations, which may be viewed as structures in a language of 2 linear orders, we show the corresponding problem is undecidable for hereditary classes of structures in a language of 3 linear orders.

The notion of interval order was introduced by Norbert Wiener \cite{wie} in order to clarify the relation between the notion of an instant of time and that of a period of time. This was a problem on which Bertrand Russell \cite{rus} worked at the time. Interval orders play an important role in many areas of pure and applied mathematics, graph theory, computer science and engineering. Special cases of interval order are the semiorder and linear order. All of these notions are especially important in the study of linear-interval and linear-semiorder dimension of a binary relation. This kind of dimension, which we call {\it hybrid order dimension}, gives a common generalization of linear order and interval order (semiorder) dimension and is arguably the most important measure of ordered set complexity. In this paper, we present three main results of the theory of hybrid order dimension. More specifically, we obtain necessary and sufficient conditions for a binary relation to have an interval order (resp. linear-interval order, linear-simiorder) extension, as well as an interval order realizer of interval orders (resp. linear-interval orders, linear-simiorders). We also obtain a characterization of the interval order (resp. linear-interval order, linear-simiorder) dimension. Because a binary relation's hybrid order dimension is less than its (linear) order dimension, these results will be able to improve known results in graph theory and computer science by identifying more efficient algorithms.

The Dushnik-Miller dimension of a partially-ordered set $P$ is the smallest $d$ such that one can embed $P$ into a product of $d$ linear orders. We prove that the dimension of the divisibility order on the interval $\{1, \dotsc, n\}$, is equal to ${(\log n)^2}(\log\log n)^{-Θ(1)}$ as $n$ goes to infinity. We prove similar bounds for the $2$-dimension of divisibility in $\{1, \dotsc, n\}$, where the $2$-dimension of a poset $P$ is the smallest $d$ such that $P$ is isomorphic to a suborder of the subset lattice of $[d]$. We also prove an upper bound for the $2$-dimension of posets of bounded degree and show that the $2$-dimension of the divisibility poset on the set $(αn, n]$ is $Θ_α(\log n)$ for $α\in (0,1)$. At the end we pose several problems.

A big Ramsey spectrum of a countable chain (i.e. strict linear order) C is a sequence of big Ramsey degrees of finite chains computed in C. In this paper we consider big Ramsey spectra of countable scattered chains. We prove that countable scattered chains of infinite Hausdorff rank do not have finite big Ramsey spectra, and that countable scattered chains of finite Hausdorff rank with bounded finite sums have finite big Ramsey spectra. Since big Ramsey spectra of all non-scattered countable chains are finite by results of Galvin, Laver and Devlin, in order to complete the characterization of countable chains with finite big Ramsey spectra (or degrees) one still has to resolve the remaining case of countable scattered chains of finite Hausdorff rank whose finite sums are not bounded.

Classes with bounded rankwidth are MSO-transductions of trees and classes with bounded linear rankwidth are MSO-transductions of paths -- a result that shows a strong link between the properties of these graph classes considered from the point of view of structural graph theory and from the point of view of finite model theory. We take both views on classes with bounded linear rankwidth and prove structural and model theoretic properties of these classes. The structural results we obtain are the following. 1) The number of unlabeled graphs of order $n$ with linear rank-width at most~$r$ is at most $\bigl[(r/2)!\,2^{\binom{r}{2}}3^{r+2}\bigr]^n$. 2) Graphs with linear rankwidth at most $r$ are linearly $χ$-bounded. Actually, they have bounded $c$-chromatic number, meaning that they can be colored with $f(r)$ colors, each color inducing a cograph. 3) To the contrary, based on a Ramsey-like argument, we prove for every proper hereditary family $F$ of graphs (like cographs) that there is a class with bounded rankwidth that does not have the property that graphs in it can be colored by a bounded number of colors, each inducing a subgraph in $F$. From the model theoretical side we obtain the following results: 1) A direct short proof that graphs with linear rankwidth at most $r$ are first-order transductions of linear orders. This result could also be derived from Colcombet's theorem on first-order transduction of linear orders and the equivalence of linear rankwidth with linear cliquewidth. 2) For a class $C$ with bounded linear rankwidth the following conditions are equivalent: a) $C$ is stable, b) $C$ excludes some half-graph as a semi-induced subgraph, c) $C$ is a first-order transduction of a class with bounded pathwidth. These results open the perspective to study classes admitting low linear rankwidth covers.

Suppose $V$ is an $n$-element set where for each $x \in V$, the elements of $V \setminus \{x\}$ are ranked by their similarity to $x$. The $K$-nearest neighbor graph is a directed graph including an arc from each $x$ to the $K$ points of $V \setminus \{x\}$ most similar to $x$. Constructive approximation to this graph using far fewer than $n^2$ comparisons is important for the analysis of large high-dimensional data sets. $K$-Nearest Neighbor Descent is a parameter-free heuristic where a sequence of graph approximations is constructed, in which second neighbors in one approximation are proposed as neighbors in the next. Run times in a test case fit an $O(n K^2 \log{n})$ pattern. This bound is rigorously justified for a similar algorithm, using range queries, when applied to a homogeneous Poisson process in suitable dimension. However the basic algorithm fails to achieve subquadratic complexity on sets whose similarity rankings arise from a ``generic'' linear order on the $\binom{n}{2}$ inter-point distances in a metric space.

A linear-interval order is the intersection of a linear order and an interval order. For this class of orders, several structural results have been known. This paper introduces a new subclass of linear-interval orders. We call a partial order a \emph{linear-semiorder} if it is the intersection of a linear order and a semiorder. We show a characterization and a polynomial-time recognition algorithm for linear-semiorders. We also prove that being a linear-semiorder is a comparability invariant, showing that incomparability graphs of linear-semiorders can be recognized in polynomial time.

We introduce the theory of $(\mathcal{P},ρ)$-partitions, depending on a poset $\mathcal{P}$ and a map $ρ$ from $\mathcal{P}$ to positive integers. The generating function $\mathfrak{F}_{\mathcal{P},ρ}$ of $(\mathcal{P},ρ)$-partitions is a polynomial that, when the images of $ρ$ tend to infinity, tends to Stanley's generating function $F_{\mathcal{P}}$ of $\mathcal{P}$-partitions. Analogous to Stanley's fundamental theorem for $\mathcal{P}$-partitions, we show that the set of $(\mathcal{P},ρ)$-partitions decomposes as a disjoint union of $(\mathcal{L},ρ)$-partitions where $\mathcal{L}$ runs over the set of linear extensions of $\mathcal{P}$. In this more general context, the set of all $\mathfrak{F}_{\mathcal{L},ρ}$ for linear orders $\mathcal{L}$ over determines a basis of polynomials. We thus introduce the notion of flagged $(\mathcal{P},ρ)$-partitions, and we prove that the set of all $\mathfrak{F}_{\mathcal{L},ρ}$ for flagged $(\mathcal{L},ρ)$-partitions for linear orders $\mathcal{L}$ is precisely the fundamental slide basis of the polynomial ring, introduced by the first author and Searles. Our main theorem shows that any generating function $\mathfrak{F}_{\mathcal{P},ρ}$ of flagged $(\mathcal{P},ρ)$-partitions is a positive integer linear combination of slide polynomials. As applications, we give a new proof of positivity of the slide product and, motivating our nomenclature, we also prove flagged Schur functions are slide positive.

Under what circumstances might every extension of a combinatorial structure contain more copies of another one than the original did? This property, which we call prolificity, holds universally in some cases (e.g., finite linear orders) and only trivially in others (e.g., permutations). Integer compositions, or equivalently layered permutations, provide a middle ground. In that setting, there are prolific compositions for a given pattern if and only if that pattern begins and ends with 1. For each pattern, there is an easily constructed automaton that recognises prolific compositions for that pattern. Some instances where there is a unique minimal prolific composition for a pattern are classified.

A transitive graph is 2-dimensional if it can be represented as the intersection of two linear orders. Such representations make answering of reachability queries trivial, and allow many problems that are NP-hard on arbitrary graphs to be solved in polynomial time. One may therefore be interested in finding 2-dimensional graphs that closely approximate a given graph of arbitrary order dimension. In this paper we show that the maximal 2-dimensional subgraphs of a transitive graph G are induced by the optimal near-transitive orientations of the complement of G. The same characterization holds for the maximal permutation subgraphs of a transitively orientable graph. We provide an algorithm that enables this problem reduction in near-linear time, and an approach for enlarging non-maximal 2-dimensional subgraphs, such as trees.

We present new exact and asymptotic results about the size of the largest antichain in the product of $n$ linear orders.

We consider two orthogonal points of view on finite permutations, seen as pairs of linear orders (corresponding to the usual one line representation of permutations as words) or seen as bijections (corresponding to the algebraic point of view). For each of them, we define a corresponding first-order logical theory, that we call $\mathsf{TOTO}$ (Theory Of Two Orders) and $\mathsf{TOOB}$ (Theory Of One Bijection) respectively. We consider various expressibility questions in these theories. Our main results go in three different direction. First, we prove that, for all $k \ge 1$, the set of $k$-stack sortable permutations in the sense of West is expressible in $\mathsf{TOTO}$, and that a logical sentence describing this set can be obtained automatically. Previously, descriptions of this set were only known for $k \le 3$. Next, we characterize permutation classes inside which it is possible to express in $\mathsf{TOTO}$ that some given points form a cycle. Lastly, we show that sets of permutations that can be described both in $\mathsf{TOOB}$ and $\mathsf{TOTO}$ are in some sense trivial. This gives a mathematical evidence that permutations-as-bijections and permutations-as-words are somewhat different objects.

A $k$-majority tournament $T$ on a finite set of vertices $V$ is defined by a set of $2k-1$ linear orders on $V$, with an edge $u \to v$ in $T$ if $u>v$ in a majority of the linear orders. We think of the linear orders as voter preferences and the vertices of $T$ as candidates, with an edge $u \to v$ in $T$ if a majority of voters prefer candidate $u$ to candidate $v$. In this paper we introduce weighted $k$-majority tournaments, with each edge $u \to v$ weighted by the number of voters preferring $u$. We define the maximum approval gap $γ_w(T)$, a measure by which any dominating set of $T$ beats the next most popular candidate. This parameter is analogous to previous work on the size of minimum dominating sets of (unweighted) $k$-majority tournaments. We prove that $k/2 \leq γ_w(T) \leq 2k-1$ for any weighted $k$-majority tournament $T$, and construct tournaments with $γ_w(T)=q$ for any rational number $k/2 \leq q \leq 2k-1$. We also consider the minimum number of vertices $m(q,k)$ in a $k$-majority tournament with $γ_w(T)=q$.

We classify primitive, rank 1, omega-categorical structures having polynomially many types over finite sets. For a fixed number of 4-types, we show that there are only finitely many such structures and that all are built out of finitely many linear orders interacting in a restricted number of ways. As an example of application, we deduce the classification of primitive structures homogeneous in a language consisting of n linear orders as well as all reducts of such structures.

We classify the homogeneous finite-dimensional permutation structures, i.e., homogeneous structures in a language of finitely many linear orders, giving a nearly complete answer to a question of Cameron, and confirming the classification conjectured by the first author. The primitive case was proven by the second author using model-theoretic methods, and those methods continue to appear here.

In the course of classifying the homogeneous permutations, Cameron introduced the viewpoint of permutations as structures in a language of two linear orders, and this structural viewpoint is taken up here. The majority of this thesis is concerned with Cameron's problem of classifying the homogeneous structures in a language of finitely many linear orders, which we call finite-dimensional permutation structures. Towards this problem, we present a construction that we conjecture produces all such structures. Some evidence for this conjecture is given, including the classification of the homogeneous 3-dimensional permutation structures. We next consider the topological dynamics, in the style of Kechris, Pestov, and Todorčević, of the automorphism groups of the homogeneous finite-dimensional permutation structures we have constructed, which requires proving a structural Ramsey theorem for all the associated amalgamation classes. Because the $\emptyset$-definable equivalence relations in these homogeneous finite-dimensional permutation structures may form arbitrary finite distributive lattices, the model-theoretic algebraic closure operation may become quite complex, and so we require the framework recently introduced by Hubička and Nešetril. Finally, we consider the decision problem for whether a finitely-constrained permutation avoidance class is atomic, or equivalently, has the joint embedding property. As a first approximation to this problem, we prove the undecidability of the corresponding decision problem in the category of graphs. Modifying this proof also gives the undecidability, in the category of graphs, of the corresponding decision problem for the joint homomorphism property, which is of interest in infinite-domain constraint satisfaction problems.

In~\cite{Hartman:2014}, Hartman, Hubi\v cka and Ma\v sulović studied the hierarchy of morphism extension classes for finite $L$-colored graphs, that is, undirected graphs without loops where sets of colors selected from $L$ are assigned to vertices and edges. They proved that when $L$ is a linear order, the classes $MH_L$ and $HH_L$ coincide, and the same is true for vertex-uniform finite $L$-colored graphs when $L$ is a diamond. In this paper, we explore the same question for countably infinite $L$-colored graphs. We prove that $MH_L=HH_L$ if and only if $L$ is a linear order.

Tournament solutions provide methods for selecting the "best" alternatives from a tournament and have found applications in a wide range of areas. Previous work has shown that several well-known tournament solutions almost never rule out any alternative in large random tournaments. Nevertheless, all analytical results thus far have assumed a rigid probabilistic model, in which either a tournament is chosen uniformly at random, or there is a linear order of alternatives and the orientation of all edges in the tournament is chosen with the same probabilities according to the linear order. In this work, we consider a significantly more general model where the orientation of different edges can be chosen with different probabilities. We show that a number of common tournament solutions, including the top cycle and the uncovered set, are still unlikely to rule out any alternative under this model. This corresponds to natural graph-theoretic conditions such as irreducibility of the tournament. In addition, we provide tight asymptotic bounds on the boundary of the probability range for which the tournament solutions select all alternatives with high probability.