arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study the behavior of phylogenetic tree shapes in the tropical geometric interpretation of tree space. Tree shapes are formally referred to as tree topologies; a tree topology can also be thought of as a tree combinatorial type, which is given by the tree's branching configuration and leaf labeling. We use the tropical line segment as a framework to define notions of variance as well as invariance of tree topologies: we provide a combinatorial search theorem that describes all tree topologies occurring along a tropical line segment, as well as a setting under which tree topologies do not change along a tropical line segment. Our study is motivated by comparison to the moduli space endowed with a geodesic metric proposed by Billera, Holmes, and Vogtmann (referred to as BHV space); we consider the tropical geometric setting as an alternative framework to BHV space for sets of phylogenetic trees. We give an algorithm to compute tropical line segments which is lower in computational complexity than the fastest method currently available for BHV geodesics and show that its trajectory behaves more subtly: while the BHV geodesic traverses the origin for vastly different tree topologies, the tropical line segment bypasses it.

In phylogenetics it is of interest for rate matrix sets to satisfy closure under matrix multiplication as this makes finding the set of corresponding transition matrices possible without having to compute matrix exponentials. It is also advantageous to have a small number of free parameters as this, in applications, will result in a reduction of computation time. We explore a method of building a rate matrix set from a rooted tree structure by assigning rates to internal tree nodes and states to the leaves, then defining the rate of change between two states as the rate assigned to the most recent common ancestor of those two states. We investigate the properties of these matrix sets from both a linear algebra and a graph theory perspective and show that any rate matrix set generated this way is closed under matrix multiplication. The consequences of setting two rates assigned to internal tree nodes to be equal are then considered. This methodology could be used to develop parameterised models of amino acid substitution which have a small number of parameters but convey biological meaning.

Recent investigations in computational biology have focused on a family of 2-colored digraphs, called 2-colored best match graphs, which naturally arise from rooted phylogenetic trees. Actually the defining properties of such graphs are unusual, and a natural question is whether they also have properties which well fit in structural graph theory. In this paper, we prove that some underlying oriented bipartite graphs of a 2-colored best match graph are acyclic and we point out that the arising topological ordering can efficiently be used for constructing new families of 2-colored best match graphs.

In phylogenetics, tree-based networks are used to model and visualize the evolutionary history of species where reticulate events such as horizontal gene transfer have occurred. Formally, a tree-based network $N$ consists of a phylogenetic tree $T$ (a rooted, binary, leaf-labeled tree) and so-called reticulation edges that span between edges of $T$. The network $N$ is typically visualized by drawing $T$ downward and planar and reticulation edges with one of several different styles. One aesthetic criteria is to minimize the number of crossings between tree edges and reticulation edges. This optimization problem has not yet been researched. We show that, if reticulation edges are drawn x-monotone, the problem is NP-complete, but fixed-parameter tractable in the number of reticulation edges. If, on the other hand, reticulation edges are drawn like "ears", the crossing minimization problem can be solved in quadratic time.

The Colless index for bifurcating phylogenetic trees, introduced by Colless (1982), is defined as the sum, over all internal nodes $v$ of the tree, of the absolute value of the difference of the sizes of the clades defined by the children of $v$. It is one of the most popular phylogenetic balance indices, because, in addition to measuring the balance of a tree in a very simple and intuitive way, it turns out to be one of the most powerful and discriminating phylogenetic shape indices. But it has some drawbacks. On the one hand, although its minimum value is reached at the so-called maximally balanced trees, it is almost always reached also at trees that are not maximally balanced. On the other hand, its definition as a sum of absolute values of differences makes it difficult to study analytically its distribution under probabilistic models of bifurcating phylogenetic trees. In this paper we show that if we replace in its definition the absolute values of the differences of clade sizes by the squares of these differences, all these drawbacks are overcome and the resulting index is still more powerful and discriminating than the original Colless index.

Phylogenetic networks are notoriously difficult to reconstruct. Here we suggest that it can be useful to view unknown genetic distance along edges in phylogenetic networks as analogous to unknown resistance in electric circuits. This resistance distance, well known in graph theory, turns out to have nice mathematical properties which allow the precise reconstruction of networks. Specifically we show that the resistance distance for a weighted 1-nested network is Kalmanson, and that the unique associated circular split network fully represents the splits of the original phylogenetic network (or circuit). In fact, this full representation corresponds to a face of the balanced minimal evolution polytope for level-1 networks. Thus the unweighted class of the original network can be reconstructed by either the greedy algorithm neighbor-net or by linear programming over a balanced minimal evolution polytope. We begin study of 2-nested networks with both minimum path and resistance distance, and include some counting results for 2-nested networks.

Tree-child networks are a recently-described class of directed acyclic graphs that have risen to prominence in phylogenetics (the study of evolutionary trees and networks). Although these networks have a number of attractive mathematical properties, many combinatorial questions concerning them remain intractable. In this paper, we show that endowing these networks with a biologically relevant ranking structure yields mathematically tractable objects, which we term ranked tree-child networks (RTCNs). We explain how to derive exact and explicit combinatorial results concerning the enumeration and generation of these networks. We also explore probabilistic questions concerning the properties of RTCNs when they are sampled uniformly at random. These questions include the lengths of random walks between the root and leaves (both from the root to the leaves and from a leaf to the root); the distribution of the number of cherries in the network; and sampling RTCNs conditional on displaying a given tree. We also formulate a conjecture regarding the scaling limit of the process that counts the number of lineages in the ancestry of a leaf. The main idea in this paper, namely using ranking as a way to achieve combinatorial tractability, may also extend to other classes of networks.

The Neighbor-Joining algorithm is a popular distance-based phylogenetic method that computes a tree metric from a dissimilarity map arising from biological data. Realizing dissimilarity maps as points in Euclidean space, the algorithm partitions the input space into polyhedral regions indexed by the combinatorial type of the trees returned. A full combinatorial description of these regions has not been found yet; different sequences of Neighbor-Joining agglomeration events can produce the same combinatorial tree, therefore associating multiple geometric regions to the same algorithmic output. We resolve this confusion by defining agglomeration orders on trees, leading to a bijection between distinct regions of the output space and weighted Motzkin paths. As a result, we give a formula for the number of polyhedral regions depending only on the number of taxa. We conclude with a computational comparison between these polyhedral regions, to unveil biases introduced in any implementation of the algorithm.

In previous work, we gave asymptotic counting results for the number of tree-child and normal networks with $k$ reticulation vertices and explicit exponential generating functions of the counting sequences for $k=1,2,3$. The purpose of this note is two-fold. First, we make some corrections to our previous approach which overcounted the above numbers and thus gives erroneous exponential generating functions (however, the overcounting does not effect our asymptotic counting results). Secondly, we use our (corrected) exponential generating functions to derive explicit formulas for the number of tree-child and normal networks with $k=1,2,3$ reticulation vertices. This re-derives recent results of Carona and Zhang, answers their question for normal networks with $k=2$, and adds new formulas in the case $k=3$.

Introgression is an evolutionary process in which genes or other types of genetic material are introduced into a genome. It is an important evolutionary process that can, for example, play a fundamental role in speciation. Recently the concept of an overlaid species forest was introduced to represent introgression histories. Basically this approach takes a putative gene history in the form of a phylogenetic gene tree and tries to overlay this onto a forest which usually consists of a collection of lineage trees for the species of interest. The result is a network called an overlaid species forest in which genes jump or introgress between lineages. In this paper we study properties of overlaid species forests, showing that they have various connections with models for lateral gene transfer, maximum parsimony, and unfolding of phylogenetic networks. In particular, we show that a certain algorithm called OSF-B UILDER for constructing overlaid species forests is guaranteed to a produce a special type of overlaid species forest with a minimum number introgressions, as well as providing some characterizations for networks that can arise from overlaid species forests. We expect that these results will be useful in developing new methods for representing introgression histories, a growing area of interest in phylogenetics.

Recent investigations in computational biology focus on a family of 2-colored digraphs, called 2-colored best match graphs, which naturally arise from rooted phylogenetic trees. Actually the defining properties of such graphs are unexpectedly unusual in graph theory, and they were established only recently after the discovery of their links to evolutionary relatedness via phylogenetic trees. In this paper several results are obtained on 2-colored best match graphs which well fit in the mainstream of graph theory.

We provide precise asymptotic estimates for the number of general phylogenetic networks by using analytic combinatorial methods. Recently, this approach is studied by Fuchs, Gittenberger, and the author himself (Australasian Journal of Combinatorics 73(2):385-423, 2019), to count networks with few reticulation vertices for two subclasses: tree-child and normal networks. We follow this line of research to show how to obtain results on the enumeration of general phylogenetic networks.

We study model embeddability, which is a variation of the famous embedding problem in probability theory, when apart from the requirement that the Markov matrix is the matrix exponential of a rate matrix, we additionally ask that the rate matrix follows the model structure. We provide a characterisation of model embeddable Markov matrices corresponding to symmetric group-based phylogenetic models. In particular, we provide necessary and sufficient conditions in terms of the eigenvalues of symmetric group-based matrices. To showcase our main result on model embeddability, we provide an application to hachimoji models, which are eight-state models for synthetic DNA. Moreover, our main result on model embeddability enables us to compute the volume of the set of model embeddable Markov matrices relative to the volume of other relevant sets of Markov matrices within the model.

Phylogenomics is a new field which applies to tools in phylogenetics to genome data. Due to a new technology and increasing amount of data, we face new challenges to analyze them over a space of phylogenetic trees. Because a space of phylogenetic trees with a fixed set of labels on leaves is not Euclidean, we cannot simply apply tools in data science. In this paper we survey some new developments of machine learning models using tropical geometry to analyze a set of phylogenetic trees over a tree space.

In 2004 Pachter and Speyer introduced the higher dissimilarity maps for phylogenetic trees and asked two important questions about their relation to the tropical Grassmannian. Multiple authors, using independent methods, answered affirmatively the first of these questions, showing that dissimilarity vectors lie on the tropical Grassmannian, but the second question, whether the set of dissimilarity vectors forms a tropical subvariety, remained opened. We resolve this question by showing that the tropical balancing condition fails. However, by replacing the definition of the dissimilarity map with a weighted variant, we show that weighted dissimilarity vectors form a tropical subvariety of the tropical Grassmannian in exactly the way that Pachter--Speyer envisioned. Moreover, we provide a geometric interpretation in terms of configurations of points on rational normal curves and construct a finite tropical basis that yields an explicit characterization of weighted dissimilarity vectors.

We describe Galois connections which arise between two kinds of combinatorial structures, both of which generalize trees with labelled leaves, and then apply those connections to a family of polytopes. The graphs we study can be imbued with metric properties or associated to vectors. Famous examples are the Billera-Holmes-Vogtmann metric space of phylogenetic trees, and the Balanced Minimal Evolution polytopes of phylogenetic trees described by Eickmeyer, Huggins, Pachter and Yoshida. Recently the space of trees has been expanded to split networks by Devadoss and Petti, while the definition of phylogenetic polytopes has been generalized to encompass 1-nested phylogenetic networks, by Durell and Forcey. The first Galois connection we describe is a reflection between the (unweighted) circular split networks and the 1-nested phylogenetic networks. Another Galois connection exists between certain metric versions of these structures. Reflection between the purely combinatorial posets becomes a coreflection in the geometric case. Our chief contributions here, beyond the discovery of the Galois connections, are: a translation between approaches using PC-trees and networks, a new way to look at weightings on networks, and a fuller characterization of faces of the phylogenetic polytopes.

Phylogenetic networks are used to study evolutionary relationships between species in biology. Such networks are often categorized into classes by their topological features, which stem from both biological and computational motivations. We study two network classes in this paper: tree-based networks and orchard networks. Tree-based networks are those that can be obtained by inserting edges between the edges of an underlying tree. Orchard networks are a recently introduced generalization of the class of tree-child networks. Structural characterizations have already been discovered for tree-based networks; this is not the case for orchard networks. In this paper, we introduce cherry covers---a unifying characterization of both network classes---in which we decompose the edges of the networks into so-called cherry shapes and reticulated cherry shapes. We show that cherry covers can be used to characterize the class of tree-based networks as well as the class of orchard networks. Moreover, we also generalize these results to non-binary networks.

Cographs are exactly the hereditarily well-colored graphs, i.e., the graphs for which a greedy vertex coloring of every induced subgraph uses only the minimally necessary number of colors $χ(G)$. We show that greedy colorings are a special case of the more general hierarchical vertex colorings, which recently were introduced in phylogenetic combinatorics. Replacing cotrees by modular decomposition trees generalizes the concept of hierarchical colorings to arbitrary graphs. We show that every graph has a modularly-minimal coloring $σ$ satisfying $|σ(M)|=χ(M)$ for every strong module $M$ of $G$. This, in particular, shows that modularly-minimal colorings provide a useful device to design efficient coloring algorithms for certain hereditary graph classes. For cographs, the hierarchical colorings coincide with the modularly-minimal coloring. As a by-product, we obtain a simple linear-time algorithm to compute a modularly-minimal coloring of $P_4$-sparse graphs.

The concept of $k$-compatibility measures how many phylogenetic trees it would take to display all splits in a given set. A set of trees that display every single possible split is termed a \textit{universal tree set}. In this note, we find $A(n)$, the minimal size of a universal tree set for $n$ taxa. By normalising the $k$-compatibility using $A(n)$, one can then compare incompatibility of split systems across different taxa sizes. We demonstrate this application by comparing two SplitsTree networks of different sizes derived from archaeal genomes.

We show that the space of rooted tree-based phylogenetic networks is connected under rooted nearest-neighbour interchange (rNNI) moves.